3 The Library As Armory
THREE

The Library as Armory
“When you come, bring… my scrolls, especially the parchments.”
APOSTLE PAUL TO TIMOTHY
I love to read. As a young boy I can remember devouring Ellery Queen mysteries on long vacation drives, taking a hot bath and reading The Long Winter by Laura Ingalls Wilder, curling up in the bay window of a local library, as rain cascaded down the glass, with a harrowing tale of Blackbeard the Pirate. I still have the copy of Roald Dahl’s Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, worn from countless readings, given to me on my twelfth birthday by my grandmother. For me, the perfect day is one with a sky full of dark and heavy clouds, promising a furious rain storm or inches of snow, with a fire in the fireplace and a book by my side waiting to be explored.
My love of reading as a boy grew into something altogether different when I became a follower of Christ in college. Reading took on an urgency that it had never held before. Attending a secular university as a new Christian was not an easy task. I was surrounded by very bright people who were not Christ-followers and were eager to explain why. To hold on to my faith, much less contend for it, would demand fulfilling the Bible’s clear and commanding exhortation to “always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have” (1 Peter 3:15). I knew I had to out-think those who were challenging my faith; and to out-think them, I knew I had to outread them. From this, reading moved from mere pleasure to real purpose. No longer did it matter whether I enjoyed reading; it had become essential.
From reading alone could I gain a sense of the currents shaping the world; from reading alone could I understand the prevailing worldviews assailing Christianity; from reading alone could I place myself in the vanguard of taking the Word of God to the word of the world. Reading would fill my mind with virtually limitless knowledge, instruction and insight, and it would exercise my mind and force it to break through barriers of stagnancy.
So I read the existentialist philosophers, such as Camus and Sartre. I read the great Greek thinkers, such as Plato and Aristotle. I delved into history, literature and science. I read the plays of Ibsen and Beckett. I was purposeful in my approach because I was on a mission to prepare my mind to not simply understand the ideas of the world but to engage the ideas of the world. And not simply to challenge others but to find everywhere God’s truth existed—for all truth is God’s truth, and the presence of that truth is the beginning of dialogue and redemption. I was not the first to hold to this conviction. As a monk in Normandy wrote in 1170: “A monastery without a library [sine armario] is like a castle without an armory [sine armamentario]. Our library is our armory.” This was certainly the conviction of the apostle Paul, who even from his prison cell in Rome implored Timothy to be sure to bring him his books (2 Timothy 4:13).
Yet according to the comprehensive “Reading at Risk” report (2002) from the National Endowment of the Arts, for the first time in modern history, less than half of the adult population now reads literature, reflecting a larger decline in all other sorts of reading— a rate of decline that is accelerating, particularly among the young. The report cataloged a massive cultural shift toward electronic media for not only entertainment but also information, which can make reading seem superfluous. Such a shift comes at great cost, for much is lost when reading is discarded—much more than the knowledge that might have been gained through the act of reading itself. Reading a book requires a degree of engagement, of active attention, that enlivens and expands the mind. Electronic media makes far fewer demands; it breeds passive participation, fosters shorter attention spans and creates the demands for immediate gratification. The report went on to note that the diminishing print culture brings a diminished capacity for focused attention and contemplation that makes complex communications and insights possible. In the end, it can lead us to forgo the practice of active learning altogether.
As a result, reading is the foundation for intellectual development.
My wife was an elementary education major in college and chose to homeschool each of our four children through to the eighth grade. While we partnered on this, my part was, to say the least, secondary. My wife guided each of our four children to an education that served them admirably throughout high school and college, and the heart of her curriculum was reading. Homeschooling is a challenging and arduous task. When nothing went as planned (e.g., math assignments left uncompleted, science projects remained undone), Susan would wearily collapse into a chair at the end of the day and say, “Well, at least they read. If I can just get them to read, everything else will fall into place.” And she was right. It would, and it did. The national campaign in the United States that touted reading as “fundamental” was one of the truest campaigns ever launched through the media.
Yet there is far more that reading brings into our life. It prepares us to think, for it is reading which allows us to understand and interpret the events of our day. The Christian mind cannot simply absorb the news; it must consider the news in light of God’s purposes in the world. How should we think about what is happening? What does it mean? What should our response be? Susan Wise Bauer suggests that when you hear the morning news, you may find out that a suicide bomber has just devastated a restaurant on the West Bank. This is nothing but information—a collection of facts—gained passively, without exertion and taken at face value. “What a tragedy,” we might add. “But in order to be enlightened about the suicide bombers on the West Bank,” Bauer writes, “you must read seriously: history, theology, politics.” Information alone simply washes over us, Bauer adds, without leaving its traces behind. Or, one might add, its implications. “Wrestling with truth,” she concludes, “marks us forever.”
The critical importance of reading reminds me of something I came across long ago—so long that the author now escapes me. But I recall it was a lament for a book never read. The loss of pages never turned, covers never opened, words never seen. A single book can deepen your understanding, expand your vision, sensitize your spirit, deepen your soul, ignite your imagination, stir your passions and widen your wisdom. There truly can be mourning for a book never read—mourning for the loss of what our lives could have held and could have accomplished.
CHOOSING TO READ
How can we become active readers in the midst of the frantic pace of our lives? It is tempting to view the act of sitting down with a book—much less many books—as a luxury afforded those with unique schedules or privileged positions in life. In truth, it is available to us all. It is simply a matter of choice or, perhaps more accurately, a series of choices.
To read, you must first position yourself to read. I have learned to keep books around me. When I travel, when I take my car to have the oil changed, when I pick my children up from school, when I go to the doctor’s office, I bring a book, journal or magazine. If you were to look around my home, you would see stacks of books everywhere: on the tables by the side of beds, on the floor by chairs.
But this reflects a deeper decision in relation to reading. Having a book at hand is only of use if I choose to spend available time reading it. Key to that choice is the word available. I once heard Jim Collins, known best as the author of business titles, comment that we do not need to make more “to do” lists but rather a few “stop doing” lists. I know that in my life the great opposition to reading is what I allow to fill my time instead of reading. To say we have no time to read is not really true; we have simply chosen to use our time for other things or have allowed our time to be filled to the exclusion of reading.
And there is little doubt what offers the greatest temptation.
According to a 1997 study reported in the New York Times, the average person in America spent about 1,100 hours a year watching broadcast TV, an additional 500 hours watching cable TV and 300 hours listening to music. Only 100 hours were spent reading. Imagine what a repeat of this now-dated study would find in light of the time spent on the Internet. Neil Postman noted that the great fear of George Orwell, as conveyed in his novel 1984, was of a day when there might be those who would ban books. Aldous Huxley’s portrait of the future in Brave New World was more prescient; Huxley feared that there would be no reason to ban a book, for there would be no one who wanted to read one.
Recently my family and I visited Disney World in Orlando, Florida. There for a week, we developed a pattern of going to the parks early in the morning, coming back to the hotel for a mid-afternoon break and then going back out for the evening. One day, during one of the afternoons back at the hotel, we were sitting in the atrium around a table doing what seemed normal to us as a family.
We were reading.
My oldest daughter was tearing through the latest installment of Harry Potter in order to pass it on to her siblings; my other daughter was soldiering her way through Dostoevsky’s The Brothers Karamazov; my oldest son was reading—again—Tolkien’s trilogy The Lord of the Rings; and my youngest son was laughing uproariously over some unfortunate event conceived by Lemony Snicket.
I had my own stack of books beside me, as if they were a mound of pastries from which I had yet to choose which one to eat first. A history by David McCullough, I believe, finally won. My wife, bless her soul, was actually reading one of her husband’s books. Martyrs still exist.
A woman walked over to our table, openly marveling at seeing six people—and particularly four children—reading. She said it was a wonderful sight and wondered how we did it. I remember thinking that we didn’t do anything—we genuinely enjoyed reading. But there was something that caused my children to love a book. It started by doing what my mother did—talking about books like they were truly a pleasure. Then, throughout their lives, we modeled a life that read.
But another thought entered my mind. What led us to read that day? The same thing that had led us to read a thousand days before. On that day, upon returning to the hotel room, the TV went on just like it would in your family. But then Susan and I instinctively said to our kids, “Why don’t you get a book and read instead? Come on, let’s go out together and sit by a table and read.” So we did.
But first, the choice had to be made.
WHAT TO READ
But what should we read? It is one thing to be widely read, but something altogether different to be well read. The difference is important.
When it comes to the actual books we open, it is very essential to be selective. As Arthur Schopenhauer once suggested, “If a man wants to read good books, he must make a point of avoiding bad ones; for life is short, and time and energy limited.” Richard Weaver observes that it may be doubted whether one person in three draws what may be correctly termed “knowledge” from his freely chosen reading matter.
This is not a matter of avoiding what is often termed “beach reads”—those books that are light, frivolous page-turners. Just as exercise can and should involve play, sport, and recreation, so reading should involve fun and fantasy, escape and entertainment. But if this is all that reading holds for us, our minds will quickly become the equivalent of a body that eats only fast food. In the 2004 documentary film Super Size Me, a mere thirty days of such diet resulted in weight gain of twenty-five pounds, chest pains, liver problems and trouble breathing. Imagine what month after month and year after year of feeding our minds such a diet would produce.
So what are the “good” books? Where is “knowledge” gained? Robert Maynard Hutchins observes, “Until lately the West has regarded it as self-evident that the road to education lay through the great books.” And what are the great books? “There never was very much doubt in anybody’s mind about which the master-pieces were,” writes Hutchins. “They were the books that had endured and that the common voice of mankind called the finest creations, in writing, of the Western mind.” The great books are those writings that have most shaped history and culture, civilization and science, politics and economics. They prompt us to think about the great issues of life. C. S. Lewis simply called them the “old” books.
Actual collections of such writings have been attempted. Along with Mortimer Adler, Hutchins compiled a set of “Great Books” that spanned Homer to Freud, covering more than twenty-five centuries, including the works of Plato and Aristotle, Virgil and Augustine, Shakespeare and Pascal, Locke and Rousseau, Kant and Hegel, Darwin and Dostoevsky. Charles W. Eliot, who served as president of Harvard for forty years, dreamed of a five-foot shelf of books that would provide an education to anyone who would spend even fifteen minutes a day reading them. His vision took form when he became the editor of the fifty-volume Harvard Classics (1909).
Critiques can be made of such reading programs, both in scope and intent, but at least they propel the reader into what Hutchins calls the “Great Conversation.”1 Or as René Descartes would suggest, the reading of such books is like a conversation with the noblest men of past centuries, “nay a carefully studied conversation, in which they reveal to us none but the best of their thoughts.” Lewis went further, arguing that the old books were needed to confront our current ages perspective. “Every age has its own outlook,” Lewis contended. “It is specially good at seeing certain truths and specially liable to make certain mistakes. We all, therefore, need the books that will correct the characteristic mistakes of our own period. And that means the old books.”
Lewis was right. As the author of Ecclesiastes noted, there is very little that is new under the sun. The ancient heresy of Gnosticism, which holds to “secret” knowledge through a spiritual enlightenment and emphasizes the spiritual over the material, rears its head on an ongoing basis. The voice of Pelagius continues to echo down the centuries, suggesting that we must, or at least can, do something to earn our salvation. And much within postmodernism is simply the philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche coming into his own.
If every generation of Christians faces these ideas as if for the first time, the damage will be incalculable. The old phrase “fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me” rings true. Not only will vast amounts of time and resources be wasted grappling with what Christians have already addressed, but large numbers of casualties will be tallied on both sides; Christians who fall prey to such thinking and non-Christians who might have been receptive to the gospel will be subject to distortions that confuse their thinking and ability to respond to the gospel.
Our tendency, of course, is not to read the old books at all, or at least to do no more than read books about the old books. More often than not it is because we determine in advance that they are beyond us, are irrelevant or would be dry, dull reading. The wonderful surprise is how seldom this is true. Some might take more effort than others, but that is the point—to exercise the mind. We accept that getting into physical shape will take determination, will power and sweat. The mind demands no less yet offers so much more.
THE GREAT BOOK
Of course, the foundation of the Christian mind is the great book—the Bible. It is God’s revelation to us, imparting knowledge that cannot be known apart from its revelation. The Bible alone is “living and active. Sharper than any double-edged sword, it penetrates even to dividing soul and spirit, joints and marrow; it judges the thoughts and attitudes of the heart” (Hebrews 4:12).
As one would expect, the Bible is not to be read like any other book. More than concentrated study of the Scriptures is called for; this is a book to be obeyed. Other books are to be engaged, understood and evaluated as to the truth and wisdom, place and purpose of their contents. The Bible must also be engaged and understood, but not for the purpose of determining whether we should take it into consideration. The Bible alone calls for complete and utter submission of life and thought. As New Testament scholar N. T. Wright observes, “The Christian is prepared to say, ’I don’t like the sound of this, but golly, if this is what it really means, I’m going to have to pray for grace and strength to get that into my heart and be shaped by it.”
Sadly, very few read the Bible, as Gordon Fee titled one of his books, “for all that it’s worth.” As I have observed as both pastor and educator, there are many ways people read the Bible. There are “service” readers, those who engage the Bible when it is presented during a weekend service, and that is all. Then there are devotional readers who take bite-size bits of Scripture through secondary conduits (devotional magazines or books). This goes light-years beyond the “service” reader because it encourages reflection on a text, but it is far from the feast the Scriptures offer and the mind needs. What is required is studious reading: an open Bible, a dictionary and concordance nearby, and time to reflect on what the psalmist described as “a lamp to my feet and a light for my path” (Psalm 119:105). This is the foundation of the Christian mind. A biblical worldview—a view of the world informed and shaped by the Bible—has always marked the most developed and formidable of Christian minds.
Consider Augustine. In Loving God, Charles Colson recalls how Augustine—brilliant, learned and handsome—held one of the most prestigious and enviable professorships in Italy. When he spoke, he was overwhelmingly persuasive. Few considered themselves his equal. Although he had a Christian mother and was personally intrigued by the Christian faith, Augustine lived a life distant from God. He was torn about how best to live; he was engaged to be married, yet had a mistress and an illegitimate child. In fact, he had many mistresses. Sex was necessary for him, he said, for he had no power to resist his natural desires. On the other hand, he was riddled with guilt, even from the time he stole fruit from a neighbor’s pear tree with a gang of youthful rowdies.
But change was afoot in Augustine’s heart. The great philosophers, such as Plato, had convinced Augustine that there was more to the world than what could be seen, tasted, touched, heard or smelled. Things beyond his own senses could be real. Then Augustine encountered Ambrose, a Christian pastor in Milan. In Ambrose, Augustine found a speaker equal to his own rhetorical skills. But Ambrose had more than verbal ability—Augustine was intrigued with what Ambrose was saying.
Augustine had tried reading the Scriptures as a teenager but was not impressed. At the time he had been in love with beautiful language, and the language of Scripture seemed dull and plain. But years had passed since then. Under Ambrose’s influence, the simplicity of Scripture began to sound profound.
One evening he sat in his garden, utterly silent in the stillness of the summer heat. But inside his heart, a storm raged. Confusion over his life built up until finally it seemed as if his chest would burst. He threw himself under a fig tree, unable to stop sobbing.
Then… a voice.
A childish, piping voice seemed to come from a nearby house. It chanted over and over, “Take up and read. Take up and read. Take up and read.”
Were the words for him?
“Read what?” Augustine shouted into the sky.
Then he glanced around him, and there, lying nearby, were the letters of the apostle Paul from the New Testament. Was he to take up the Scriptures and read?
He snatched up the book and began reading where it fell open—Romans 13. The words burned into his mind: “not in orgies and drunkenness, not in sexual immorality and debauchery, not in dissension and jealousy. Rather clothe yourselves with the Lord Jesus Christ, and do not think about how to gratify the desires of the sinful nature” (vv. 13-14). Instantly, the shadows of his heart fled before the streams of light. A book he once dismissed as a mere fable lacking in clarity and grace of expression altered the entire trajectory of his life and gave him what he had sought for so long. He had encountered truth.
Augustine gave his life to Christ. And for the next forty-four years, Augustine continued to “take up and read,” becoming one of the most influential Christian thinkers and writers of history. But it all started in the garden, where he learned that the Scriptures were not just words to be interpreted; they were words that interpreted the reader.
Little wonder that J. I. Packer once wrote, “If I were the devil… I should broadcast doubts about the truths and relevance and good sense and straightforwardness of the Bible…. At all costs I should want to keep them from using their minds in a disciplined way to get the measure of its message.”
In the first appendix to this volume, I offer my own suggested list of books for the great conversation.
