2 The Cultural Mind
TWO

The Cultural Mind
“Our minds are as the days are, dark or bright.”
HOMER
In his provocatively titled book From Darwin to Hitler, historian Richard Weikart examines the revolutionary impact Darwinism had on the ethics and morality of social thinkers in Nazi Germany. Believing that Darwinism had overturned any sense of the sanctity of human life, an evolutionary “fitness” (especially in terms of intelligence and health) became the highest arbiter of morality for the Nazis. Weikart concludes that Darwinism played a strategic role not only in the rise of eugenics but also in the rise of euthanasia, infanticide, abortion and racial extermination—all ultimately embraced by the Nazis.
The contention that Hitler built his views on Darwinian principles raises one of the most important truths a mind can comprehend: Ideas have consequences. This is what Richard Weaver titled his seminal work, asserting that the catastrophes of our age are the product not of necessity but of choice. Increasingly, the basis of that choice is a worldview divorced from spiritual moorings. The great Russian novelist Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, speaking of his country’s spiritual demise, concurred, saying, “If I were asked today to formulate as concisely as possible the main cause of the ruinous Revolution that swallowed up some sixty million of our people, I could not put it more bluntly than to repeat: ’Men have forgotten God; that’s why all this has happened.’ ” The solution, Weaver contends, is the right use of reason, which entails a recognition of absolute reality and a recognition that ideas—like actions—have consequences.
But this is not a conviction that shapes our world.
Though a 2004 survey of religion and politics sponsored by the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life found only 7.5 percent of the American population categorized themselves as “secularists,” columnist David Klinghoffer maintains that those embracing secularism far exceed the 7.5 percent figure, as many individuals who identify nominally as Jews or Christians are, in fact, devout secularists. Perhaps even more decisive is to consider the secularized subculture currently resting at the top of the American educational system, the media of mass communication and the upper echelons of the legal system. These are the epicenters of culture and the means by which values and ideas come into being and are disseminated. While their forces may be “relatively thin on the ground,” sociologist Peter Berger observes, “they are very influential, as they control the institutions that provide the ’official’ definitions of reality.” Berger quips, “If India is the most religious country on our planet, and Sweden is the least religious, America is a land of Indians ruled by Swedes.” So a country like the United States is clearly secularized politically, and arguably intellectually; it just may take a while for it to get to the “man on the street.”
It should be noted that by secularism I do not mean atheism, which is, as Alister McGrath has written, entering into its twilight as an idea. Atheism is neither at the heart of the secular religion nor the principal challenge to Christian faith. The heart of the secular religion is moral relativism, a functional atheism, if you will, which holds that what is moral is dictated by a particular situation in light of a particular culture or social location. With moral relativism, moral values become a matter of personal opinion or private judgment rather than something grounded in objective truth.
But few see this as the great challenge facing the Christian faith. An online poll conducted by AOL soon after the selection of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger to be the next pope revealed what people perceived as Pope Benedict XVI’s greatest challenges. “Sanctity of life” issues, such as cloning or stem cells, came in first, followed by the priest shortage. Distant on the list was the rise of secularism.
Fortunately, the new pope is not driven by polls, exhibiting a sound awareness of secularism’s threat and wisely discerning that “sanctity of life” issues and the priest shortage are the symptoms of secularism’s rise. Benedict XVI has had a courtside seat to secularism’s deadly effects in Western Europe and specifically his German homeland. Fewer than one of every ten Germans worships even once a month, and a majority of Germans and other Northern Europeans confess that God does not matter to them at all (which accounts for the absence of any reference to God in the draft of the proposed European constitution).
Little wonder that in Ratzinger’s pre-election sermon to his fellow cardinals he made the following declaration: “We are moving toward a dictatorship of relativism… that recognizes nothing definite and leaves only one’s ego and desires as the final measure.” John Paul II began his papacy with the cry “Be not afraid!” Benedict XVI seemed to initiate his pontificate differently: “Be afraid. Be very, very afraid.” And we should be. But more than afraid, we should be aware; if the war we wage is one of ideas, we must be aware of those ideas arrayed against us.
The mind for God faces a cultural challenge: the god of this world—who is not without intellectual forces, which he arrays against the kingdom. Within this assault are four major ideas, each of which is critical to understand.
MORAL RELATIVISM
The first idea within our culture that is in direct opposition to a biblical worldview is that of moral relativism. The basic idea of moral relativism is: What is true for you is true for you, and what is true for me is true for me. What is moral is dictated by a particular situation in light of a particular culture or social location. Moral values become a matter of personal opinion or private judgment rather than something grounded in objective truth.
This is so entrenched in Western culture that Allan Bloom, reflecting on his role as a university educator, maintains that there “is one thing a professor can be absolutely certain of. Almost every student entering the university believes, or says he believes, that truth is relative.” Much of this has led to a changing view of reality itself, based on the growing sense that no one can be truly objective. You cannot stand outside of your own context—including experiences, biases and the historical-cultural current—and be free to make an unconditioned observation. More than the sentiment “That’s your opinion,” the idea is that everything is opinion. This does not mean that there is not a reality “out there,” just that all of our “stories” about what is “out there” are the products of individual, highly subjective minds engaging “what is.” So reality is little more than what we as individuals perceive it to be.
Because truth is considered to be relative, existing only in the realm of our private opinions and preferences, matters of faith are increasingly rejected in the public sphere. Far more than being perceived as showing poor form, explicit talk of faith has been banished from the wider public agenda. As historian and educator Page Smith once sarcastically observed, in our day, “God is not a proper topic for conversation, but ’lesbian politics’ is.” Unless it becomes politically expedient, then “God” is resurrected and bandied about as if a part of one’s resume (as has become the rage of late). Yet this is far from a defined God, meaning the One who has revealed himself and truth about himself. Spirituality and religion may be “in”; transcendent truth, which is exclusive by its very nature and claims lordship over an entire life, is not.
So while Christianity used to be rejected by Enlightenment intellectuals because they thought its central beliefs had been disproven by science or philosophy, today it is disqualified on the grounds that it argues for a truth that is unchanging and universal. A particular faith used to be wrong on the basis of what was perceived to be truth; now a faith is wrong for claiming there is truth. As Allen Bloom has wryly noted, “The true believer is the real danger.”
AUTONOMOUS INDIVIDUALISM
A second idea coursing through the currents of culture is that of autonomous individualism.
To be autonomous is to be independent. Autonomous individualism maintains that each person is independent in terms of destiny and accountability. Ultimate moral authority is self-generated. In the end, we answer to no one but ourselves, for we are truly on our own. Our choices are ours alone, determined by our personal pleasure, and not by any higher moral authority.
As opposed to the Christian idea, famously articulated by Dutch leader Abraham Kuyper, that there is not an inch of any sphere of our lives that Christ does not declare “Mine!” current thinking would respond “How dare you!” Or even more to the point, “Who do you think you are?” The answer Christ would give, of course, is “God,” but that would be the point of contention. As the French existentialist philosopher Jean Paul Sartre contended, “Man is the being whose project is to be God.”
NARCISSISTIC HEDONISM
A third idea the Christian worldview must contend with is narcissistic hedonism.
In Greek mythology, Narcissus is the character that, on seeing his reflection in the water, becomes so enamored with himself that he devotes the rest of his life to his own reflection. From this we get the term narcissism, signifying a preoccupation with self. The value of narcissistic hedonism is the classic “I, me, mine” mentality that places personal pleasure and fulfillment at the forefront of concerns.
Or as Francis Schaeffer maintained throughout his writings, the ultimate ethic of the day seems to be the pursuit of personal peace and individual affluence. In agreement with Schaeffer’s conclusion, the noted cultural historian Christopher Lasch christened ours “the culture of narcissism,” determining that the current taste is for individual therapy instead of religion. The quest for personal well-being, health and psychic security has replaced the older hunger for personal salvation.
This runs deeper than mere self-gratification. Narcissism has become a guiding worldview. Stanley Grenz observed that Anselm’s famed dictum “I believe in order that I may understand” was altered by the Enlightenment to become “I believe what I can understand.” The modern twist goes further, becoming “I believe when I understand that it helps me.” This puts the idea that rests at the heart of the Christian faith—that of self-sacrifice—in more than opposition to the culture. The modern world can barely fathom its embrace.
REDUCTIVE NATURALISM
Gerard Piel, founder and publisher of Scientific American magazine, has argued that when historians examine Western civilization of the twentieth century, it will be deemed the “age of science.” But not just any kind of science; ours will be the age of naturalism, the idea that nature is “all that is.” This is the fourth idea rooted in our culture. Naturalism holds that life is accidental. There is nothing beyond ourselves that will ever bring order, reason or explanation. Reductive naturalism states that all that can be known within nature is that which can be empirically verified. What is real is only that which can be seen, tasted, heard, smelled or touched and then verified, meaning able to be replicated through experimentation. Knowledge is “reduced” to this level of knowing. If it cannot be examined in a tangible, scientific manner, it is not simply unknowable but meaningless.
Even dangerous.
As astronomer Carl Sagan argued in his final work, the goal is to rid ourselves of a “demon-haunted” world, meaning anything that would challenge the rule of science and technology as the ultimate arbiter of truth and reality, for there is no other truth or reality to embrace. So we do not simply have science but scientism— the deification of scientific methods and results as religion.
MODERNITY’S WAKE
For the Christian mind, understanding the world we live in is decisive on two fronts. First, we need to be aware of how such worldviews might be living in us. Is our thinking informed and directed by the authority of Scripture and the leading of the Holy Spirit, or have we succumbed to the subtle temptation of moral relativism? Do we mark our years by dedication to God and his eternal purposes, or do we strip our lives of any sense of calling and answer only to the voice of an autonomous individualism? Do we live in light of the great redemptive drama, selflessly giving ourselves to the advance of the kingdom and the building of the church, or do we find ourselves drifting into a narcissistic hedonism that makes all spiritual alignments a consumer affair? Do we view the world through a materialistic lens, or do we see a God who not only created but who, through his providence, continues to oversee that creation?
Second, we need to understand how the world affects those around us who we will engage for Christ, not simply in terms of intellectual challenge but also in terms of unmet needs. How might we begin to live and speak and act and serve in ways that might intersect with their deepest questions and longings?
And the world has left much unmet.
The trauma of our world is that the secular worldview, rooted in naturalism, has failed to deliver on its promises. Rather than enhancing personal satisfaction and fulfillment, we live in a moral and spiritual wasteland. Moral relativism has led to a crisis in values; we find ourselves needing values but not having them, and divorced from any means of finding them. Autonomous individualism has led to a lack of vision; there is nothing calling us upward to be more than we are beyond our selves. Narcissistic hedonism has fostered empty souls; anyone who has followed its ever-deadening trail knows how hollow its entreaties are. And of course reductive naturalism has proven inadequate for human experience; we intuitively know that there is more to reality than what our five senses can verify, and we long to find that which is beyond ourselves.
But do Christians have anything to offer the world that it does not already have? Are we able to present Christ so clearly that non-Christians understand he alone is able to intersect the deepest needs of their life?
Not unless we forge our minds on the anvil of development. And the rest of this book is dedicated to examining just what that might look like.
