Chapter 6 of 13

4 The Lost Tools Of Learning

4 The Lost Tools Of Learning

FOUR

image

The Lost Tools of Learning

“It would be a pity if we overlooked the possibilities of education as a means of acquiring wisdom… and if we lost our respect for learning.”

T. S. ELIOT

In our world, knowledge is on the decline, with wisdom on an even more rapid descent. What is taking its place is information, virtually unlimited amounts coupled with immediate access. The founders of Google, one of the leading Internet search engines, took their name from googol (the numeral 1 followed by 100 zeros), signifying how much information they initially hoped to catalog. So one can “Google” God and come up with millions of “hits”—but what does this deliver? How do we wade through such vast amounts of information? What is right, what is wrong, what is reputable, what is without merit?

Quentin Schultze writes that such forays often leave us with little more than “endless volleys of nonsense, folly and rumor masquerading as knowledge, wisdom, and even truth.” At the least, it is information without coherence—there is no organizing whole. It is fragmented, disassembled and piecemeal. Even worse, there are no gatekeepers, no counselors and no guides. It is the Wild West without a sheriff, a darkened alley without police patrol.

The inadequacy of this cannot be overstated, particularly as this information is not simply at our demand but under our control. We live in a world where we can see only what we choose to see, hear only what we choose to hear and read only what we choose to read. Through technology, we have the ability to filter out everything but what we wish to be exposed to—creating what University of Chicago professor Cass Sunstein has called the “Daily Me,” a self-created world in which we see only the sports highlights that concern our favorite team, read only the issues that address our interests and engage only the op-ed pieces with which we agree.

The highly lauded personalization of information protects us from exposure to anything that might challenge our thinking or make us uncomfortable. Unchecked, we begin to follow the sound of nothing more than the echo of our own voice. At the very least, knowledge becomes trivialized. So as laudable as Google’s project may be, the most popular Google searches of 2005 included Janet Jackson, Xbox 360, Brad Pitt, Michael Jackson, American Idol and Angelina Jolie.

This is why education matters.

And having it matter is, of course, quite Christian. The very foundation of liberal arts education can be traced back to the monastic education developed during the Middle Ages. There was sacred learning through the Bible and secular learning through the seven liberal arts of the trivium (grammar, rhetoric and logic) and quadrivium (arithmetic, geometry, astronomy and music). The idea was that the whole of human learning could be gathered into these “arts.”

But the sacred-secular divide was not pronounced. The liberal arts were aimed at something beyond themselves, as evidenced in the very words trivium and quadrivium—the “threefold way” and the “fourfold way”—referring the way to the wisdom contained in the Word of God. In other words, such learning was decisive for the development of a Christian mind, for all truth was God’s truth. Learning, in and of itself, was sacred, for it was pursuing the very knowledge of God, and life in light of that knowledge. The idea was the simultaneous cultivation of character and knowledge— and that the two were, in fact, inseparable.

T. S. Eliot wrote of the tragedy of losing our respect for learning. If all truth is God’s truth, then truth is to be celebrated wherever it is found—and to be pursued wherever it can be found. Inherent within the idea of learning is placing ourselves in situations and experiences that allow such learning to take place. Reading is certainly a part of this, but reading that is separate from dialogue and instruction, guidance and challenge, creates a rather narrow learning experience. There is much to learn from others and from the interaction others have had with the books we have read. In Proverbs, the Bible speaks of our interaction with others as being akin to iron sharpening iron, one person sharpening another (Proverbs 27:17). I may have read the works of Shakespeare, but to study under someone who has devoted his or her life to Shakespeare is well worth the investment and holds far more than reading alone ever could. Otherwise I may fall prey to narrow thinking, limited opinion and often shallow conclusions.

But there is more for the Christian. The Bible speaks clearly of the spiritual gift of teaching (Romans 12:7; 1 Corinthians 12:29; Ephesians 4:11). Spiritual gifts are given by the Holy Spirit because they are needed by the body of Christ. The gift of teaching implies that there are students. And it means we need to be students. It is not an option but an implicit command. We must be learners, and one of the primary ways we are to learn is through teachers—this is so important the Holy Spirit actually distributes the gift of teaching for this very purpose. Failing to take advantage of this entails refusing the work of the Holy Spirit in our life. We are not to be indiscriminate learners, for not all teachers are Spirit-gifted, much less Spirit-led, but learning itself is not an option.

This is a radically different perspective on learning than that which currently dominates our world. Our tendency is to embrace what Clifford Williams terms a “utilitarian” view of education. We think of something like college as a way to ensure our place in the larger culture. We take courses so that we can enhance our resumés and get better jobs. At best, we study computer science, chemistry and biology in order to improve communication, transportation and medical technologies. At worst, we use them as a means to an end—that end most often being financial gain.

“The point of an education, the culture declares, is to better oneself by gaining skills and knowledge that will be useful in the marketplace,” Williams maintains. “Rarely is the idea of learning as a good in itself mentioned.” Yet if the mind is a creation of God to be stewarded as much as any other part of our existence, education can and should be seen—in and of itself—as intrinsically good. As Williams concludes, “attending school is not just a means of preparing for a good life. It is a good life.”

CHRISTIAN LITERACY

So what should we commit ourselves to learning? Are there certain things we are to “know”? The respected academic E. D. Hirsch, who burst onto the cultural scene in the late 1980s, captured the attention of the wider populace with a simple idea, followed by an ambitious project. His idea was the value of “cultural literacy,” meaning the importance of having a core of background knowledge for functional literacy and effective national communication. His project? To catalog what that literacy would entail. His book Cultural Literacy became a bestseller. Hirsch has cataloged over six thousand names, phrases, dates and concepts that he considers “essential.” The same year another academic, Allan Bloom, published the bestseller The Closing of the American Mind. Though Bloom lamented far more than the loss of cultural literacy, he joined with Hirsch in the call for a return to a common denominator within education. These men ignited a national debate about the nature of education and the meaning of literacy. Questions swirled around the form and content of such knowledge, and whether education can actually be reduced to such things. But the central thesis remained: there are certain things we should know.

They were right.

There is a body of knowledge that lends itself to cultural literacy—and even further, Christian literacy. This is why as a professor of theology I teach certain things and not others, and then (along with every other teacher) proclaim, “You will need to know this for the test.” The understanding inherent within education is that there are certain facts that should be known, books that should be read, lives that should be studied, events that should be remembered, and ideas that should be understood.

So what are those things?

Biblical literacy. The church has felt the need to identify what should be known from the earliest days. Luke, along with Matthew, Mark and John, felt it critical to pull together the central teachings and life events of Jesus, with John acknowledging, “Jesus did many other things as well. If every one of them were written down, I suppose that even the whole world would not have room for the books that would be written” (John 21:25).

And reflecting the importance of a core knowledge beyond the Gospels, God gave us the rest of the Scriptures. God boiled the law down to ten commandments; we need to know what they are— along with Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount, the seven letters to the seven churches, the wisdom of the Proverbs, the great theological treatise of Romans, the evangelistic thrust of John’s Gospel and everything else within the canon.

So the starting point of our education (or our commitment to learning) is biblical literacy. In terms of overall literacy, this is arguably where the church has done its best, where the spiritual gift of teaching has been most recognized and where Christians have most devoted themselves as students. But we are always one generation away from biblical illiteracy. Learning the Bible is an ongoing challenge that lies in the vanguard of our commitment to education. We simply must become students of the Scriptures, sitting under teachers devoted to the Scriptures and forming a deep understanding of God’s Word.

Historical literacy. Beyond biblical learning, there are certain

events in history, specifically Christian history (which is often overlooked by Christians), that should be known. And not simply dates, names and places, but more importantly significance.

History, as has often been noted, is “his story”—meaning the story of God’s activities in the world. It is common knowledge that to ignore history is to be condemned to repeat it. More to the point, to ignore history is to ignore our world, the people that have shaped it and the current of events that have brought us to where we are. It would be difficult to imagine a Christian mind operating without such knowledge.

The ultimate authority within the Christian faith is the triune God. The Trinity is revealed first and foremost in Scripture, but we also must drink deeply from its conveyance through our Christian heritage. History is certainly secondary to Scripture—it is informative, not normative—but it does inform. History is walking back through time, listening to its better minds. We sometimes imagine that the issues of our day did not exist before our day, but this is a grave mistake. The church has previously wrestled with most of our issues, and those “wrestlings” are well worth our time to explore, or we cut ourselves off from the accumulated wisdom and insight of the ages.

So what significant events should be known—at least in terms of Christian history? Historian Mark Noll has suggested the following twelve as seminal: the fall of Jerusalem (A.D. 70), the council of Nicaea (325), the council of Chalcedon (451), Benedict’s Rule (530), the coronation of Charlemagne (800), the “great schism” between the Eastern and Western church (1054), the Diet of Worms (1521), the English Act of Supremacy (1534), the founding of the Jesuits (1540), the conversion of the Wesleys (1738), the French Revolution (1789), and the Edinburgh Missionary Conference (1910).

In decisive ways, these events, as well as many others, have shaped the church and the way it interacts with the world. Understanding the significance of such events is indispensable to interacting with the world in positive and productive ways. Failing to do so is akin to joining a conversation that is well under way without any sense of what has already been said.

Theological literacy. Beyond biblical and historical literacy is theological literacy. Theology is built from two Greek words: theos (God) and logos (word). Thus theology means “words about God,” the great attempt to pull together what can be said about God and the things of God. The Bible is God’s revelation; history walks us through how some of the better minds have wrestled with it; theology puts it all together and applies it to the great questions of life and to our spiritual formation. If the Bible tells us the “what,” theology attempts to give the “so what.”

In pulling this together, theology has traditionally organized itself in ten categories: (1) the existence, nature and attributes of God (theology proper); (2) revelation (the inspiration and authority of Scripture); (3) creation and providence; (4) humanity and human nature; (5) original and actual sin; (6) the person and work of Christ; (7) sin and grace; (8) the person and work of the Holy Spirit; (9) the church; and (10) the end times.

Each of these areas is critical to explore and understand. We say we believe in the God of the Bible—so what kind of God is God: personal or impersonal, caring or indifferent? We say we believe the Bible—in what way: as truth without mixture of error or as simply a relatively reliable guide? If we hold to the Bible’s inspiration, do we mean “inspired” in the sense of Bach’s Brandenburg Concertos or something more? We say we believe in creation and that humans are made in the image of God—but what does that mean? Where is the image located? When does life even begin? What gives it value?

These are theological questions. Before a mind can contend with culture, it must first ground itself in a sound and vibrant Christian theology. This is why theology was called the “queen” of the sciences throughout the medieval era. There was no other field of study, no other topic, which held greater worth.

GETTING AN EDUCATION

Of course, talking about education and actually getting it are two different things. Where do Christians go to learn theology or church history? In times past this took place in churches and the seminaries that serve them. Unfortunately, this is often no longer the case. So churches and seminaries must rise to the educational challenge.

Fortunately, many are.

Churches are increasingly taking a community college approach to their educational ministries. The church I belong to offers an institute for adults with a fresh slate of courses—from Christian theology to Bible 101 to church history to book studies—each quarter. Such learning opportunities are seen as a vital “third leg” to the learning stool, complementing weekend and midweek services and small group experiences.

Seminaries are beginning to think outside of the standard educational box. Many of the larger seminaries are offering branch campuses and extension centers in key population centers throughout the United States. Even more are using the Internet to offer distance learning programs. Others have produced CD-ROMs that include audio lectures and lecture outlines, study guides and study questions, and bibliographies for further reading. Companion websites provide further resources and allow significant interaction among students, and between students and instructors.

But we are not strictly dependent on traditional institutions for the development of our minds. Audio journals, mentoring programs, book discussion groups, community colleges, online libraries and study programs abound.

The issue is taking advantage of them.1

EDUCATION AND EDUCATORS

As you might imagine, the importance of education highlights the importance of educators—not simply within the life of the church or the seminary but in academia in general. Christians committed to a life of learning must lift high the calling to be an educator, for it is a call in desperate need of being answered.

Recently, a Brooklyn College professor dropped his bid to become chairman of the department of sociology due to outrage over his description of religious people as “moral retards.” In an essay he published in an online journal, he argued that religious people are incapable of moral action, and that “self-righteousness, paranoia, and hatred” characterize Christians in particular. An apparently earlier version of the online essay added, “Christians claim that theirs is a faith based on love, but they’ll just as soon kill you.” He even suggests that Christians have a greater proclivity toward child molestation.

Unfortunately, such outrageous campus rhetoric is not unusual. Obviously the relationship between Christians and the academy is a challenging one. But it has not always been that way, and it can be changed. Thus there is a desperate need for Christians to not only obtain an education but also pursue a scholarly vocation within the academy—for the express purpose of making a mark for God in that arena, serving and equipping the next generation of learners.

The aforementioned Brooklyn College, which has more than fifteen thousand students, recently observed its seventy-fifth anniversary. It was named one of the top ten best values among under-graduate institutions in the country by the Princeton Review. But Brooklyn College is more than that. Like every other institution devoted to higher education, it is a mission field filled with students who, according to many seasoned observers, are in their best season for responding to Christ. And as Daniel Tauber, president-elect of Brooklyn College’s student government lamented, “I would like to see professors in high positions who don’t believe religious people are moral retards.”

In The Outrageous Idea of Christian Scholarship, historian George Marsden observes that the “contemporary university culture is hollow at its core.” Or as a Harvard Law School professor once expressed, many professors have become like “priests who have lost their faith, and kept their jobs.” There is a highly significant need, argues Marsden, for explicit discussion of the relationship between religious faith and learning. But this can only be pursued if Christians answer God’s call to the university, and from that position relate their belief in God—a Christian worldview—to all thinking.

Sadly, Marsden notes that even Christians scholars have not reflected much on the relationship of their faith to their intellectual life. Imagine if they did—becoming models for thousands more to follow, who then used their positions to encourage generations of learners in Christ.

1.

An introductory list of resources for continued education is provided in appendix two, “Resources for Learning.”

↑ Back to top

↑