The Way Forward: AResponse to aPost-Christian World
CHAPTER FOUR
THE WAY FORWARD: A RESPONSE TO A POST-CHRISTIAN WORLD
Recently I sat on a park bench and had one of those amazing conversations with a high school guy. We talked about life, drugs, family, faith, and of course, sex. Ultimately he wanted to get a feel for me and my faith. His older brother, an agnostic, was in college. And big brother had heard that this young man had started going to some youth group. (To be more specific, he was going to my youth group—the one that’s really into Jesus.) So he’d been giving his little brother a hard time about it. What I’ve learned over the years is that before students make a decision for Christ, they ask themselves, Do I want to be like you and your friends? I think that’s what this high schooler was doing. He’d been coming to our group for a couple of months, and now he needed to evaluate what we were all about. Did he truly want to be like my friends and me?
Over the last couple of years, our group has taken students through Youth Alpha, an amazing program for 11-18 year-olds that was created by a spectacular church in London called Holy Trinity Brompton. The Alpha website says, “Alpha is a practical introduction to the Christian faith, aimed particularly at non-churchgoers and new Christians... Youth Alpha is designed to give young people . . . the opportunity to explore life and faith.” (For more info, check out www.alpha.org or www.alphausa.org.) One of the videos we show during the Youth Alpha course is “Word on the Street.” You’ve probably seen these types of videos before, but this one begins by asking random people what they think of Jesus. The cool thing is that almost across the board, everyone interviewed in the post-Christian city of London is extremely positive about Jesus. Everyone loves him.
However, when the question changes to “What do you think of Christians?” I’m sure you can guess some of the responses:
Every descriptive word they used is one you’d never want to be called; yet these words were being used to describe us. So the kid I’m talking with on the park bench asks, “If I become a Christian, do I have to be like that? Do I have to believe that homosexuals are going to hell? Do I have to be a Republican? Can I love science? Do I have to be . . . you know?”
Over the years I’ve mostly worked in fairly conservative churches. And at times I’ve gotten the feeling that part of my job is not only getting kids into the faith but, more importantly, helping them grow up to be conservative. Conservative theologically, conservative morally, conservative politically . . . you get the idea. But I just have to ask, is this really my job? Is it my job to not only get students to Jesus, but also make sure they behave and believe what most evangelical Christians deem as being culturally acceptable? Do they have to be encouraged to vote correctly and to love apple pie and the American way? To take a strong stance for the inerrancy of Scripture and believe in the rapture? Really? That’s in my job description? Just getting kids to open their lives to Jesus is more work than I can handle sometimes. Now I also have to make sure they believe in a literal six-day creation?
If it’s true that the life stage of adolescence now lasts until a person is in his or her mid-twenties—and I believe that it’s true—then we’ve got some time to work on those issues before our students reach adulthood. And honestly, I don’t much care where they land on the nonessentials of life and faith. This young man who was sitting with me at the park just wanted to know if he could come to Jesus as is. He wanted to know if it was okay for him to come to God with his own thinking, his own ideas, bents, leanings, and understandings. I said, “Of course!”
Dr. Kenda Creasy Dean (pastor, author, and professor of youth, church and culture at Princeton Seminary) spoke to the upperclassmen in our youth group during a retreat. She was amazing and really challenged our students’ thinking. Afterward, I was talking with one of our students who admitted that she felt so relieved. She said she’d been thinking about leaving the faith. She just wasn’t sure if she could call herself a Christian any longer because her view of Scripture has changed. She told me her view of the Bible is that it’s inspired by God, but that man’s opinions are in there as well. She said that after listening and interacting with Kenda, she felt let off the hook a bit. Then she looked at me and said, “I just really want to follow Jesus and use my brain at the same time.” I was proud of her willingness to stay engaged with her faith.
Now if you assumed that Kenda presented an “easy to follow” faith, you’d be wrong. She did present a gracious faith, yes. But she also challenged the MTD (Moralistic Therapeutic Deism) belief system (which I touched on in chapter one), and she challenged it in a big way. I was so impressed as she led our students away from religion and back to Jesus.
But in the midst of this post-Christian world, we have to allow space for students to explore and search and maybe even end up in a different theological paradigm than our own. This is not an easy task. Believe me, if I could just shake teenagers by the shoulders and yell at them to think what I think, I would do it. But this tactic is highly ineffective. (I’ve tried it with my wife, and she’s not having any of it.) So what’s the alternative?
EMBRACE CHRISTIAN RELATIVISM
I’d like to offer some food for thought, so please just hear me out. First of all, we have to begin by embracing what I’ve termed “Christian relativism.”
“Whoa, Brock! What are you saying here?”
I know, I know. Just hold on a minute.
Years ago we did a series for our high school students called “Pick One.” We took controversial issues in the Bible and taught all the different orthodox positions on the topic. For example, we taught on the topic of homosexuality. We looked at the Scriptures together, and then we talked about all of the different views and interpretations of those passages that are accepted by orthodox Christians. We also looked at hell, women in ministry, the end times, and many other issues.
The funny thing is—well maybe it’s not so funny—this discussion brought a lot of heat my way. As you can imagine, both the church leaders and the parents wanted me to just tell the students what to think. However, I was more interested in teaching them how to think. I wanted them to know how gracious and big the faith was. I really don’t care all that much if a student believes in the rapture or not.
So now back to that student who’s chatting with me on the park bench. He’s ultimately asking, “Is there room for all of me in this faith?” Embracing Christian relativism is, as Brian McLaren wrote in his brilliant book by the same name, a generous orthodoxy. What if Christians were seen as being generous? Generous with ideas, generous with theology, generous and patient and tolerant with each other and with the world. Another word for this would be gracious. What if Christians were known for showing grace to each other and the world, first and foremost? Right now the world looks at us and thinks, Christians aren’t even gracious toward each other. I hate to think what they might think of me!
