A New Kind of Mission
CHAPTER FIVE
A NEW KIND OF MISSION
For the first 10 years of my life, I grew up on a tour bus. In the 1970s my parents were in a Christian rock band called The Amplified Version, and they traveled all over the country performing their hippie Jesus music. The cool thing was they truly had a heart to see teenagers come into a relationship with Jesus. But during this time, the church rejected their brand of music. In fact, kids would give their lives to Jesus inside the arenas while church people were outside burning the band’s albums and protesting this “devil music.”
I don’t know if the church rejected them because the band sounded too contemporary or because their style of music wasn’t folksy enough. But this antagonistic environment forced my parents’ band to work outside of the church. Their bus would pull into a town on a Monday, and the band would find the highest place that overlooked the city. They would go to that spot and pray passionately that God would come and do an awesome work in the hearts, minds, and souls of every kid who lived there. Then they’d play at every high school and college all week long and invite kids to a Friday night concert. (Now this was during the Jesus Movement of the ’60s and ’70s, so Jesus was “just alright” with the youth culture back then.) Teenagers would come by the thousands, and hundreds upon hundreds would give their lives to Christ. One of my college professors told me he’d worked with Youth for Christ in the 1970s, and he’d brought my parents’ band to Chicago with zero support from the churches. He also said it was one of the most powerful weeks in his ministry there.
In the early ’80s The Amplified Version disbanded, so to speak. My parents became youth pastors and started discipling students. As I watched them interact with teenagers, both as members of the band and as youth workers, I remember thinking they were radicals. They were living life with kids, pointing them to Jesus in a world that was dead set against the in-breaking kingdom. So when I got my own call to youth ministry, I knew that if I ever worked in a church, it would have to be outward facing and a blessing to its community.
Two weeks after we got married, Kelsey and I moved to Southern California to minister in a town just outside of Los Angeles. I was the middle school director at Glendale Presbyterian Church, and I made all of $25,000 a year while ministering to the five kids in the program. My boss at the time was the brilliant Tim Galleher who served every week in every high school in the city. I thought, I’ll do the same thing, but I’ll do it in middle schools. One day I was talking with a police officer, and I asked him who the most dangerous kids in the city were. He told me they were middle school students “because they are bored, they are trying to prove themselves to the gang, and they have no sense of consequences.”
So Tim and I had the idea to develop an after-school program for middle school students in the city. I remember sitting in front of the city council and asking for $100,000 to get it going. They gave me $80,000, and we were off and running. We offered an after-school boxing program, an after-school basketball program, and a teen pregnancy counseling center. And we also ran all of the school dances in the city. It was an exciting and grueling time of ministry, and overnight our little group of five middle schoolers became bigger than we could manage. Over the next 15 years, Kelsey and I worked in a couple of different churches in Southern California, discipling and equipping students while also trying to serve and be a blessing to the community.
When I first started doing youth ministry, I told students to be salt and light on their school campuses. I’d say things like, “Your school is the only mission field in the world that if you don’t go to it, a truancy officer will come and drag you there.” It was a difficult challenge 20 years ago for students to be a light at their schools. And as the years have gone by, this difficult missional hill has slowly become a mountain, a rugged and steep mountain. Students today find it nearly impossible to bring Jesus to school in this post-Christian world. And I soon found that it was an impossible ask on my part.
I’ve also grown weary of trying to disciple kids inside a youth room in just 90 minutes a week—especially since I know the only way they’ll learn the way of Jesus is through on-the-job training. At the end of a typical night, I’d say to students, “Have a great week! See you next Wednesday.” But as I started serving on school campuses, I loved saying, “See you at school tomorrow!” I would show students how to be salt and light at their schools by doing it myself. They could join me if they wanted.
In 2006, my family, along with ministry partners Peter and Katie Nelson, moved to the liberal Northwest to work in a church and start a nonprofit called The Common Good that would bless the schools in that region. My first order of business was to set up meetings with principals, teachers, and city officials to lay the groundwork for what an outward-faced youth ministry would look like. So there my team and I were, sitting in a coffee shop with a group of principals from this town in Oregon. It had taken a couple of months just to set up a meeting with them, but the day finally came. I explained what the mission of our nonprofit was and what we were trying to do. And then I asked, “What do you guys need? Is there any program or dream that you’d like to see happen if you just had the right amount of manpower, resources, or money?” Every principal said they were fine, thanked me for asking, and went on their way.
But a day later, one of the principals called me. He’d been a principal in that town for about 30 years. He was loved, and he was one of the most influential leaders in the city. He asked me if we’d be willing to help him with his school assemblies—apparently, they were awful. The teachers hated them, he hated them, and worst of all the students hated them. He said the school had no school spirit. So if we were willing, he’d love to have us take a shot at doing them. I was thrilled and told him we’d love to do it if he could give us about 30 of his finest students to pull it off. He gave us 60 student government kids.
We started meeting with them, dreaming, scheming, and putting together the best darn school assembly known to man. It went off without a hitch. We had kids flying in on zip lines, a freestyle contest, funny videos, and pie-in-the-face games. The best part was that I didn’t get on the mic once; the students were the stars. Afterward, the principal asked if we could do that every month. So within two months, our role had grown into running the student government class on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday mornings. The student government kids would ask me, “Why are you here?” This is every minister of the gospel’s dream question. I’d answer briefly, without proselytizing, and share about the call of God on my life in a fun yet vague kind of way. Some students were floored. Others said, “I knew there was something different about you.” And still others confessed that they were followers of Jesus too.
Within another two months, we were responsible for all of the school’s activities. We even started taking students to serve in a soup kitchen once a week. They’d just sign up to come with us during lunch period. As word got around to the other principals in the city, we started getting asked to do the same thing in their schools. One middle school needed mentorship help because 40 percent of their students didn’t have a father living in the home. I asked how many mentors they needed, and they came back with a conservative 100. We partnered with some folks who felt called to this ministry, and they helped us by recruiting mentors from local churches, training them, and putting them in place.
Exciting things happened every week, and we really felt like we were a blessing to our community. The cool part is that instead of doing youth group dances or activities, our youth group kids participated in the public school’s dances and activities. Our students ran the sound, worked as the DJ, operated the lights, set up, and tore down. And then they began dreaming about other ways they could be salt and light on their own campuses. We were able to break down the barriers between the sacred and the secular for our students, as we discipled young passionate activists who were developing kingdom values.
Once we’d shown ourselves to be committed, the principal who’d asked us to start with his school started feeling bad about getting something for nothing. “Brock, we kind of feel guilty. You’re doing all of this work for us and not getting a penny. Is there anything you want to do?” I said we loved what we were doing. He said, “I know you’re a youth pastor. Do you want to hand out flyers for your youth group?” I told him we would never do that. We weren’t doing this to get more kids to come to our youth group. He prodded, “Come on, what would you like to do here if you could do anything?” What a question! I told him about my idea for teaching kids about social justice and connecting it to the history department. I said we could teach students all about the unjust things that are happening around the world, what people are doing to remedy those problems, and how students might get involved. He thought it was a brilliant idea and gave us the go-ahead.
Then he asked, “Anything else?” I told him that maybe as an all-school project over spring break, we could build houses for people in need of homes. He said, “You mean like a mission trip?”
I said, “Yeah, kind of like that.”
His response? “Let’s do it!”
God did amazing things in and through us. Instead of our church being insulated and inward, we started blessing our community. They were thankful we were there.
In order to be a blessing to our communities, we have to become more like and more unlike our culture. Tim Keller, senior pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York City, said this during a webcast:
My understanding of how you reach a culture is Christians have to be extremely like the people around them, and yet at the same time extremely unlike them. If Christians are not unlike, they won’t challenge the culture; but if they’re not like, they won’t persuade the culture. Now, hitting that middle ground is hard. Before the coming of Christ, believers were culturally different. Christ comes, and now you can be a Christian in every tongue, tribe, people, and nation. Jesus gets rid of the ceremonial laws and all those things that made Christians culturally strange. In that sense, [now] your neighbor is like you.21
When we get out from behind the walls of the church and truly start caring for our community, we will become like our culture. We will care about what they care about, we will want the same things to succeed, and we will contribute to the whole. But when we don’t promote our own stuff or ask for money or come with ulterior motives, then we are unlike the culture. We become a breath of fresh air. We become a blessing. That’s when our youth ministry can become like what Jesus did with his disciples—on-the-job training. We get to live life with our students and show them what it means to be a blessing and live in the way of Jesus.
I spoke at the National Youth Workers Convention in 2012, and I talked about getting in the schools and serving. A hand went up in the back of the room and a young gentleman asked, “So are you seeing kids getting saved because you’re in the schools?”
I don’t think he, or many others in the room, liked my response. I said, “We don’t serve to get people saved; we serve because we are saved.” Ultimately, God saves people, and we are the fortunate ones who have the privilege of blessing them along the way.
At the end of their band years, my parents could no longer get inside the schools to sing. Too many Christians were preaching on school campuses and crossing the separation of church and state lines. They disregarded the rules and tried to evangelize the schools. Reaching a school is not about growing your youth group or increasing your salvation tally. It’s about being Jesus with skin on. It’s about living life well with your students right on their campuses and showing them how to serve others. And in the midst of doing this, we get to bless our communities in the name of Jesus.
But a major obstacle in doing this is that none of us have time to do much of anything in the schools. All of our time is spent running programs and youth events. About 20 years ago, a middle school boy came up to me at church and asked, “Hey, are you the activities director?” That’s when I knew I needed to change what I was doing. I needed to stop entertaining and trying to attract students to my events. If we’re honest, we’ll admit that our “attractional” programs aren’t attracting students nearly as well as they once did. We’ve got better sound, better lights, and unlimited quantities of pizza. But students today just don’t care about those things.
I was talking with a fellow youth pastor who’s looking to hire someone to focus on the high school ministry at his church. He said the church board had already thrown out some numerical expectations for this next hire. And their “BIG idea”? Pizza feeds. They said that when kids came to youth group en masse back in the early ’90s, all the youth pastor needed to do was offer cool music and pizza. Sorry, those days are far behind us. I’m reminded of the book Jim and Casper Go to Church. In this incredible read there is an atheist, Casper, and a pastor, Jim, who travel around and attend services at many of America’s “top” churches. After visiting all of them and experiencing the lights, cameras, music, and programs, Casper says to Jim, “Is this what Jesus told you guys to do?”22
So what if we made a change? You may have heard the term “sacred cows” used when referring to longtime programmatic expectations within the church. It’s the attitude that we’ve always taken the students to that camp, or we’ve always met on that night of the week. Even though the surrounding culture has shifted, our ministry approach has not. We’ve accumulated so many programmatic “sacred cows” that we are ineffective to the point of impotence in a very different cultural time. We must kill the sacred cows—yes, the holy heifers must die! And then we’ve got to replace them with a more thoughtful and strategic approach. I love 1 Chronicles 12:32—“from Issachar, men who understood the times and knew what [God’s people] should do” (NIV). We have to be like those men of Issachar.
But it’s not just sacred cows that keep us from revolutionary ideas. Another major problem is that many of us work for lead pastors who served in youth ministry in the ’80s and ’90s. They can place upon us the mantle of loud music, big gatherings, and passionate speakers. But the culture has changed during the last 20 to 30 years. Youth culture today is about movement. So if we want to speak effectively to the rising generations, then our ministries must shift with the culture. This creates a conundrum for the lowly youth worker. Somehow we must lead those who are above us on the totem pole and also carry the vision to those around us.
April Diaz, human development director at Newsong Church in Irvine, California, just wrote an empowering book that I recommend you read. It’s called Redefining the Role of the Youth Worker. In it, she outlines Bill Hybel’s 360-degree leadership ideas and describes how she and her team at Newsong carried them out during a time of transformation in their church. See, you are in the position that you’re in so you can lead not only those who are under you, but also your peers and your supervisors. You must carry the vision to the body of Christ.
But are we brave enough and in tune enough with the Spirit to know the way forward? In Signs of Emergence: A Vision for Church That Is Always, Kester Brewin wrote, “The perception of the new step will come only to those brave enough to stop dancing the old.”23
As I’ve already mentioned, today’s students are too busy, they are overscheduled, and the days when we could attract them to attend multiple youth activities in a week are long gone. But when we’re entrenched in our communities and become a part of the social fabric of a school, that’s how we can finally live life with our students. We’ll be there coaching, teaching, and mentoring them in their world. If nothing else, we’ll model what it means to be salt and light. So we need to cut back on our programs and leave space for living. We must give away our resources. Youth pastors who do this will move away from being folks who just sit in a room and talk to students about being light, and they’ll become living, breathing lights in this dark world.
But first we have to get down on our knees and ask God to give us a revolutionary vision. I pray that we would contextualize our own communities and bring radical change to our ministries within an increasingly post-Christian culture. I love the vision of President Dwight Eisenhower’s parents. Donald Miller explains it this way:
Eisenhower was a character, getting himself kicked out of West Point, causing a lot of trouble. But always there was in him a sense of confidence, a sense that he would become somebody important. And more than this, he believed the world needed him—that if he didn’t exist, things would fall apart. He believed he was called to be a great man. I wondered, as I read, where he got this confidence, and that’s when Eisenhower started talking about his family... he said his mother and father made an assumption that set the course of his life—that the world could be fixed of its problems if every child understood the necessity of their existence... If you believe your family will fall apart without you, you probably go on to believe your community will fall apart without you, and then your city and country. And in just about every dynamic you walk into, you would feel the need to lead, to hold things together, to bring life and service to the people you interact with—just as you had done when you were a kid with your family.24
Your community needs you to struggle for them. And it may begin with you filling out a volunteer form in the school office. Our kids live at their schools, and they need us to get down off the stage and go where they are. This fall our youth group plans to launch an outward-facing missional ministry in our community, and God is already opening doors for us. If we can get inside the schools in Greenwich, Connecticut, and begin serving people, then you can do it anywhere.
Last night my wife and I went to the highest point of our town to pray over our community like we always do. We passionately asked God to do an awesome work in the hearts, minds, and souls of every kid who lives in this city. We asked that God would give us favor as we try to bless the people who live and work there. We prayed for revival.
