Chapter 13 of 15

A New Measurement for Success

A New Measurement for Success

CHAPTER SEVEN

A NEW MEASUREMENT FOR SUCCESS

It’s springtime. The flowers are blooming, the rains come in every couple of days to wash everything clean, and the sun is warming us up. I just love this time of the year. But I also hate it. Springtime seems to be when churches decide to fire their youth workers. I guess they figure the spring mission trip is over, the school year is wrapping up, and they need to hire a new youth leader so that person can get used to the job before the busy fall semester begins. Three youth worker friends of mine were fired in the last two weeks. But it’s not just in the spring that I’ve seen this happen. In fact, I’ve been hearing about youth workers getting fired en masse over the last five to ten years. In all my years in youth ministry, I’ve never seen so much firing, and it makes me angry.

I had a conversation with a lead pastor about this issue, and he said he thought more youth pastors are getting fired because this generation of youth workers doesn’t know how to work hard. He said, “They’re lazy and they can’t draw a crowd.” Then he went on to say something to the effect that youth workers today can’t seem to do what he and his friends were able to do with previous generations of students. I told him he was an idiot.

Over the last 30 years, church work has become more professionalized, leading many churches to hire businessmen to implement business strategies in the church. While this change has helped the church on many fronts, such as fiscal integrity, it has also turned parishioners into clients, pastors into salesmen, and the gospel into a product. A while back I was in a meeting where an executive pastor started talking about how churches must have quantifiable and measurable goals. Now I’m all for having measurable goals (and we’ll talk about this some more later on in the chapter), but it’s very difficult to measure anything other than numbers. And once we’ve collected the numbers, we can’t help but compare them to the numbers from previous years or to other churches’ numbers.

A brilliant youth worker friend of mine called to tell me he was quitting youth ministry. He said he didn’t want to carry the weight of the church’s ridiculous expectations any longer. He was tired of having a constant pit in his stomach, and he didn’t like what the church was turning him into. Doesn’t that sound odd coming from someone who works in Jesus’ church? God forgive us!

A church asked me to do some consulting and help them find their next youth pastor. I asked if I could speak with their previous youth pastor first. They initially said they didn’t think that would be a good idea. Hmm? But I pressed it and they eventually caved and let me speak to her. It’s never a good sign if an organization, especially a church, won’t let you speak with their previous employees. So I spoke with this woman on the phone; and as we began to talk, I quickly realized that she was broken by her experience at this church. There were long periods of silence because she was weeping and couldn’t answer my questions. I spent the better portion of an hour just ministering to her and trying to repair some of the damage this church had caused.

I can empathize. Yes, I’ve worked in healthy church environments, but I’ve also ministered in unhealthy ones. I’ve endured plenty of sleepless nights and even a few stress-induced panic attacks over some difficult situations at the church. I’ve worked in an environment where the ministry took precedence over the minister, where the head count was considered a priority over heart change. We can try to spiritualize the numbers, but that approach can easily be misused. And it creates a “cog in the machine” environment for pastors. Running the race to beat last week’s/month’s/year’s numbers is exhausting and a no-win situation.

There is a crisis in American churches today: youth workers have become disposable pieces in the machinery of the church. It chews them up, leaving them damaged and traumatized. And this trend is on the rise because churches still expect large crowds of students to gather weekly, even in this progressively post-Christian environment. The world is changing, but the church’s expectations haven’t adjusted to the climate in youth culture today. The leaders in many of our churches use pressure tactics to try to get the results they want. It creates a stifling context to minister in for sure.

Let me say something here about job evaluations—just in case a lead pastor or a future lead pastor is reading this book. Most performance reviews begin with the boss telling you a few positives, and then they drop the bomb by naming all of the things you still need to work on or improve. Such a list essentially negates all of the positive things they just said about you. And there usually isn’t much constructive criticism or anything concerning your personal well-being either. It’s just a list of your “shortcomings” based on the church’s vision of what student participation should look like. You know what I’m talking about. Well, today I had my year-end review with the lead pastor of our church. And my boss handed me a document that may have been the most thoughtful and insightful review of my work and the ministry that I’ve ever seen. He began with 14 paragraphs detailing all of the wonderful things he’s been seeing. And then he dropped the bomb. The list of things I need to work on. Want to know what was on the list? Rest. That’s it. Pretty cool, huh?

He wants me to rest more, to feed my soul. He knows my pastoral heart keeps me up at night over the lives of teens. He actually pays attention to the fact that I frequently don’t get my Fridays, or any day, off each week. When there is a calendar meeting for all of the pastoral staff, his mouth drops open when he hears about the amount of time and energy my little team and I spend running after students and creating environments in which they’ll sense God’s warmth. He is aware that I spend hours every day counseling students and parents, and that when I go to a retreat or camp, it’s not a vacation for me.

So I’m taking the next six months off to rest . . . I wish!

Seriously, though, I want to work hard for a boss like that. There are some people you want to work for, for the rest of your life. And I’m so blessed to work for one of those guys.

We’ve already talked about why youth ministries around the country are numerically in decline. Culturally we are fighting an uphill battle. But in order to understand this issue further, you’ve got to get into the mind of a Christian teenager. Now imagine that you’re a 16-year-old in your church’s youth group. As Chap Clark described in his book Hurt, you have multiple authentic personalities. You have your church self, your home self, and multiple selves at school depending on which class you’re in and who you’re with. You might have a different self in English class than you do in history. And you consider all of these selves to be your authentic self in each of those environments. You just put on the “you” that feels safest in that environment.

Let’s hypothesize that your church/spiritual self only feels comfortable with loving Jesus, praying out loud, and growing spiritually at youth group meetings or church. Let’s also say that the youth pastor is asking you to invite friends from school to a youth group event. Church self doesn’t want your school friends to come to youth group because that’s the only place where your spiritual self can shine. You feel safe there when you’re away from your school friends. And you don’t want the youth group to grow. Or if it does grow, you want kids you don’t know to come so that your church self can continue to feel safe. But the youth pastor is trying to keep her job. She’s trying to keep the church board happy by doing whatever she can to grow the group numerically. Yet none of the students are willing to help her do this. In fact, the idea of the group growing bigger scares them. They like it the size it is now. They want it to stay the same. That’s one of many dilemmas youth workers face today.

Twenty years ago if I told high school students to invite friends to special events, it would double or triple the amount of students at youth group that night. Today, students don’t want their school friends to see them at youth group.

It’s like the Seinfeld episode where George’s worlds start to collide because Jerry, Elaine, and Kramer start hanging out with his fiancé Susan. George doesn’t want Susan interacting with his friends, and he definitely doesn’t want them to become friends. He doesn’t want to lose the sense of safety that keeping different aspects of his life separate provides. Why? “Because a George divided against himself cannot stand!” Students have multiple selves and multiple worlds. They don’t want their worlds to collide.

In the youth ministry world of the 1980s and 1990s, numbers determined success; they were the driving force of youth work. We even spiritualized numbers by calling them “souls.” Don’t get me wrong, numbers are indicators, and they’re important ones at that. But there are other ways to determine success in a post-Christian world—more valid ways.

INDIVIDUAL CARE

The first marker for a successful youth ministry is individual care. Does every student in your church have caring adults assigned to him or her? This has got to be our priority. Every student, no matter how he or she appears on the outside, is desperate for a dedicated fan, a loving adult to come alongside and journey through life with them. I just asked some of our tenth grade girls what the best thing about the youth group is. (I was expecting to hear things like my talks, our programs, or our mission trips.) The first thing they said was, “The adult volunteers.” They absolutely love their small group leaders! They feel heard, cared for, known, and respected.

When a kid misses youth group, we know why. We know what’s going on. When a kid misses two months of youth group because of play rehearsals at school and then shows up again after such a long time away, we don’t say, “Hey, where have you been?” We know where she’s been because her small group leader is a part of her life. Even though she couldn’t make it to youth group, she’s still been getting together with her leader for coffee after rehearsals each week.

Youth leaders should be kids’ dedicated fans. Every kid must feel cared for and pursued, and every student has to know that we want to spend time with them—and not just at “our” events. This is going to require a huge cultural shift in our churches. Members of the congregation must change from being supporters of the youth to seeing these students as their students. You’ve read the books. You know students need about four dedicated adults in their lives. The church must wake up to this need; otherwise we’ll continue losing the students we claim to love and care about. But we’ll talk about that in just a minute.

TOUCHPOINTS

Success in youth ministry shouldn’t be based on student attendance. Instead, a second indicator for success might be called touchpoints. How many times have we reached out to students this month? It’s not about how often they come to our meetings; it’s how often adult leaders have gone to their activities. How many texts or Facebook messages have they received from us? Or how many coffeehouse meetings have we invited them to? Have we reached out to them? These are called touchpoints.

There’s a student who’s been to our youth group only a couple of times this year. He’s been gone from one season to the next, beginning with cross country, SAT testing, play rehearsals, and then the golf team. But his group leader has personally spent time with him on many occasions. He’s met with this student for coffee, watched his sporting events, and texted him regularly. When our students are involved at their schools, which is what we want, then we have an opportunity to do what Jim Rayburn called incarnational ministry. God became one of us in the person of Jesus. He came to where we were. It’s time for us to get out of the youth room.

INTEGRATION WITH THE CONGREGATION

Third, we can determine the success of our ministry based on how we’re doing at assimilating students into the church body. How integrated are your students with the rest of the congregation? This is a tough one. The structures and programs of many of our churches aren’t sensitive to the fact that 15-year-olds are in the room. Case in point: we call the main service “big church.” This has got to end. We can spearhead this change and advocate for our students to be included. In order to do this, the next step of integration will help us immensely.

My great-grandmother was the youth worker at her church in Oregon from the 1930s through the 1960s. She actually led my grandmother, her future daughter-in-law, to the Lord when my grandmother was just 12 years old. All of the students sat with her in the front row every Sunday morning during the church service. They absolutely loved her. She was constantly including the students in the life of the church. This was the norm for the church back then. It was generational, and kids saw themselves as part of a multigenerational group of people called to be salt and light in their community.

Hinging on the success of groups like Young Life and Youth for Christ in the 1970s and into the 1980s, churches started hiring youth directors for the first time. They abandoned an integrated form of church life and pulled students out of the church body. They hired youth workers to run completely separate programs, retreats, missions, and services away from the church family. So what once was a group of teenagers fully integrated into the life of the church now became a youth ministry ghetto. No longer did students see their identities as being a part of the church family. Over the years this has become the norm in churches around the country, so when kids graduated from high school in the late 1980s through the present, they also left the church. Hiring a 22-year-old and paying that person an extremely low amount of money to disciple students apart from the church has an effect. Many students graduate from the youth group and simultaneously graduate from their faith.

Integration is key. Integration means we shut down the youth ministry ghetto. Integration means we put pathways back in place. It is vital that students see the generations ahead of them loving and serving Jesus—people become pathways for students. Teenagers have to be able to envision themselves as a part of the church when they’re older. And we help them do this by allowing students to serve and worship with adults who are including them in the life of the church. You won’t be able to do this overnight, but we have to carry the vision to others.

An integrated youth ministry means we stop doing a guys retreat and we join the church’s men’s retreat. It means we get students involved in leading in the main service. We give them a role and we see them as a valuable part of the church family. The system of the church must change, and we must adapt in order to receive the next generation. In order for kids to make it in the post-Christian world, they need a bunch of adults around them who see them as a part of the church family. Our job as youth workers is to lead a movement, a movement of adults who invest in this new generation. We get the privilege of carrying this vision of integration and inclusion. That means we’re always training and encouraging our adults to love students better.

So what would happen if we disbanded the youth ministry ghetto? What if we stopped running alternate programs separate from the church? What would that free us up to do? What if we integrated our mission trips and our retreats with other ministries in the church? How much freedom would that give us? I know it would create some problems, but we already have massive problems and obstacles to overcome. What solutions might this change bring? And what if students began getting their identities from being a part of the church rather than being apart from the church?

REACH OUT TO THE PARENTS

Fourth, much of a student’s success is based on his or her home environment. In fact, the National Study of Youth and Religion found that students directly inherit their parents’ faith. So if a kid’s default religion is Moralistic Therapeutic Deism, then guess what? That means their parents have given this religious construct to them. We have to reach mom and dad.

When I was 23 years old, I ran my first parent meeting. About five really good parents showed up, and I spoke to them for about an hour and a half. I talked about what was going on in our youth ministry, but then I began telling them how I thought they should be parenting their kids. After the meeting a very nice, but blunt, mom came up to me and said, “Brock, you don’t know what the hell you’re talking about!” Ouch! She was right; I was clueless.

I’m in my 40s now, and I’ve learned some things. This is key, by the way. Many youth workers get out of youth ministry before they have the wisdom and experience to help parents. Some of the best youth ministries in the country are run by youth workers in their forties and fifties. And that’s because they finally have enough real-world experience to help the parents. I have a voice in the lives of teenagers because they know I care about them; however, I also have enough life experience that I now have something to offer their parents.

If you’re a young youth pastor, you can still develop a year-round program that will help train and encourage the parents in your ministry. You can bring in guest speakers, plan retreats, and hand out resources. But if it’s true that students grow up and inherit the habits and the faith of their parents, then we must do something to acknowledge and support them.

PRAY

The next way we can measure success is with prayer. I once heard Francis Chan speak at the National Youth Workers Convention. He got up in front of a few thousand youth workers and said, “When I’m looking for a youth pastor, I’m not looking for someone who is cool and hip to youth culture. I just want someone who will pray over our students.” We all sat in silence. I was cut to the quick. I felt convicted. I sensed a calling back to Jesus. And it’s true: I can’t change anyone with my cool youth talks. I can’t change a student’s heart, but God can. I can’t even change my own daughter’s heart, but God can.

What I’ve found is that prayer works. Will someone pray for my daughter? Will someone pray for every student in my church? Will someone join me in bringing our students before the throne of God? This is what I look for whenever I hire someone or when we’re looking for youth ministry volunteers. So how much are you praying? This is a vital measure for success.

Think about it: your boss calls you into his office and asks, “How are things going in the youth ministry?”

And you say, “We’ve got 20 people praying for our students every day, and we’re seeing God work because of it.” Success!

STORIES OF TRANSFORMATION

Lastly, we can measure our success by stories. In particular, stories of transformation. What is God doing? How is he working? What prayers is he answering? When we have a great event and more than the usual number of students show up, I don’t go around the office or stand in front of the church and tell them how many students came. If I did that, then I’d be telling everyone that I measure success by the numbers. Instead, I tell stories to anyone who will listen: to the administrative assistants, maintenance workers, fellow pastors, moms, and my neighbors. I tell anyone who will listen. And then I invite them to pray for the students in those stories.

I make the rounds at least a couple of times a month. I just walk around the office and carry the vision of our students to my coworkers. I tell them about students like Evan and Freddie and Harry. I tell them about Ruth and Krista and Zoe and Jenny. I tell them what God is doing in their lives. This habit of mine has caused people to no longer ask, “So how many kids did you have last night?” Instead they ask, “So what did God do?” Then I get to brag about my Jesus.

Success is a funny word in the context of ministry. Somehow it has come to mean large not deep, loud not still, and entertaining not equipping. I love Mike Yaconelli’s legendary talk about getting fired for the glory of God. And I’m baffled by the fact that Jesus would probably get fired from many of today’s churches. According to the religious leaders of his day, Jesus said the wrong things, did the wrong things, and reached the wrong people; and eventually, the crowds died down. He even looked at the Twelve and asked, “You do not want to leave too, do you?” (John 6:67, NIV).

As ministers of the gospel, let’s be the standard-bearers. It’s our mission to carry a new vision of caring for students and loving them through this tough terrain called life. The church today might never be kind to this generation of youth workers. Like the prophets of old, we might get stoned (and I don’t mean on pot). So let’s travel lightly, love deeply, forgive quickly, pray often and pray desperately, speak truth, and, like the prophets, be ready to move.

↑ Back to top

↑