Chapter 10 of 15

Embrace Tolerance

Embrace Tolerance

People need to know that the faith is big enough for them. That our orthodoxy is generous and allows for all kinds of positions on all kinds of issues. We need to remember to keep the main thing the main thing. Some things in the Christian faith are just relative. They are minor issues that can sometimes, mistakenly, take center stage. You can be a Christian, a follower of Jesus, and land in a different place on a host of topics and issues. It’s what makes the faith so beautifully complex. And I believe the mystery of such things is a purposeful, sovereign act of God. We must show the world that we can disagree yet still love and respect each other.

To embrace Christian relativism is to embrace a unified faith. It’s to embrace each other. Followers of Jesus must see the beauty in our diversity. To embrace Christian relativism is to actually live out Philippians 2. Check out verses one through four in The Message:

If you’ve gotten anything at all out of following Christ, if his love has made any difference in your life, if being in a community of the Spirit means anything to you, if you have a heart, if you care—then do me a favor: Agree with each other, love each other, be deep-spirited friends. Don’t push your way to the front; don’t sweet-talk your way to the top. Put yourself aside, and help others get ahead. Don’t be obsessed with getting your own advantage. Forget yourselves long enough to lend a helping hand.

Does agreeing with each other mean we agree on everything? I think not. It means we agree to love each other, to embrace each other, to honor each other’s perspective. We must show students who are struggling in this post-Christian world what unity really is, what Christian relativism can look like, that we will cherish whatever they faithfully bring to the table as followers of Jesus. Now, I want you to know that I am aware of the danger here, but let me talk about that after my next point.

About a year ago I received an email from a parent telling me that her ninth grade daughter would no longer be coming to our youth group. The family doesn’t attend church, although they consider themselves religious, and the parents felt their daughter’s regular attendance at our church would end up confusing her. In the middle of her email, the mom basically said their family doesn’t believe the things we believe. I wondered which of our beliefs would cause them to pull their daughter out of our group. So I called the mom and asked. Her response was that we probably didn’t agree on hell, homosexuality, and other issues like that. I told her our group focuses on Jesus, and Christians hold to all kinds of positions on those issues. I also stressed to her that all are welcome in our church—but to no avail. We haven’t seen that girl at youth group since. The perception that Christians are closed-minded and not welcoming was just too great for me to overcome in a phone conversation.

EMBRACE TOLERANCE

I realize the word tolerance, and maybe this whole chapter, might be setting off some warning sirens inside of you. But when did tolerance become our enemy? Don’t get me wrong, I know what tolerance has come to mean in our culture. I just want to reclaim the word.

Tolerance doesn’t write anyone off. True tolerance says you can belong before you believe. Tolerance embraces different thinking, differing views, and differing ideas—it embraces. What I find interesting is that the most tolerant students in our youth group are the ones who bring their friends most often. Why? Because they know how to tolerate their friends, and they also tolerate me as their youth leader. Our most tolerant kids are our best evangelists because they respect their friends’ beliefs. At the same time, they are experiencing the transformative love of Jesus, and they want their friends to experience him too.

A student named Codey got involved with our youth group after he found the Lord at a summer camp. When he returned home, he told his aunt that he really needed to find a church. So they went looking for one and, fortunately for us, found ours. Codey has such a beautiful walk with Jesus, and he’s one of the most thoughtful students I’ve ever met. When I first met Codey, his brother wasn’t a Christian. And Codey doesn’t have a single Christian friend at his school. Yet somehow Codey is a light, and his brother and friends all feel respected by him.

In fact, just last week Codey’s brother went to camp with our youth group and surrendered his life to Jesus. It was amazing to watch the brothers embrace each other in a mutual love for Christ. I think one of the main reasons why Codey’s brother invited Jesus into his life was because Codey has been consistently patient, kind, and respectful toward him.

Codey told me a friend of his has been getting into Buddhism, and he’s really been learning a lot from this friend. Initially that kind of troubled me. But then I thought, Why should this trouble me? I can’t learn from a Buddhist? Sure I can, and so can Codey. Here’s the cool thing: he said his Buddhist friend encouraged him to start meditating, so Codey decided to look to Scripture to learn how to meditate. He’s been meditating on the Psalms, and the Bible has truly been coming alive. Codey even thanked his friend for pointing him toward this spiritual discipline. Amazing! Tolerance not only accepts someone’s view, but tolerant people allow themselves to be moved, to be pushed, and to be shaped.

All truth is God’s truth, even if a Buddhist says it. So we don’t need to cover up the fact that truth exists in other faiths and religions. Our students will realize it sooner rather than later, and we don’t want them to be shocked when they hear a Muslim professor say something true. All truth is from God and belongs to him. And since we belong to God, all truth is ours.

What flies in the face of tolerance is this “Christian” notion that we have to be right all the time. For some reason Christians are willing to argue and fight, and we’ve earned a reputation for always needing to be right. Some Christians even refer to themselves as “the Christian Right.” The need to always be right colors their interactions with everyone around them. I’d hate to think that people aren’t open to Jesus because we’re perceived as not being open to them. My prayer is that this reputation dies with my generation. It’s creating a huge chasm between the post-Christian world and Christians that can’t be crossed. Instead, the world needs to know that Christians are great listeners and great learners, that we are respectful and tolerant. Those traits are appealing.

I know we’re getting into slippery-slope territory here. I can hear the questions already: “Brock, so far your first two points stink; they are ignorant and offensive. What are you thinking?! If we become Christian relativists and embrace tolerance, won’t that lead kids to reject the faith? Doesn’t that mean we’re saying there’s no absolute truth? Doesn’t this devalue the authority of Scripture? Won’t this lead to a free-for-all where people can believe anything they want to believe?” I hear you.

My first response is this: Post-Christian kids are already there. They’re already rejecting the faith, they don’t believe in absolute truth or the authority of Scripture, and they do believe whatever they want to. What I’m talking about is being tolerant toward students during their journeys, and then showing them how big our faith really is. It’s not one-size-fits-all. Not only that, but we also need to show that there is unity in the faith, a commonality that every Christian, every denomination, and every church can point to. And that commonality is the Person of Jesus. What I’m really suggesting is that we embrace humility. Anything less than that is disingenuous. I mean, what if you’re wrong about that one theological issue that you believe is so vital?

For many people, the church is a place that says, “If you don’t believe what we believe, vote how we vote, and take the same stand on issues that we take a stand on, then you don’t belong.” I believe God is calling us to bigger things and a more humble posture. He is calling us once again to trust the Holy Spirit. To trust that he will work out the minor things of the faith in the lives of our students. When a kid lands on his or her view of homosexuality, Jesus won’t fall off his throne. And who knows? Maybe over time the Holy Spirit will change a person’s mind on that issue? Then again, maybe not.

I heard about a woman from India who became a Christian during the time of British rule. The British missionaries taught the female converts how Christian women dress and keep their homes. Many of the things they taught were actually healthier, cleaner, and seemingly better ways to live. The problem was that the Indian women started to act, behave, dress, and keep their homes in ways that alienated them from their native community. And rather than encompass these new converts into their own society, the British community acted in ways that were bigoted and demeaning toward them. Feeling isolated on both sides, these Indian women struggled to survive their ostracized existence. When the church ignores the realities that new believers face and refuses to embrace them as they are, we leave people feeling isolated and with no option but to return from whence they came.

Still feeling unsure? Consider what our choice to embrace tolerance is doing for the students at Trinity. They’ve gone from rejecting the faith to reading their Bibles, writing prayers, and making life choices that are pleasing to Jesus. And it’s all because the environment of our group has allowed them to be themselves—whatever those selves might be at the time. They get to belong before they believe. And they get to belong as they wrestle with the details of those beliefs. They know they are safe in the church.

EMBRACE SPIRITUALITY

I’ve noticed a growing trend over the last few years. Some students in our youth group have been listing “spiritual” as their religious status on Facebook. Initially, this troubled me. I thought, Are they ashamed to put “Christian”? But as I said in chapter one, the word Christian has a negative connotation not only to Muslims, but also to post-Christian students. They might love Jesus, but they could never use the word Christian. It’s a curse word. It comes with too much baggage.

However, they do resonate with the word spiritual. I had to come to terms with this one. I had to figure out why I struggled with the word spiritual. I mean, I have a spiritual life, and I think of myself as a spiritual person. But I felt like the word spiritual, as it’s used in our culture anyway, was just too vague and uncommitted. (Like, pick a side, dude!) But in the context of a post-Christian world, I get it. And to be honest, I’ve become more and more uncomfortable with the word Christian. I don’t like what that word has come to mean either. So I started thinking, What if we helped students discover that the most spiritual life you can have is a life with Jesus? That knowing and following Jesus is the most spiritual way possible?

I was hanging out with Drew Williams, the lead pastor of our church (who is brilliant, by the way), when a student named Sam came over to chat with us. The three of us started talking and the conversation went to spiritual things. Sam said, “I’m one of the only religious kids in my class.”

Drew corrected him and said, “Sam, you’re not religious; you’re spiritual. Religion is man-made; spirituality is from God.”

Sam looked at him and said, “You’re right; I’m spiritual.” I kind of like that.

I know the term spirituality lacks a definitive definition. Social scientists have defined it as “the search for the sacred,” where “the sacred” is broadly defined as “that which is set apart from the ordinary.”20  I love that definition. I want to be a person who is on a quest for things that are set apart. One of the reasons we struggle with the term is because it seems to separate itself from religion. But how many of us have told students that our faith is not a religion but a relationship? So again I pose this question: What if we could show our students who are living in this pluralistic society that following Jesus is the most “spiritual life” they could live? Let’s reclaim that word and embrace it.

EMBRACE INTELLECTUALISM

I once heard an interview with Alec Baldwin during which the interviewer asked about his religion. Alec confessed that he goes to church every Sunday. When the interviewer asked him why, Alec responded, “Oh, because I love going and listening to professional thinkers.” And I thought, YES! Professional thinkers—that’s how I want Christians to be seen.

When I was in my late twenties, I started a habit of reading works written by agnostic, atheistic, or liberal-minded writers. I wanted to challenge myself a bit and get into the minds of people who don’t believe in God because of their intellectual sensibilities. The first book I read floored me and sent me into a time when I doubted and questioned my own faith. But I figured if I couldn’t handle these topics and work through serious questions, then I shouldn’t be a youth pastor leading students into faith. I needed to wrestle a bit. It was important. One night at youth group, I was getting ready to walk out and explain the cross. It was a communion service, and I was preparing myself to point our students to Jesus in the clearest way possible. But I wasn’t feeling very clear-minded; I was doubting and unsure. The worship band finished playing their last song, and I walked onto the stage in the midst of my doubts. I decided to stay faithful to what I was called to do as a pastor. I pointed them to Jesus. After that, I continued to wrestle and pursue truth, which brought depth to my shallowness. All truth is God’s truth, and we can’t be afraid of where truth might lead us. For me, it led me back to Jesus.

Socrates believed that intellectualism allowed a person to do what is right or best just as soon as they truly understood what is right or best. Understanding is critical for so many intellectual teenagers. If we don’t embrace intelligent thinking and show students how sociology and science and psychology don’t have to be at odds with the faith, then we are missing it. You can be a liberal-minded evolutionist and still follow Jesus. As Josh McDowell says, you don’t have to check your brains at the door. If we don’t embrace humble intellectualism, then we’ll miss a whole barrage of post-Christian students.

Our students ask questions that I didn’t begin to ask until I was in my twenties. While I was leading a small group of sixth grade boys, one said, “I’m agnostic; I don’t really believe this stuff.” This kid went on to talk about why he couldn’t have faith because of what he believed about science. He’d watched something on the History Channel that talked about the earliest religions, prior to Christianity, and how they had a virgin birth messiah story as well. This kid’s mind and his thoughts needed to be embraced, not disregarded.

A couple of years ago, a high school senior asked to meet with me to talk about the faith. She told me she just couldn’t believe what I believed. I asked her why. She said science keeps her from faith. She longed to have faith like mine, but she just couldn’t make the leap. I asked what her issues were exactly. She mentioned evolution. I told her to go ahead and believe in evolution; most Christians around the world are actually theistic evolutionists. She was surprised by this and felt relieved. She didn’t want to abandon her faith, but she felt like society and the church were asking her to choose between faith and intellectual pursuit. God, in that moment, became so much bigger to her.

But keep this in mind: she didn’t need me to show her that my way of thinking was wrong or that a conservative’s way of thinking is reasonable—although there might be times when that is necessary. What she needed to see was that Christian faith is not at odds with her desire to learn and her respect for the natural world.

Modernists in the twentieth century loved to help Christians defend their faith. Liberal attacks in the early 1900s caused the Christian community to move to an insular, more defensive posture, which put us at odds with “the intellectual world.” And at times we still use this language today. But intellectual honesty is so refreshing to our students. We have to become professional thinkers who join in and keep the beautiful questions alive. We must become the keepers of the questions, the ones to whom skeptics and thinkers are drawn.

EMBRACE MYSTERY

Intellectualism gets you only so far. As I embrace my mind and am open to the questions of others, I will come to a place where faith is required. All of my thinking and intellectual answers will come to an end, and this is where mystery begins. Reason and mystery give rise to each other as they act in relationship to one another giving us a depth we did not posses before.

We used to have quarterly “Doubt Nights” in our high school group. During the week before these evenings, students would write down their questions and their doubts about the faith. Then we’d pick a few and talk about them at the event. Our rule was that we didn’t allow “pat answers.” No easy answers to complex questions. But as the evening went on, we’d strategically lead students toward this idea of mystery, beautiful mystery. We’d share how God is so big and amazing and beyond us; that he is God and we are not. And every Doubt Night would end in exuberant worship. We’d worship the God who is above us and beyond our imaginations, who walks in front of our understanding. Honestly, students were never more engaged in worship than they were on these nights, and mystery got them there. Unanswered questions open us up to the bigness of God. When we offer pat answers to complex questions, we shrink God down to our level. We’ve gotten rid of all the mystery. Don’t be afraid of mystery.

In a post-Christian world, mystery is acceptable. In fact, it draws students in. The modern world of the nineteenth century longed for answers to every question, but that’s not the post-modern, post-Christian world we’re living in today. Show students the mysteries of faith, and you’ll find that they’ll be drawn into worship.

EMBRACE THE MIRACULOUS

I went to a seminary that taught that miracles don’t happen much today, that we live in a different dispensation of time in which God doesn’t use miracles to get our attention, that the Holy Spirit just empowers people to be disciplined but doesn’t do much else.

When we first arrived at Trinity Church, we were met with such opposition to the faith. The students didn’t—they couldn’t—believe in God. And especially not Jesus. So after about six months of building relational trust, I told them how I appreciated their doubts and their questions about the faith. But now I wanted them to do an experiment with me. I asked them to take their doubts and put them to the side for just a bit, for just a little while. And then I challenged them to open their lives to Jesus and see what would happen. I knew many of them were full of anxiety and needed God’s peace. I suggested they ask God for it. I knew many of their families were really struggling. I asked them to invite Jesus into the middle of all of that. I was super nervous about doing this; but after studying what’s been happening in Europe, I knew the post-Christian world is open to the miraculous. They long to see God move in real and true ways. If he is real, they want to experience him. So I prayed quietly, “God, you’d better come through here!”

Would you believe that God was getting ready to not only show himself to our students, but also increase my faith? God started answering prayers, students were coming to faith every week, and this little experiment of mine was working. And then we all went to camp. You’ll never guess what happened next.

On the first night of camp, we began our worship time. Now you have to remember who I’m dealing with here. These students didn’t know a single worship song, so projecting the lyrics was super important. Just as we began strumming our guitars, someone turned off the generator, and the light bulb in the projector went up in smoke. The projector was now dead, which meant the evening’s program was going to be a bit more difficult to present. One of our students, who’d been experiencing God in prophetic ways, came to me and said he thought we should pray for the projector. I told him the bulb was broken and I’d tried everything I could think of to get the projector working again; it was impossible to fix. I clearly remember his response. He said, “Exactly.” Basically, this tenth grade boy stood there and challenged me to have faith.

So we plugged my laptop into the projector and placed our hands on that stupid thing. I prayed these words, “God, it would be super cool if you could heal this projector.” And then I added for good measure, “And we don’t even need it on Friday night, Lord. Just get us through Thursday night’s program.” In a flash of light, the projector turned on and a verse from my keynote presentation on Acts 1 shone brightly on the wall:

“But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit comes on you; and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth.” (Acts 1:8, NIV)

I was surprised, stunned, and I think a little pee came out.

But here’s the really crazy thing: That projector worked every night of camp. Word got out amongst our group that God had healed our projector and that I’d prayed it would work through Thursday night. So then Thursday evening rolled around, the worship time came to a close, and I was praying with a student as the band strummed their last chord. Suddenly, the projector shut down. It just stopped working, and the light bulb was blackened and broken. Kids fell to their knees in wonder at the mystery of the God who not only heals anxiety and broken hearts, but also turns on small electrical appliances! He does so because he loves us and longs to be known by us.

I asked a European friend of mine what post-Christian Europeans are looking for spiritually. He simply said, “They are looking for a God who is alive and working, who answers their prayers and blows their minds.” I thought, Well, that sure sounds like the God I’ve been running into lately. To be open to the miraculous doesn’t mean you have to have pink hair and fake eyelashes, shake around the room, and preach health and wealth. You don’t have to be weird. You can be intellectually sound, yet still believe that God is at work in miraculous ways. Maybe James meant what he wrote when he said, “You do not have because you do not ask God” (James 4:2, NIV).

EMBRACE ANSWERS

About 10 years ago, a bunch of post-modern youth ministry books hit Christian bookstores all over the country. These books taught that youth workers have to antagonize and challenge Christian thinking and instigate students to question their faith. At the time I completely agreed with their premise—and I still do in certain settings. But here’s the danger: When your students are already asking critical questions because they’re living in a culture that’s antagonistic to the faith, then we must affirm faith when we see it.

Now, if little Tommy, a homeschooler who’s been sheltered his whole life, offers a pat Christian answer to a very complex issue, then by all means challenge him! Make him uncomfortable and bring depth to his shallow faith. But if little Tommy is already struggling with faith because of his intellect, and he does verbalize faith, then affirm him. When he finds answers, encourage him and embrace his answers. I love that old saying, “Comfort the afflicted, and afflict the comfortable.” I believe the same thing applies here: Affirm those who come to answers with difficulty, and challenge those who come to answers easily. We must know our audience.

Our mid-week program’s teachings are based around the big questions of life. When a volunteer leader first joined our youth ministry team last year, he thought his job was to antagonize our students’ answers—to question them and help them think critically. He grew up in a post-modern youth ministry program and just assumed this was the same approach we used today. But what he didn’t realize was that our students have already worked through the criticisms of the faith. They have those down. They’re post-Christian, after all. So what they really needed was for someone to help them see that their newfound faith is reasonable and makes sense. They need to know they’re on the right track.

Every year we take our juniors and seniors on a “Theological Road Trip.” Our goal is to help students land on the majors of the faith. We want them thinking theologically about everything. So this year we traveled to Princeton University, and, as I mentioned earlier, Dr. Kenda Creasy Dean was our keynote speaker. She stood in front of our students and just loved them. You could tell that, yes, she’s a brilliant professor, but she’s also a youth worker at heart. She really showed our students the bigness of our faith, that Christianity has a generous orthodoxy, that the faith makes sense, and that the answers they’ve been landing on are true. So many of our students are new to the faith, and we want to affirm this in them.

Youth ministry today is no easy task. You have to be a sociologist, a counselor, a pastor and a teacher, and an intellectual European charismatic. Ha! Tough stuff. And you have to do all of this in a world where it seems like everyone else is traveling on a freeway headed in the opposite direction—away from Jesus. But here’s the truth: God has called you, and he actually believes in you. He knows that you and I can do this. And as we embrace this world with the kindness and love of Jesus, we will see students rise up and discover who they really are. What a gift. What a dream job!

↑ Back to top

↑