The Home Front: Marriage, Ministry, and Adoption
The Home Front: Marriage, Ministry, and Adoption
Beaver Falls, Pa., 2002, and Purcellville, Va., 2002–2009
I could fill a whole book about Kent Butterfield—if he’d let me! I could tell you how his soft brown eyes put me immediately at ease. I could tell you how his outstretched hand placed on my lower back dissipates the tension from the day away. I could tell you how his practical jokes still stump me. I could tell you about the time that I celebrated the departure of two weeks of back-to-back needy houseguests. One guest from the group would root me out of the bathroom in constant need of detailed and specialized kitchen equipment: “Rosaria, where is your Pampered Chef garlic press (spring-form pan, electric rice maker, water-filtering system)?” I commemorated her absence by taking a long shower with the bathroom door unlocked. Suddenly, the door opened. I felt a rush of cold air and someone said, in a voice I couldn’t place, “Mrs. Butterfield? Where is the Williams Sonoma cappuccino maker?” I screamed! Kent confessed his joke. It is a good thing that his outstretched hand cures the twitch in my back, because his practical jokes assemble the plucky comic relief of our life in ministry and our marriage.
Kent is my husband, my best friend, my prayer partner for life, and my one true love. But, alas, dear reader, I cannot write a whole book on Kent Butterfield. He is too humble and modest to allow it. Or perhaps he is too fearful about the details that I might share! Either way, you will have to make do with the book that continues here.
How did a woman like me ever get married? I do not know many feminists who hold the institution of marriage as radically negative or dangerous as I had in my past. While I was researching the Religious Right in the early 1990s, I subscribed to some Christian women’s journals. My favorite was entitled Adam’s Rib and was published by the Promise Keepers. My lesbian friends and I would pore over this magazine and howl in laughter at its absurdity. I could not imagine people with two or three synapses still firing in their neuro-pathways that could live this way. The pictures in the magazine seemed right out of the 19th century. And the issues these women addressed? My three favorites were these: should women wear pants (no metaphor intended), should women be college-educated, and should the 19th amendment be repealed? That marriage was slavery, as first feminist Mary Wollstonecraft declared in the 18th century, was never more obvious to me than in the pages of Adam’s Rib. (Of course the title for me and my friends was worthy of a few good cackles too.)
Before I became one of Christ’s own, this was how I viewed the institution of marriage: as dangerous and as something to be avoided. When the subject of “gay marriage” would come up among my friends, I would respond by asking, “Why add good people to a sick institution?”
Kent and I were married on May 19, 2001, in the church where Kent had graduated from seminary the night before. Our wedding was simple—cold cuts from Sam’s club and sweet ice tea by the gallons. We even rearranged and reused the flowers that were “gently used” by the previous night’s ceremony!
Our wedding was officiated by two pastors: Pastor Bruce Backensto and Pastor Doug Comin. Doug was Kent’s pastor and Bruce was mine. Before I met Doug, a colleague warned me about him like this: “Rosaria, had he met you before you were converted, he would have stoned you to death before asking the first question.” After I had met Doug, read a selection of his sermons and books-in-progress (he is one of the most prolific writers I know), sat under his preaching for a season, and had the privilege to get to know his family (including spending our daughter Mary’s first homecoming at his home for Thanksgiving), this caricature of Doug became even more baffling. Doug is his own man and a gifted scholar as well. I had friends like Doug in graduate school: they could make high theory out of pepperoni pizza and juggle fourteen Modern Language Association interviews without popping a pimple. Doug is super smart and his ability to put his finger on the pulse of sin and just hold it there can just knock your socks off. His capacity to weave a text together, layering scripture upon life premise or pain, so that the end result is neither intellectual nor experiential but something both deeper and wiser, is unsettling. Doug has slow-motion impact. Doug’s integrity silently commands a response-in-kind.
One component of Christian weddings in the Reformed Presbyterian church is something called the “biblical charge.” In it, the pastor charges (i.e., commands or exhorts) the groom and bride to remember God’s authority in creating the institution of marriage. I quote here in full, with the author’s permission, the biblical charge written and delivered to us by Pastor Doug Comin at our wedding:
Dearly beloved, we are not gathered here today in order to observe a social convention devised by human wisdom for the mutual comfort and happiness of men and women.
Nor do we assemble here to participate in a mere tradition which has come down to us from ages past and which we have deemed to be worth preserving among ourselves.
We are gathered in this place in order to acknowledge, celebrate, and solemnize the divine institution of marriage, which is ordained by the Creator and Savior of the world, sealed and governed by His authority, and entered into by His people with humble obedience and heartfelt rejoicing for the wondrous provision of the Lord for their mutual happiness and completion.
It is the popular misconception of marriage as a mere social convention or quaint tradition invented by the brain of man which has led to the denigrating of this holy relation, the multiplication of unspeakable immorality, the common unrest between husbands and wives, and the gradual disintegration of society and civilization.
For if marriage exists merely by human authority then men and women may do with it or conduct themselves in it as they please. They may redefine it, or they may abandon it altogether. But if marriage is a divine institution, then it is governed by a higher authority. It becomes, then, a matter of obedience, and the conduct of husbands and wives within marriage is a conduct for which they must give their account to God.
The original institution of marriage is therefore basic to our understanding of marriage, our estimation of marriage, and our right behavior in marriage.
The fact that marriage is a divine institution is emphasized in the very beginning of God’s written revelation. The creation of the human race was not complete until the institution of marriage was sealed by God Himself.
And the Lord God said, “It is not good that man should be alone; I will make him a helper comparable to him.” Out of the ground the Lord God formed every beast of the field and every bird of the air, and brought them to Adam to see what he would call them. And whatever Adam called each living creature, that was its name. So Adam gave names to all cattle, to the birds of the air, and to every beast of the field. But for Adam there was not found a helper comparable to him. And the Lord God caused a deep sleep to fall on Adam, and he slept; and he took one of his ribs, and closed up the flesh in its place. Then the rib which the Lord God had taken from man he made into a woman, and he brought her to the man. And Adam said, “This is now bone of my bones, And flesh of my flesh; she shall be called Woman because she was taken out of Man.” Therefore a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife and they shall become one flesh. (Gen. 2:18-24)
There are many important truths contained in these verses, and time does not permit us to address them all on this occasion. Several foundational facts, however, may be noted:
1. It was “not good” for the man to be alone. He was incomplete, and what was necessary to make him complete was his wife. Men and women are not independent individuals who happen to share the same dwelling. They are mutually dependent upon one another and each is incomplete without the other.
The Apostle Paul applies this truth of the mutual dependence of men and women when he writes:
But I want you to know that the head of every man is Christ, the head of woman is man, and the head of Christ is God… For man is not from woman but woman from man. Nor was man created for the woman but woman for the man… Nevertheless, neither is man independent of woman, nor woman independent of man, in the Lord. For as woman came from man, even so man also comes through woman; but all things are from God. (1 Cor. 11:3-12)
2. God made Adam experience the fact that he was incomplete. It was necessary for the man to be made aware of his incompleteness before God brought his wife to him. Had this not been so, he would tend to regard her as a nice, but really unnecessary addition to himself. He would view her as something that he could take or leave. But God prepared him to receive her—and treat her—as one who was necessary for his own completion.
3. Adam was utterly passive in the institution of marriage. God made him fall into a deep sleep, and while the man slept, God created the woman who would make him complete. Since marriage is by God’s design, and not by man’s, it is plain that marriage must conform to God’s will.
4. The woman was created by God with special “hands on” care, which signified her special nature as a creature made in the image of God. Someone has written, “The woman has had a long history of being trampled on. This has especially been the case in heathen civilizations. She has differed little from the cattle that a man owned. Even in the church the notion has prevailed with some that the wife is a lowly creature, fit to bear whatever abuse the man might pour on her. Men have disdained their wives as if this were true piety, because the man is head of his wife. Every such notion and practice is cut off by the account of the woman’s creation in a position of high honor.”
5. The woman was created, not from the dust of the earth, but out of the very substance of the man. Adam recognized her as “bone of his bones, and flesh of his flesh.” Jesus emphasized this truth and its implications:
And he answered and said to them, “Have you not read that he who made them at the beginning ‘made them male and female,’ and said, ‘For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh’? So then, they are no longer two but one flesh. Therefore, what God has joined together, let not man separate.” (Matt. 19:4-5)
The mysterious and intimate union which God designed between a husband and wife is the reason that the dissolution of marriage, whether by divorce or by death, is such a painful and devastating experience. The separation of a husband and wife is like the severing of a part of the body. This truth also has important implications for how husbands and wives are to treat one another, as we will see.
The original account of creation, then, lays the groundwork for marriage as a divine institution for the mutual good of men and women in order that they may be complete. But even more important than the happiness of men and women found in this union is the fact that marriage was instituted in order to fully manifest the image of God. Thus we read in Genesis 1:27, “So God created man in his own image; in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them.”
The union of men and women in marriage is therefore put forth in the scripture as a mirror, or image, or the relationship between God and His people. In the Old Testament God speaks of Israel as a bride which he betrothed to Himself, and the New Testament portrays the Church as the Bride of Christ. This truth forms the basis of Paul’s commands to Christian husbands and wives concerning their mutual duties toward one another:
Wives, submit to your own husbands, as to the Lord. For the husband is head of the wife, as also Christ is head of the church; and he is the Savior of the body. Therefore, just as the church is subject to Christ, so let the wives be to their own husbands in everything. (Eph. 5:22-24)
Paul’s instruction begins with the duty of the wife toward her husband, which is to “submit to him, as unto the Lord.” Elsewhere, wives are told to be obedient to their husbands. The reason for this submission and obedience, according to the scriptures, is that the wife is to be a living illustration of the Church in its submission to Christ. When a wife refuses to live in submission to her husband, this picture of the Church’s relationship to Christ is distorted before the world.
Submission refers to the inner attitude of the heart. It is therefore invisible and secret. Obedience is the outward expression of submission seen in the behavior of the wife. A wife may outwardly obey her husband and yet inwardly despise him. She is, therefore, not in submission to him in spite of her outward behavior. If this is the case, then the picture presented is no different from those who go through the motions of religious activities and yet have no regard toward Christ in their hearts.
True religion, which is pleasing to God, is obedience which flows from the humble submission of the heart. Anything less than this in religion is hypocrisy. Likewise, that which pleases the Lord, and illustrates the beautiful relationship between Christ and his Church, is a humble submission of the heart of the wife to her husband, which results in outward obedience to his will.
This does not mean that she must do everything that he says, for Paul makes it clear that her submission is to be “in the Lord.” She is not bound to obey her husband, therefore, if he requires her to sin against God. Yet in all things that do not violate the word of God, the wife is not to overrule, oppose, or contradict her husband. By God’s design, she stands in relation to her husband as the Church stands in relation to Christ. The Church is not the ruling head over Christ, but the obeying body, and the wife is to imitate this relationship toward her husband.
“But what if my husband is unreasonable?” This cannot be said of Christ, but it may certainly be said in regard to many husbands.
“Am I bound to submit and obey even if my husband is clueless?”
Wives, likewise, be submissive to your own husbands, that even if some do not obey the Word, they, without a word, may be won by the conduct of their wives, when they observe your chaste conduct accompanied by fear. (1 Pet. 3:1-2)
God’s word is clear. Even if your husband is an unbeliever, your purpose is not to make him submit to you, but rather to win him to submission to the Lord through the example of your own humble conduct so that he is won “without a word.”
The “fear” of which Peter speaks is not fear of the husband, but fear of the Lord. This is why Solomon’s description of the virtuous woman says, “Charm is deceitful and beauty is vain; but a woman who fears the Lord shall be praised.”
To a God-fearing wife, it is important that God’s word not be blasphemed, especially on account of her. Paul wrote to Titus that the younger women in the Church were to be taught “to be discreet, chaste, homemakers, good, obedient to their husbands, that the word of God may not be blasphemed.
He understood that the conduct of a wife in marriage presents a picture of the Church’s relationship to Christ. For a wife to be indiscreet, unfaithful, independent, unhelpful, and disobedient to her husband would therefore reflect upon the glory of Christ.
Let all of your conduct as a wife, therefore, be governed by this understanding—you represent before God, before your husband, and before the world the humble character of the Church in relation to Jesus Christ.
Now to the husband, Paul writes:
Husbands, love your wives, just as Christ also loved the church and gave Himself for her, that he might sanctify and cleanse her with the washing of water by the Word, that he might present her to Himself a glorious church, not having spot or wrinkle or any such thing, but that she should be holy and without blemish. So husbands ought to love their own wives as their own bodies; he who loves his wife loves himself. For no one ever hated his own flesh, but nourishes and cherishes it, just as the Lord does the church. (Eph. 5:25-29)
Again, the instruction is based upon the reflection in marriage of the glorious relationship between Christ and His Church. Here, however, we find that the husband stands not in the place of the Church, but in the place of Christ as he relates to his wife.
Immediately, the sinful pride of man begins to assert itself! This is wonderful! That means that I am the head! I am the boss! I give the orders and she must do what I say! But wait! The word does not say, “Husbands, rule your wives as Christ rules the Church.” It says, “Husbands, love your wives as Christ loved the Church, and gave Himself for her.” The first thing that we must understand is that “love” is not put forth here as a feeling or emotion. The world defines love in this way, but the Bible speaks of love not in terms of feeling but of action. Love “does this” and love “does not do that” for the promotion of the good of its object.
When God says, “Husbands love your wives,” he is not commanding you to feel a certain way toward them—he is commanding you to act in a certain way toward them, regardless of how you feel!
And how did Christ show His love for the Church by His actions?
For even the Son of Man did not come to be served, but to serve, and to give his life a ransom for many. (Mark 10:45)
Greater love has no one than this, than to lay down one’s life for his friends. (John 15:13)
He was willing to sacrifice everything for the welfare of His Bride, not looking to His own welfare, comfort, happiness, or fulfillment, but surrendering all of this in order to bless her and make her complete.
Such a husband is not difficult to submit to! But a husband who takes the role of a tyrant toward his wife will only provoke her inclination to resist him. What is worse, when a Christian husband lords it over his wife in a harsh and unloving manner, he declares to the world that Christ rules over his church in the same way.
There is no doubt that the scripture teaches the husband’s headship over the wife in marriage, for Paul clearly declares “the head of every man is Christ, the head of woman is man, and the head of Christ is God.” And again he says, “For the husband is head of the wife, as also Christ is head of the church.”
Yet the role of the Christian husband, according to God’s design for marriage, is not to press his headship or to assert his rule, but rather to demonstrate it according to the pattern of Christ. He is to love his wife in the same way that Christ loved the Church—that is, by self-sacrifice. Test your love toward your wife by the scripture’s own definition of love in 1 Corinthians 13:
Love suffers long and is kind;
When you are tempted to be impatient and harsh with your wife, remember the infinite patience that Christ has shown toward you, and continues to show on a daily basis.
Love does not envy; love does not parade itself, is not puffed up;
When you are tempted to be jealous for preeminence over your wife, remember Christ who did not think it beneath Himself to wash the feet of His disciples.
Love does not behave rudely, does not seek its own;
When you are tempted to insist upon your own way, and belittle your wife, remember the condescension of Christ, who left the glorious habitation of heaven, clothed Himself with flesh, and endured the shame and suffering of the cross all for the sake of your own helpless, hopeless soul.
Love is not provoked,
When you are tempted to raise your voice in frustration against your wife, remember Christ, who “when he was reviled, did not revile in return.”
Love thinks no evil; does not rejoice in iniquity, but rejoices in the truth;
When you are tempted to judge her motives, or to exalt in being proven right when she is in the wrong, remember Christ who had every right to think evil of you and to rejoice in your destruction, but instead took your shame upon Himself and covered you with His righteousness.
When you are tempted to belittle your wife, or to sit quietly while others tear her down, remember Christ, who comes to the defense of His sheep and stands between them and the accuser.
Love bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things.
When you are tempted to throw in the towel, and surrender hope that your marriage can continue—when conflicts mount and it seems that it would be easier to walk away than to persevere, remember Christ who bears your sin daily in order to cause your hope to persevere until the end, and who promises “I will never leave you nor forsake you.” The love of Christ for His people is not based upon any worthiness within them, nor should your love toward your wife be conditioned upon her actions and your judgment as to whether or not she has earned your love.
Love never fails.
Therefore, what God has joined together, let no man separate. In all of these things, and in many more ways, the self-sacrificial, loving headship of the Christian husband mirrors the love of Christ for His Church. This is your calling as you enter into this sacred union. But there is more.
Paul speaks of the purpose for which headship has been committed to the husband in marriage. It is for the edification of his wife in all purity and holiness. Your role, then, as a Christian husband, is to nurture your wife in the faith, and to provide for her spiritual as well as her physical welfare. Christ ever lives to make intercession for the saints. You must, therefore, pray constantly for and with your wife. Christ nourishes His Church with the milk and meat of His word. You must therefore minister the word to your wife, and teach her to know the deep things of God.
Finally, Paul summarizes the whole matter with these words:
For we are members of his body, of his flesh and of his bones. “For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh.” This is a great mystery, but I speak concerning Christ and the church. Nevertheless let each one of you in particular so love his own wife as himself, and let the wife see that she respects her husband. (Eph. 5:30-33)
“In the world,” it has been said, “marriage is a battlefield on which a vicious, relentless struggle rages between the tyrant-husband and the rebel-wife. Now the one, now the other, is temporarily victorious. At present in our society, the rebellious woman has the upper hand. If the world lasts, the male will again assert himself, overthrow the woman’s dominance, and rule her more tyrannically than before.”
Over and against this stands God’s glorious design of Christian marriage, in which husband and wife are joined together as one flesh—not competing individuals vying for supremacy—each fulfilling an essential role and together manifesting the wondrous beauty of God’s love, care, and provision for His precious Bride to the glory of Jesus Christ.
May our Lord so bless this union, that it is a living and true portrait of the mystery of Christ and his Church.
—Married by God’s Design, Pastor Doug Comin
I quote this text in full because it shows that in Christ anyone can have a good marriage. Jesus is an equal opportunity Prophet, Priest and King: He equips, strengthens, forgives, comforts, and brings into fruition the reality of sanctification. Jesus can equip anyone—no matter how lost or broken—for godly living. I’m living proof of that.
I also quote this text in full because, like our vows for membership in the Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America, it still startles me. I still hear this text with the ears of both an insider and an outcast.
As a newly married Christian woman, I had to confront this dual point of view, this insider/outsider identity. I also had to confront something that may seem so obvious it is not worthy to mention: I had to confront my age. I was 39 years old when I married Kent. I was too old to have children (without fertility treatments). This was startling to me. I had spent my childbearing years fighting windmills and now I was, yet again, waking up to my life. There is a biblical principle that lies behind my confusion: people whose lives are riddled with unrestrained sin act like rebellious children. Sin, when unrestrained, infantilizes a person. Here I had thought that I was so mature, so capable, so “important” in the world, and the truth remains that I didn’t even know how to act my age! After conversion, I was surprised to discover how old I really was.
When you come to Christian marriage from a feminist perspective, the most difficult idea to embrace is that of a husband’s headship and a wife’s submission. When I’m looking at this paradigm from a secular perspective, it smacks of the abuses of patriarchy. But when I’m seeing it through Christ-centered eyes—as Doug Comin’s biblical marriage charge exhorts—Kent’s headship and my submission has been a source of comfort and solidarity. When Christ is at the center of our marriage, Kent’s headship and my submission has allowed us to be a functional team. When Christ is at the center of our marriage, we don’t struggle with what Ken and Floy Smith have identified as a major antagonist of Christian life in our century: a “right-of-choice” mentality. When Christ is at the center, each major decision does not throw us into crisis. Each joy and each danger does not make the walls of our relationship crumble.
I don’t mean to imply that I have never felt oppressed or undervalued by my role or that Kent has never felt over-burdened by his. We are human. And our feelings, like the rest of our being, are fallen too. We each have struggled with our roles, more in the first year of our marriage than today. But when we are in sync, in Christ’s center, together we are like a hammock, bearing the weight of our labors and ministry in the most efficient way. When we got married, Ken and Floy gave us a copy of one of the books that they have written. It is called Learning to be a Family. The twelve chapters of this Christian workbook outline the picture of the happy family found in Psalm 128. Ken and Floy’s book helps me to articulate—even when I can’t manifest or apply it—the process and the balance of what it means to be a happy family. A happy family is not one where each member gets to do his or her own thing. A happy family fears God and strives for obedience. Psalm 1, in its entirety, outlines the happiness, prosperity, and enduring good reputation that a person receives in obedience:
How blessed is the man who does not walk in the counsel
of the wicked,
Nor stand in the path of sinners,
Nor sit in the seat of scoffers!
But his delight is in the law of the Lord,
And in his law he meditates day and night.
He will be like a tree firmly planted by streams of water,
Which yields it fruit in its season
And its leaf does not wither;
And in whatever he does, he prospers.
The wicked are not so,
But they are like chaff which the wind drives away.
Therefore the wicked will not stand in the judgment,
Nor sinners in the assembly of the righteous.
For the Lord knows the way of the righteous,
But the way of the wicked will perish. (NASB)
When Christ is at the center, the distinct roles that we assume have allowed us to claim unity in Christian heritage (by understanding the origin of the family as outlined in the first three chapters of Genesis and in the catechism questions that ask: “Who made you?” [God]; “Of what were you made?” [Of dust]; “What doth that teach you?” [To be humble and mindful of death].) Even without the experiential wisdom of a Christian history or practice in our families of origin, Kent and I claim a Christian heritage through Christ’s redemption. That is, we know that no one is naturally “born into” the family of God. Being “born again” is the equal footing that we all need. Adoption is not just a Christian metaphor or the process by which we became parents: adoption into Christianity is the process by which we claim our heritage.
One of the texts commonly used by members of our denomination for family Bible study is the Westminster Shorter Catechism. It was written for lay people (technically, “babes and imbeciles”!) in the 1640s by an assembly called the “Westminster Divines,” a group of pastors who also assembled the Westminster Confession of Faith and the Westminster Larger Catechism. These three texts together offer the central teachings of the Reformation. The Shorter Catechism offers 107 questions on the following subjects: God as Creator (questions 1-12); Original Sin (questions 13-20); Christ the Redeemer (questions 21-38); The Ten Commandments (questions 39-84); the Sacraments of Baptism and Holy Communion (questions 85-97) and the Lord’s Prayer (questions 98-107).
The Shorter Catechism question number 34 addresses what it means to be a “born again” Christian. This Shorter Catechism question defines our born again status as adoption:
Question: What is Adoption?
Answer: Adoption is an act of God’s free grace, whereby we are received into the number, and have a right to all of the privileges of the sons of God.
We also see this outlined in the Bible, in Galatians 4:7, “Therefore, you’re no longer a slave (orphan), but a son; and if a son, then an heir through God.”
When Christ is at the center, the distinct roles that we assume have allowed us to claim a unity in family purpose. Kent is called to be a pastor and with his call comes special and unique expectations upon me, his wife. When Christ is at the center, we have been able to embrace our dual call with a sense of shared obedience to God’s word.
When Christ is at the center, the distinct roles that we assume have allowed us to claim a unity in family structure. A family structure designed by foster care and adoption is a unique unit. Later in this chapter I will discuss the distinct miracle of each of our four children’s placement in our family and the pain of our one disrupted adoption. One of the distinct challenges that families like ours face is race and a confusion of birth order. Son Knox came to us in May, 2003, at 5 months, having had one foster placement. His adoption was finalized in February 2004. Daughter AJ came to us in April, 2004, at 15-and-a-half years old, having had eleven previous foster placements. Her adoption was finalized in March 2006. Daughter Mary came to us at one-hour-old. Son Knox and I got to be present at the hospital at her birth and were privileged to be the first people to hold and touch her. Mary had no foster placements and her adoption was finalized in October 2006. Foster daughter S came to us in 2007 at two days old. At the hospital we signed “foster to adopt” contract, only to have S removed from our home because the agency’s director didn’t like the placement coordinator’s choice of a “white” home for an African-American child. Son Matt came to us in February 2009 at the age of sixteen; Matt’s adoption was finalized in November 2010, with the whole family getting dressed up and going to the courthouse, returning home to a sheet cake the size of a small refrigerator and a great neighborhood celebration.
Even this book that you are reading has been marked by our family. I finished the first chapter after Knox’s arrival. AJ came in the midst of chapter two. Mary came during chapter three. S came and was taken from us during the first draft of this chapter. Chapter 5 and all revisions for publication happened when Matt came home.
Like it or not, ready or not, we enter into the spotlight of inquisition each time we leave our house, as many people want to understand what it is like to be a transracial family or to adopt a teenager. Are those your real children? Are we a real family? Do we feel like real parents? Do our children love us? How can we afford the expense of adoption? Do we trust the bonds created by adoption? Does our extended family accept us? My children are apparently so startling to many people that they figure as aberrations.
One time, Kent was filling a pulpit at a small church in a small town. These places scare me, and for good reason. Knox was asleep on my shoulder and Mary was asleep in the car seat. A man walked up to me, not knowing that I was the preacher’s wife, and said: “So, is it chic for white women to adopt black kids these days?” I took a deep breath and stood up to meet his gaze.
“Are you a Christian?” I asked him.
“Yes, ma’am,” he replied.
“Did God save you because it was chic?” We locked eyes until he dropped his head. He stammered something unintelligible and backed away slowly, seeming to understand that even when the bear does not look like the cubs, the trauma of having one’s head ripped off by a protective mama can be bloody business.
When Christ is at the center of our family, the distinct roles that we assume have allowed us to claim a unity in family purpose—even when the rest of the world can’t get beyond the transracial picture that we present.
When Christ is at the center of our marriage, our worship refreshes and equips us even as we are in the spotlight Lord’s Day after Lord’s Day. Kent and I have always had an extensive hospitality ministry. From 2002 to 2007, Kent was a church-planter in Purcellville, Va. During the first two years, I was preparing around fifty meals each Lord’s Day. The labor involved in this, and the wear and tear on our house and again, privacy, was mind-boggling. Many, many women—some strangers—came up along my side, giving me money, recipes, prayer support, and counsel. My friends from the Syracuse RP Church organized cooking days, sending up truckloads of baked goods and lasagna for our Lord’s Day fellowship meals. But even so, this intense hospitality ministry, which overlapped with the placement of five-month-old Knox and 15-and-a-half-year-old AJ, was exhausting. Learning to be refreshed in the context of intense labor is important spiritual work. God truly gave us what we needed. When Christ was at the center, we learned to “draft” off of the word the way cyclists draft off of another cyclist during a long race. Perhaps even more importantly, when Christ was at the center, we learned to say no and to close the door.
When Christ is at the center of our marriage, our work outside of the home—our service in the community—is conducted with relevance, integrity, and courage. Both in organized service (for example, planning a vacation Bible school and hosting more children for VBS than we have church members) and unplanned service (for example, hosting children in my neighborhood for play dates, preschool, knitting class, and meals during snow days and sick days) has allowed us to fulfill God’s simple directive to care for others.
When Christ is at the center of our marriage, we have been able to maintain a Christian household that ministers to others. When Christ is not at the center, all of our good intentions are swallowed up by selfishness.
How do we put Christ at the center? By intentionally holding all things captive to Christ, each moment of each day. By never daring to do anything without fervent prayer, seeking the Lord’s wisdom, counsel, blessing, and life-sustaining breath. I learned, during those years, that the idea that one is ever too busy to pray is delusion of the most dangerous variety.
In our first year of ministry, we remained in Beaver Falls. Kent served as pastoral intern for the Geneva Church, working under Pastor Bruce Backensto and the elders there. I stopped teaching and started to recover from the previous two years of Christian life. Only Kent knew how badly I needed to step out of the public and into the home. Kent and I wanted to start a family (through adoption or birth) and I needed to learn how to shift gears. In our first year of marriage, I rested, regrouped, and recovered from my painful conversion. In our first year of marriage, in the context of normal Christian family life, Kent and I developed our philosophy of hospitality and of mercy ministry.
Two distinct kinds of home-based ministry developed in our first year of marriage: ministry to those who know God (encouraging the fellowship of the saints through hospitality) and ministry to those who do not yet know God (developing a theology of the public, meeting the “stranger at the gate,” and finding intentional ways and means to bring the gospel to the outcast, the lost, and the lonely). At different times over the years we have had to emphasize one ministry community over the other. For my personality, it was always much easier to meet the outcast at the gate and bring her home. I love first gospel contacts. I love the raw and risky conversations and relationships that develop from this.
After spending the 2001–02 year in Beaver Falls, Kent was called by the Trinity RPC of Beltsville, Md., to plant a church in Northern Virginia. With our two cats and one dog, we packed our U-Haul and moved to Purcellville, Va., a small Northern Virginia suburb outside of Washington, D.C. Church planting is lonely work. A church plant is considered a daughter church, a minor child who will thrive under the protection, support, guidance, and encouragement of the mother church. Our daughter church started to look stillborn almost before we unpacked the U-Haul.
First, our “seed family,” the family who chooses to labor with the pastor to bring the daughter church into adulthood, abandoned not just the church plant but the denomination—before we even arrived on site! They helped us move in and told us they were splitting. They told us that they decided that God was in fact not calling them to plant a church. Since they heard this call from God between the time that they recruited us to accept the job offer and the time when we pulled the U-Haul into the driveway, it might have been helpful had they alerted us to God’s (perceived) proclamation. What was the reason that God told them to not unite with the church plant? They didn’t want to “lack fellowship.”
All that being said, Kent and I arrived in Purcellville in April 2002 with no seed family and no ministry community who had any inkling we had arrived. We trusted that God doesn’t get addresses wrong and that God had us where he wanted us. We just wondered why.
Purcellville, Va., is a small (but growing) and wealthy outer D.C. suburb. It is located in Loudoun County, the fastest growing and wealthiest county in the U.S. The average income here is twice my husband’s paycheck and first year public high school teachers in our county have a higher starting salary than tenured and senior professors make at Syracuse University. Why are we here? This is what we asked the Lord on our first night in our new home.
The first manifestation of this church plant (2002–2004) was exclusively a college ministry. A small Christian college courting the homeschool community had just opened its doors, right across the street from our house. Students flocked to our services, our Bible studies, and mostly our home, in droves. For two years our church consisted of 35-40 college students, two local families, and the Butterfields. At this time, many other families, one at a time, visited for awhile. Each left after a month using the same reason that our original seed family gave to us: they lacked fellowship and they feared for their children in a church without other like-minded families.
Over the years, I have contemplated what this really means. What does it really mean to “lack fellowship”? At least as it regards the handful of families that showed immediate excitement and then after a month a changed heart, this is what “lacking fellowship” means. It means that the family needs to be in a church made up of people who are just like they, who raise their children using the same childrearing methods, who take the same stance on birth control, schooling, voting, breastfeeding, dress codes, white flour, white sugar, gluten, childhood immunizations, the observance of secular and religious holidays. We encountered families who feared diversity with a primal fear. They often told us that they didn’t want to “confuse” their children by exposing them to differences in parenting standards among Christians. I suspect that they feared that deviation from their rules might provide a window for children to see how truly diverse the world is and that temptation might lead them astray. Over and over and over again I have heard this line of thinking from the fearful and the faith-struggling. We in the church tend to be more fearful of the (perceived) sin in the world than of the sin in our own heart. Why is that?
Here is what I think. I believe that there is no greater enemy to vital life-breathing faith than insisting on cultural sameness. When fear rules your theology, God is nowhere to be found in your paradigm, no matter how many Bible verses you tack on to it. I think that as parents we would be more effective in our parenting if we leveled with our children, if we told them that some of our dearly held rules are not morally grounded but are made for our convenience. I know that many times that I insist that my children turn off the video, my “rules” are the result of my own noise-sensitivity, not some moral abhorrence about Pixar or Disney. I never know how to respond to the women who tell me that they need to be in a church made of people with whom they can identify, people who are like them.
This upstart college with whom we ironically held a shared community had no health clinic, limited dining hall services on Sunday, and no women’s dean. I was driving women students to doctor’s appointments (and learning how to give subcutaneous injections), counseling more students than I could have imagined, leading two Bible studies per week, and still serving endless meals every Lord’s Day. These students were amazing. I genuinely loved these students and learned much from them about grace and perseverance. These students were smart and devout in their faith. They also were sheltered. They imparted to me in a firsthand way the serious dangers of isolating our children from real life. Adult children can appear obedient when they are tuning out instead of acting out. College life tends to bring out all the fears and doubts and perceptions of contradictions and hypocrisies. Between this hyper-sensitivity to authority and rules, and a growing sexual awareness, we met students who were struggling with real moral issues. Their unsuspecting parents had no idea how their over-protection had dangerously ill-prepared their beloved, overly protected children from all of this. Sin—especially sexual sin—has a sneaky way of triumphing in an environment of secrecy and shame. Kent and I had our ministry cut out for us.
What was most amazing about those days in the church plant was how labor-intensive it was. No life experience or professional training had prepared me for this labor. The hospitality demands on the Lord’s Day and throughout the week were daunting. So many meals to prepare. So much preparation and clean up. So many trips to Costco for supplies. So many unexpected knocks on the door. Students came for breakfast and stayed late into the night. Our work was always different. Kent would go from teaching large groups of students the doctrine and theology of applied Christian living, taking other students to the local nursing home to pray with and for the residents, helping students with papers and homework, to teaching some kids how to drive a car. The wear and tear on our house, car, washing machine, and bodies was enormous. We worshiped at this time in a gymnasium at a local community center. Saturday night before the community center closed, the gymnasium was open to the public for pick up basketball games. Custodial service for the community center was not in place until Monday morning. At one point, my first task each Lord’s Day was to clean the public restrooms in the community center so that they were presentable for our church community.
Our church life never lacked for love. We never “lacked fellowship.” I still laugh to think that families left us because they thought we “lacked fellowship.” We had more fellowship than we knew what to do with! Real fellowship requires stepping outside of you, and our church community stretched us and enriched us. We cared for the students as faithfully as we could and they cared for us in return. We were sustained by their prayers. They helped us in material ways, as well. We never lacked for house-sitters, dog-walkers, lawn-mowers, leaf-rakers. Each year they faithfully and generously remembered our anniversary. We were privileged to see a whole generation of students through college and into graduate school or marriage. Kent even had the privilege of baptizing the baby of one such couple.
Our mother church, Trinity RPC, provided us with a generous hospitality budget. Pastor Steve and Julie Bradley came out as many times as they could to help us with the after-service studies and activities. Elder TG and family faithfully came out many Lord’s Days, bringing food and encouragement and helping hands and hearts. One family even drove all the way from Pennsylvania once a month and contributed bountifully to our worship, meals, Psalm singing and fellowship. Our beloved dentist and his family worshiped regularly with us for over two years even though they hold strong doctrinal ties in Baptist theology. And a strong handful of parents of our college ministry came to our aid. These families gave to us the counsel that we desperately needed at this time. They sustained us with their prayers and with material help.
Each week, I benefited from the recipes that many women gave to me. Sue Wilkey’s “Groundhog Day Soup” was on the menu each week, as was NM’s minestrone, Floy Smith’s oat bread, Robyn Zorn’s chocolate chip cookies, and my own Mediterranean chicken. The More with Less cookbook was my constant companion. My mother kept me flush in cooking magazines and gadgets. When she and my stepfather would visit, she would stock my freezer with homemade meatballs and Pasta e Fagiole. One year she bought me the top-of-the-line Kitchen Aid with all the attachments. I still use it almost every day.
Then something started to slip. We started to notice something about our college ministry. It was always very busy, very active, very exciting, but it never really took root. Students were great at bringing other students, but they were awkward in talking with people outside of their world. Sometimes, they were so busy sharpening their intellectual sword that they lacked compassion and empathy for people who didn’t already share their worldview. One time, on a Saturday, a young college woman, S, was baking cookies with me. A neighbor came by at the same time to return a book and mentioned something to me about her daughter trying out for something at the local public high school. The neighbor was sharing a concern that she had about something going on in the high school, something that her special needs daughter would not understand. S shook her head and muttered audibly, “Sending a child to the public schools is like giving pearls to the swine.” This student was not known to be combative or rude. She was so accustomed to being around like-minded people that she slipped. I know that she did not intend to do harm. But her heart was revealed in this slip (as our hearts always are). My neighbor was, understandably, offended, and, privately, the following week, said to me that she knew the student was hurling the Bible at her, but she had no idea what it meant: was she the pearl or the pig? Why did this pert and disrespectful girl think that public schools were for the pigs? These sorts of encounters happened too frequently. Of course, these sorts of encounters can provide wonderful teachable moments, but to convert them into these takes a skill and grace that I lacked. I felt broken. My unsaved neighbor needed Jesus more than this college student needed to hurl a few well-rehearsed epithets about the evils of public schools.
One day while I was scrubbing a coffee stain from our beige carpet it dawned on me: I am now caring for the very people whom I would have given anything to study just a few years back. And then with the same flash of insight, I wondered if this really was what God was calling me to do. Of course, knowing God’s call is very humbling business. How do we really know the difference between “God’s call” and our own selfish desires? I personally confuse the two all the time. At the same time, Kent and I had completed the lengthy program of study and home study process to be adoptive parents. We knew that our current ministry could not sustain a household with children. It lacked the appropriate boundaries for parenting. Desiring children can be a noble pursuit, if it’s not God’s will then it is simply a more sanctified form of covetousness. So I scrubbed at the stain in my carpet and tried to focus on the ministry that God had given me.
Then two phone calls came that would change our lives forever. I remember someone telling me that God doesn’t act quickly, he acts suddenly. We had been licensed to adopt a child for six months. And within one day we were matched with four children: a five-and-a-half month baby boy through a private Christian adoption agency and a sibling group of three from the public welfare system. While this did not seem quick (we had been trying to start a family from the beginning of our marriage), it sure was sudden. And now we had a fateful choice before us: the infant or the sibling group? We had twelve hours to decide.
Adoption is a complex affair, especially when you have to choose between children and agencies. Adoption has a complex political and financial underside. In the U.S., the average cost of private adoption is $25,000 (Adoptive Families Magazine, Feb. 2006). Because of the culture of legalized abortion and the exoneration of teenage pregnancy, infants are rarely available for adoption. Adoption also suffers from bad press, with all members of the adoption triangle (children, birth parents, and adoptive parents) suffering from misrepresentation. We were surprised and horrified to learn that even Christian crisis pregnancy centers encourage teenagers to try to parent their children rather than consider the adoption alternative. Also, because of these social factors, the children who end up in the foster care system are often trapped for years and years, as social workers try to patch the holes of sin and poverty that render bad parents abusers or worse. Trapped with these children are identities forged by trauma, neglect, self-hatred, and the degradation of drugs and poverty.
Birth parents that gravitate toward private adoption generally relinquish their own parental rights. Birth parents that choose private adoption usually know their limits and receive the counsel and support that they need to come to this painful and sacrificial decision. Children in the foster care system have birth parents who do not know their limits. They try to parent beyond their means. Some are criminally neglectful and abusive; others are mentally ill or themselves victims of prisons of poverty, abuse, neglect, drugs, and dysfunction. The parental rights of birth parents whose children end up in foster care are usually terminated by a judge, a process that requires documentation over time of abuse or neglect. This lengthy and invasive process can eat up whole childhoods. It costs a lot of money to adopt a child through a private agency and it is “free” to adopt a child from the public welfare system. At the same time, the moral and fiscal cost of retaining a person in the foster care system for a lifetime is enormous. The question isn’t if any of us pays for the cost of orphanhood but when—and with what kind of hope left over at the end.
Kent and I have never been the type of people who believed that only babies are worthy to adopt. We know that all children need loving and stable homes. As people converted outside of covenant homes, we know firsthand that the covenant isn’t only for babies born to biological believers. Yes, the first three years of life are formative and the opportunity to parent a child from infancy into adulthood is a privilege. But, life is precious and children beloved not because they may heal and grow, but because God made us in his image. If that is good enough for God, it must be good enough for us.
When two phone calls came in the same day from two different agencies, we had to choose: the baby or the brother and sisters? How does one choose?
It is times like this that I am grateful that I am a reformed Christian. I know that I don’t choose. God chooses. He rules and he overrules. We walk in faith and (at times) terror, but we walk nonetheless. Our walk into parenthood led to the next phase of our life.
Our beloved son Knox, our beautiful five-month-old baby boy, created before the foundations of the world and destined by God to be a Butterfield, joined us three days after our second anniversary, May 22, 2003. His skin is mocha, just like rich dark coffee with the perfect amount of cream. I loved him immediately with a love I didn’t know existed. He had lost so much by the time that I met him: he had lost a birth mother and a foster mother. My only care at the time was to get to know him and to assure him that I would be there for him no matter what. I “wore” him in a sling, like African mothers do. Together we walked, worked, slept, heart-to-heart. He bonded, slowly at first and then with his whole heart. During our early days, as he cried my own heart cried for the sibling group who was not with us. I was overrun with emotion and with a sense of my own inadequacy.
AJ came next, 11 months later, at the age of 15-and-a-half, in April 2004. We were her eleventh foster home. For AJ, I stand in a long, long line of bad mothers. Kent stands alone in the role of a father. And although he tried beyond measure to take an active role in her life, because of the history that preceded him, he was rooted in a role enshrined in absence and mystery. I loved AJ immediately and wanted to champion her cause. With Knox, my most important task was bonding. With AJ, my most important task was recognition—the ability to see her and to try to understand.
The values and social arrangements of a privileged family life too often regard teenagers in the foster care system as invisible or dangerous. AJ taught me (and continues to teach me) the value of recognizing, of looking and seeing a person with eyes of intimacy. There is a moment in parenting an older child when you feel that “click” of recognition, when you swap the lack of shared life experience for a simple love. This happened for me when I was picking AJ up from school during the first week that she lived with us. Knox and I sat in the car in a long line of families waiting to pick up their teenage child. I felt an awful fear that I would not recognize AJ. I had just met her five days ago. Had I really looked at her? Had I spent the time required to know my child? No. I hadn’t and not one of the ten rejecting mothers who preceded me had. As I sat amidst a sea of strange faces, I felt the weight of our collective neglect. I started to panic, trying to recall to mind the color t-shirt she was wearing. What if I lost her? What if she ran away? With great relief, I found her. Always poised, even in the most stressful situations, there was AJ standing at ease with a group of girls waiting casually for their mothers to pick them up. Once my eyes held her I didn’t want to let go. AJ reminds me that too often our lofty goals for our children interfere with simply recognizing them. AJ does not live in our home any longer. Our lifestyles and values clashed too deeply. AJ fears discipline the way a fish fears dry land. But we talk and visit and hold on to our fragile relationship.
Mary came eighteen months later, as a newborn, in November 2005. Amy Comin, Doug’s wife, called in October to tell us that four bi-racial or African-American babies were soon to be born to a small private adoption agency with no waiting families. I called the number that Amy gave to me immediately and by God’s providence, the agency’s director took my phone call even though I was from out of state. Out-of-state adoptions in the U.S. are even more complex because of the need to gain approval from social workers and attorneys in each state. Many agencies are reluctant to even consider out-of-state adoptions. (This is part of why many adoptive parents prefer International adoptions.) But God forged the path for Mary’s adoption. Indeed, I had the privilege to hold her during her first hour of life. In that hour, I sang to her Psalm 104 (Knox calls this the “Butterfield Baby Song”) and she queued my voice immediately. She taught me the marvelous ways that newborns learn to trust and grow. She teaches me the iron behind trust and the powerful strides the human brain stakes out in infancy and childhood. I watch her step into the world with a confidence that still startles me. She knows something that the rest of my children don’t: that it is safe to take her family for granted.
S came fourteen months later, as a newborn, in January 2007. With S, we faced our first disrupted adoption. Her adoption disrupted after she was in our care for ten days. The director was on vacation when the placement coordinator placed a black child in a white home. That really rocked her world. How can people who don’t match be a family? With her racism on the front line, she refused to support the adoption. We witnessed racism firsthand: we watched a racist community (Department of Family Services) “solve” the problem of race (black kids who don’t match white parents) by putting into place a racist solution (disrupt the adoption). When S’s adoption started to unravel, we were faced with the moral question: Do we fight this or concede? We did neither. Instead, we prayed. We at first prayed lofty, conceited prayers, trying to force God’s hand. Then, after we got sick of our own pride interfering with God’s work, we whittled down the prayer to this: a covenant family for this dear child that I hold in my arms, because Your arms, dear Lord, shaped and formed her, and Your arms are the ones that will always hold this dear child, not mine, but yours. The Department of Family Services called with a date to remove this baby in my arms from our home. It was heartbreaking. We felt powerless and wondered if we had done the right thing by not fighting this battle. One of the hardest facets of adoption is the total exposure the adoptive family feels as the agency or birth mother selects or rejects you. What does rejection say about us as people? As a family? Am I right to believe that segregation (placing children of color with families of color) is not the solution to racism? Do I believe that to the harm of my four biracial children and in defense alone of my white privilege? Am I right or wrong, good or bad, competent or incompetent? Will my family stand the test of time?
We had two Christian attorneys who were willing to take the agency to court, since it is illegal to use race to disrupt an adoptive placement. (MEPA—the 1994 Multiethnic Placement Act—is the antidiscrimination law that prohibits this as well as racial matching as the primary placement criterion.) But we did not want S to suffer as a victim of the court system, a situation that could have retained her in foster care for years. We believe that we adopt children because of need. We reasoned like this: if there is no need, there is no adoption. We reminded ourselves that we are not called to covet other people’s children. But we also knew from firsthand experience, having adopted before through the public welfare system, that this agency is no friend to children. Like other government agencies, it is overburdened and understaffed. Children do fall through the cracks. We didn’t want this for S. We were torn and in doubt. Kent posted a prayer request on our denomination’s prayer list—“CovieNet.” Our denomination is a praying community. I believe that there were thousands of saints praying for this child on the day that Kent posted our plea. Kent’s request was simple: Dear God, may S have a Christian home.
The day that was S’s last one with us was a dark and fearful one. Did we make the wrong decision? Wouldn’t we have fought to retain the other children in our home? We tearfully brought S back to the agency and there we met S’s preferred potential adoptive family. They are African American and they are Christian. God heard our prayers. Yes, we were hurt. Deeply. But S wasn’t! In God’s amazing mercy, he used us to protect the baby! Isn’t that at the center of our prayers for our children? He didn’t hurt us to punish us. We were hurt in service to him. Why was S with us for ten days? What kind of spiritual warfare played out in the hidden backdrop of those ten days? Did our humble prayers shake the gates of heaven for this orphan child? Did our prayers avail much? Did God use our prayers to secure for her a Christian home? The day that the agency took S away, we found on our porch an expansive take-out bag from the restaurant Red, Hot, and Blue (including my favorite, banana pudding) and this note, scribbled in pencil, with a child’s drawing of a flower with a petal falling off. The note read:
A family that never opens its heart never feels heartbroken. A family that never welcomes in others never misses them when they leave. A family that never embraces life’s risks, never really lives. Thinking of you all on this tough day. With love from the many, many people whose lives you’ve touched and who love you all.
I don’t know who penned the note or drew the picture. But the note captures for me an often overlooked spiritual truth: betrayal and risk are at the heart of the gospel life. This I know: God heard my prayers.
In this broken world, people break promises (and contracts). The social worker that made the contract and the social worker that broke the contract are women I respect and value. We come to the table with different points of view. Because we are Christ’s, we know that children are not grafted into a family to resolve our fertility problems or to boost our egos or to complete our family pictures or because we match color or race or nation-status. We know, because we are Christ’s, that adoption is a miracle. In a spiritual sense, it is the miracle at the center of the Christian life. We who are adopted by God are those given a new heart, a “rebirth.”
When God brings children out of neglect, abuse, dysfunction, gangs, drugs, and hate, and places them in a covenant home, he has just moved a mountain in the hearts and families of men. When God gives a childless couple a child of any age using the means of his powerful will, he has just moved a mountain in the hearts and families of men. When mountains move, the earth shakes. When you stand as close as we have to real life miracles, you will get roughed up. Mountains are big and we are small. A moving mountain can crush us. Splinters fall from the cross. They travel a long distance and they pierce the skin—maybe even the heart. And wrapped in this risk and danger is God’s embrace and promise to work all things (even evil ones) to the good of those who love him. When we read in the book of Romans, “And we know that God causes all things to work together for good to those who love God, to those who are the called according to his purpose” (8:28), we are not to be Pollyanna about this. Many of the “things” we will face come with the razor edges of a fallen and broken world. You can’t play poker with God’s mercy—if you want the sweet mercy then you must also swallow the bitter mercy. And what is the difference between sweet and bitter? Only this: your critical perspective, your worldview. One of God’s greatest gifts is the ability to see and appreciate the world from points of view foreign to your own, points of view that exceed your personal experience. That is what it means to me to grow in Christ—to exceed myself as I stretch to him. The loss of S taught us this.
I think a lot about the way our family had shaped our little church plant. I was our church’s precentor (the person who leads the singing). In our denomination, precentors lead by voice and music director hand motions to indicate the pace of the psalm. During the life of the church plant, I was honored to lead the singing in our church with one and sometimes two children in tow, one in a baby sling and the other on my hip. Knox took great interest as a baby in “helping” me to lead the psalms, swinging his hands to keep the beat or turning the pages of the psalter with arbitrary confidence. Daughter Mary was more dancer than singer, or so it seemed. She kicked her legs and threw her body around or sometimes in the middle of a stanza would fall into a deep sleep. I led the singing of the psalms with my babies attached. My babies often shifted their weight or kicked me in the gut as I precented. It made me think about the “Psalms of Ascent,” imagining the Israelites walking as they sang into foreign lands, in weakness and in faith. With babies attached, I felt a sensible and tangible awareness growing in me, a little window into the mystery of the Christian life.
Children bring other children. The children in our home brought other children into our home. When we became parents, we suddenly became a children’s church. Because we are licensed foster parents, we had access to children who don’t have homes (and live in group homes). We have enjoyed vital and vibrant ministries that emerge in the process of daily life: knitting club for the girls on the block (with the Westminster Shorter Catechism taught alongside knit and purl), pick-up football for the four-year-old boys (with prayer and snacks to follow), and neighborhood preschool. We also enjoyed the lost art of simply being available to care for children lost in emergencies, from snow days that strand children at home and send parents to work, to domestic abuse or worse. We see this as an investment in community. Anything worth doing will take time and cost you something. We noticed, as our attention focused more on families and children, that many people in our community protect themselves from inconvenience as though inconvenience is deadly. We have decided that we are not inconvenienced by inconvenience. The needs of children come up unexpectedly. We are sure that the Good Samaritan had other plans that fateful day. Our plans are not sacred. Our house is open to children for after school care. No money is exchanged. The younger children enjoy the attention of the older children and we enjoy seeing a small shadow of real community emerge—right here in our kitchen.
My attention for the college ministry weakened over time as my interest and commitment to children (those that God would allow us to adopt and those who remain trapped in the foster care system) increased. Parenting adopted children and children marked by the trauma of foster care is serious business. Adoption is not a pathology that marks and plagues people and families for their whole life. But adoption is a complex paradoxical event that combines loss, brokenness, and rejection with gain, connection, and embrace. No child asks to be adopted. No child asks for incompetent or rejecting birth parents. No child asks to be constantly told how “lucky” he is to be adopted. Wanted or not, adoption always starts with loss. Adoption always combines ambiguous loss with unrequested gain. An adopted child faces this paradox—this ambiguous grief—at each developmental stage. His or her family must choose to either welcome the complexity or make the child go it alone. We choose to walk alongside our children, even as we don’t always understand how deep or how raw the complexity rests. This journey is frightful. At its core is this: do I love Jesus enough to face my children’s potential rejection of me?
I began to grow weary and tired of the issues that the women brought into my home from the campus. I started to feel like all I was doing was helping homeschool loyalists choose between their para-church allegiances. As I faced the demons of neglect and loss and the hard work of extra care and nurture, I found myself constantly out of step with women who were my peers. And the crowning moment for me was when the mother of one of my favorite students said to me, “Rosaria, I don’t understand how a Christian can be effective in parenting foster children. As I see it, if you can’t homeschool them and you can’t spank them, you surely can’t lead them to Jesus.”
This woman—this friend of mine—did not say this with intended malice or disrespect. It merely came from her heart and from the narrow walls of a fear-driven theology. It came from an odd allegiance to the means of discipline and love rather than its purpose or origin. From our experience, children in the welfare state are no less worthy of a covenant home than the biological children of believers. God calls us to discipline our children in an effective way. Spanking is not the only means of discipline, and for children who have been abused it is the least effective means. And while children in the foster care system are wards of the state, we have found that social workers are willing to take into consideration alternative means of schooling. We have homeschooled a child in foster care. We firmly believed that it was her only hope—and we were successful in convincing her social workers and public school teachers and guidance counselors of this. We were successful in accomplishing the educational and social goals that we had for her in the year that we were given permission to educate her at home.
Indeed, my own experience as a foster parent has made me a great advocate of homeschooling—but not for the reasons that most homeschool loyalists provide. I have found that traditional school settings are hostile to children who live under constant stress and duress. I resent the idea that, just because it is “free,” public education is the first choice. Public education is one choice among many, but it is not the norm against which other schooling options are to be graded.
For about a year, a 16-year-old girl named Jessica came to our church and home. She was in terminal foster care and lived in a local group home. She was saddled with labels, mental illness categories, and medication. She helped me with VBS and with crocheting granny squares for blankets. Like most children in terminal foster care, she fell between the cracks of the system when she turned eighteen. In our first floor restroom, the children stand on a stool to wash their hands that Jessica made in a woodworking class in an adult psychiatric ward. One day in church, Pastor Steve Bradley was preaching on knowing God’s call. Jessica was listening with rapt attention. After the service, she approached Pastor Steve and said, “Steve, I hear voices all the time. How do I know the difference between hearing the voice of God and hearing the voices of my own sick mind?” With great compassion, Pastor Steve said, “Dear one, we all have to check the voices of our own sick mind with the Bible. Daily. You are no different.” I have always been so grateful that my church is a safe place for the orphans and the outcasts—for God’s children.
Jessica told me later that day that never before had someone made her feel so good. It was so good to know that, at least in regards to this, she was no different. It gave her great comfort to know that others struggled, too.
When she turned 18, we watched first-hand the graphic horror faced by children who “age out” of foster care. In some Orwellian, grotesque turn of phrase, the welfare state calls this “aging out” process (i.e., turning 18) “emancipation.” Here is what happened to Jessica. On her 18th birthday, she was moved from a group home for children with mental illness to a series of adult psychiatric wards, first in Maryland, then Connecticut, then New York. We lost her when she left Maryland. In 2010, a month before Matt’s adoption was finalized, we learned that Jessica died in a homeless shelter in New York on her 23rd birthday.
Jessica was a child of God.
She spent time in our home.
She wanted to be adopted.
She never was.
She died alone.
In November 2010, at Matt’s adoption ceremony at the Loudoun County Courthouse, I was privileged to read to the court a short text about what adoption means. I looked out at a sea of faces, children of all ages and races and abilities, parents and siblings in our best dress; I felt peaceful gratitude that the Lord had put Matt in our family. But in the backdrop of this picture, in the crevice behind the blessing offered to us by these children who will forever be our emotional betters, whom we need more than they need us, I could picture, thick as pudding, the faces of the absent, lost, dead, unnamed, unknown.
I will always regard Jessica as the child we did not adopt.
The college students who remained with us after the children and foster children started coming became our allies in real outreach ministry. We all grew in Christ in our opportunity to serve people who would otherwise be invisible to us because of our privilege or fear. G was our advocate even after he graduated and moved away. B moved into our basement for a summer and became daughter AJ’s confidante and swim partner. D moved to Maryland after graduation and tied in with the Trinity church. Others married and stayed in the community for awhile.
All of this bounty came from God’s blessing upon my marriage to Kent. My Mom and stepfather love Kent. I love Kent’s sisters, brothers-in-law, and nephews. Someone once teased that in our family, we have enough PhDs and differences of political opinions to become our own small unaccredited liberal arts college! During one fellowship dinner at our house, we had Kent’s family in attendance. One of the students, excited to have a whole room full of PhDs, asked what advice we had for him in his pursuit of his doctorate. Kent’s oldest sister Rebecca challenged him—and the rest of us—to recite our thesis in one sentence. We all sounded like such idiots, all except for Rebecca. Her PhD is in Environmental Studies, and her thesis could be reduced to this: “dead trees don’t grow.” Well, she won the “name that thesis in four notes” contest hands down!
I never was a seasoned pastor’s wife. We were church-planters, and that is scrappy work. But I believe, from my limited experience, that there is a little-known secret about the inner spiritual lives of pastor’s wives: the experience of really knowing the man behind the pulpit, counting the costs of his week, palpably knowing how deeply Satan wants the gospel to simply die from lack of interest, seeing the Holy Spirit triumph in his preaching even when just the hour before all looked grim, is a great shot in the arm to enduring faith. I wish that others knew this: Pastor’s wives get the cream of the ministry, even as we sacrifice certain aspects of our personal, private, and family lives to have this. I have found my life as Kent’s wife to be full, rich, exciting, amusing, edifying, and exciting. I have tasted a small bit of the gospel of Jesus Christ. I would not trade this life for anything.
In 2007, we closed the church plant. We were holding services in Harpers Ferry, W. Va., at the time of the last worship service. Kent preached to a packed crowd. Friends came from Pennsylvania and Maryland. Kent delivered a resounding sermon about thanking God at all times, not only when we win. I was in the back, tears welling in my eyes, when the doors opened and people I vaguely recognized but could not place walked in to the service. A beautiful family with a year-old baby girl approached me. I shifted Mary to one hip and the woman put the other baby in my arms. “Rosaria, here is our baby. We came to worship with you today.” Baby S, taken away from us, and returned briefly on this fateful day. Baby S’s dad is a jolly, joyful man, whose large mocha hands warm a wide expanse. He scooped Knox into his lap and told him all about how God used him to help Baby S when she was so tiny. He told Knox that we are one, big, Christian family. It was time, and, without thinking, I took both Mary and Baby S with me to the front of the church to lead in the singing of Psalm 78. Kent was reading from the book of Exodus. He was retelling the story of Moses’s parents placing him in a basket of reeds, lowering him into the Nile, not knowing his destination. I handed Kent Baby S, as I flipped through the psalter and fished in my pocket for my pitch pipe. Kent embraced the baby in his arms, and mouthed, “Who is this?”
I told him, and he broke into tears.
