Conversion and the Gospel of Peace
Conversion and the Gospel of Peace
How do I tell you about my conversion to Christianity without making it sound like an alien abduction or a train wreck? Truth be told, it felt like a little of both. The language normally used to describe this odd miracle does not work for me. I didn’t read one of those tacky self-help books with a thin coating of Christian themes, examine my life against the tenets of the Bible the way one might hold up one car insurance policy against all others and cleanly and logically, “make a decision for Christ.” While I did make choices along the path of this journey, they never felt logical, risk-free, or sane. Neither did I feel like the victim of an emotional/spiritual earthquake and collapse gracefully into the arms of my Savior, like a holy and sanctified Scarlett O’Hara having been “claimed by Christ’s irresistible grace.” Heretical as it might seem, Christ and Christianity seemed eminently resistible.
My Christian life unfolded as I was just living my life, my normal life. In the normal course of life questions emerged that exceeded my secular feminist worldview. Those questions sat quietly in the crevices of my mind until I met a most unlikely friend: a Christian pastor. Had a pastor named Ken Smith not shared the gospel with me for years and years, over and over again, not in some used-car-salesman way, but in an organic, spontaneous and compassionate way, those questions might still be lodged in the crevices of my mind and I might never have met the most unlikely of friends, Jesus Christ himself.
It is dangerous to look back on my life, from the perspective of a lover and follower of Christ, now also a wife and a mother. It is painful to lay my hand on the absence of my former life, and breathe. My former life still lurks in the edges of my heart, shiny and still like a knife.
I come to the limits of language when I try to describe my life in Jesus Christ.
My life as I knew it became train wrecked in April of 1999, at the age of 36—just a few weeks shy of 37. At that time, I was an associate professor at Syracuse University, recently tenured in the English Department also holding a joint teaching appointment in the Center for Women’s Studies. I was in a lesbian relationship with a woman who was primarily an animal activist and a nature lover and also an adjunct professor at a neighboring university. Together we owned homes, co-habitating both in life and in the university’s domestic partnership policy. My partner T ran a business: she rehabilitated abused and abandoned Golden Retrievers for placement as helper dogs for the disabled or family dogs for those animals not strong enough to work. Our houses (we owned and lived in two—one in the country and one in the university district) were hubs of intellectual and activist work. Aside from the kennel, we supported a lot of causes: AIDS health care, children’s literacy, sexual abuse healing, and disability activism. We were members of a Unitarian Universalist Church, where I was the coordinator of what is called the Welcoming Committee, the gay and lesbian advocacy group.
My historical field in English studies was 19th century literature and culture. My historical interests in 19th century literature were grounded in the philosophical and political worldviews of Freud, Marx, and Darwin. My primary field was Critical Theory—also known as postmodernism. My specialty was Queer Theory (a postmodern form of gay and lesbian studies). In my department, tenure requirements were rigorous, expecting a published and reviewed book, six scholarly articles, and significant exposure at conferences, delivering lectures on the topic of your research. I remember thinking that this intensity of intellectual work was normal until I explained our department’s tenure requirements to a doctor friend. He said, “Wow! That’s like having to cut out your own spleen and eat it!” Albeit apparently toxic, my work, nonetheless, felt vital and enriching.
Looking back now, I don’t know how to think about myself as a professor. Most often, I felt like an imposter—I felt like I wasn’t really smart enough to be there. I always felt lucky to get a job at Syracuse University. I didn’t assume I would get tenure there and was a little surprised that I did.
I soon (within three years) became the Director of Undergraduate Studies and I enjoyed advising and organizing our curriculum and encouraging our students. Some of my senior colleagues advised me against becoming a department administrator before I received tenure, not only because administrative work would take time away from my research and writing, but also because administrators get embroiled in department politics where it is easy to make gratuitous enemies and hard to recover lost ground. I rejected this traditional counsel and took the job anyway. In bucking the traditional advice, I learned a good lesson: that success comes when we build on our strengths. Doing something I loved and I was good at helped me to get my writing and research done in an efficient and focused way. Although risky, working from my strengths turned out to be a good risk and I’m glad that I took it. I felt vindicated in the principle that risks are worth taking and that gain is only sweet when you actually have something to lose.
In spite of feeling like an imposter, I apparently didn’t look like one. I did a lot of high profile things as a professor. I have given a keynote address at a gay pride march and have been invited by major universities, including Harvard University, to lecture on gay and lesbian studies. I tried to do my work with integrity and enthusiasm, but certain aspects of my job were hard for me, like working with graduate students on their dissertations and comprehensive exams. The job market was always bad and I never really felt equipped to mentor their research.
The part of my job that I loved the best was undergraduate teaching. I still shiver at the dynamism and the epiphanies of the classroom. I miss this. I also miss my colleagues. I miss being in the company of risky and complex thinkers, people who are invested in our culture and who challenge me to think to the edges of my comfort zones. I believed then and I believe now that where everybody thinks the same nobody thinks very much. I miss being around people who find their equilibrium in contradiction and diversity. Of course, there were other perks—a dependable salary, the best job security in the world, tuition remission for my family members at Syracuse University and research universities of equivalent status, a great research budget, a book budget, opportunity to travel. But even living now, homeschooling two of our four children and living on one salary, I don’t miss the material benefits. I miss the people.
As a lesbian activist, I was involved in my gay community. I had drafted and lobbied for the university’s first successful domestic partnership policy, which gives spousal benefits to gay couples. I had to put up with a lot of flack from the conservative Christian community for this. My life was busy and full, and I thought, moral. I was concerned with issues of morality, and even authored an article on the subject of the morality of gay and lesbian lives. I was an “out” lesbian in the same way that I am now an “out” Christian. It would never occur to me to live my life in falsehood, and I had and have the kind of privileged jobs (then as a professor and now as a Christian wife) where I do not have to be “careful” or closeted. The closest I ever got to Christians during these times were students who refused to read material in university classrooms on the grounds that “knowing Jesus” meant never needing to know anything else; people who sent me hate mail; or people who carried signs at gay pride marches that read “God Hates Fags.” (By the way, “God Hates Fags” is also a website where young nominally Christian homophobes can log on to acquire hate tactics).
Christians always seemed like bad thinkers to me. It seemed that they could maintain their worldview only because they were sheltered from the world’s real problems, like the material structures of poverty and violence and racism. Christians always seemed like bad readers to me, too. They appeared to use the Bible in a way that Marxists would call “vulgar”—that is, common, or, in order to bring the Bible into a conversation to stop the conversation, not deepen it. “The Bible says” always seemed to me like a mantra that invited everyone to put his or her brain on hold. “The Bible says” was the Big Pause before the conversation stopped. Their catch phrases and cliches were (and are) equally off-putting. “Jesus is the answer” seemed to me then and now like a tree without a root. Answers come after questions, not before. Answers answer questions in specific and pointed ways, not in sweeping generalizations. “It’s such a blessing” always sounds like a violation of the Third Commandment (“Do not take the Lord’s name in vain”) or a Hallmark card drunk with schmaltz. It seemed to me that the only people who could genuinely be satisfied with this level of reading and thinking were people who didn’t really read or think very much—about life or culture or anything.
In addition to appearing to be anti-intellectual, Christians also scared me. Outside of the Lord, life is a very treacherous ordeal. Proverbs teaches this when its author Solomon writes: “the way of the unfaithful is hard” (Prov. 13:15). Of course Christian life is hard too, but it is hard in another way, in a way that is at least bearable and purposeful. Christians can lay hold of the meaning and purpose and grace of suffering and truly believe that all things, even the evil ones, “work together for good for those who love God, to those who are called according to his purpose” (Rom. 8:28). A life outside of Christ is both hard and frightening; a life in Christ has hard edges and dark valleys, but it is purposeful even when painful. Ah, but I get ahead of myself. Here is one of the deepest ways Christians scared me: the lesbian community was home and home felt safe and secure; the people that I knew the best and cared about were in that community; and finally, the lesbian community was accepting and welcoming while the Christian community appeared (and too often is) exclusive, judgmental, scornful, and afraid of diversity. What also scared me is that while Christianity seemed like just another worldview, this one for people who enjoyed living narrowly circumscribed lives, Christians claimed that their worldview and all of the attending features that I saw—Republican politics, homeschooling biases, refusal to inoculate children against childhood illnesses, etc.—had God on its side.
Christians still scare me when they reduce Christianity to a lifestyle and claim that God is on the side of those who attend to the rules of the lifestyle they have invented or claim to find in the Bible.
Although I knew that I wasn’t the smartest scholar in my department, I enjoyed doing research and writing. I enjoyed (and still do) the risk of examining new ideas. I had a stick-em on my computer with a quotation whose author I never knew. It read: “I would rather be wrong on an important point than right on a trivial one.” This quotation reminded me that when you make your mistakes in public you will learn that they are mistakes and in being corrected you will grow. It also reminded me that being wrong and responding to correction with resilience was a higher virtue than covering up your mistakes so your students and the watching world assumed that success meant never being wrong. Working from your strengths and cultivating resilience in all matters of life have always been guiding principles for me.
I’m a former gymnast and marathon runner and I have always found flexibility and a steady pace to be more useful than perfection or bursts of speed. Winners have always seemed to me people who know how to fall on their face, pick themselves up, and recover well. It has always seemed to me that without the proper response to failure, we don’t grow, we only age. So I was and am willing to take the risk of being wrong for the hope of growing in truth. It seemed to me that if we fall, we need to fall forward and not backward, because at least then we are moving in the right direction. Resilience, recovery, and recognition of my strengths and failures galvanized my research and my life.
In spite of having a worldview that valued flexibility, unanswerable Big Life Questions started to nag at me while I was doing initial research and writing for my second book, a study of the rise of the Religious Right in America, and the hermeneutic of hatred that the Religious Right uses against their favorite target: queers, or at that time, people like me. I had been studying the Christian right since 1992, since Pat Robertson at the 1992 Republican National Convention declared: “Feminism encourages women to leave their husbands, kill their children, practice witchcraft, destroy capitalism, and become lesbians.” I thought then, and I think now, that this is a foolish and a dangerous statement. After all, it was the first wave of feminism in this country that secured for women the right to vote and access to public education. It seemed to me then and it seems to me now that Christians truly become ugly when we become jealous of the successful persuasive rhetoric of others. The truth is, feminists have been more successful rhetoricians at the core of major U.S. universities than have Christians, even though most of these universities have Christian origins.
Although I live my life now for Christ and Christ alone, I do not find myself in like-minded company when my fellow Christians bemoan the state of the university today. Feminism has a better reputation than Christianity at all major U.S. universities and this fact really bothers (and confuses) many Christians. Feminism has truly captured the soul of secular U.S. universities and the church has either been too weak or too ignorant to know and to know better. But how has the church responded to this truth? Too often the church sets itself up as a victim of this paradigm shift in America, but I think this is dishonest. Here’s what I think happened: since all major U.S. universities had Christian roots, too many Christians thought that they could rest in Christian tradition, not Christian relevance. Too often the church does not know how to interface with university culture because it comes to the table only ready to moralize and not dialogue. There is a core difference between sharing the gospel with the lost and imposing a specific moral standard on the unconverted. Like it or not, in the court of public opinion, feminists and not Bible-believing Christians have won the war of intellectual integrity. And Christians are in part to blame for this.
The Pat Robertson quotation is a good example of what I saw in my study of the religious right (and what I still see): spiritual pride and club Christianity. But I also knew that there was more to it than that. I wondered about this. What is the core of Christianity? Why do true believers believe? What do they believe? Why is their faith person-centered and not idea-centered? Because I’m an English professor, I had to read the Bible to make sense of the hermeneutic used by the Christian Right. Because I was a scholar, I knew that without having studied Hebrew or Greek, or knowing the relationship between the different fields of theology and different applications of doctrine, canon, and textual study, I was not able to study the Bible on my own. I started a self-study of Greek and searched for someone to help me understand the Bible. “Help” came in a most unusual way.
After I published in the local newspaper a critique of the Promise Keepers for their gender politics, I received a batch of mail: hate mail and fan mail. I received so many letters for this little editorial that I kept empty Xerox paper boxes on both sides of my desk, one for hate mail and one for fan mail. (Oh, how I wished people would have read my recently-gone-into-paperback-tenure-book with the same gusto!). In this batch of mail, I also received a letter from Pastor Ken Smith, then-pastor of the Syracuse Reformed Presbyterian Church. It was a kind and inquiring letter. It encouraged me to explore the kind of questions that I admire: how did you arrive at your interpretations? How do you know you are right? Do you believe in God? He didn’t argue with my article; he asked me to explore and defend the presuppositions that undergirded it. I didn’t really know how to respond to Ken’s letter, but I found myself reading and rereading it. I didn’t know which box to file this letter in, and so it sat on my desk and haunted me.
After many days of thinking about this, Ken’s letter made me confront the presuppositional problem of my research: as an intellectual, I was working from a historical materialist worldview, but Christianity was essentially a supernatural worldview. Christians maintained that Jesus Christ was historically and globally true, but his entrance into history violated a core value of my research: no one, according to the tenets of historical materialism, enters history; rather, we all emerge from it. The “who, what, why, and how” of Jesus Christ is a great mystery. I had never thought about presuppositional questions that were supernatural or spiritual in nature, and yet here I was embarking in a writing project that made me confront this worldview-divide. Pastor Ken’s letter punctured the integrity of my research project without him even knowing it!
It may seem strange to you, but no one had asked me those questions before or led me to ask them of myself. These were reasonable questions, but not the sort of questions that postmodern professors toss around at faculty meetings or the local bar. The Bible makes it clear that reason is not the front door of faith. It takes spiritual eyes to discern spiritual matters. But how do we develop spiritual eyes unless Christians engage the culture with those questions and paradigms of mindfulness out of which spiritual logic flows? That’s exactly what Ken’s letter did for me—invited me to think in ways I hadn’t before.
By the way, I hate a messy desk, one where papers litter the surface. Pastor Ken’s letter sat on my desk for a whole week—this is six days longer than I can normally stand. It really bothered me that I didn’t know where to file it. I threw it away a few times but always found myself digging through the department’s recycling bin to reclaim it at the day’s end. It was a careful letter, two pages in length, written on church stationery. It was neatly typed and Pastor Ken’s signature was bold and clear. The name of the church was Syracuse Reformed Presbyterian Church and I assumed that “reformed” implied a critique of tradition-for-tradition’s sake. From his signature and some of the language he used I assumed that Pastor Ken was old but not priggish. The letter invited me to call its author to discuss these ideas more fully. It was the kindest letter of opposition that I had ever received. After a week, I called.
We had a nice chat on the phone, and Pastor Ken invited me to dinner at his house to explore some of these questions. Before we ended our phone call, almost as an afterthought, Pastor Ken also said that if I was afraid to come to some stranger’s home that he and his wife would meet me at a restaurant. I thought that that was very considerate of him—almost chivalrous! I was comfortable with the idea of going to his house. The gay and lesbian community is also a community “given to hospitality.” I honed my hospitality gifts serving pasta to drag queens and queers—people like me. I prefer discussing matters of disagreement around a private table. Plus I really wanted to see how Christians lived! I had never seen such a thing! So I took him up on it. I was excited to meet a real born again Christian and find out why he believed such silly ideas. I assumed that this dinner was another aspect of my research. Pastor Ken lived about two miles from my house, his house also in the university district. I knew exactly where he lived—in fact, his house was on my running route—so I wasn’t too nervous about this first meeting. I went alone.
I remember in great detail that first meeting with Ken and his wife Floy. I remember being conscious of my butch haircut and the gay and pro-choice bumper stickers on my car. I remember how relieved I was when I learned that Floy made a vegetarian stir fry for supper. (I tried to maintain a vegetarian diet for health as well as for moral reasons.) I remember awkwardly greeting my hosts at the door and pulling out of my bag two gifts—a bottle of good red wine and a box of strong tea. It was a hot July day and I was glad that they didn’t use air conditioning (I was concerned about the environment in general and the ozone layer in particular and assumed that they were, too). I share with you these details because they reflect my thinking at the time. I wanted to get to know these people but not at the expense of compromising my moral standards. My lesbian identity and culture and its values mattered a lot to me. I came to my culture and its values through life experience but also through much research and deep thinking. I liked Ken and Floy immediately because they seemed sensitive to that. Even though obviously these Christians and I were very different, they seemed to know that I wasn’t just a blank slate, that I had values and opinions too, and they talked with me in a way that didn’t make me feel erased.
The most memorable part of this meal was Ken’s prayer before the meal. I had never heard anyone pray to God as if God cared, as if God listened, and as if God answered. It was not a pretentious prayer uttered for the heathen at the table to overhear. (I have heard a few of those at gay pride marches or in front of Planned Parenthood clinics.) It was a private and honest utterance, and I felt as though I was treading on something real, something sincere, something important, and something transparent but illegible to me. Ken made himself vulnerable to me in his prayer by humbling himself before this “God” of his, and I took note of that. During our meal I remember holding my breath and waiting to be punched in the stomach with something grossly offensive. I believed at this time that God was dead and that if he ever was alive, the fact of poverty, violence, racism, sexism, homophobia, and war was proof that he didn’t care about his creation. I believed that religion was, as Marx wrote, the opiate of the masses, an imperialist social construction made to soothe the existential angst of the intellectually impaired. But Ken’s God seemed alive, three-dimensional and wise, if firm. And Ken and Floy were anything but intellectually impaired.
Our conversation was lively and fun. If Floy was a “submissive wife” she was also gifted, smart, perceptive, well-read, and a great cook! If Ken was the “Bible-thumping” pastor, he was also a good listener, a balanced interpreter, a lover of good poetry, a reader of culture and politics, and a husband who clearly adored, relied upon, and valued highly his wife’s counsel. These people simply didn’t fit the stereotype and I simply didn’t know what to do with this. Like his letter, Ken wouldn’t be filed away easily so that I could just go on with my life.
Ken and Floy did something at the meal that has a long Christian history but has been functionally lost in too many Christian homes. Ken and Floy invited the stranger in—not to scapegoat me, but to listen and to learn and to dialogue. Ken and Floy have a vulnerable and transparent faith. We didn’t debate worldview; we talked about our personal truth and about what “made us tick.” Ken and Floy didn’t identify with me. They listened to me and identified with Christ. They were willing to walk the long journey to me in Christian compassion. During our meal, they did not share the gospel with me. After our meal, they did not invite me to church. Because of these glaring omissions to the Christian script as I had come to know it, when the evening ended and Pastor Ken said he wanted to stay in touch, I knew that it was truly safe to accept his open hand.
Since this beginning, the journey on which the Lord has taken me has been a great adventure, and this simple meal in a pastor’s home, the unlikely circle made by a radical lesbian feminist professor and two strong Christians in their 70s, a heavy Syracuse sun setting as we talked behind a large wall of windows in their home, was the first leg of this journey. I left their table needing to know a number of things: does God exist? If God does exist, what does he expect from me? How do I communicate with him? How do I know who he is and what he wants? What if God is dead? Do I have the courage to face the truth, either way?
Before I ever set foot in a church, I spent two years meeting with Ken and Floy and on and off “studying” scripture and my heart. If Ken and Floy had invited me to church at that first meal I would have careened like a skateboard on a cliff, and would have never come back. Ken, of course, knows the power of the word preached but it seemed to me he also knew at that time that I couldn’t come to church—it would have been too threatening, too weird, too much. So, Ken was willing to bring the church to me. This gave me the room and the safety that I needed to match Ken and Floy’s vulnerability and transparency. And so I opened up to them. I let them know who I was and what I valued. I invited them into my home and into my world. They met my friends, came to my dinner parties, saw me function in my real life. They made themselves safe enough for me to do this.
At the beginning of any project, I read and re-read the book that I am trying to understand. At this point, I read and re-read the Bible. I read it voraciously and compulsively—as I do all books. I spent about five hours each day reading the Bible. I read every translation I could acquire—including the Catholic Bible. I still thought I was doing research for a book on the Religious Right. Ken and Floy, during those two years, asked me questions about my reading and my observations, but didn’t pressure me or push me or interfere in my life. They were just there. If a month or two went by and I hadn’t responded to Ken’s e-mail inquiry or phone call, he would pop over to my house, like any neighbor might do, bringing greetings or a book or a loaf of homemade bread. Ken and Floy and I became friends. My father died when I was 22. I found myself trusting Ken the way that I had imagined myself as a grown woman trusting my own deceased Dad.
After we had been meeting for a while, Ken approached me with a proposition: how about if he, Pastor Ken Smith, had a chance to speak to my English majors about why the Bible is a foundational book for English majors to read. He explained that he had a lecture already written and that he had delivered it successfully before. Clearly, he reasoned, as I was now reading the Bible, I could tell that it was filled with every literary genre and much literary merit. I remember being intrigued at what his lecture might contain but also remember feeling like a full-on threatened Mama Bear at even the hint that I would let this evangelical Christian have at my English majors! I was the gatekeeper and I didn’t want my students hearing something that would undermine what we all had been teaching them. So I told Ken no, firmly and definitively. And then I asked Ken how he would feel about having an audience of one for this lecture—me. Much to my surprise, he took me up on it.
Ken and Floy came over for dinner to give me this lecture on the Bible. I invited them on a night when I was sure to be alone in the house. I think I served tofu and brown rice and broccoli and peach tea. I still have the scribbles on the legal pad that Ken used as he lectured. He gave an impressive overview of all the 66 texts that make up the Bible. His focus was on redemption—on how the Old Testament concealed the cross and the New Testament revealed it. His point of contact was Calvary and it made me think for the first time about what Jesus had endured at Calvary. Ken did a lot of talking at this lecture—he had a lot of material to cover. I was both intrigued and infuriated. The more he talked, the more infuriated I became. If what this guy said was true, then everything that I believed—every jot and tittle—was false! At the end, which by the way I thought would never come, he said, “What do you think?” I said something like, “You have one book that claims itself to be true, which is in philosophy called an ontological fallacy, and I have about 50 on my shelf that says you’re wrong. So it all comes down to how and why you claim that the Bible is true.” I hoped this would burst his bubble and send him packing and out the door. But it didn’t. Ken clapped his hands with a big toothy smile that seemed to imply that we were on the same page. (We were not.) He said with great joy and delight, “Exactly!” Ken’s enthusiasm for opposition annoyed me to no end.
We agreed that next time he would tell me how and why the Bible is true.
This seemed so naïve and so preposterous. I was a product of a postmodern education. There are no truths, only truth claims. After Ken and Floy left, I took a long walk with my dog Murphy. Walking in the cold dark I thought about how peaceful life would be if I really believed that there was a knowable, dependable, sturdy, and comprehensive idea of truth and a man-God who so loved his people that he endured the wrath of God the Father for the sins that I had committed and those I would go on to commit. But even this train of thought was not comforting to me. After all, what would I do with my past? I surely couldn’t throw it all away. My past was my shrine and any person or worldview that entered into my little world had to genuflect to this. I wondered about these Christians. Surely some of them had pasts. What did they do? How did they let go of their past without losing their identity? Who would I be without my lesbian identity? Of course, I had not always been a lesbian. But once I had my first girlfriend, I was hooked and I was sure I found my “real” self. Still, I wondered about this God who died for the sins of his people. It sounded too good to be true. I allowed myself to wonder if it could possibly be true. This self-question gave me a frightening pause.
Was I losing myself? Was I losing my mind?
A few weeks later Ken came over to my house with a book on Christian education and I was out running. I felt kind of embarrassed that he met my lesbian partner. Even though we had been meeting for over a year, I had kept T hidden. It was the first time that I ever felt anything but pride in “who I was.”
From April of 1997 to February of 1999 I read the Bible, (mostly) enjoyed talking with Ken and Floy, and (mostly) enjoyed turning over these new ideas. If I started to struggle with something, or started to face a word like “sin” or “repentance,” I quickly pushed it aside and read on.
I felt like a bonafide liberal, having friends who were so different from me! I felt like, on the liberal front, I had finally arrived! Ken would come to campus a lot and he and I continued to debate one another on panels discussing things like patriarchy or Promise Keepers. Some of my graduate students thought he was dangerous but I thought he was safe in a dangerous way. They said I was splitting hairs and losing my objectivity. I reminded them that I was a postmodernist who didn’t believe in objectivity.
One thing that made Ken safe as well as dangerous was a point of commonality between us. We both are good teachers. Good teachers make it possible for people to change their positions without shame. Even as Ken prayed for my soul, he did it in a way that welcomed me into the church rather than made me a scapegoat of Christian fear or an example of what not to become.
One thing that really struck me about Ken and Floy’s character during these years was how unselfish they were. I observed that they fed and housed and counseled countless people from all walks of life. I saw how wide the door to their home and the door to their heart opened. I remember feeling like I could talk to them about anything. Ken stressed that he accepted me as a lesbian but that he didn’t approve of me as a lesbian. He held that line firmly and I appreciated that. I had a whole university of approving people so I didn’t feel that I needed his, too. I learned that their eldest son, Dr. Ken Smith, was a colleague of mine at Syracuse. Oddly, we were on an important all-university committee together, the Budget Committee. I had thought that Dr. Ken was the only one on the committee who had a clue about what was going on. (I surely knew that I didn’t.) The Budget Committee was an important committee because it gave the current administration a time to check out those professors who had been selected to become future deans and presidents. They could watch and groom and invent us. Of course this is one of the many little open secrets of the life of a professor, but secret or not, it was gospel and we all knew it. We were being watched, we were being groomed, and some of us would go places. Dr. Ken and I had also experienced “professor camp” together—a weeklong seminar in the Adirondacks—during black fly season!—where we were indoctrinated by the administration into the latest teaching fad.
Dr. Ken, seeing me struggle with the Budget Committee work, became an accounting tutor and big brother of sorts. I thought that odd but helpful. With these Christians in my life, certain aspects of my life had started to lose the sharp edges that it had before. With these Christians in my life, my life became a little kinder and a little safer.
One night Ken and Floy introduced me to a man named R. He had been a former sex addict and heavy drug user. He also was Italian and had an English degree from Berkeley. We had much in common. I was drawn to him immediately. He worked at the university also and had come to a number of my lectures, unbeknownst to me. We became fast friends. R shared the gospel with great spontaneity and relevance. He would soon become my link to the church.
During this time, I thought about going to Ken’s church—I thought that it would be good for my research and I also thought that it would be interesting. What did they do there at this Reformed Presbyterian Church, I wondered? Did they speak in tongues? Did they wail and weep and dance in the aisles? Sometimes I would get in my truck Sunday morning and try to drive to church. I would make it to the Cole Muffler parking lot next to church. I imagined how absurd my red truck with the gay rights bumper stickers and NARAL (National Abortion Rights Action League) support sticker would look in the church’s parking lot, with all the minivans with stickers that read “Abortion stops a beating heart” and “Warning: un-socialized homeschoolers on board!” I figured that people probably didn’t wear jeans, as I always did, and the women probably didn’t wear a crew cut. Sometimes I would just sit there and read the New York Times and drink my Starbucks coffee and watch. I laughed out loud once realizing that I had become a church stalker! I did wonder about those large families pouring out of their minivans. I wondered who they were, what they struggled with, what substantive issues comprised their lives. I wondered how they could afford all those children.
During this time of struggle, others tried to help. A Methodist pastor and the Dean of the Chapel at Syracuse University believed that I did not have to give up everything to honor God. Indeed, he told me, since God made me a lesbian, I gave God honor by living an honorable lesbian life. He told me that I could have Jesus and my lesbian lover. This was a very appealing prospect. But I had been reading and rereading scripture, and there are no such marks of postmodern “both/and” in the Bible. Plus, truth be told, I was getting tired of my relationship with T. Something in my value system was changing. While I continued to find T attractive, I no longer found her compelling. The things she cared about seemed shallow. I thought that maybe I was just bored.
My friends from the gay community were on the alert. On Thursday nights, I had a regular tradition: I made a big dinner and opened my home for anyone in the gay and lesbian community to come and eat and talk about issues and needs. This is important for professors and pastors alike to do, since both jobs put you out of reach from the very people you think that you know. A regular at these events was a transgendered woman, J, a dear friend of mine who lives full-time in drag—she is biologically male but lives full-time as a woman and has taken female hormones for long enough that he is now chemically castrated. I was in the kitchen and J came in to help. She told me point-blank that all this Bible reading was changing me, and she wanted to know, before any more pasta could be served or wine glasses filled, what was going on in my life. At first I denied it, but she pressed. Finally, I said, “What would you say if I told you that I’m beginning to believe that Jesus is real, is a real and risen and loving and judging Lord, and that I am in big trouble?” She sat down at the kitchen stool, exhaled deeply, took my small hands in her large ones, and said, “Rosaria, I know that Jesus is a risen and living Lord. I was a Presbyterian minister for 15 years, and during that time, I prayed that the Lord would heal me. He didn’t, but maybe he’ll heal you. I’ll pray for you.” The next day, when I came home from work, I found two milk crates over-filled with books: J gave me her library of theology, and a few summers ago, when I read through Calvin’s Institutes, in pen, in my friend’s handwriting, are cautions, notes to self, “be careful here; don’t forget Romans 1.” Romans 1, especially verses 24-28, are the most frightening lines in scripture to anyone struggling in sexual sin:
Therefore, God gave them over in the lusts of their hearts to impurity, so that their bodies would be dishonored among them.
For they exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshipped and served the creature rather than the Creator, who is blessed forever, Amen.
For this reason God gave them over to degrading passions; for their women exchanged the natural function for that which is unnatural.
And in the same way also the men abandoned the natural function of the woman and burned in their desire toward one another, men with men committing indecent acts and receiving in their own persons the due penalty of their error.
And just as they did not see fit to acknowledge God any longer, God gave them over to a depraved mind, to do those things which are not proper. (NASB)
Finally, my dear lesbian neighbor, a woman old enough to be my mother, as she was fond of reminding me, turned to me one morning as we were having coffee at my kitchen table before our weekly farmer’s market journey and said: “Why Jesus? Why not Buddha? Or Yoga? Why did you surrender your life to the God in whose name so much harm has been done to gay people?” Indeed. Why Jesus?
I was so tossed about by what I was hearing that I learned, in spite of my pride, to pray. I had stopped writing my book on the Religious Right because I couldn’t talk myself into believing the things that I used to believe. I had been raised in the Catholic Church, and in spite of myself, I started to recall teachings and sensibilities that had once organized my childhood faith. I even started to bring to mind the Lord’s Prayer and the Apostles’ Creed, prayers and creeds that Catholics learn by heart and recite each Sunday. I decided to put all of this before Ken Smith and see what he thought of my confused state. It was risky to do, but Ken was by now my friend. He was the only person in my life that could help me make sense of a spiritual crisis. Without an appointment, I showed up at the Syracuse Reformed Presbyterian Church and found Ken in his office. I sat down in his chair and said, “Ken, my whole world is turning upside down. What should I do?”
Ken listened. He didn’t tell me what to do. Instead, he asked me a question. He said, “Did you ever repudiate your Catholic background?”
His question intrigued me. (They always did). I told him that I had never thought about it, that being Catholic was like being Italian for me. I told him that I didn’t ever remember a time when I chose to be Catholic, but I clearly remember the time when I chose to walk away from the church—after my best friend confessed to having sex with our parish priest. Years later, I learned through a newspaper article that my Mom found that Father P had had sex with a lot of children. The clincher was that Father P was the best priest I ever had and he taught me the most about God’s commandments, law, and love. I felt the furious betrayal of a jilted believer. My feminist vocabulary gave me the words to articulate this fury: when God, Father, and Culture become bedfellows, patriarchy’s danger is unleashed. That’s how I called the game.
Ken listened deeply and was silent for a while. When he spoke he refocused me. He said, “No, I don’t mean the church, I mean God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit. Did you ever really repudiate the God outlined in the Apostles’ Creed?”
I was stunned that he had mentioned the Apostles’ Creed.
I told him that I had been reciting in my head that week the Lord’s Prayer and the Apostles’ Creed. I wasn’t calling them to mind in an intentional way. They were just stuck in my head the same way that the theme song to the old 1970s TV show “Petticoat Junction” was stuck in my head for the first ten miles of my last marathon.
For someone raised Catholic, though, the church was God himself, so I never thought about separating the two. I never thought you could believe that the Apostles’ Creed might be true and not be a member of the Catholic Church (the “one true Church” as the Catholic Church teaches). I also thought that the use of the word “catholic” in the Apostles’ Creed meant the Catholic Church. Here is the Apostles’ Creed as I had memorized it and as Catholics teach it:
I believe in God, the Father Almighty, Creator of heaven and earth; and in Jesus Christ, his only Son, our Lord; who was conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary, suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, died, and was buried. He descended into Hell; the third day he rose again from the dead; he ascended into heaven, sitteth at the right hand of God, the Father Almighty; from thence he shall come to judge the living and the dead. I believe in the Holy Ghost, the Holy Catholic Church, the communion of the saints, the forgiveness of sins, the resurrection of the body, and life everlasting. Amen. (The Catholic Encyclopedia, p. 14)
I never thought about “Holy Catholic Church” meaning the church universal, that is, all who call upon Christ for forgiveness of sins. I thought it meant the Catholic denomination.
Ken asked me another question.
“Have you ever repudiated your baptism?”
I said that I had never thought about my baptism, not once.
My mom keeps in a box the little white dress that she dressed me in and the church bulletin that announced my baptism. I knew my godparents, although I had never had a spiritual God-centered talk with either one. Why is my baptism important, I wondered? I was an infant. Again, it was not something that I chose but rather it was an imposed symbol of my family’s culture and heritage. Ken told me that while baptism is not regenerative, it marks those within the covenant of God’s family. He told me to go home and think about my baptism and about God having orchestrated my life such that I was placed in a family that raised me with religious education. I attended Catholic schools and public schools and received four Catholic sacraments, none of which I understood. Ken instructed me to go home and think about the meaning of my baptism and my history of religious instruction.
What an odd assignment, I thought!
I went home that night and I prayed that God would help me make sense of Ken’s questions and of my strange feelings.
I often think about how Ken handled my questions—this one in particular. He of course could have cut this conversation short. When I confessed my spiritual struggle, he could have recited Acts 16:31, “Believe in the Lord Jesus and you will be saved, you and your household.” Most evangelical pastors would have acted like a shark in the water smelling fresh blood at the opportunity to quote this Bible verse to someone like me! Surely, it would have been an easier conversation had he handled my question by quoting the Bible. But Ken told me recently that the Holy Spirit did not give him liberty to say this. Ken felt that I needed to search my heart, and he also felt that he needed to know more about what my own religious background and training was. Ken responded to my question by making me take stock of myself before God.
I decided that my baptism meant something—although what, I wasn’t sure! I decided that God’s providence to provide me with more religious education than most people receive also meant something, although each jot and tittle I had to relearn. I decided that God was bigger than my consciousness.
The following Sunday, I started to go to the RP church—and not for research. That morning—February 14, 1999—I emerged from the bed of my lesbian lover and an hour later was sitting in a pew at the Syracuse RP church. I share this detail with you not to be lurid but merely to make the point that you never know the terrain someone else has walked to come worship the Lord.
Even though I felt like a freak in that church, I was drawn to keep going back. After a subsequent meeting with Ken, I came home and my lesbian partner told me that I was changing and that she was concerned. What did I need? Some time away from my work? Maybe we needed to take that long vacation. T is a psychologist, and you can’t hide a lot from a psychologist.
My transgendered friend’s words were still weighing heavily upon my heart. Who is this Jesus that he heals some but not others? Is it right to pray for healing when, from the Bible’s perspective, I was to repent from my sin? Does God hear prayers that are not construed in the terms he lays out in the Bible? If Jesus is the living word, can we pray “through” him if we do not follow him as our Savior and Lord? These questions weighed hard on me.
That night, I prayed, and asked God if the gospel message was for someone like me, too. I viscerally felt the living presence of God as I prayed. Jesus seemed present and alive. I knew that I was not alone in my room. I prayed that if Jesus was truly a real and risen God, that he would change my heart. And if he was real and if I was his, I prayed that he would give me the strength of mind to follow him and the character to become a godly woman. I prayed for the strength of character to repent for a sin that at that time didn’t feel like sin at all—it felt like life, plain and simple. I prayed that if my life was actually his life, that he would take it back and make it what he wanted it to be. I asked him to take it all: my sexuality, my profession, my community, my tastes, my books, and my tomorrows.
Two incommensurable worldviews clashed together: the reality of my lived experience and the truth of the word of God. In continental philosophy, we talk about the difference between the true and the real. Had my life become real, but not true? The Bible told me to repent, but I didn’t feel like repenting. Do you have to feel like repenting in order to repent? Was I a sinner, or was I, in my drag queen friend’s words, sick? How do you repent for a sin that doesn’t feel like a sin? How could the thing that I had studied and become be sinful? How could I be tenured in a field that is sin? How could I and everyone that I knew and loved be in sin? In this crucible of confusion, I learned something important. I learned the first rule of repentance: that repentance requires greater intimacy with God than with our sin. How much greater? About the size of a mustard seed. Repentance requires that we draw near to Jesus, no matter what. And sometimes we all have to crawl there on our hands and knees. Repentance is an intimate affair. And for many of us, intimacy with anything is a terrifying prospect.
When Christ gave me the strength to follow him, I didn’t stop feeling like a lesbian. I’ve discovered that the Lord doesn’t change my feelings until I obey him. During one sermon, Ken pointed to John 7:17, and called this “the hermeneutics of obedience.” Jesus is speaking in this passage, and he says: “If anyone is willing to do God’s will, he will know of the teaching, whether it is of God or whether I speak from myself.” Ah ha! Here it was! Obedience comes before understanding. I wanted to understand. But did I actually will to do his will? God promised to reveal this understanding to me if I “willed to do his will.” The Bible doesn’t just say do his will, but “will to do his will.” Wanting to understand is a theoretical statement; willing to do his will takes action.
I knew I didn’t have that! I prayed that the Lord would give me that whole-hearted will. I learned that the Lord wants all of our loyalties under submission to him. He wants us to identify ourselves, to call ourselves by name, in his name for us. In my case, my feelings of lesbianism were familiar, comfortable, and recognizable, and I was reluctant to give them up. I clung to Matthew 16:24, remembering that every believer had to at some point in life take the step that I was taking: giving up the right to myself, taking up his Cross (i.e., the historicity of the resurrection, not masochism endured to please others), and following Jesus. The Lord made it clear to me that I had to make some serious life changes.
I started to obey God in my heart one step at a time. I broke up with my girlfriend. My heart really wasn’t in the break-up, but I hoped that God would regard my obedience even in its double-mindedness. I started to go to the RP church fully, in my heart, for the whole purpose of worshiping God. I stopped caring if I looked like a freak there. I started to receive the friendship that the church members offered to me. I learned that we must obey in faith before we feel better or different. At this time, though, obeying in faith, to me, felt like throwing myself off a cliff. Faith that endures is heroic, not sentimental.
And then came the night terrors. Night after night, dreams so vivid and real that I could taste and feel them. Dreams so commanding that when I finally awoke, I felt filthy and delirious.
My journey out of lesbianism was messy and difficult. I spent a lot of time in prayer—and still do. I leaned heavily on the counsel of the women of the Syracuse church: Floy Smith, Vivian Rice, NM, Becky Smith, Robyn Zorn, Corrine Thompson, Marty Wright, Kathy Donath. I asked them vulnerable and real questions and they answered me and loved me anyway. The journey out of lesbianism had many dimensions, and the Lord was gracious in leading me a small step, and then burning the bridge I crossed to keep me safely closer to him. From the first night, there was no going back.
Slowly but steadily, my feelings did start to change—feelings about myself as a woman and feelings about what sexuality really is and what it really isn’t. I—like most everyone who identified as gay or lesbian—felt very comfortable, very at home in my body, in my lesbianism. One doesn’t repent for a sin of identity in one session. Sins of identity have multiple dimensions, and throughout this journey, I have come to my pastor and his wife, friends in the Lord, and always to the Lord himself with different facets of my sin. I don’t mean different incidents or examples of the same sin, but different facets of sin—how pride, for example, informed my decision-making, or how my unwillingness to forgive others had landlocked my heart in bitterness. I have walked this journey with help. There is no other way to do it. I still walk this journey with help.
The teaching, the prayers, and the friendships the Lord has given to me through the Body of Christ have blessed me richly. I’m grateful that the Lord brought me to a church that was as strong on teaching as it is on compassion. Did I find the perfect church? No. I almost left when things got hard, and they got hard fast. The time that I brought my drag queen friend to church pushed a lot of folks out of their comfort zone.
When a lesbian student of mine recovered from a suicide attempt first at the pastor’s home and then later at my home, and the Christian community and the lesbian community had to spend a lot of time together, I was really nervous. My lesbian friends had to learn that not all Christians are bigots. My Christian friends had to learn that Christians have a lot to learn from gay and lesbian folks about mercy work. At first, I missed the power in this fruitful exchange, and instead felt deeply uncomfortable. I didn’t know how to bridge the two groups.
Sharing this one Friday night at the home of Ron and Robyn Zorn, Ron reminded me that bridges get walked on and that is a normal part of being a bridge. Ah ha! And then I relaxed, remembering that this is the Lord’s work, not mine. Bridges, though, do get walked on, and if the Lord calls us to be a bridge, we have to learn to bear in his strength the weight. And it hurts. And it’s good. And the Lord equips. As he promises in scripture, he gives us the strength that we need to stand steadfast and trust in him. The Syracuse church no doubt grew in compassion because of the urgency of need that I brought, and my lesbian community grew in knowledge of what life in Christ can look like.
God sent me to a Reformed and Presbyterian conservative church to repent, heal, learn and thrive. The pastor there did not farm me out to a para-church ministry “specializing” in “gay people.” He and the session knew that the church is competent to counsel (to quote the title of one of Jay Adams’ useful books). I needed (and need) faithful shepherding, not the glitz and glamor that has captured the soul of modern evangelical culture. I had to lean and lean hard on the full weight of scripture, on the fullness of the word of God, and I’m grateful that when I heard the Lord’s call on my life, and I wanted to hedge my bets, keep my girlfriend and add a little God to my life, I had a pastor and friends in the Lord who asked nothing less of me than that I die to myself. Biblical orthodoxy can offer real compassion, because in our struggle against sin, we cannot undermine God’s power to change lives.
Healing comes through God’s work, and God deals differently with us when we deal differently with him. When we repent, he hears. Do I believe that I’m healed? Yes. My life shows the signs. My life went from black-and-white to color. At first I didn’t recognize myself in the world. Today, I don’t recognize myself in the pictures from my life as a lesbian.
Dr. Maureen Vanterpool, a colleague from Geneva College, told me recently that being a lesbian was a case of mistaken identity. This became an intriguing and important paradigm for me. And even though I’m no longer a lesbian, I’m still a sinner. I’m redeemed, but still fallen. And sin is sin. I believe that the Lord is more grieved by the sins of my current life than by my past life as a lesbian. How did the Lord heal me? The way that he always heals: the word of God got to be bigger inside me than I. My natural inclination was to resist, so like a reflex, I did this. God’s people surrounded me. Not to manipulate. Not to badger. But to love and to listen and to watch and to pray. And eventually instead of resisting, I surrendered.
Shortly after becoming a Christian, I counseled a woman who was in a closeted lesbian relationship and a member of a Bible-believing church. No one in her church knew. Therefore, no one in her church was praying for her. Therefore, she sought and received no counsel. There was no “bearing one with the other” for her. No confession. No repentance. No healing. No joy in Christ. Just isolation. And shame. And pretense. Someone had sold her the pack of lies that said that God can heal your lying tongue or your broken heart, even cure your cancer if he chooses, but he can’t transform your sexuality. I told her that my heart breaks for her isolation and shame and asked her why she didn’t share with anyone in her church her struggle. She said: “Rosaria, if people in my church really believed that gay people could be transformed by Christ, they wouldn’t talk about us or pray about us in the hateful way that they do.”
Christian reader, is this what people say about you when they hear you talk and pray? Do your prayers rise no higher than your prejudice?
I think that churches would be places of greater intimacy and growth in Christ if people stopped lying about what we need, what we fear, where we fail, and how we sin. I think that many of us have a hard time believing the God we believe in, when the going gets tough. And I suspect that instead of seeking counsel and direction from those stronger in the Lord, we retreat into our isolation and shame and let the sin wash over us, defeating us again. Or maybe we muscle through on our pride. Do we really believe that the word of God is a double-edge sword, cutting between the spirit and the soul? Or do we use the word of God as a cue card to commandeer only our external behavior?
Although grateful, I did not perceive conversion to be “a blessing.” It was a train wreck. After we profess faith in Christ, the next morning, the alarm still rings and we have to swing our feet out of bed and do something. And while we cannot lose our salvation, if we are not growing in spiritual maturity, we can lose everything else. What I faced at work following my conversion was the rubbish of my sin, forgiven by God, but still there to be cleared away. This required a newer and even more intense understanding and application of scripture.
When I became a Christian, I had to change everything—my life, my friends, my writing, my teaching, my advising, my clothes, my speech, my thoughts. I was tenured to a field that I could no longer work in. I was the faculty advisor to all of the gay and lesbian and feminist groups on campus. I was writing a book that I no longer believed in. And, I was scheduled in a few months to give the incoming address to all of Syracuse University’s graduate students. What in the world would I say to them? The lecture that I had written and planned to deliver—on Queer Theory—I threw in the trash. Thousands of new students would hear my first, fledgling attempts to speak about Christian hermeneutics at a postmodern university. I was flooded with doubt about my new life in Christ. Was I willing to suffer like Christ? Was I willing to be considered stupid by those who didn’t know Jesus? The world’s eyes register what a life in Christ takes away, but how do I communicate all that it gives? Do I really believe, in Charles Bridges’ words, “The very chains of Christ are glorious” (p. 33)?1 Peter, after being beaten for preaching the gospel, rejoiced that he was “counted worthy to suffer shame for [Christ’s] name” (Acts 5:41). I pondered this. To the world, this is masochism. To the Christian, this is freedom. Did I really believe this? Do I really believe this today?
I wondered: If my life was the only evidence that Christ was alive, would anyone be convinced?
And what about my home, my habitus? A habitus is a way of life that forms habits of the head, habits of the heart, and habits of the mind. My habitus had heretofore been a bastion of leftist political activism. What does a Christian habitus look like, especially one run by a single ex-lesbian with a now defunct PhD?
And what about my drag queen friend, who had prayed for the Lord’s healing? What exactly did that mean? What exactly is repentance? If it is a way of life for a Christian, I needed to understand it fully, comprehensively, deeply, and well.
And what of my responsibilities to my gay friends? Were their secrets still safe with me?
What does joy in Christ mean when faced with duties that you don’t want?
As I am sure it is clear by these concerns, I did not, in any way want to “share the hope that lies within me.” I wanted to go back to bed and draw the covers over my head.
Conversion put me in a complicated and comprehensive chaos. I sometimes wonder, when I hear other Christians pray for the salvation of the “lost,” if they realize that this comprehensive chaos is the desired end of such prayers. Often, people asked me to describe the “lessons” that I learned from this experience. I can’t. It was too traumatic. Sometimes in crisis, we don’t really learn lessons. Sometimes the result is simpler and more profound: sometimes our character is simply transformed.
