Chapter 6 of 10

The Good Guys: Sanctification and Public Worship

The Good Guys: Sanctification and Public Worship

The Good Guys: Sanctification and Public Worship

Geneva College, Beaver Falls, Pa., 2000–2001

Somewhere in the process of conversion, I picked up knitting with a vengeance. I have been a knitter all my life, since my Nana taught me when I was six. My post-conversion life found me obsessed with simple, repetitive tasks, and thus knitting became a love, a crutch, a twitchy habit, and the thing that I absolutely could not do without. I loved the feel of wool between my fingers, the material carving a little familiar callus on the outside of my ring finger. I loved the colors. I would pore over knitting books and linger in yarn stores, drinking in the color, breathing in the fiber. I experimented with color and with patterns. I made myself learn how to read a pattern accurately. I found myself reaching for my knitting at all times, but especially when I prayed. I still pray better with needles in my hands. Rows stand for worship, thanksgiving, petition, confession, renewal, people, problems, wisdom, insight, character, memory verses. Some people keep a prayer journal. My prayer journal is knitted into ridges and rows. I can look at sweaters, blankets, mittens, socks, dishcloths and potholders and remember what I prayed about during their birth. I wonder sometimes how much of this is the old habit of praying as a little girl with rosary beads in hand.

Packing to leave Syracuse was filled with terror. I kept my yarn box open, checking to make sure I had brought enough wool to get me through two semesters. I was more careful with my wool than with my clothes. I had planned to be gone for an academic year. I was sure that I brought enough wool for that. Confident that I would return, I left the remainder of my yarn stash, my completed projects, and my personal journals in a box in my neighbor’s basement. Syracuse—even with its losses now outnumbering its gains—had become my home. My life as a professor—even with its losses outnumbering its gains—had become my “I am.” It was the thing I couldn’t imagine living without—my title, my role, my secret place. It was my not-so-secret-stash of self-righteous pride.

I’ve always been more in tune with the inner landscape of life than with the outer landscape. It takes a lot to get me to notice geographical landmarks or the color shoes that somebody is wearing. I’d make a terrible witness in a crime. While internal landscapes have depth, shape, color, texture and taste, the external world is usually just a shade of gray for me. Even with this deficit in visual acuity, I couldn’t help but notice that in driving from central New York to western Pennsylvania, the landscape transformed.

Everything was greener, for one. Trees were lush. The air was moister. My hair started to curl on the turnpike and didn’t flatten out until January. As I exited the turnpike and entered Beaver County, something else took me by surprise. The whole county felt “religious.” On houses and even businesses, scripture verses advertised the worldview of the inhabitants. In New York, I was used to seeing pink flamingoes or statues of the Virgin Mary on lawns of neighbors. (I learned that one very important reason to keep my dog on a leash was his propensity to lift his leg on such ornaments, a gesture that did not usually endear me to my neighbors.) Here in Beaver Falls, 1945-style brick bungalows displayed scripture on placards. (I made a mental note to always keep my dog on leash around here.) The most popular verse was John 3:16, “For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have everlasting life.” Other houses displayed verses about God’s judgment and about the separation of the saved from the lost. It also was an election year. And clearly, I had entered George W. Bush country. Political advocacy plastered next to Bible verses makes me anxious. I’m not a betting woman, but if I was, I’d say that Jesus is not a member of either political party.

It took me a while to figure out how I felt about the Bible verses on the placards. On the one hand, the Bible had become my life, my guide for life, my paradigmatic mirror in which I found meaning and direction. I loved (and love) the Bible, gorging on huge chunks at a time. But these skinny verses, taken out of their rich and complex context, were just sitting out there on placards, naked and rude. I felt an immediate aversion to the aesthetic even as I identified with the message. For example, John 3:16 without John 3:17 seems to balance itself in the wrong place. John 3:17 says, “For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through him might be saved.” This verse gives me greater clarity into how to read the one that comes before it. It tells me that if Jesus did not come into the world to condemn it, then neither should Christians. The use of the word “might” in the final clause, “that the world through him might be saved,” tells me that the domain of Christian witness is not salvation (that is God’s work) but service—selfless love and sacrifice. John 3:16 standing alone and without the theology of care offered in John 3:17 makes it harder to interpret.

I had learned in a rich and organic way that the Bible webs into all conversations and cultures, like active verbs in sentences or oxygen in the atmosphere. I had learned that Christians need to follow the complex and counterintuitive ways that the Holy Spirit leads. I had learned that being a hero for Jesus was noble work, especially when no one but Jesus himself knew the stakes of the sacrifice at hand. But Bible verses that front salvation over Christian service, instead of being important interfaces between Christian homes and the watching world, seemed like sneaky little raids, quick and insulated targets into culture, with no sense that a worldview of care lay behind them. I had been the beneficiary of real Christian evangelism. Ken Smith spent time with me—and not just spare time. He spent pricey time—real time. He didn’t hide behind bumper stickers or slogans. He never let pride masquerade for principle. Perhaps I was being overly reactionary about the new landscape in Beaver Falls. Perhaps I or one of my drag queen friends would be welcome to have a cup of coffee at one of these Bible-loving houses, resting our cups between sips on vinyl tablecloths in country kitchens. Perhaps we would be talked with as people made in God’s image. But perhaps not. These placards made me wonder: Would I be welcome because I’m visibly saved? Which is the greater of God’s gifts, being made in God’s image or being saved, or both? Are we to rank-order these? Are we to treat the visibly saved with greater honor than all of humanity, made as it is in God’s image? Do these Bible verses that sit on placards take up the same cultural space as the rainbow flag that once resided on my flag-pole? Are these “Welcome” signs or signs that read “Insiders Only”?

Simply put, driving into Beaver Falls gave me the creeps. The placards scared me and the air smelled like Tide laundry detergent and box cake mix behind a backdrop of stale valley-trapped pollution.

I arrived on campus tired and hungry and scared. At the College’s main building, a stranger was waiting for me with a key. He drove me the back way to the place that would become my new home. This second-floor apartment faced an alley that reminded me of the one I used to play Kick the Can in as a child. I keyed in through the basement and entered a large storage and laundry room. I didn’t think I would have onsite laundry! This small detail thrilled me. As I walked up the flight of stairs into the living space, the first thing that I saw was a beautiful rocking chair. I love rocking chairs and was sad to leave mine in Syracuse. I scanned the place. A tidy kitchen, a soft couch, a comfortable bed, a desk, and even a TV (a much larger and nicer TV than I had!). The carpet was clean and the kitchen had a fresh coat of white paint. I put Murphy’s dog bed between the bedroom and living room. I sighed. I had to face it. This place was simply perfect. God has led me to my perfect home. I sang Psalm 23B to myself while I unpacked the car and took Murphy for a walk in our new neighborhood:

The Lord’s my Shepherd, I’ll not want;

He makes me down to lie

In pastures green, he leadeth me,

the quiet waters by;

My soul he doth restore again,

And me to walk doth make

Within the paths of righteousness

Ev’n for his own name’s sake

Yea, though I walk in death’s dark vale,

Yet will I fear no ill;

For Thou art with me and Thy rod

And staff me comfort still.

A table Thou hast furnished me

In presence of my foes;

My head Thou dost with oil anoint,

And my cup overflows.

Goodness and mercy all my life

Shall surely follow me;

And in God’s house for evermore

My dwelling place shall be.

I fell into a deep and peaceful sleep. I felt like a little child, fully dependent on someone wise and knowing. I had grown used to thinking that I was taking care of myself. Leaving my faculty post, even temporarily, was my way of saying, “Lord, I’m yours; give me what you will have me to hold.” There, as the fog of sleep receded, I experienced something that I simply could not conjure up in my consciousness: I experienced peaceful trust.

The enormity of the risk I had just undertaken didn’t hit me until I woke up for the first time in Beaver Falls, hearing trains, church chimes, and cardinals. Where was that trust that I had felt in my sleep? Why didn’t obedience produce trust? I contemplated this: could it be that obedience is somehow easier than trust? This is the point that begins Jerry Bridge’s book Trusting God Even When Life Hurts: The boundaries for obedience are clear, but trust must somehow manifest itself in the boundary-less world of “anything can happen.” The fact that God is sovereign over the good and the evil does not necessarily make the evil any less frightening. I recited Psalm 23 and got myself out of bed.

It was Psalm 15 that got me to Beaver Falls and Psalm 23 that kept me there.

For my birthday that year, Floy had given me a little book by F. B. Meyer called The Shepherd’s Psalm (1889). In it, I found what we in English studies call a controlling metaphor (a powerful albeit understated idea that holds all the other parts of a paradigm together). This, I believe, is the controlling metaphor of the Christian life, and one that I first found in Meyer’s book and first seized in that little cozy apartment during my first day in Beaver Falls. Meyer says, “Unbelief puts circumstances between itself and Christ, so as not to see Him…Faith puts Christ between itself and circumstances, so that it cannot see them” (p. 17).

When I woke up to my new life in Beaver Falls, it was the Lord’s Day. My first order of business was to choose a church. I had moved to the Mecca of the Reformed Presbyterian denomination. In Beaver Falls alone, there were five RP churches—two within walking distance, two within running distance, and one approachable by car. I never did find this last RP church, although I have it on good report that it exists. My plan was to visit each of the RP churches and then to transfer my membership to the one where I believed I would grow in the knowledge and grace of Jesus Christ and in my service to the church and to the world.

That morning I worshiped at the RP church right across the main street of Geneva College. The face of this church was different from Syracuse. People were younger and more casually dressed. Most of the people in attendance were Geneva College faculty, retired faculty, staff, students, or alumni. I had never even heard of this college until I united with the RPCNA. Now it seemed that everyone in my vicinity attended it at some point or another. I had never lived in any community that was quite this ingrown.

The new academic year was about to begin, and all the before-church-service-buzz was Geneva College Shop Talk. People rehashed the humanities curriculum, building plan, lack of raises, concerns with the administration’s handling of this and of that. The sharp edge of the conversation was different than I had expected. Because we are such a small denomination, I expected that we all got along! Silly me! The talk here was local, personal, and sometimes conspiratorial: the conservatives have taken over the seminary! The Truly Reformed were alienating Christians from other denominations! Some presbytery thought that it owned the college and was trying to impose adherence to a literal 24-hoursix-day creation standard that violated the academic freedom of both Reformed and non-Reformed faculty!

I had been on faculty, as a graduate student, non-tenured professor, and tenured professor for over a decade and I had never heard faculty talk like this. I could not have been more confused if these folks started talking Telugu. I felt a slow panic bleed through me. I knew how to be a professor. I knew (barely) how to be a Christian. But if understanding the lingua franca buzzing around me was necessary to function here as a Christian professor, then I was dead in the water.

Some people probably learn how to swim by falling off a boat and almost drowning. But that doesn’t necessarily mean that they would make great swim coaches. I felt like someone whose Christian life was born in this kind of death-or-life tug-of-war. I was just coming to my Christian senses. I hadn’t written my testimony in a way appropriate to share with strangers. I felt like a non-native speaker trying to communicate the most important and complex truth in a tongue I barely handled. My embryonic biblical literacy crumbled under the weight of the expectations around me.

My most sincere prayer that morning at this church was that no one would ask me a question whose depth or merit extended beyond “Would you like a cup of coffee?”

This early introduction at the pre-service talk time typified my time at Beaver Falls. This would be a year of tearing down and melding together, of tossing out and grafting to the Cross. Grief makes us fickle, as we try on our self-diagnosis from all points of view. What ails me? My broken engagement? My feminism? My church community’s naïve relief in resolving my past homosexuality in my future heterosexual marriage? My past sexual sin? My present sin? My driven covetousness of a life built on something other than bad choices? Here I was in a public setting and I didn’t have a game face to put on. These people with their complete marriages, their kind children, their well-spent lives cast a reflection on the legacy of my choice-making. I wondered how different my life would have been had I gone to Geneva College. Would I have met the Lord as a college student? When I used my old worldview, my life felt like a cruel joke. But I knew even then that God’s providence was neither arbitrary nor fickle. God allowed me to rise as high as I could and fall swiftly and publicly. Had my sin not preceded me in a public way and had my repentance not been my lifeboat, had I found myself neatly protected within the confines and choice-making of Christian family and community, I today would probably have been the greatest of all Pharisees. Some people are smart enough to learn lessons the easy way. Not me. I always need to fall on my face.

Folks at this church were friendly. I was immediately welcomed to join the women’s Bible Study and given many slips of paper with phone numbers to call if I needed anything. (My phone would not be hooked up for weeks to come, as I moved to Beaver Falls during the Verizon strike, but I valued the sentiment nonetheless.) From the church bulletin I could tell that this church was as committed to outreach as to caring for its own members. And although they were at the time in search of a new pastor, they didn’t appear to be divided, angry, or confused. The retiring pastor was preaching that day. Dr. Jonathan Watt has a PhD in linguistics and was on faculty at both Geneva College and our seminary. He was leaving the pastorate to commit himself to full-time teaching. His sermon was shorter than Ken Smith’s and much more polished.

I had gotten used to the fact that in every Ken Smith sermon, my still-kicking feminist sensibilities would be offended—deeply. Ken used the male pronoun exclusively and once used “totalitarian” throughout a whole sermon when he really meant to say “totalizing.” I was seething. And, oddly enough, I kept coming back for more. Was I a masochist, I wondered? Or was I learning to forbear? I came to believe that my job was not to critique and “receive” a sermon, but to dig into it, to seize its power, to participate with its message, and to steal its fruit. I learned by sitting under Ken Smith’s preaching that the easily offended are missing the point. At the Syracuse church, my colleague and friend Dr. Ken Smith taught an adult Sunday school class. In Dr. Ken’s class, I was learning how Christians make priorities. I was learning to examine my gender politics against the teachings of scripture. I was learning that it was safe to do this, and that even Bible-believing Christians upheld a range of possible biblical applications to the question of gender and women’s roles. But here at this church I found a more sophisticated message and a more sophisticated audience. I didn’t leave the sermon feeling raw. I left the sermon thinking about literature and the rich array of languages that webbed through a biblical worldview. It got me thinking about biblical literacy in new and deeper ways. The service was short and to the point. The pastor was very warm and kind. Part of me loved this place and part of me didn’t trust myself here.

In Beaver Falls, the Reformed Presbyterian churches offer not just morning services, but evening worship services as well. This was a new tradition for me (and one I had a hard time incorporating). My usual pattern in Syracuse was to don my pajamas after supper and curl up in bed with a good book. The churches in Beaver Falls all had different identities. The church that I had visited that morning felt like the company church—it was for professors and students—the young, cool, hip and happening people. For evening service on that first Lord’s Day in Beaver Falls, I walked the two blocks from my apartment to the Geneva Reformed Presbyterian Church. The pastor at the Geneva Reformed Presbyterian Church was Bruce Backensto. I had heard that Bruce was working on a PhD in Theology on the doctrine of sanctification, and that he and his wife Kim both had prior divorces.

I entered the church building ten minutes early—my usual for a first time visit anywhere. I stayed to the back and listened to people talk. The buzz here was about a woman named Mary Lou who was fighting liver cancer. A match had just been found and the operation was to take place soon. Years of prayer carved this long and painful journey. God has heard the prayers of his people.

Once spotted, I was greeted by people who made me feel like old friends: there by the church kitchen were Willard McMillan and Renwick Wright, and their dear wives, Shirley and Maureen. They welcomed me as if they were waiting for me to come. I had met both couples in Syracuse where their grown daughter and son and grandchildren lived and worshiped. There was nothing hurried here. No pretenses. Willard said: “You’ve been through so much. Are you well? Is God sustaining you?” Renwick said, “Here is our Daniel, David and Paul all in one! Has our Lord given you victory today? If not this whole day, how about this very minute?” I felt immediately safe to explore my fickle and unstable heart. I hoped that here at the Geneva church, it was safe to grieve. I couldn’t impress anyone here if I tried, so I settled into the hard work of turning the pages of my heart, holding each one open and naked for spiritual scrutiny.

The service was about to begin and we took our seats in folding chairs in the damp and moldy church basement. The congregation consisted mostly of people in their 70s and 80s. The only visible exception to this was the pastor’s large and young family. There were also a few college students and a handful of 20- and 30-somethings. The psalm singing was the most dreadful that I had ever heard, with hearing aids bumping and crashing the already-unstable pitch at each stanza. There was one old gentleman who insisted on holding on to the note from one stanza until the next was well under way. The singing made me dizzy in a seasick kind of way. Bruce walked to the podium with a lurch and a limp uncharacteristic for a man who appeared to be in his fifties. His presence in the pulpit was intense and urgent. He seemingly had no notes. He was preaching from Galatians 5:16-25:

So I say, live by the Spirit, and you will not gratify the desires of the sinful nature. For the sinful nature desires what is contrary to the Spirit, and the Spirit what is contrary to the sinful nature. They are in conflict with each other, so that you do not do what you want. But if you are led by the Spirit, you are not under law.

The acts of the sinful nature are obvious: sexual immorality, impurity and debauchery; idolatry and witchcraft; hatred, discord, jealousy, fits of rage, selfish ambition, dissensions, factions and envy; drunkenness, orgies, and the like. I warn you, as I did before, that those who live like this will not inherit the kingdom of God.

But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. Against such things there is no law. Those who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified the sinful nature with its passions and desires. Since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit. Let us not become conceited, provoking and envying each other. (NIV)

The focus of this sermon series, Bruce explained, was to explore in detail each of the deeds of the flesh, and to examine ourselves in the light of this scripture. Today, we would explore, in explicit detail, the first deed of the flesh mentioned: sexual immorality.

As I sat in that folding chair and listened to Bruce preach, I knew that I had never heard anything like this. It corresponded to scripture, and to what I had been reading in the Bible. But I had never heard anyone talk like this from the pulpit. In Syracuse, we only talked like this in private, and then, only with some people (never Pastor Ken). Pastor Bruce was eagle-eye direct, painfully honest, and unapologetically bold. There was no question in my mind, as the tears started to run down my face: I had just barely started on the journey of my repentance. And here I had thought that I had repented in full and that my pain was the result of R’s sin. Ha! This sermon hit me hard across the face: I was suffering from my own sin, from the pride that was still rising high in my heart, and from my false sense of entitlement and deserved goods. Here I had spent the summer feeling and acting like some innocent victim of a random crime. How false! I was guilty.

R’s sin was on his head, but I had much of my own sin to both claim and shed at the throne of Grace. One of the complexities of repenting from sexual sin is that its consequence is double-directional, casting a shadow on both our past and our future. It affects the way we remember (and rationalize) and the way we live. I felt completely transfixed by Bruce’s message. I was scribbling notes as fast and as furiously as I could. I felt like someone parched gulping water in panic and frenzy. As I was trying to keep up with this unfamiliar style of preaching, Willard McMillan passed a note down to me from his folding chair row. He winked at me when a stranger placed it in my hand, so I would know that it came from a friendly place. The note said: “Hang in there and keep breathing!” I looked up and over to him, and he beamed that melting smile that made his eyes dance like falling stars. In the hue cast by Willard’s dancing eyes, I knew it. I had now found my church home. After the benediction, which I sorely needed, I unfolded myself from my chair and I walked to the door. I was too wiped out to talk to people or to thank the pastor. The usual niceties of church were completely lost to me that night.

I was drenched with sweat and had used up all my Kleenex. I walked the two blocks to my apartment slowly and gingerly, as if injured. Never in my life had I had a spiritual experience like this. I felt like I had just come as close as I ever had to understanding the living Jesus. I wanted my friends in Syracuse to hear what I just heard. I felt both vindicated and convicted. I felt peace. Walking home in the dark, it became perfectly clear to me why God brought me to Beaver Falls, the real reason, the best reason. The Lord brought me to Beaver Falls to sit under Bruce Backensto’s preaching and to live out what I was learning. I had much more sin, layers of sin, from which to repent. And through Bruce’s preaching, I would learn how to grieve through repentance without feigning false innocence. I learned that night the simple truth of sanctification on this side of heaven: it is as the writer of Hebrews tells us, both “already” and “not yet.” Even when faced with the blinding sting of someone else’s sin, it really is not someone else’s sin that can hurt us. It is our own festering sin that takes the guise of innocence that will be the undoing of us all.

I spent my first week in Beaver Falls trying to catch my breath. I was incommunicado. No phone. No e-mail. I wrote a letter to Ann O’Neill, to let her know that I was in town and that my phone wasn’t working. Ann lived in Pittsburgh and her husband Jerry was (and is) the president of our denomination’s seminary. Although I had only met them a few times, they both maintained the rigorous faith that I wanted and that I admired. They reached deep into the world and touched people that most conservative Christians don’t even know exist. I could tell that by the way that they welcomed me. They gave me good counsel when R broke off the engagement. They were no strangers to suffering. They were the kind of people that could handle someone else’s grief without taking things personally. Getting to better know Jerry and Ann was one of the things that I was most looking forward to in my new life in Pennsylvania.

My first week at Geneva College was startling to me. Faculty culture is always a deeply peculiar thing. I had grown comfortable with the faculty culture at Syracuse, where it was OK to not like each other. Here was another story! Many of the faculty were themselves Geneva College alumni. I was (and am) suspicious of this. It seemed to me that former students (even if now faculty members) would not exercise the proper liberty when debating their former and beloved professors. Instead of bringing a fresh look with new angles to the curriculum, the student culture and the faculty climate, I feared that these former-students-now-professors would be swayed by nostalgia, sentimentality, and respect for authority. Instead of growing into their own professorial identity, I suspected that many young faculty were trapped in their mentor’s identity. Or maybe I was just jealous of the fact that these people still had a career while I had just flushed mine down the toilet.

My schedule looked like this. I team-taught one Critical Theory class with another Geneva College faculty member. I taught a senior seminar on Charlotte and Emily Brontë in the context of Christian hermeneutics. During the week I also conducted independent study classes and led one campus Bible study. Students at Geneva presented a wider range of college preparation compared with my Syracuse undergraduates. The students welcomed me with an intensity that surprised me. They shared with me the many conflicts that are universally faced at Christian colleges: denominational fighting and cultivation of sin, both big and small. One big issue was how the Catholics and Protestants would get along. On the first night of Bible study in my small apartment, one student turned to another and said, “You’re Catholic? What are you doing here?” The Catholic student responded: “Twenty percent of the student body is Catholic! The question is: ‘You’re RP? What are you doing here?’”

Well, this was surely going to be an interesting place! Monday through Thursday was filled with students filing into my office, trailing me to the cafeteria, coming to my apartment for Bible study, and helping me find my balance as a Christian and as a professor.

One of the Herculean feats of my schedule was my weekly commute into Pittsburgh to teach at the Center for Urban Biblical ministry. The challenge was getting there. Pittsburgh is littered with rivers, tunnels, and one-way streets. Driving to Pittsburgh from Beaver Falls required transporting oneself through the land-equivalent of the Bermuda Triangle.

This treacherous journey was well worth its dangers. The single most important and life-changing experience of my academic life waited for me at the other end. At the Center for Urban Biblical Ministry (CUBM), I worked for a no-nonsense black woman named Karla Threadgill Byrd, and I taught courses in the Bible as Literature and Research Methods. My students were all much smarter than I was. Each person there had a story—or ten. Each was a jewel in Christ’s crown. My students were black and, more often than not, over 40. They were putting their lives together after much hardship. In spite of poverty, racism, and lack of education, my students found the time to be foster parents, parents, students, and some pastors. (I’m sure that my husband and I are licensed foster parents today and parents of four children-of-color because of the fine and godly example that these saints gave to me). When I drove from Beaver Falls to Pittsburgh on Friday afternoons, and when I stepped into my classroom, no matter how tired or discouraged I was, I knew that I was entering holy ground. If I ever go back to teaching, I would consider it an honor to work again at CUBM and for Karla Byrd. CUBM was a desperate place. We weren’t trying to impress anyone, least of all, each other. We tried, with humility, to hear God’s call on our life and muster the courage and integrity to fulfill it.

My work at CUBM ended late on Friday nights. I was grateful when Jerry and Ann O’Neill offered extended hospitality—to me and my dog! After teaching, I could go to the home of Jerry and Ann, for dinner, for prayer, and for the best sleep I would have all week. Each Friday night, Jerry and Ann spent time with me—again, pricey time, not spare time. They allowed me to integrate into their family, to spend time with the children who were still young enough to live at home, to watch a Christian family function. I stayed at their home every Friday night for that whole academic year. I shared with them everything. No matter how late into the night we talked, we always ended the evening with prayer. Their home was my safe haven, and their friendship helped hold me together week after week. I would return home Saturday afternoon refreshed and ready for the Lord’s Day. On some weekends, I would join them for worship at the Providence RP Church. I was taking it all in, everything from content of sermons, family dynamics, personal styles in ministry and life, roles for women, loss, healing. Like Ken and Floy, Jerry and Ann allowed me to experience with them real Christian living.

One month into my new life, a faculty colleague approached me asking if I would like to be part of a lecture series on the integration of faith and life. I was intrigued. I hadn’t found my public voice yet in this strange Christian climate, and this seemed like a good place to start. I accepted the invitation and decided to give my “Solomon” paper, revising the introduction to explain its context and its original audience. Since my paper was already written, I agreed to give it the following week.

I was shocked that many faculty colleagues came out for these talks. At Syracuse, I would have been speaking to an audience of about three. The unspoken rule among the overachieving faculty at Syracuse was clear: if the activity didn’t beef up the Curriculum Vitae, then don’t do it! I was doubly shocked to see Pastor Bruce there. The difference between giving the same talk at Syracuse and then again here at Geneva College was startling to me. At Syracuse, I was speaking as a traitor and an outcast. Now, I was speaking as an insider to other insiders. People responded with support and encouragement. As I was reading my paper, I felt sort of like I was floating on the ceiling watching myself deliver the paper. I recalled my deep traitorship to the gay community. I started to feel that weak-kneed nausea that had accompanied its first delivery at Syracuse. My talk felt flat and unimportant. I felt like I was making a fool of myself.

Two very important things happened after this talk, both related to counseling. As the audience was filing out, Pastor Bruce approached me and asked if I was OK (I wasn’t) and if I needed weekly counseling (I did). Bruce is direct, if not blunt, and I have always appreciated this about him. We set up a weekly counseling time. For that whole year, Bruce and Kim spent hours with me, listening to my journey and helping me to see God’s providence in its twists and turns. They shared their own journeys, and I saw bits and pieces of their lives and of the Rugged Cross that Bruce shared in his sermons. He wasn’t just writing a dissertation on sanctification; he and his family were living it. Had Bruce and Kim charged me by the hour for their time and counsel, I still would be paying back the debt I owe to them.

Second, Dr. Dean Smith, chair of the Bible Department (and former pastor of the College Hill RP Church, a church with a long history and equally long solid reputation), asked me if he could help me in any way. He had noticed that I wasn’t OK and invited me to his office to talk. I spent time—a lot of time—in Dean’s office that academic year. I told him that I felt like an imposter and that I didn’t know how to be a Christian professor. I asked him if he would mentor me and if I could sit in on a class of his, to see him teach and to learn how to integrate my faith and my life. Dean’s warmth and his vulnerability put me at ease. He and his wife Nancy brought me into their home during times that would likely be hard on me. I spent the best Christmas Eve of my life in their home (even though, for several reasons, I didn’t then and don’t now celebrate Christmas). Dean welcomed me to audit a class he was teaching in Christian Counseling, and it was in Dean’s class that I first learned how to study the Puritans. It was also in Dean’s class that I saw a real Christian professor at work. I was amazed at the levels of integration (of discipline, knowledge, Christ, hardship, betrayal, perseverance, compassion, and faith) that I could discern in Dean’s lectures and his manner of dealing with students. I didn’t then and I don’t now have this gift. Dean’s gift is tangible and ethereal. He moves fluently between preaching and lecturing. He redeems every student question. He humbles himself, but only gains respect in doing this. I was mesmerized by his biblical fluency, his emotional intelligence, and his humility. I tried to take notes about Dean’s giftedness as a professor, to see if I could apprehend even a kernel of it. I’m still working on this today. I had spent my best years steeping in the wrong worldview. God saved me, but hadn’t lobotomized me. My deep patterns of thinking and interpretation were also suspect to sin. That was painfully evident to me now.

After two weeks in Beaver Falls, God assembled for me a powerful team of Christian counselors and role models. Pastor Bruce taught me to apply the means of grace that God provides to repent and to grow in sanctification. Jerry and Ann taught me to pray even when I didn’t feel like it. Karla taught me to sacrifice and take risks. And Dean modeled for me how one grafts “Christian” and “professor” into one.

After I thanked God for my teachers and role models, and after I started praying risky and bold prayers, he sent me ministry—students, in packs, hungry and searching and real.

A month or so after my Solomon talk, the college chaplain approached me with a proposition. He was putting together the schedule for a chapel-sponsored grab bag called Convocation (sometimes lecture, sometimes praise and worship songs, etc.). Students were required to attend a certain number of chapel services and convocation lectures, so I was guaranteed a good turnout. (If this was said to make me feel better, it didn’t.) He wanted to know if I was ready to share my testimony with the college community. “No thanks,” I said. “Really,” he said, “Think about it.” I didn’t have to think about it. I was having a hard enough time living my testimony. And I had seen too many Oprah Winfrey shows, where one off-her-rocker contestant after another claims salvation-through-something. And I had read too many cheesy Christian testimonies, all written in the past tense, all very simple, happy, and filled with more clichés than sugar in grandma’s cookies (or, in my case, garlic in Nana’s meatballs). I decided to excuse myself from the myriad of rhetorical snares implicit with the sharing of one’s testimony. My conversion still felt like a train wreck, and I am adverse to clichés on any level. I decided to vow silence.

All of the testimonies that I had heard up to this point were egocentric and filled with pride. Aren’t I the smarty-pants for choosing Christ! I made a decision for Christ, aren’t I great? I committed my life to Christ, aren’t I better than those heathens who haven’t? This whole line of thinking is both pervasive among evangelical Christians and absurd. My whole body recoiled against this line of thinking. I’m proof of the pudding. I didn’t choose Christ. Nobody chooses Christ. Christ chooses you or you’re dead. After Christ chooses you, you respond because you must. Period. It’s not a pretty story.

“Pray about it,” the chaplain said.

I did pray about it, so that I could with good conscience say no. I was reluctant to make myself a poster child for gay conversion. I felt and feel no solidarity with people who think their salvation makes them more worthy than others. I didn’t want to call attention to myself. I didn’t want every wacko on campus to confess his or her feelings of same-sex love or homophobia or refer for counseling their gay aunts or neighbors. I thought about the bumper sticker once popular in the gay community as a spoof against evangelical Christians: “I killed a gay whale for Christ!” Or the other bumper sticker, “Lord, please protect me from Your people!” I still felt ambivalence about my disloyalty to my gay friends. And I knew that I could not write a neat, happy, schmaltzy, G-rated, egocentric testimony if my life depended on it.

But, I wondered, could I write an honest testimony? Could I, in the Apostle Paul’s words and tradition, write and deliver a testimony that reveals repentance as fruit of the Christian life? In English studies we have a mantra: a culture is comprised of its stories. “We are the stories we tell,” I’ve said to my students year after year. I was critical of the stories I heard from my churchy friends and my evangelical culture. But could I be more than just critical of the stories that encompassed me? Could I start a new conversation? What would happen if I just told the truth? Was anybody else out there ambivalent about conversion? Did anyone else see it as bittersweet? Did anyone else get lost in fear when counting the costs of discipleship? Did anyone else feel like giving up? Did anyone else tire of taking up the Cross daily? Did anyone else grieve for death to one life that anticipates the experience of being “born again”? Did anyone else want to take just one day off from the command that we die to ourselves?

I told the chaplain the next day that I was ready to give my testimony to the campus. “But,” I warned him, “My testimony is R-rated.”

I gave myself a month to write and revise the ten-page paper that became my testimony. I put up pictures of my old friends in my apartment and I pictured myself delivering this paper in front of them. I panic-wrote in the early dark mornings and revised late into the dark night. I held every thought captive to the truth. I prayed that in telling the truth that God would be honored.

I don’t have a copy of the testimony that I first wrote and delivered at Geneva College in the fall semester of 2000. When I walked into the auditorium, it was packed and noisy with the energy of student life. I remember being relieved that Pastor Bruce and most of the elders of my church were there to support me. Someone introduced me, and I stepped up to the microphone. I began the talk by asking if anyone knew the difference between the concepts “private” and “confidential.” I told them that what I was about to tell them was private. Private things can be discussed in special circumstances, but not in common ones. Therefore, if students wanted to talk with me about what I was about to tell them, they needed to schedule special time. I was not going to address what I was about to say in my classroom or at the lunch table. This is hard for me, I told them, and they are to respect my boundaries about this. They listened well. I remember feeling the visceral respect that a speaker feels when a room suddenly goes tear-dropping quiet.

I shared my life. I told them the real truth as best as I could. I remember feeling great dread as I read from my prepared manuscript.

The talk generated a lot of questions. Some questions revealed what these students had not learned about God’s grace. One student asked: “how do you know you are healed if you are not having sex with a man?” In return, I asked him, “Why is my health as a Christian determined by having sex at all?” I went on to explain what has always seemed obvious to me, but often comes to a great shock to Christians. I explained that too often good Christians see sexual sin as merely sexual excess. To a good Christian, sex is God’s recreation for you as long as you play in God’s playground (marriage). No way, José. Not on God’s terms.

What good Christians don’t realize is that sexual sin is not recreational sex gone overboard. Sexual sin is predatory. It won’t be “healed” by redeeming the context or the genders. Sexual sin must simply be killed. What is left of your sexuality after this annihilation is up to God. But healing, to the sexual sinner, is death: nothing more and nothing less. I told my audience that I think that too many young Christian fornicators plan that marriage will redeem their sin. Too many young Christian masturbators plan that marriage will redeem their patterns. Too many young Christian internet pornographers think that having legitimate sex will take away the desire to have illicit sex. They’re wrong. And the marriages that result from this line of thinking are dangerous places. I know, I told my audience, why over 50% of Christian marriages end in divorce: because Christians act as though marriage redeems sin. Marriage does not redeem sin. Only Jesus himself can do that. The audience seemed a little shocked to hear this.

The questions shifted from sexual sin to expressed anger at church culture: specifically, how do we talk like this in church when church is, according to one student, “filled with hypocrites.” Although only one student articulated this sentiment, the auditorium sighed with solidarity. I pointed that out to them and asked for a show of hands to better see how many shareholders this idea had. The majority of the audience raised a hand. I then put my manuscript aside and issued a challenge to these students. “Maybe churches are filled with hypocrites because you are not there. Or maybe churches are filled with hypocrites because you are there in pride and in self-promotion. Here’s my challenge to you: for those with church ties, start going to church in honest vulnerability. For those of you who are not going to church at all, come to church with me. Make a 6-month commitment. Pray with me for God’s saving and guiding grace, and then we can talk about whether or not church is filled with hypocrites.”

I should tell you that I rarely speak off of my manuscript and that when I do, I always get myself in trouble. This was the dumbest charge I have ever issued in a public forum.

After this talk, a group of students organized to take me up on my offer. These were students who were doubting, or unbelieving, or deep in sin, or seeking real ministry hoping to support fellow students who were ready to ask honest questions of the church and of the Lord. I started bringing with me to the Geneva RP Church a troupe of students. The church was grieving the imminent death of one of its younger members. Mary Lou, in her early sixties, for whom a liver was matched and ready for transplant, could not accept the match because cancer had already hijacked her life. The church had prayed for years for Mary Lou to have a donor. God’s will in this situation seemed like a trick or a bad joke. Pastor Bruce, preaching through Romans, was highlighting the mystery of God’s will and the overriding power of God’s character. Pastor Bruce was preaching through Romans in the morning and Galatians 5 in the evening. My students and I watched Pastor Bruce preach and watched a congregation grieve. After church, we came back to my small apartment and addressed basic and fundamental questions: Why shouldn’t I have sex before I’m married? Who is God to say that my body is not my own? How does my internet sex really hurt anybody else? What do I do with my past? My family? My friends? My depression? My addiction? My anxiety? After a time of discussion and prayer, we took a walk with my dog and reassembled for evening worship.

What we did, these students and I, for a whole academic year, is very simple. It is called “Sabbath keeping,” and my denomination values it highly. We simply took a day off from real life so that we could explore and expand our spiritual lives.

During this time, colleagues and friends continued to pose to me questions that I had avoided answering. These questions were about my church’s worship standards (sometimes also called the “distinctives” of the RPCNA) and about why I believed such worship standards were indeed biblical. My colleagues wondered why such bizarre worship standards were not off-putting, especially to unbelieving students, and why a postmodern gal like me could abide by them. One colleague put it succinctly: The RP Church’s worship standards lack New Testament grace.

I had to face these questions head-on. I didn’t want to. I liked my church. I liked my pastor. I liked my history with Ken and Floy Smith. I felt and feel connected to my denomination because of emotional and experiential attachments.

These questions from my colleagues made me squirm. I felt like a lightning rod for confusion and suspicion about the RP church. I was asked at a faculty meeting if I was a plant for the RP church. (At the time, my friend Dr. Ken Smith was Chairman of the Board of Trustees, and, I assume, my new colleagues at Geneva felt that I was reporting directly to Ken.) I was told by a department chair that my denomination was “exploiting me for my testimony” and once they found out who I really was (who am I? I wondered, and how did this guy think he had me figured out?), they would “run me up the flag pole and light a match.” I was told by a retired biblical feminist that I should leave this patriarchal denomination for its unbiblical gender politics and find my spiritual niche in the Episcopalian church, perhaps as a priest.

I was asked—time and again—to explain why I was a member of the Reformed Presbyterian denomination. It was a good question, but a hard one. The question hurt because it touched a raw nerve. I knew that I was Christ’s, but I really didn’t know why I was a member of this denomination. At the time, all that I could say was, “These are the people that God sent to come get me, and I’m loyal as a bird dog!” Well, loyalty is fine and good (especially for a bird dog), but real Christian intellectuals expect (and rightly so) more than that. Why am I a member of this denomination, I wondered? And why are those things that set us apart in worship so alienating to others? Why do people think that I am not “using my gifts” in the worship of God if my church doesn’t let women preach or sing solos? Do I have to perform in a church service in order to participate in it? Do performers grow in grace more strongly than participators? It seemed to me, that in worship, God wanted me to sit down, shut up, and listen—so that I could go and use my gifts out there in the world. It did not occur to me that God wanted me to show off or bring attention to myself. But even this was just an impression, a sensibility. I had nothing solid to say to anyone who inquired: Why are you RP?

I started to ask other people who worshiped in the RP church these questions. Many people seemed untroubled by these questions. Many of my RP colleagues took a “live and let live” attitude about the worship practices that divided us. Indeed, some of my RP colleagues were even apologetic about our worship practices. Many of my colleagues were “blue bloods,” that is, members of families that have a long lineage in our denomination. It seemed to me that their “membership” was never under the kind of scrutiny that mine was. There was only one person who took my questions as seriously as I did: Kent Butterfield, then a seminary student. He recommended two important books to examine: Michael Bushell’s Songs of Zion: A Contemporary Case for Exclusive Psalmody and Brian M. Schwertley’s Sola Scriptura and the Regulative Principle of Worship. Through the study of these books, I became convinced that the worship of the Lord was the most important thing that we can do. Notice: I did not say that it is the only thing that we do. But worship is the launching pad for life. And, through it, God equips us to do Kingdom work in the world. Therefore, worship has to be right in God’s eyes and right in our hearts and minds. Through the study of these books I fell in love and gratitude with our denomination’s worship standards, seeing it as foundational, not to our salvation, but to our sanctification and our service.

These questions led me back to my first intellectual love—hermeneutics—and to a book by a Christian scholar named Kevin Vanhoozer entitled, Is There a Meaning in this Text: The Bible, the Reader, and the Morality of Literary Knowledge. It seemed to me that I had to grasp these questions about worship practices from the point of view of hermeneutics. Hermeneutics is an old Greek word that refers to how we interpret life, text, and event. That is, hermeneutics is the study of how we make meaning out of text. Another word that often interchanges with hermeneutics is worldview. Hermeneutics focuses on the details; worldview takes the point of view of the frame. These two terms need to be understood in relationship. A stained glass window relies on the right relationship between the details that make up each frame and the big picture that emerges when you lift your eyes off the minute detail. It is exceedingly dangerous to build a Christian life on one or the other. You must hold both in tension and balance. Taken together, hermeneutics and worldview make up a critical perspective. Is there such a thing as a Christian critical perspective on worship, I wondered?

As a feminist scholar, this concept—worldview—was the most important concept in my intellectual arsenal. Worldview is central to feminist studies and to any field of study that analyzes oppressed or marginalized peoples. It helps us to understand how interpretations come from the frames of intelligibility that we use to look at the events that matter. Critical perspective asserts that we make meaning out of our lives not by personal experience but by the frames through which we filter that experience. On my Women’s Studies 101 syllabus, I wrote this about critical perspective:

NB (nota bene, or, “note well”): Students are expected to write all papers and examination essay questions from a feminist worldview or critical perspective. In Spanish class you speak and think in Spanish. In Women’s Studies you speak and think in feminist paradigms. Examination essay questions written from critical perspectives outside of feminism will receive an automatic grade of F. Papers written from critical perspectives outside of feminism will be allowed one revision. Any student who is unable to write and think from a feminist critical perspective or worldview with a clear conscience should drop the class now.

How did I get away with this? The secular academic world is bold in its protection of worldview. And, I and all of my feminist colleagues put this statement on our syllabi. We worked as a bloc. We comprised an interpretive community. An interpretive community consciously and intentionally protects its way of thinking. This is how important worldview is to education—of all stripes and colors. And this is how important interpretive community is to worldview. We do not make meaning in isolation.

But is worldview really that important? Doesn’t life teach us lessons on its own terms? My students and I often discussed this question. My students and I often discussed it like this:

Let’s take for example a teenager who keeps getting into trouble with the police and with the rules at school. Parents want to teach this child that cause has an effect. Parents may think that the best way to teach this kid a lesson is to let the school of hard knocks, i.e., life, be the teacher. But the problem with this is it assumes that these “hard knocks” stand on their own. Everything filters through a worldview. Let’s say this kid’s worldview is “I can only trust my friends. All people in authority (parents, pastors, teachers, police, etc.) are out to get me.” With this worldview, the harder the knocks the more firmly this worldview gets hammered home. And of course this kid’s choice of peer group—his interpretive community—helps him see all “hard knocks” as proof that people in authority are out to get him. Maybe this kid will turn out like the Prodigal Son. But how did the Prodigal Son come to his senses? The Prodigal Son didn’t repent of his sin because he got tired of living like and with the pigs. He repented because God gave him eyes to see. Until this happens, no personal experience can topple his critical perspective. That’s the thing about the frame that we use to look at the world. It is actually stronger than life experience because it is mindful, positioned, owned, established, and deeply held. Personal experience can seem fickle. Worldview (the end result of the critical perspective we choose) is always intimate and claimed.

What are the elements of a Christian critical experience? The Bible, the individual denomination or church’s practices and traditions, and the personal experience of the believer. But because different denominations rank these elements differently, there really is no such thing as “a” Christian worldview. The question, then, for me, was: how do we in the Reformed Presbyterian church assemble our worldview? What goes first, my personal experience as a believer or the church’s doctrines? The Bible or the church’s traditions and practices?

At the time that I was struggling with these questions, I was reading and teaching from Is There a Meaning in this Text. Specifically in the context of worship, Vanhoozer’s book helped me formulate my problem with the questions that my colleagues were asking me. The right questions are important. As any college sophomore can tell you, you can’t produce the right answer on a final examination if the professor asks the wrong question. My colleagues were asking me about worship and how it related to my personal experience. Asking a former heathen like me if I missed the hymns in formal worship is like asking a cannibal if he misses tofu. I had no personal template for worship. It was all foreign, all uncomfortable, all well outside of my experience. Vanhoozer’s book helped me dispense with the wrong questions so that I could focus on the right ones.

The right question is this: do we have a biblical mandate for our worship practice? If God tells us how to live, does that include providing specific warrants for how to worship? Living out our Christian lives takes creative thinking, as we try to split the hairs of prepositions, as it were, and live in but not of the world. Fluency is always creative, slangy, and contemporary. But the question is this: is my biblical fluency stronger or weaker in the context of a worship service that includes room for creative additions to the worship of God? Are we better off? Is God pleased with our creativity in the context of worship? How much creativity does God want? Yes, interpretation matters, yes, interpretation is messy, but is there a biblical warrant for worshiping God in specific ways? If so, how tightly does God draw in the boundaries? These questions could only be answered by understanding the hermeneutics of some basic teachings in the Bible: the authority of scripture—sola scriptura—and its logical consequence for worship—the Regulative Principle of Worship. These questions forced me to focus on other devices central to textual studies: on canonicity (to understand sola scriptura) and genre (to understand exclusive psalmody).

My use of literary devices here may seem very technical. But I remind you that I am an English professor by training. My training prepares me to think highly about how a text is assembled and to respect its authority. But it shouldn’t only be “my training” that matters here. As Christians, we follow Jesus. Jesus is, as John’s Gospel explains, “the Word [who] became flesh, and dwelt among us” (John 1:14). Many Christians, to their great deficit, have never thought about the importance of Jesus as the word, or about the Bible as a literary text. Many Christians, to their great deficit, have never thought about genre and canonicity. I find these literary devices invaluable in understanding the Person and Work of Jesus Christ and in approaching Jesus in formal worship.

I turned then to the literary device called “canonicity” and to Brian Schwertley’s book, Sola Scriptura and the Regulative Principle of Worship. Schwertley is a hard read. He is harsh in his caricatures of others. Nevertheless, his book taught me a lot. I don’t mind being offended if I grow in grace through the sock in the chops. Schwertley’s point is this: the consequence of sola scriptura (the belief that the Bible is authoritative, complete, perfect, and sufficient) is a principle that regulates worship. This principle has the following components: proof texts from the Bible and a hermeneutic or a way of handling these proof texts. The proof texts that Schwertley asserts are these:

Deut. 4:2—Do not add to what I command you and do not subtract from it, but keep the commands of the Lord your God that I give you.

Prov. 30:6—Do not add to his words or he will rebuke you and prove you a liar.

Deut. 12:32—See that you do all I command you; do not add to it or take away from it. (NIV)

What principles about worship are derived from these verses? If we believe that God in his Bible teaches us how to live, then it is principally true that God also teaches us in his Bible how to worship him. Importantly, what regulates worship is a principle—an overarching idea—not a specific verse in the Bible. The regulative principle requires that you handle the whole Bible, sifting its details for its overarching principles. If you read your Bible the way unbelievers read their horoscopes, you can’t mine the book for principles.

While the Bible is inerrant, the doctrine of sola scriptura does not deny “the diverse means of divine revelation before the close of the canon” (Schwertley, p. 11); and does not deny that “there were many revelations and historical events that did not make it into the canon” (p. 11). In other words, the Bible has been “canonized.” That means that certain texts by divine appointment have been admitted into a place of authority, which, by implication, means that other texts while written and available have not, by divine appointment, been given this authority. The Bible comes to us as a text edited by men through God’s divine power. This point requires a big intellectual leap: the Bible is the only book edited by God himself. But, and this is important, while the Bible is true, it does not contain all lessons we need to know in the world—God expects us to learn from life. The question then is this: should worship practices be derived from our experiences in life? Our tastes? Our cultural values? If we believe in sola scriptura, we have to say no. Worship is separate from life and worship standards must come from the Bible, that is, it must come from divine revelation and not from natural revelation.

This may be a hard pill to swallow. Worship is regulated by God’s authority and for that reason, we are to do what God commands and not add to it in the formal worship of God. This doctrine does not deny the value of learning from life. Each person must seek to learn God’s lesson from God’s providential struggles, sufferings, and joys. But—and this is a “big but”—this doctrine does “fence” the worship of God—it places a special boundary around it, for its sacred protection and for our own. The more God-centered our worship practice, the more mercy-centered our life. Worship is our rehearsal for how to live today and how to glorify God in heaven. It is not merely a Sunday morning exercise meant to make us feel good. Upholding the Regulative Principle puts real pressure on real issues: in an RP church, you will get no show, no comedian pastors, no rock bands, no skits, no videos, no interpretive dancing. Either Jesus comes to worship with us and the Holy Spirit fuels and fills us and God is honored or we have, simply, painfully, nothing at all.

Finally, I turned to the literary device of genre to better understand the “distinctive” of the RP Church that is often most critiqued: our adherence to a capella psalm singing to the exclusion of all other music of praise. The book that helped me to understand our position on psalm singing is Michael Bushell’s Songs of Zion. The literary principle that undergirds an understanding of the Regulative Principle of Worship is canon: the Bible is canonized. The literary principle that undergirds an understanding of exclusive Psalmody is genre: the books of the Bible are organized as all books are under genre. A genre is a “style or category (of text) characterized by a particular form and purpose” (OED). The word genre and the word gender share an etymological history. Just as genre has a specific purpose so too does gender. If we care about genre—and we should—then we have to grapple with the question: if God gave us a book of praise songs, who are we to add to them? Bushell points to exclusive Psalmody as the logical consequence of sola scriptura. Why? First because of the importance of the genre of the Book of Psalms within the scope of the canonized Bible. Second, because, as the high priestly prayer of Jesus in the seventeenth chapter of the Gospel of John declares: it is the word of God alone that directs our lives and purifies our desires and our prayers. Jesus says in his prayer to our Heavenly Father:

Sanctify them by Your Truth. Your Word is Truth. As You sent Me into the world, I also have sent them into the world. And for their sakes I sanctify Myself, that they also may be sanctified by the truth (or, the word). (John 17:17-19)

The Psalms are the word of God. While hymns and praise and worship music take up themes of Christian life, we are told very clearly here that we are sanctified by the word and by the word alone. Themes may educate and inform, but only the word sanctifies and directs and discerns and convicts:

For the word of God is living and powerful, and sharper than any two-edged sword, piercing even to the division of the soul and the spirit, and of joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart. (Heb. 4:12)

Because Jesus Christ is alive and sits at the right hand of God the Father, interceding on behalf of his people, and even singing with us as we worship God, we know that we believe in a God who is personal, alive, compassionate, and involved in our day-to-day and moment-by-moment concerns. What does Jesus likely sing with his people in worship? What did Jesus sing 2000 years ago? The Psalms.

Because the Psalms are dialogic (they pose questions and offer answers), psalm singing involves learning the meaning, purpose, and grace that undergirds each individual’s life calling, and, living under the faithful presence of God’s guiding Hand. This manifestation of aesthetics, the study of what makes something beautiful, bittersweet, compelling, and enduring, imbues each note of each psalm. The Christian life becomes a symphony of aesthetics, as each note resounds and resonates to God’s glory and, by the Hand of his composition, fits together, even during those times of darkness and struggle, those times when the symphony rings cacophony. In singing the Psalms, in worship and in life, we always know where God is in our suffering. In singing the Psalms, we always have a song in our heart that provides us with direction, redirection, rebuke (when needed), and encouragement. After years of singing the Psalms, and because the word does not return void, we listen, we respond, and, as part of God’s training of our hearts, we grow in grace and sanctification.

The Psalms are the words of Christ. Christ is the word (logos) made flesh. Because Jesus calls himself the word made flesh (and not the “theme” made flesh or the “paraphrase” made flesh), we take him at his word. We do not rewrite or revise God’s word. Rather, we live it. We live it when it fills us with joy. We live it when we are frightened. We live it in his grace. We live the word and it endures through each personal trial and each disappointment. We live the word and it endures through the faithful presence of God’s Holy Spirit working through us. His faithful presence becomes our faithful presence. It is known through the senses, like the oil on Mary’s hair, oil that she rubbed into our Savior’s cracked and pained feet, and oil that she wiped off with the most intimate resource she had: her own hair. Wherever Mary went, the faithful presence of our Savior and the memorial of her love for him followed her. We step into that faithful presence and its palpable aesthetic as we sing psalms.

I had come to the close of my first leg in the study of this material. This is rich terrain, and I am still studying this today. And the more that I study, the more I believe that God commands us to sing psalms in worship to the exclusion of man-made hymns.

And what about that Kent Butterfield who directed me to such important books and who took my spiritual questions and needs so seriously? Well, to quote my favorite 19th century heroine Jane Eyre, I have only this to say about Kent Butterfield:

“Reader, I married him.”

↑ Back to top

↑