Chapter 5 of 10

Repentance and the Sin of Sodom

Repentance and the Sin of Sodom

Repentance and the Sin of Sodom

Syracuse, N.Y., April 1999–August 2000

In April of 1999, I felt the call of Jesus Christ upon my life. It was both subtle and blatant, like the peace inside the eye of the hurricane. I could in no way resist and I in no way understood what would become of my life. I know, I know. How do I know it was Jesus? Maybe it was my Catholic guilt, my caffeine-driven subconscious, or last night’s curry tofu? Well, I don’t. But I believed—and believe—that it was Jesus.

At this time, I was just starting to pray that God would show me my sins and help me to repent of them. I didn’t understand why homosexuality was a sin, why something in the particular manifestation of same-gender love was wrong in itself. But I did know that pride was a sin, and so I decided to start there. As I began to pray and repent, I wondered: could pride be the root of all my sins? I wondered: what was the real sin of Sodom? I had always thought that God’s judgment upon Sodom (in Genesis 19) clearly singled-out and targeted homosexuality. I believed that God’s judgment against Sodom exemplified the fiercest of God’s judgments. But as I read more deeply in the Bible, I ran across a passage that made me stop and think. This passage in the book of Ezekiel revealed to me that Sodom was indicted for materialism and neglect of the poor and needy—and, that homosexuality was a symptom and an extension of these other sins. In this passage, God is speaking to his chosen people in Jerusalem and warning them about their hidden sin using Sodom as an example. Importantly, God does not say that this sin of Sodom is the worst of all sins. Instead, God uses the sin of Sodom to reveal the greater sin committed by his own people:

“As I live,” says the Lord God, “neither your sister Sodom nor her daughters have done as you and your daughters have done. Look, this was the iniquity of your sister Sodom: She and her daughters had pride, fullness of food, and abundance of idleness; neither did she strengthen the hand of the poor and needy. And they were haughty and committed abomination before Me; therefore I took them away as I saw fit.” (Ezek. 16:48-50)

I found this passage to reveal some surprising things. In it, God is comparing Jerusalem to Sodom and saying that Sodom’s sin is less offensive to God than Jerusalem’s. Next, God tells us what is at the root of homosexuality and what the progression of sin is. We read here that the root of homosexuality is also the root of a myriad of other sins. First, we find pride (“[Sodom] and her daughters had pride”). Why pride? Pride is the root of all sin. Pride puffs one up with a false sense of independence. Proud people always feel that they can live independently from God and from other people. Proud people feel entitled to do what they want when they want to.

Second, we find wealth (“fullness of food”) and an entertainment-driven worldview (“abundance of idleness”). Living according to God’s standards is an acquired taste. We develop a taste for godly living only by intentionally putting into place practices that equip us to live below our means. We develop a taste for God’s standards only by disciplining our minds, hands, money, and time. In God’s economy, what we love we will discipline. God did not create us so that we would, as the title of an early book on postmodernism declares, “amuse ourselves to death.” Undisciplined taste will always lead to egregious sin—slowly and almost imperceptibly.

Third, we find lack of mercy (“neither did she strengthen the hand of the poor and needy”). Refusing to be the merciful neighbor in the extreme terms exemplified by the Samaritan traveler to his cultural enemy left to die on the road to Jericho (Luke 10:25-37) leads to egregious sin. I think this is a shocking truth and I imagine that most Bible-believing Christians would be horrified to see this truth exposed in such bare terms! God calls us to be merciful to others for our own good as well as for the good of our community. Our hearts will become hard to the whispers of God if we turn our backs on those who have less than we do.

Fourth, we find lack of discretion and modesty (“they were haughty and committed abomination before Me”). Pride combined with wealth leads to idleness because you falsely feel that God just wants you to have fun; if unchecked, this sin will grow into entertainment-driven lust; if unchecked, this sin will grow into hardness of heart that declares other people’s problems no responsibility or care of your own; if unchecked, we become bold in our sin and feel entitled to live selfish lives fueled by the twin values of our culture: acquiring and achieving. Modesty and discretion are not old-fashioned values. They are God’s standards that help us to encourage one another in good works, not covetousness.

You might notice that there is nothing inherently sexual about any of these sins: pride, wealth, entertainment-driven focus, lack of mercy, lack of modesty. We like to think that sin is contained by categories of logic or psychology. It’s not. So why do we assume that sexual sin has sexual or affectual origins? That is because we have too narrow a focus about sexuality’s purview. Sexuality isn’t about what we do in bed. Sexuality encompasses a whole range of needs, demands, and desires. Sexuality is more a symptom of our life’s condition than a cause, more a consequence than an origin.

Importantly, we don’t see God making fun of homosexuality or regarding it as a different, unusual, or exotic sin. What we see instead is God’s warning: if you indulge the sins of pride, wealth, entertainment-lust, lack of mercy, and lack of discretion, you will find yourself deep in sin—and the type of sin may surprise you. That sin may attach itself to a pattern of life closely or loosely linked to this list. While sin is not contained by logical categories of progression, nonetheless, sin is progressive. That is, while sin does not stay contained by type or trope, if ignored, excused, or enjoyed, sin grows and spreads like poison ivy.

But God is a God of mercy, redemption, second-chances, and salvation. And therefore, when Jesus uses Sodom as an example during his ministry on earth, the example reveals that God is angrier at the religious people of Jesus’ day than the inhabitants of Sodom. Jesus says this to God’s people in Capernaum:

And you, Capernaum, who are exalted to heaven, will be brought to Hades; for if the mighty works which were done in you had been done in Sodom, it would have remained until this day. But I say to you that it shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom in the day of judgment than for you. (Matt. 11:23-24)

Jesus tells us clearly that had Sodom seen God’s power manifested before them as Capernaum had, they would have repented and lived. Jesus’ injunction that God is more greatly grieved by the sins of those who claim to know him than by those who know him not, struck a chord for me. There is a fairness and capaciousness to Jesus’ words that simply is not reflected in modern evangelical culture. We see this capaciousness reflected in Jesus’ invitation noted in the chapter’s end. Jesus declares: “Come to Me, all you who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest. Take My yoke upon you and learn from Me, for I am gentle and lowly in heart, and you will find rest for your souls. For My yoke is easy and My burden is light” (Matt. 11:28-30). These passages also convicted me that homosexuality—like all sin—is symptomatic and not causal—that is, it tells us where our heart has been, not who we inherently are or what we are destined to become.*

These passages forced me to see pride and not sexual orientation as the root sin. In turn, this shaped the way that I reflected on my whole life, in the context of the word of God. I realized that my sexuality had never been pure and my relationships never honored the other person or the Lord. My moral code encompassed serial monogamy, “safe” sex, and sex only in the context of love. Love, grounded only in personal feelings as mine had been, changes without warning or logic. The truth is, outside of Christ, I am a manipulator, liar, power-monger, and controller. In my relationships with men and with women, I had to be in charge. I killed with kindness and slayed with gifts. I bought people’s loyalties and affections. I had been a lesbian for almost a decade. I considered myself an “informed” lesbian—someone who had had relationships with men and found them wanting and dissatisfying. I did not consider myself bisexual because I had had no intention of having a relationship with a man ever again. I did not find men compelling or interesting. My lesbian identity began in non-sexual ways: I have always enjoyed the good communication that women share. I also found myself bonding with women over shared hobbies and interests and feminist and leftist political values. I’m not given to pornography in any form, and therefore visual attraction never motivated my friendships or responses to other people. I share my sexual history with you not to flaunt my sin or offend my reader, but to reveal that my sexuality was sinful not because it was lesbian per se but because it wasn’t Christ-controlled. My heterosexual past was no more sanctified than my homosexual present. God had revealed that to me powerfully as I sat under the preaching of his word, as I read the Bible, and as I talked to other Christians in my church about what sexuality meant in God’s economy. In understanding myself as a sexual being, responding to Jesus (i.e., “committing my life to Christ”) meant not going backwards to my heterosexual past but going forward to something entirely new. At the time I thought that this would most likely be celibacy and the single life. Sexuality that did not devour the other person seemed unimaginable to me. And while I never really liked the idea of growing old alone, I accepted that if God could take me this far in life safely, he would see me through this next part, too.

Every aspect of my life came under the scrutiny of my new Christian worldview. It was like someone turned the search light on and I couldn’t dim the intensity. I understood why the Pharisee Saul on the road to Damascus was struck blind for three days from the light of the gospel! I learned that sin roots not in outward behaviors, but in patterns of thinking. I felt like a non-native speaker as I fumbled around as a new Christian. My housemate (not my ex-lover but someone who rented a room in my house) was a lesbian writer and Wiccan witch who had recently undergone a messy break-up. She wanted to know if she had to move out—now that I was a Christian and all. We had a long talk about tolerance and honesty. She was a gentle spirit and had helped me to find balance before, and I was glad that she wasn’t going to move out right away. We decided she should stay for the summer and planned for a November 1999 move-out date. We settled into our domestic routine.

As I re-read my life, I realized that my sexual sin was rooted not only in pride but also in a false understanding about gender. I came to the understanding that I could not possibly be a godly woman if I didn’t even know how to be a woman. Pastor Ken preached a sermon that really brought this point home to me, and one Monday afternoon, after praying fervently for God to show me how to live as a godly woman, I went through the church directory and picked out the three women whose godliness, sense of self, personal strength, and integrity really stood out to me. I picked women who were different from me, but people who would answer me honestly. I called Becky Smith, Corrine Thompson, and Kathy Donath. I asked simple questions, even perhaps naive ones, and I remember how tender each woman was in answering my questions. I was still struggling with my identity, now with my new Christian identity. How could a woman “like me” be a godly woman? Each woman directed me to Mary Magdalene and to the Proverbs 31 woman. Each woman reminded me that knowing God’s forgiveness in a real and vital way is the root of all godliness—for men or for women.

Making a life commitment to Christ was not merely a philosophical shift. It was not a one-step process. It did not involve rearranging the surface prejudices and fickle loyalties of my life. Conversion didn’t “fit” my life. Conversion overhauled my soul and personality. It was arduous and intense. I experienced with great depth the power and authority of God in my life. In it I learned—and am still learning—how to love God with all my heart, soul, strength and mind. When you die to yourself, you have nothing from your past to use as clay out of which to shape your future.

Because conversion, in scripture and in my personal experience, is arduous and transformative, I fear the consequence of the easy believism that typifies modern evangelical culture. I live now in a neighborhood that often seems like the Disneyland of evangelical culture. I have neighbors who are members of one of the big churches in our community. Their church has a fast-food restaurant (so no one gets hungry), a well-known coffee chain (so no one gets sleepy or feels deprived of creature comforts), and a Moon bounce (so children will think that God just wants you to have fun). The church organizes a church-sponsored pool (i.e., gambling program) around the NCAA Final Four.

When we compare what we did at church, what we learned in Bible study and what we mean when we call ourselves followers of Christ, our vocabulary may be the same, but the meaning behind our vocabulary is vastly different. And when it comes down to how we parent our children, the differences are profound. Another church in our neighborhood is projecting a budget of 19 million dollars to build their Tabernacle, following this same model. These churches define themselves as purpose-driven and seeker-friendly. And their annual budgets, as missionary friends pointed out to me, could feed all the AIDS orphans in Africa for years. Just their Sunday morning doughnut budget would make a big dent in the problem of Third World poverty!

The purpose-driven movement makes conversion a simple matter of saying the magic words, a mantra that makes Jesus the Mr. Rogers of the conscience. In his popular book, The Purpose Driven Life,2 author Rick Warren represents conversion in these words: “Jesus, I believe in you and I receive you” (p. 59). There is a pit of false hope in placing our faith in our words rather than in God’s compassion to receive sinners to himself. Warren falsely (and dangerously) assures us of our salvation. He writes: “If you sincerely meant that prayer, congratulations! Welcome to the family of God!” (p. 59). How do I judge my own sincerity? The saving grace of salvation is located in a holy and electing God, and a sacrificing, suffering, and obedient Savior. Stakes this high can never rest on my sincerity.

When I read something like this, I do not recognize Jesus, the Holy Bible, my conversion or myself at all. Recently, on vacation in South Carolina, my husband and I went to a “community church.” My conservative Reformed Presbyterian pastor and husband noted when we got back to the hotel room that we had just witnessed a service that contained a baptism without water, preaching without scripture, conversation about disappointment and pithy observations about financial responsibility without prayer, the distribution of flowers and trinkets without grace, and a dismissal without a blessing. Everyone was smiling, though, when it came time to walk out the door. This church’s conversion prayer was printed in the bulletin. It read like this: “Dear God, I’m so sorry for my mistakes. Thanks for salvation.”

These misrepresentations of the gospel are dangerous and misleading. Sin is not a mistake. A mistake is taking the wrong exit on the highway. A sin is treason against a Holy God. A mistake is a logical misstep. Sin lurks in our heart and grabs us by the throat to do its bidding. Remember what God said to Cain about his sin? It’s true for us too. In the fourth chapter of Genesis, God warns Cain like this: “Sin lies at the door. And its desire is for you, but you should rule over it” (Gen. 4:6). In accepting misrepresentations of the gospel that render sin anything less than this, you will never learn of the fruit of repentance. The Apostle Paul defines his post-conversion life simply: in Christ he now does “works befitting repentance” (Acts 26:20). This idea that we repent and we serve is also reflected in the words of the last of the Old Testament prophets, John the Baptist, who prepares the way of the Lord by warning the religious people of his day to “Repent, for the kingdom of God is at hand!” (Matt. 3:2) and after repenting, to “bear fruits worthy of repentance” (Matt. 3:8). And Jesus himself warns us against failing to count the costs of discipleship or of testing ourselves in the faith, when he says,

“Not everyone who says to Me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ shall enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father in heaven. Many will say to me in that day, ‘Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in Your name, cast out demons in Your name, and done many wonders in Your name?’ And then I will declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness’” (Matt. 7:21-23).

The Christian life is a life imbued with the supernatural power and authority of God. God is the God of salvation. We do not control God by saying magic words or attending church. Conversion is a heart-affair. Before we can come to Christ, we must empty ourselves of the false pride, blame-shifting, excuse-making, and self-deception that preoccupies our days and our relationships. Before we can come to Christ, we must come to ourselves.

After conversion, every day and every part of the routine of my life was a faith test. I had formerly been a very popular teacher in gay and lesbian studies. I was already scheduled to teach for the fall semester 1999 Introduction to Women’s Studies (a class that routinely enrolled over 200 students) and Feminist Pedagogy (a graduate seminar for graduate students who taught under me). I would have to follow through and teach these classes, but would have to find a way to teach them as a Christian. I still needed to make course descriptions for the classes in Christian hermeneutics that I would teach for the spring semester 2000. I had liberty to teach new courses—as long as the classes drew students. I had formerly used my classroom to advocate for gay and lesbian rights and ideas. I now used my classroom to abandon the discipline in which I was hired to create instead courses in a field of study—Christian hermeneutics—unheard of in my liberal postmodern department. Who would take such courses? What if no one signed up?

Each day brought a deluge of moral choices couched in the daily routine of a radical professor. Each day, R was there to support me through these. He would tell me to be like King David, Prophet Daniel and the Apostle Paul. He also shared with me the details of his daily struggle with sexual sin, and in so doing made me feel less alone in my own journey. But by the time the summer ended, I noticed something: God was healing me. I was repenting and God was healing me. At the same time, R seemed stuck in the same place. I prayed daily for him. I wondered why he was not experiencing any liberty from his sin, as I was experiencing from mine.

I also started to notice something else about my life: I wasn’t plagued with anxiety or nightmares anymore. The intestinal distress that had been my daily companion was no longer a part of my life (and I hadn’t taken a Tums in months). I changed my exercise routine from intense running to active walking. I cleaned my house and my office the way God was cleaning my soul: I pitched things that weren’t honoring to God. I got rid of whole libraries of books, CDs, movies, pictures. I unsubscribed to magazines and professional journals. I suddenly had time in my life to reflect. I took up gardening. I enjoyed baking bread from scratch for my friends and neighbors. I relaxed. I grew in strength in the Lord. I forgave my enemies and enjoyed the solitude of daily prayer. I read and re-read the Bible, searching for examples for my life. Jesus was my Teacher and the Apostle Paul my brother and kindred spirit. I started to develop real friendships from within my church family.

During one of my weekly discipleship meetings with Floy, she asked me if I had thought about church membership. Church membership? Me? This church? I was horrified! Membership! Yuck! I have never been a person given to joining clubs and I found the whole question to be antithetical to my free spirit. I told Floy that I loved our church but that I didn’t see any reason to “join the club.” She then told me something that really made me stop and think: she said that every believer in the Bible is what we would consider today to be a church member. There is no such thing as an independent Christian. At the 2004 Reformed Presbyterian International Conference, I heard Pastor Ted Donnelly put it this way. Imagine, he said, if the U.S. declared that we were going to send one soldier to Iraq. One soldier! Even with the best equipment in the world, how could one little soldier survive? His point resonated with me and reminded me of Floy’s counsel about church membership: nobody goes into battle alone. Sanctification—growing in Christ—is always both personal and communal. We need one another. Our faith struggles and our successes are part of the Body of Christ, not possessed by our own little kingdom. This Christian life was war—of this I was certain. Who in her right mind, Floy asked, would go to war without an army?

The covenant membership vows of the Reformed Presbyterian Church are simple, yet they cut me to the core. Here are our seven vows of church membership. After each vow, I have recorded my initial internal turmoil:

Official Vows: Covenant of Church Membership

1. Do you believe the scriptures of the Old and New Testaments to be the word of God, the only infallible rule of faith and life?

My “rule of faith and life” had been my own intellect. As a document wholly produced through oral history, I had had no faith in the Bible as true or accurate. Indeed, as a scholar, I wouldn’t even have trusted a chocolate chip cookie recipe passed down through oral history, and here I was putting my life on the line—for a document produced by something as intellectually flimsy as oral history! Only the seriously anti-intellectual would do this. And what about the ontological fallacy inherent in using the Bible to “prop up” God while simultaneously using God to “prop up” the Bible? How could a committed postmodernist like me believe that the gospel is true?

2. Do you believe in the one living and true God—the Father, Son and Holy Spirit, as revealed in the scriptures?

I had believed that God was an imperialist social construct invented to soothe the consciousness of the intellectually infirm. Friedrich Nietzsche was kinder than I in his assessment that God is dead.

3. Do you repent of your sin; confess your guilt and helplessness as a sinner against God; profess Jesus Christ, Son of God, as your Savior and Lord; and dedicate yourself to His service: Do you promise that you will endeavor to forsake all sin, and to conform your life to His teaching and example?

Repent? Sin? Guilt? Helplessness? These were once anathema to my character and life. After all, I had given speeches to gathering crowds at gay pride marches! Profess Jesus Christ as my Savior and Lord? The very name of Jesus I had once hated—deeply—and the only time his name was uttered from my mouth was in cursing something.

4. Do you promise to submit in the Lord to the teaching and government of this church as being based upon the scriptures and described in substance in the Constitution of the Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America? Do you recognize your responsibility to work with others in the church and do you promise to support and encourage them in their service to the Lord? In case you should need correction in doctrine or life, do you promise to respect the authority and discipline of the church?

Submit myself to the elders of my church? Submit myself to a bunch of men, not one of whom had a PhD? Had I lost my mind? What would this look like? Would they come to my Women’s Studies 101 lectures and hold up placards at the end of each lecture, taunting my double-mindedness and disloyalty?

5. To the end that you may grow in the Christian life, do you promise that you will diligently read the Bible, engage in private prayer, keep the Lord’s Day, regularly attend the worship services, observe the appointed sacraments, and give to the Lord’s work as He shall prosper you?

How will I build my empire if I spend all of this time on God? How will I conduct my professional life without using Sunday as a workday?

6. Do you purpose to seek first the kingdom of God and His righteousness in all the relationships of life, faithfully to perform your whole duty as a true servant of Jesus Christ, and seek to win others to Him?

I had always sought first the kingdom of my own pleasure and person. I sought to win others to myself and myself alone.

7. Do you make this profession of faith and purpose in the presence of God, in humble reliance upon His grace, as you desire to give your account with joy at the Last Great Day?

I didn’t like thinking about my mortality or about the Last Great Day. I had buried countless gay friends to the AIDS epidemic, and it felt blasphemous to even entertain the idea that after a hellish death that they would now spend eternity in hell. I almost feared that believing this condemned them to hell.

In July 1999, I made my profession of faith before God, before the elders of my church at one meeting and before my church congregation during a worship service. Ken Smith had taught me that I was not “joining” a church, but rather, was making a covenant with God and with a church body. As I stood before the congregation to make this profession of faith, I felt the assault of my disloyalty to the gay community as powerfully as I did my loyalty to Christ. Indeed, I could barely speak the “I do.” Pastor Ken took my uncontrolled shaking as consent and the rest of the congregation took me on faith. I still remember the trauma in my body when I hear our membership vows or watch someone stand before the congregation for the purpose of baptism or church membership. Each Lord’s Supper made me experience my traitorship to my gay friends and to the person that I once was.

It took me three months after committing my life to Christ to consent to these vows because I was afraid to move too far away from my life, as I had known it. A chapter of my life had just closed, but I had no idea at the time how severely I would feel its closure. Consenting to these vows meant simply that there was no going back. Once I had said these vows with my lips and held them in my heart, therein truly lay my treason from the gay community. I felt like I lived in some liminal invisible place, with no history and no sense of future. I felt like a vampire—possessing no reflection in mirrors. I realize now that this is what it means to be washed clean, to be truly made new again. The past really is gone. The shadow of what was remains, but the substance is truly taken away. The Apostle Paul explains it this way, “I do not count myself to have apprehended, but one thing I do, forgetting those things which are behind and reaching forward to those things which are ahead” (Phil. 3:13). This forgetting was a painful process. Like grief, the cost of relief is the you that you used to be. Surviving means sacrificing something of you.

On August 17, 1999, I returned to my office after delivering a lecture to all incoming graduate students. The topic was to be of my choosing. When the graduate school invited me, I was a lesbian postmodernist. When I delivered the lecture six months later, I was a fledgling follower of Jesus Christ. The lecture was entitled: “The Solomon Problem.” I felt awkward and uncomfortable as I took the podium and adjusted the clip-on microphone to the neckline of my dress. I was in process of growing out my butch haircut, so every day was a bad hair day. And the lecture was going to be a bomb. In it, I would become a traitor and a turncoat. To the lesbian community, I would become the example of what not to be. I could not have gotten through that lecture had R not been there. In the six months since my conversion, he had become my watchdog, big brother, champion, simultaneous translator, and best friend. He came to my lectures, to my classes, to my Thursday night dinners. He talked to my students and my colleagues. He embraced my drag queen friends. He translated my concerns to the session of our church with a deftness and sensitivity that I still marvel at. As I fingered my pages on the podium, R gave me a firm thumbs up from his spot, the nosebleed section of the balcony, and left of stage. He was the only person who understood this spiritual and professional schizophrenia that had quickly become my new normal after conversion. Here is the talk that I gave that day:

What King Solomon Teaches Those in the Wisdom Business: Active Learning and Active Scholarship

Since I was 16 years old, I have been inspired by three categories of ideas: text—the written testimony of experience and meaning; history—the content of events that stands outside of consciousness and shapes it perpetually; and mercy—the category of selfless love and stealth compassion. These categories have never been merely academic, and indeed, they have saved my life on more than one occasion. As a child and teenager, I used these categories to store understanding about the dynamics in my home. I wrote my first book about this. As an adult, these categories have expanded to address the historicity of social genocide to the historicity of the resurrection; the authority of texts produced in the social margins of women’s literature to the Bible as an authoritative text, the written revelation of the living triune God (too often misread and misused as our contemporary political Trojan horse); from social justice on behalf of women, people of color, the disabled, and queer liberation to the counterintuitive lessons of mercy taught in the New Testament. Text, History, and Mercy. These categories raise my life’s Big Questions. What are yours? What are yours?

This leads me to my first point about real learning: It’s not a recipe, it’s not a toolbox that neatly fashions any notion, no matter how bankrupt or dubious or silly. At least two decades of poststructural and postmodern research has equipped intellectuals with powerful methods to question the reliability of truth-claims and procedures of evidence, and to reveal the social effects of oppression produced by epistemological imperialism. But the powerful legacy poststructuralism bequeaths to contemporary intellectuals should not create its own hegemony of intellectual expectation, one which categorically trades in truth for doubt and faith for skepticism. Students smell fear, laziness, and fraudulence faster than a scavenger on road kill, and real learning depends on our quest for real knowledge, not its perpetual deferment in the form of endless doubt. In order to seek real knowledge, we will confront times when we have to choose between the old ideas that give us comfort in their familiarity or the safe paradigms that encourage endless questioning for the bold quest of capacious truth. Knowledge depends on the renewal of our minds. If you fear such renewal and its consequences, then you don’t belong in graduate school. This may seem like a tall order, perhaps even an unfriendly one, and you should get a second opinion, to be sure. From my position, though, the stakes only get higher from this day on, so risking immediate comfort and facing instead the Big Questions is a skill that must begin early if it is to begin at all.

Graduate school can be like purgatory, and at various times professors make proclamations, as I just did a sentence ago, about who belongs in graduate school and who doesn’t. Professors usually base these judgments on grades, scores on comprehensive examinations, expedience in academic hoop jumping, publications, and too often for my moral code, the disciple’s adoration of the mentor. For graduate students, the value of your undergraduate teaching may seem as distant as Kansas and the pursuit of deep ethical questions as unreclaimable as the sting of your first skinned knee. Here’s my advice: don’t buy it. Strong scholars and successful professors experience bumpy roads in graduate school and after. Learn how to fall on your face and pick yourself up. Learn how to turn the train around. Learn how to glean good lessons from bad teachers in an effort to be a good teacher to those undergraduates under your care. Learn to look up, act on faith that the Big Picture has purpose: failing an exam does not mean that you don’t belong here. The only people who don’t belong in the classroom, library, laboratory, or lecturing from the podium are those who fear confrontation of incommensurable truth-claims, and who seek safety over the production and excavation of ideas—even scary ideas. If truth-claims, the scholarly evidence that supports them, and the opportunity to engage in meaningful and testy debate with those who think differently than you do are burning in your heart and mind, then you are in the right place and I have only one thing to say: welcome home.

In juxtaposing truth-claims with endless questions or in advancing the case that we make decisions based in articulated presuppositional values, I intend no formula. Newer is not always better. Nor is the traditional more solid than the contemporary. It’s not that easy. The university classroom is neither a shopping mall whose existence depends on disseminating the latest, sexiest critical approach, nor a museum, where ideas are valued because of tradition alone and where you can look but never touch. Instead, the classroom is a place of joy fueled by the quest for excellence and the productive fear generated by the awesomeness of our ignorance and our inability to transform human reason into wisdom on its own terms, when it is unhinged from a living God. If you remember the Big Questions and claim them in your heart as your Big Questions, you will find that there are more ways to succeed than to fail and you will be connected to something that matters. Don’t fret because your path to those Big Questions doesn’t look like somebody else’s journey. Don’t fret when the path is lonely or treacherous. Look up.

Enjoy the classroom. Enjoy the opportunity to touch the lives of others. Cherish the sacred relationship of student to teacher. Learn how to adjust your focus. Find ways to transmogrify the emotional manipulation or bad manners that some of your students will no doubt display as opportunities to turn the train around. Find ways to see past the symptom of seeming boredom or disrespect to its source, and then work from that. Listen first—and listen last—and listen in between. Bring the outside into your classrooms and bring your classroom outside to bear on the world.

Think about the categories that frame your Big Questions. Write them down. Think about the life lessons that shape them. Remember who you are and the road on which you traveled to get here. I’ll leave you with three of my life lessons on which I rely.

Lesson #1: When you don’t know what to do, go back to the basics.

When I used to run marathons, I had a training partner who would say to me, at the most horrific moments, usually at about mile 20, “Rosaria, this could be the best moment of your life.” I thought this man was certifiably nuts, a DSM-IV special. I tried to ignore him. But later I started to understand his meaning. This expression teaches me now that while I am motivated by the Big Questions, I do not have the Big Picture. I do not know how student resistance, classroom explosions, my own general screwing up, or mean-spirited colleagues will really affect my success or failure as an intellectual and a teacher. So I find myself, in life’s most unbearable moments, in and out of the classroom, saying, “This may be the best moment of my life.” At first, this makes me feel, perhaps too viscerally, that I am on mile 20 of the marathon and I’m about to throw up. And then it reminds me that even if I do throw up, I still have a marathon to finish, and something extraordinary will happen in the process of focusing on the rigor and simplicity of putting one foot in front of the next.

Lesson #2: Speak the truth, because you never know who is listening.

For a decade of my life, I lived as a lesbian and was a spokesperson for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgendered issues on the local and national front. One morning, as was my routine on my way to work, I stopped at the Jordan minimart to get a cup of coffee. On this particular morning, I heard a woman yelling at her kids, telling them that they were worthless and inconvenient and in the way. Nothing makes me more furious than the disrespect of children, and I turned to give her my iciest glare.

That’s when I saw the t-shirt she was wearing. It featured the General Mills cartoon rabbit speaking these words to an effeminate man: “Silly Faggot, Dicks are for Chicks.”

There in the Jordan mini-mart on a regular day in June 1996, I decided that ideas were bigger than I was, and I approached the woman. I told her that I was a lesbian and that my feelings were hurt by her tee shirt. At first she didn’t comprehend what I was saying, and so I said it again. She got it. Her jaw dropped like a fish on a line. The mini-mart went pin dropping silent. Finally, her husband elbowed her and said, “Stop talking to the queer.” I started to cry and the mini-mart exploded in laughter. When I returned to the mini-mart on the next day, stubbornness overruling fear, the woman behind the counter pulled me aside to ask me a question. It turns out that her daughter was a lesbian, and she needed help.

Lesson #3: It’s better to be wrong on an important subject than right on a trivial one, as long as you are willing to learn from your mistakes.

This lesson got me through graduate school and, most recently, became profoundly important for me during the research of my second book. I was studying the Religious Right from the lesbian feminist perspective of the secular left, and aside from discovering what I already knew, that the Religious Right was manipulating religious commitments in the name of capitalist consumerism and conservative political agendas, I discovered something else, something that I wasn’t looking for, and something that changed my life—not to mention my research—from the ground up. I discovered that God isn’t just a narrative we pick like summer berries or leave for the next person; nor is God a set of social conventions tailored for the weak of mind; nor is God a consumerist social construct who exists in the service of Christian imperialist ideologies and right-wing politics. Rather, I discovered that God through Jesus Christ exists, the triune God of the Bible exists, whether we acknowledge him or not. I discovered that God wasn’t very happy with me.

This brought me to the awesome realization that our living God is in all of our life, and that my “success” as a professor was his blessing on me, not my deserved and earned accolade. I discovered, through what the Bible calls the renewing of our minds, that what I had previously claimed as mine wasn’t even about me.

This leads me to my point and the title of today’s talk: beware of the Solomon problem of academic life. King Solomon, one of the many sons of David, ruled over Israel from 962–922 B.C. Before Solomon stepped into his kingship, he asked God to give him an “understanding heart…to discern between good and evil” (1 Kings 3:9). God gave him a gift of discernment unmatched by any other figure then or now on the condition that Solomon never forgot the first commandment (the commandment to honor God, not the idols that bolster the autonomy of our own egos). As Solomon became rich and successful, he started to believe that knowledge was something that he “owned,” something that he harbored inside of himself, rather than what it was: something loaned to him, but something fundamentally located in the radical Otherness of a Holy God. Once he lost his anchor, he lost his wisdom, and it all came tumbling down. The biblical story does not stop here, because the nature of a Holy God is redemptive, not abandoning, but that is a lecture for another day. Suffice it to say for today that Solomon failed by thinking that all truth-claims exist in a contingent relationship to the self. Solomon’s legacy offers a warning to all academics, believers and atheists alike: we all need to be anchored in something bigger than we are, something bigger than the ideas currently generated within disciplines, and certainly something bigger than the politics of our fields of study.

Real learning, no matter how polished the moves or rehearsed the rhetoric, is empty learning unless we who profess are anchored in something bigger than we are. Choose with discernment, and don’t let the proclivities of the here-and-now choose for you.

—Syracuse University, August 1999 Graduate Student Orientation Convocation

I re-read this lecture today and it seems so pragmatic and inoffensive. But at the time and place that I delivered it, I had just handed myself the proverbial pink slip. Only R knew how serious this was. After ten years of coming out as a lesbian, you would think I would have gotten used to the feeling of peering over the edge of dignity and choosing instead solidarity with the outcasts. What was different this time was that in giving this lecture, I betrayed my friends. While the lecture itself was not bold, because my friendships were bold and intimate and risky, the lecture had impact. This experience taught me a powerful lesson about evangelism: the integrity of our relationships matters more than the boldness of our words. Because of who I was to the gay community, this lecture had made its mark.

What kind of effect did this lecture have? I might as well have taken out a highway sign that said, “Rosaria is no longer safe—your secrets are out—your cover is blown.” While I gave the lecture, I saw my ex-girlfriend and my lesbian- and gay-supporting graduate students go stone cold in disgust and disappointment. Of course, I had talked with them privately before this lecture. But the gay and lesbian community truly understands the importance of the public coming-out moment, and therefore, this lecture and its impact resonated powerfully with my people.

After giving my lecture to incoming graduate students, I returned to my office drenched with panic sweat. I felt awkward wearing a dress, and the “girl” shoes I was wearing hurt my feet more than any marathon I had ever run. R left for his office and so I faced mine alone—I also faced a long line of students wanting to talk to me about what I just did.

The only person through my office door that day was an undergraduate named B. B was a skinny boy, high on prescription medication for ADHD, depression, bipolar disorder, and who knows what else. He had been flunking out of school since his first day on campus. B was the president of the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgendered undergraduate student collective and I was their faculty advisor. B came to my office to fire me. He was fuming. His eyes were red with tears and his face taut with fury. “How dare you! How could you!” He paced the length of my office, his spike orange hair and red face made him look like a carrot or a cartoon figure. His anger distorted him.

“How do you know that you are no longer a lesbian? How do you know?” he demanded. Of all the questions that someone could have asked me at the time, this was the one that I couldn’t answer. This question unsettled me and made me feel sick and dizzy. I had no idea how to answer it. Christ-honoring words and ideas were nowhere to be found. They weren’t ready to come out of me. My sense of truth was divided. One truth was simply that the word of God had gotten to be bigger inside of me than I was, bigger by about the size of a hair. The other truth was that, now back at work, I started to feel like a lesbian again. The summer break had helped me to establish new patterns, but these new patterns were flimsy. The patterns of mindfulness of a research professor are well established and they extend beyond reading and writing. Because my scholarship and my personal life shared a symbiotic relationship, the old patterns of mindfulness started to creep back as I sat in my office chair. I had always been both a professor and a lesbian at the same time. My research supported what is called “Identity Politics”—the assumption that the researcher holds integrity when she also holds membership in the area that she studies. Research professors also enjoy being part of a community of scholars. I lost my community when God saved my soul. And now I started to lose my nerve—and my faith.

I tried to stall B and so I asked him a question in return. I said, “B, how do you know you are a gay man?”

Like a birthday balloon deflated by a pinprick, B staggered and collapsed into my office chair. Slumped over and with tears in his eyes, he fell silent for what seemed a long time. Then he said, “Rosaria, I’m a gay man because the GLBT (Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgendered) community is the only safe home I have, a home made safe by you. How could you not know this? How dare you not know this!”

Although it replicated my own experience, I was taken aback by his response. And I certainly didn’t fail to hear that I was fingered in his sin. I don’t remember how I responded—right there in my office. I think I covered his hands with my own as he slumped in the chair and cried. I remember that it was dark by the time he left my office and that we agreed to talk again the next day. I accepted my resignation from the student group that he chaired and, later that week, from the other five that I advised. I accepted my resignation from every dissertation committee that I was on and started to dig through my computer and hard files to throw away the book project on the religious right. I had to accept it: I was a failure. By God’s grace, he would not allow me to work in the way that I had always wanted to labor. I was no stranger to failure, but this was an odd failure. At the infinitesimal core of this failure resided something that I didn’t at first recognize. When I examined my feelings against the rugged Cross, I realized that this failure was wrapped in relief. Whatever was God’s providence for me, it was his to lay out and mine to obey. No longer did I have to invent myself.

One week later, when the fall 1999 school semester came around, I felt more ready to face the patterns and legacy of my past. My church knew my struggles and surrounded me with prayer and counsel. I had been reading Augustine’s Confessions and was alert to the reality that God had ministry waiting for me. I prayed that I would be strong for the task at hand. Yes, I was still a laughing stock in the gay community. Yes, I was still a traitor and an example of what not to be. But so too was Paul the Apostle shamed among the Pharisees, and I trusted that God would take my life and make a place for me.

During this time, I lost my primary support person—R left for seminary in Pittsburgh. He felt called to be a pastor, or so he said. We agreed to continue to talk daily and support one another. During the past six months, I had spent most of my time with him, and while I was sad to see him go, I really needed my time back to focus on my new life as a Christian professor. We had started talking about the emotional attraction we felt for one another. I filed this away, not really knowing what to do with this kind of information. In the gay community, it is normal (and safe) for gay men and lesbian women to bond in this way. But I wasn’t in the gay community any more. Was this still safe? Was this dangerous?

During this time, I also gained a powerful support person and friend—Vivian Rice. Vivian was a professor at the university, a member of my church, and the wife of an elder. Vivian and I committed to praying together at least once a week and talking daily for support and colleagueship. With my church supporting me, I felt ready to face the semester as an “out” follower of Christ.

God did have ministry waiting for me in my classes. The story of my conversion ran like wildfire through the university community. Instead of having fewer students, I had classes that were over-enrolled with students sitting on the floor and in the aisles. Some students came for the carnival aspect, but others came because God had put them where he wanted them. Amazingly, I continued to draw students from the gay and lesbian community, students who wanted to dialogue across differences. I also drew students who were suicidal and chronically sick. As a lesbian, I had always been an outsider. But now I was a different kind of outsider, and in my new status, God brought me a new crop of hurting people.

I couldn’t believe how exhausting it was to daily put Christ before me. The old patterns were there waiting for me, and they knew my name. It was so hard to be in charge of a major program at work (as Director of Undergraduate Studies I coordinated the curriculum for over 200 majors) and at the same time be in a posture of submission to my pastor and elders—people I felt really didn’t understand the nature or rigor of my work. The only way to effectively ward off the old patterns of selfishness was to put into place intentional Christian ministry. The Thursday night dinners for the gay community were cancelled due to lack of interest. Only my drag queen friend J kept coming around and we talked almost exclusively about the gospel. At the same time, some students were openly interested in how God changed me. So I started a Friday night What’s-The-Christian-Life-All-About study. I opened my house to anyone who wanted to come and talk about Jesus or ask questions about the Bible. J started coming along with a handful of students and neighbors. One Friday a month we canceled the study and did something good in the neighborhood. It was the motliest Bible study I have ever had the privilege to enjoy.

When R left for seminary, our Christian lives became further divided. While God continued to give me victory over my sin and joy in Christ, R was becoming more and more discouraged. I started to act more like his mother than peer as I gave him counsel and fretted over his problems. When he ran out of money, I sent him mine. When he ran out of phone cards, I sent him mine. He would call me at all times during the night or day. Although this pattern was unhealthy, sick patterns bind people together as firmly as healthy ones do. Before long, we confused fusion by sick patterns with love.

My drag queen friend, J, was the first to talk to me about the “R problem,” as she called it. We had gone to a lecture together one night and I was anxious to get home because R had been having a hard day. J kept me talking in the car and told me, firmly, that R was a loser. She really pinned our relationship down when she said, “Rosaria, I know this pattern: he gets deeper and deeper in sin and calls you and you talk him off the ledge. Let him go! Let Jesus deal with him!” I marvel to this day at J’s wise and sage advice, advice that I was too proud to receive.

I once asked R if he thought that seminary was harmful to him. I asked him why he felt “called” in the first place. In response, he asked me if Pastor Ken, during the pastoral prayer part of the worship service, still prayed that the Lord would raise up men for the ministry. Pastor Ken, almost every Sunday, prayed Jesus’ instruction to his disciples in Matthew 9:38: “The harvest truly is plentiful, but the laborers are few. Therefore, pray the Lord of the harvest to send out laborers into his harvest.” He said, “That’s why I’m here. I really felt that prayer was for me.” I asked him to clarify what he meant: I wondered if R felt that Pastor Ken was directing that prayer to him, or, that the Holy Spirit was speaking to him through Pastor Ken’s prayer. I asked because it seemed to me that these were two different “calls”—one directed by man and another by God himself. He thought about it and then told me that he wasn’t really sure which “call” it was after all.

In recent years, I have contemplated this statement, thinking about the difference between the call of God on the one hand (as revealed through the Holy Spirit’s work in our conscience) and the call or influence of other people whom we deem powerful or important on the other hand (what Sigmund Freud would call the power of the super-ego). I think about this in the context of church work—about how easy it is for the church to unintentionally manipulate people. According to Freud, the super-ego is the part of the conscious that deeply feels and responds to the expectations that other people and institutions place upon us. The super-ego is our receptor site for people-pleasing. Even as a believer, it is easy to become people-pleasing instead of God-pleasing.

R proposed marriage, and we became engaged in November. We received overwhelming support from the church community. The support we received seemed so extreme and so over-thetop. I’ve come to note that normally moderate non-pretentious Christians tend towards extreme emotional excess in the areas of weddings and baby showers. This particular weakness had not been mine to witness until I became the object of this attention. I found this kind of attention uncomfortable and annoying. It seemed as though people that I thought were my friends saw me as suddenly more legitimate now that I was going to join the club of the married. I also didn’t know to whom or how to articulate my feelings of fear and doubt. Again, I confronted the question: how can a woman like me be a godly woman? I never once thought to ask if R was a godly man. After all, he had shared the gospel with me, bridged the gospel for me, prayed with me and for me. In addition, he was under the care of our session and presbytery and was going to be a pastor. Yes, he was struggling. But if the session knew his struggles and thought he would still make a fine pastor, surely he would make a faithful husband. I had no idea what godly standards of discernment were.

As R and I prepared for marriage, this promise of my first legitimate relationship became very heady for me. I fell more into step with the thinking of my friends at church. He and I talked every day—sometimes multiple times a day. He continued to lose the battle against sin. I struggled over how Jesus could give me liberty and not him, and I concluded that victory was just a matter of time. After all, he had committed (and re-committed) his life to Christ, so what else but victory could be the result? This promise of my first legitimate relationship filled me with pride and awe—the club I had never imagined joining was about to welcome me with open arms. And Jesus, I was sure, would use me in his victory over sin in a special way.

It’s a cliché in the gay community but one that I believe is true. It goes like this: gay men have sex but lesbians have talk. It doesn’t mean that lesbians are celibate (although some are), but it does mean that talk is very intimate for women. The talk that R and I shared during this time was too intimate. We started to share the kind of secrets that you can never take back, our mutual histories of sexual sin and family crisis providing more than enough material. I confused all this dredging and sifting with love.

The church’s response provided a vast contrast from the university’s response. My engagement put my former lesbian community into crisis—again. Former students cried in my office and on my porch. My closest comrades talked to me the way they talked about the deceased at funerals—hushed and careful.

While the women of the church gathered around me to help me plan my wedding, I fretted about what to say to my department chair. What should I do? R had two more years of seminary left, and who knew where he would pastor a church—pastors in our denomination do not get to pick where they live and work. It was unlikely that we would live in Syracuse. Should I quit my job? I didn’t want to string the university along while I tried to untangle my personal life. Should I apply for a research leave? I dearly wanted to study Christian education, in part to determine whether I would be a better fit at a Christian college than at a large secular one. I was only eligible for one full-year leave, but he would be in seminary for two more years. Should I try to take a research leave followed by a personal leave? Since my department chair had been such a good friend throughout all my years at Syracuse University, I decided to put the whole matter before him and get his counsel. My department chair was great—encouraging, supportive, helpful. I left his office ready to apply for a two-year research leave. I then went about making plans for renting my house.

The school year went so well. My academic dean approved my two-year leave (first year academic, second year personal). An urban ministry program in Pittsburgh contacted me about teaching in their weekend program. It was all coming together. I felt the power of God in my labor as a professor. I prayed for and with my students. Many students continued to come to my home on Friday nights for a Christian talk-exchange. My classes were all overenrolled. My classes in Christian Hermeneutics and the Romantic Poets were some of the best classes I had taught in my life. I really felt like I could be a Christian professor. And I really imagined that I could balance being a Christian professor and a pastor’s wife. R still wasn’t well, but I was sure God would turn it all around before our wedding. I prayed faithfully. The women gave me books about praying for your husband. I was so confident it would all work out.

It’s hard to explain what happens when you prepare for your first legitimate relationship, share secrets that you shouldn’t, read books about preparing for marriage God’s way, lose all your former friends for the promise of one, incur a wealth of disrespect in your work place, prepare a two-year research leave by somehow packaging all of this spiritual trauma as intellectually vital, rent out your house, tie up all the loose ends of directing the Undergraduate Studies program, prepare for a wedding, believe the whole time that what you are doing is God’s will for your life, feel love and gratitude for the person who shared over and over again the power of the gospel and who bridged for you life and ministry amidst two warring communities, only to have him come to you one day, and say: “There’s something I need to tell you. You can’t marry me. I’m not ready. And I’m probably not a Christian.”

Here’s what I thought: You jerk. You betrayer. You vile, pathetic wimp. I overhaul my whole professional life to correspond with your school schedule and you’re not ready? And, you are probably not a Christian? If you are not a Christian, then what are you doing in seminary? If you are not a Christian, then what are you doing behind a pulpit?

How could the person who shared the gospel with me in the most convincing way and whose Christian life most resembled my own “probably not” be a Christian? What did that mean? Was he not “really” a Christian or was he struggling with assurance of salvation? Assurance of salvation means knowing God’s call on your life—it means knowing in a conscious way that you are his. We know this through both the Holy Spirit’s work in our lives and his call on our hearts. The Spirit’s work in our lives is evident through our obedience to God and our love for our fellow man. We find this in the Bible in 1 John 3:10: “Whoever does not practice righteousness is not of God, nor is he who does not love his brother.” The Spirit’s call on our hearts is revealed in scripture in Galatians 4:6-7: “And because you are sons, God has sent forth the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying out, ‘Abba Father!’ Therefore, you are no longer a slave (or an orphan) but a son, and if a son, then an heir of God through Christ.” To this day, I do not know which he was lacking: assurance or salvation. The Apostle Paul tells us that “Today is the day of salvation” (2 Cor. 6:12). And what about me, what about my faith? How could I “probably” be Christian and R “probably” not be? And what does the word “probably” have to do with it? This was unthinkable.

This conversation happened a few weeks before the end of the semester and our scheduled wedding date.

Like rocks hitting water, the reverberations of shock and sadness came in steady and gentle waves. At the bottom of my crisis was this: Who is this Jesus? Am I following Jesus or R? Whom do I love more? There were other more practical considerations, to be sure. For example, what was I to do and where was I to live for the next two years? The urban ministry program in Pittsburgh with whom I had just signed a contract worked out of the seminary that he attended. This job didn’t pay enough to rent an apartment in Pittsburgh. And my house in Syracuse was rented out to grad students who were only paying enough to cover the mortgage. After addressing the practical considerations, I confronted the personal ones. The rocky underworld of rejection lodged itself in the shaky identity of my godly womanhood. I wondered if somehow R knew something that I did not. Maybe he somehow knew that I was not healed and that my sexual self would forever be in limbo or worse. How does a single and celibate person even know if she is healed sexually? What is sexual healing? And then if not healed, was I really converted?

I thought about other things, too. Do I break all my promises—urban ministry, research leave, renting my house—and just hole up at home and lick my wounds? These were big decisions fueled by big questions. But the biggest burden on my heart was a problem of worldview: Who is Jesus? Who had betrayed me, R or God? Who is the Jesus who heals some but not others? Who needs a fickle God? Faith is not a feeling. Faith rides the waves of the treachery of life on the Christian worldview that you own. Faith and worldview are intimately intertwined. Our peace, love, courage, longsuffering, and life-works, lock-step with our Christian worldview and the faith that undergirds it. Where was mine?

Psalm 15 became my guide. Psalm 15 directed me to keep my promises and showed me how to work in God’s strength to do so. In Psalm 15, the psalmist asks the question that burdened my heart—“Lord, who may dwell in your sanctuary? Who may live in your holy hill?” (Ps. 15:1). I needed to know: Was I in God’s house? Was I in God’s will? Why would God do this to me? The remaining lines of the psalm answered the question I searched for: God’s people speak truth (15:2); God’s people do not slander neighbors (15:3); God’s people fear the Lord (15:4); God’s people keep promises “even when it hurts” (15:4, NIV); God’s people give money freely (15:5); God’s people reject bribes (15:6). The psalm’s conclusion offers a promise: “He who does these things will never be shaken” (Ps. 15:5). That’s me, I discovered! I’m shaken. My faith is shaken. I prayed that God would help me to live out each line of this psalm, step by step. I finally understood what it meant that Jesus identifies with all of our troubles. I finally believed Hebrews 4:15-16: “For we do not have a High Priest who cannot sympathize with our weaknesses, but was in all points tempted as we are, yet without sin. Let us therefore come boldly to the throne of grace, that we may obtain mercy and find grace to help in time of need.” I saw something in myself. By wallowing in pity, I was holding myself back from going boldly to the throne of grace.

The church surrounded me with a gentle presence. No one told me what to do, how to feel, or what to think. The women of my church gave me gentle presence. They enfolded me into their lives and prayers. It took all I had to come to church and not bawl my eyes out the whole time. I felt like I had a year earlier, when the conviction of sin under the preaching of the word was too much and I would leave the service or shut down halfway through. One day, when I started to leave the service early, Elder B followed me out. He said, “Rosaria, it’s OK to just pray that God will get you through this moment—this very one, right now.” He prayed for me and God eventually over time gave me the peace to both grieve and survive minute-by-minute. Another elder-friend invited me to his home for dinner. He and his wife were big supporters of R and they were concerned for him and as well as for me. Elder M said to me: “This is the biggest faith test you will ever face. You may face it again in another context, but this is the test that rises as high as we can imagine: Rosaria, Jesus is saying to you, right now, in this moment of shame and defeat, whom do you love? Me or him? Whom do you follow? Me or him?” I was so thankful for bold elders and faithful praying and grieving friends.

Nobody seemed to really believe that R articulated his lack of faith to me. I suppose the session felt assured of his salvation and believed that he just needed to work on his own assurance. He had a history of exaggerating his emotions and problems, so the session just had him proceed forward, business as usual. The more that I contemplate this today, from a long distance away, married now to a real Christian, I don’t think that R was exaggerating. But I don’t like the way that my church body handled R’s articulation of faithlessness. I don’t think we should ever jolly someone into faith, especially someone who has access to a pulpit.

That spring and summer, R was on break from seminary but was expected to continue in his role as pastoral intern for our church. He was assigned to our church plant, in part, I believe, to get him away from me and allow me to worship without (more) distraction. R continued to struggle with people-pleasing. At one point, he sent a letter out to a number of pastors in our denomination, explaining in detail our relationship and our breakup and asking if there was any “sin” in his conduct. As pastors started to debate the issue, privately but within my hearing and the hearing of my friends at church, I truly felt as though an RP alpha-male convention was being played out over my dead body. I felt exposed. I was mortified. I contemplated finding another church.

Although it was not his fault, I felt betrayed by Pastor Ken. I believed he should have warned me about this guy—even protected me from him. Pastor Ken’s ministry was unique. In looking back, I see that he wanted to open the doors of the church in a wide way. The doors were wide enough for someone like me to enter and wide enough for someone like R as well. That wide path both served me and hurt me. This crisis made me ask: had I really been obeying Jesus and following him in faith? The answer was no. No, I had been a double-minded follower of Christ. I followed R who followed Jesus (or, so it appeared). He was my bridge to the gospel, the Bible, the Church, and Jesus himself. These were the incommensurable binary oppositions of my life: 1) Had R not been in that church at that particular time, I would not have kept coming back; and 2) R betrayed me—Big Time.

Sometimes binary oppositions like these are so potentially paralyzing that you just have to put them aside for awhile. I tucked this one away for two years. I knew that God calls us to walk in faith, not to be paralyzed by doubt. As Pastor Ken once said to me, “You can’t steer a parked car. If you want to turn your life around, you’ve got to get moving!” It wasn’t until recently that God gave me the language and safety to explore what betrayal by a self-proclaimed believer means in God’s economy. Pastor Peter Smith said these simple words in a sermon and my ears and eyes and heart and mind opened. Pastor Peter said, “People will betray you, but Jesus never will.” Much of my past fell in place when he said these simple words. Here is what I gleaned. Betrayal deepens our love for Jesus (who will never betray us). Betrayal deepens our knowledge of Jesus and his sacrifice, obedience, and love. (Jesus was betrayed by his chosen disciples and by all who call upon him as Savior and Lord by our sin). Finally, betrayal deepens our Christian vision: The Cross is a rugged place, not a place for the squeamish or self-righteous.

I came to learn that summer that God does use us through and in our weaknesses. I came to learn what it means that in Christ “we live and move and have our being” (Acts 17:28). From outside appearances, it looked like the church had betrayed me. And now that, in the court of public opinion, my church had, by all appearances, betrayed me in a public way, I became safe for another group of people. Friends from the lesbian community came back. An ex-girlfriend wrote me a beautiful note (she is a poet). In it, she assured me of her faith in me and told me that I was always welcome back in the lesbian community. She told me not to fear such a hard life lesson and not to think that my old friends want me to suffer. Now that I had a serious faith struggle before me, I became safe for others to share their doubts, fears, and disappointments. My lesbian neighbor had at one point been a woman of faith. I didn’t know this. Now she was dying of cancer. She approached me one day and said, “I didn’t give a damn about who God was to you in your happiness. But now that you are suffering, I want to know: who is your God? Where is he in your suffering?”

The phone rang at midnight, or maybe later. As I lay in bed listening to the phone ring, I suddenly remembered that I lived alone in my house and that I would have to answer the phone. I got out of bed, stumbled over Murphy, my dog, and ran down the stairs to the kitchen. I picked up the phone without turning on the light. It was the hospital. One of my graduate students was in the Intensive Care burn unit. She tried to kill herself by setting herself on fire. I was on her list to call in emergency (that was news to me). The hospital worker on the phone said, “Oh, by the way, we are putting Paxil in her morphine drip, is that OK with you?” Paxil? Morphine? Why is she asking me this question, I wondered.

I showed up at the hospital and they took me to a room to wash and change. They gave me a plastic bubble suit to put on. They brought me into another room with more plastic wrap and breathing tubes. My student A looked mummified. Nevertheless, she was animated. She thanked me for coming, as if I was an invited guest at a formal party. It was surreal. She was talking non-stop about her fears, her visions, and the fire. She told me that her sister was in trouble—she told me that her sister was involved in a murder and that the murder was part of a satanic ritual. She told me that something bad was after her. She told me that they have male nurses helping her to the bathroom. She asked if she could come home with me. I tried to take it all in. Was this for real? A sister in a satanic cult? Was this suicide attempt a satanic attack? I wondered how a person distinguishes morphine from Satan. I wondered why I was standing there. In that instant I realized: this is God’s work for me, right now. Right now, I am to demonstrate the love of Christ to my lesbian student who during this past school year felt deeply betrayed by me. This was God’s “right now” calling. I felt shivers run through my body. There is no finer resolution to a faith test than genuine Christian ministry. The still small voice of God was speaking to me, right now, through my student. I was there because God picked me up and put me there. It was time to wipe the sleep out of my eyes and do something.

I put my hand on A’s, plastic to plastic, and assured her that I and the church would be there for her. I asked if I could pray for her. She told me I could. I prayed for God’s mercy, peace, and saving faith. She fell asleep while I prayed.

I called Ken Smith. I called Vivian and Floy. I called my lesbian colleagues. I called my lesbian students. The lesbian community and the Christian community were going to have to work together for A. A healed—first at my pastor’s house and later at my house. I saw the liberty of Christ through her healing. I saw the unity of Christ through the friendships that were born across worldviews in the hospital. I saw the power of Christ when Satan shook A and my household from top to bottom. The elders strongly exhorted me to start to practice what our church called “family devotions”—a nightly time of Bible reading and prayer for the members of the household and its visitors to share together. How in the world does a single ex-lesbian pull off “family devotions” with a satanically suicidal student? Line up all of my dogs and put them in a sit-stay while I opened the Bible? I saw the perseverance of Christ when elders and church members came nightly to my house to help me with family devotions, giving up time that they should have rightly enjoyed with their own families. I saw the compassion of Christ when the children of the church visited A at my home (one asked her if she had ever heard of “fire safety”). A healed. She did not embrace Christ during this time or to my knowledge. But of this I am sure: Christ put his people in her life to do his work of mercy, and we obeyed.

One day, while A was knitting potholders in my living room, R came over. He and A talked privately for a while and after he left, A said, “He’s a wacko, Rosaria. All he talked about was his Prozac dosage and his difficulty when the doctors changed it.”

Situations like that made me realize a hard lesson: God gives and God takes away and he does it for our good. Indeed, R was both my best friend and no friend at all. I loved him because I confused the sick patterns that we shared with deep personal conviction. But God took him away for my good. God knew better than I did. I—and a whole church of believers—believed that marrying him was God’s will for my life. The man to whom I had said “yes” to the most important question an adult can address would have been my ruin had we gotten married. Never again will I think of knowing God’s will as anything but the most humbling of acts. And never again will I confuse other people’s hopes and dreams for me as proof of God’s will.

It was in this spirit of brokenness, upheaval, and exceeding gratitude for God’s protection, exactly one year to the day after delivering my Solomon lecture, that I packed my car for Beaver Falls, Pa. As I was loading the car, Elder and friend Bob Rice said, “Rosaria, never doubt in the darkness what God has promised in the light.” My friend Dr. Ken Smith, at that time chairman of the Board of Trustees of Geneva College, was able to get me a one-year visiting teaching position at Geneva College, our denomination’s Christian college. There I would be able to study Christian education while teaching at a real Christian college—and thus keep the promises of my research leave. I was about an hour outside of Pittsburgh, so I would still be able to drive out there on Friday nights and teach in the urban ministry program—and thus keep my promises to my contract. I didn’t have to worry about bumping into R at the seminary (where my urban ministry class would meet). God exposed his sins to the session. He would not be returning to seminary. Geneva College graciously allowed me to live rent-free in one of its apartments and the students renting my house covered my mortgage. This allowed me to give back my salary to the urban ministry program which dearly needed it (Ps. 15:5). And the president of Geneva College even allowed me to take my dog Murphy. God truly gave me more than I had asked for. His provisions were abundant. My cup overflowed.

Driving away from Syracuse was hard. I wondered if I would ever come back. I loved my white house with green trim. I loved my neighbors. And, at least in the summer, I loved Syracuse. But most of all, I loved my job. With horror, I remembered that I had been willing to give up my job for R. How God had protected me from that man! How could I even consider leaving a tenured professorship! What foolishness! I loved my job and colleagues. Were these gifts or idols, I wondered? With a chill, I knew that if they were idols, then God would, in his love and mercy, destroy them and remove them from me.

My faithful dog, Murphy, licked my face as we got on the highway. I felt exhilarated about what might come next. I was still sad. I was still grieving. I was still praying that R would get it together and come back to real faith and even to me. But no matter what, I was working for God! What a privilege! What an assurance of salvation! God was teaching me how to hold the things of this world lightly. God was teaching me how to use my skills for the Kingdom. God was revealing himself to me through the details of my life and the choices that he put before me. I was driving away from the place, the life, the career, and the people that I knew and loved. But Jesus Christ was more real to me at that moment than any of these material things. Murphy licked my face again and I laughed out loud. This was my conversion in a nutshell: I lost everything but the dog.

* My husband Kent has given me, over the years, a deeper appreciation of this passage and its pivotal role in understanding the social nature and emotional root of sexual sin. I am indebted to his sensitivity about this; my own healing continues to build as I drink deeply of the radical implications of biblical sexuality, and as repentance chips away at me from the inside out.

↑ Back to top

↑