Change 6: Add a Question Mark
CHANGE 6
ADD A QUESTION MARK
In 2015, author Alexandra Samuel gathered data from more than ten thousand North American parents about how they handle the issue of “screen time.”1 Her research revealed that parents fall into one of three groups. Each group seems to carry its own distinct attitude toward technology.
The first group she labeled enablers. This is by far the largest group. (The McAfee study I referred to earlier revealed 74 percent of parents fall into this category.) These parents have given in to the pressure from their kids and other families around them. They let their kids choose how much media is appropriate.
Samuel called the second group limiters. This is the group of parents whose favorite button is the OFF button. Their solution is simply to ban or limit screen time. I meet plenty of these parents in churches where I teach workshops.
The last group isn’t swayed by social pressure and doesn’t see any benefit to turning off screens their kids will eventually just turn on, figuring, How will this prepare our kids for a world embracing more and more technology each year? This group of parents has found the best practice is taking an active role in walking with their kids as they learn about technology and guiding them through it step by step. That’s probably why Samuel called this group mentors.
Samuel found mentors to be the “most successful in preparing their kids for a world filled with screens.” They dialogue with their kids more than twice as much as limiters and are far more likely to research specific devices or programs for their kids (44 percent of mentors do that at least once a week, compared to 31 percent of enablers and 14 percent of limiters).
If you’re like me, you’re already placing yourself in one of these three categories. I was a limiter—big-time! And if you read my previous chapter about the segue, you felt my frustration as I realized being a limiter proved ineffective with my oldest. The limiter makes all the decisions for his kids, and they never learn to discern for themselves.
Here’s what’s funny: this struggle isn’t anything new.
Sure, smartphones are new, social media is relatively new, selfies are new…in fact, some other new fad probably went viral before the ink dried in this book you’re holding in your hand (unless you have the eBook—then it was before the pixels arranged themselves).
But the practice of walking alongside our kids through all of these changes?
Not new.
God told us to do that a long time ago. (It’s in Deuteronomy 6. We’ll look at that passage in depth in the next chapter.) And it’s one of the most effective ways to raise kids who become decision makers.
Then how come these “mentor” parents are in the minority?
The answer is painfully clear.
Good parenting takes time and energy.
My friend Paul Kent wrote a Star Wars devotional.2 I got a chance to read it before it was published. It was a creative little book for teenagers, taking elements from the Star Wars films and applying them to everyday life. In the introduction to the book, he shared an intriguing story from his childhood. You see, like me, he was a kid when the first Star Wars film was first released on May 25, 1977. All his friends went to see it and immediately started talking about it every day at school.
I remember the time well. Stores began filling their shelves with Star Wars toys, puzzles, and pajamas. Kids wore Star Wars T-shirts to school. They wore Darth Vader costumes for Halloween. One of my friends even had Star Wars sheets!
But Paul wasn’t allowed to go see Star Wars. His parents held strong to their beliefs that Hollywood was of the devil!
Paul felt like he was literally the only kid who hadn’t seen the film. But his parents wouldn’t budge.
Soon the movie wasn’t in theaters anymore, and there was no renting it or buying it. Back in the ’70s, people didn’t have VCRs yet. Paul had missed out.
But hope wasn’t lost. (Or should I say, A New Hope wasn’t lost?) The film was rereleased in theaters some time later. Films used to do that if they were a big enough box office smash. Paul saw this as his opportunity. He asked his parents again and again until they finally gave in.
This is the part where I burst out laughing: his parents didn’t want to see it, so they just dropped him off at the theater to watch it by himself.
Let that sink in for a moment.
This is the emblematic response of the “limiter” parent.
They start by limiting. “You can’t do it!”
But then their kids bother them until the parents can’t fight the battle anymore (or they realize that the battle wasn’t worth fighting in the first place), so they give in.
Since my friend’s parents objected to the film so unwaveringly in the first place, didn’t they think it would be smart to at least go watch this film they had deemed unfit for their child? Did an angel come down from heaven in a dream and show these parents that Star Wars was now okay? Did Master Yoda make these parents “unlearn what they had learned”?
Why the 180-degree turn?
Even more importantly, don’t you think this would be an opportune moment, perhaps a perfect moment, to “co-view” this film with your child and talk about what you saw? Your boy has been begging you to watch this film for over a year. You’ve got this kid in the palm of your hand. You could probably convince him to read the entire book of Psalms with you at breakfast each morning for a month in exchange for watching this film.
And yet you just drop him off at the curb?
Hilarious!
Parents! Hear me! This is your chance. You can make an incredible difference in the life of your kids when you heed God’s advice and walk through life with them, dialoguing about what God has done for them.
Most parents would love to engage in meaningful conversations with their kids, talking about stuff that matters, but don’t know the secret to accomplishing this pattern of teaching.
Do you know how to be a mentor parent, instead of a limiter or an enabler?
The secret is in the punctuation.
We need to learn to use the question mark.
THE QUESTION MARK
The best way to teach our kids is to rephrase our teaching and add a question mark. Don’t get me wrong. I’m not simply repeating what I said in “Change 3: Notice” when I encouraged you to use questions to get to know your kids better. As much as that is an excellent practice, I’m now suggesting you use questions for something different.
Teach with questions!
Stop telling your kids what to do; instead, ask them what they should do.
I was terrible at this. My go-to response was lecturing.
If you asked my kids, they’d tell you, “Dad loved to lecture.” Sadly, it took me quite a while to realize lecturing isn’t half as effective as asking a question and listening.
So I made a change. I began using questions to teach. This practice moved me from lecturing to listening.
Apparently I’m not alone. As I asked other parents to look back at their own parenting, numerous parents cited listening as a skill they wish they had mastered. Like this mother of two boys now in college:
One of the things I would do over would be to ask more questions and be a better listener. More times than I’d like to admit, I gave them the answer or told our sons what they “should do.” Some of life’s most valuable lessons come from figuring them out on our own.
So what does this look like?
Your son asks you, “Can I hold off on my homework and go play football with Jake?”
Instead of answering yes or no, ask him, “Should you?” Or “What do you think is wise?”
Jesus did this all the time! He had an amazing way of using questions to teach people truth. Consider how shrewd this strategy is. When Jesus came upon a teaching moment, He often opted for asking a question and listening instead of lecturing. The result was powerful.
If we look at the Gospel record, we’ll discover Jesus asking literally hundreds of questions. Let’s take a quick peek at just a few of the questions He asked:
1. “Do you believe that I am able to do this?” (Matthew 9:28)
2. “Who do people say the Son of Man is?” (Matthew 16:13)
3. “Who do you say I am?” (Matthew 16:15)
4. “What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul?” (Matthew 16:26)
5. “Can you drink the cup I am going to drink?” (Matthew 20:22)
6. “What do you think about the Messiah? Whose son is he?” (Matthew 22:42)
7. “How will you escape being condemned to hell?” (Matthew 23:33)
8. “Why are you thinking these things?” (Mark 2:8)
9. “When I broke the five loaves for the five thousand, how many basketfuls of pieces did you pick up?” (Mark 8:19)
10. What did Moses command you?” (Mark 10:3)
11. Why do you call me good?” (Mark 10:18)
12. Why are you thinking these things in your hearts?” (Luke 5:22)
13. What is written in the Law? How do you read it?” (Luke 10:26)
14. Why are you troubled, and why do doubts rise in your minds?” (Luke 24:38)
15. I have spoken to you of earthly things and you do not believe; how then will you believe if I speak of heavenly things?” (John 3:12)
16. Do you want to get well?” (John 5:6)
17. Where are they? Has no one condemned you?” (John 8:10)
18. Do you believe this?” (John 11:26)
19. Do you understand what I have done for you?” (John 13:12)
20. Do you love me?” (John 21:17)
This list accounts for less than 10 percent of Jesus’ questions found in the Gospels. Jesus asked a lot of questions!
I love how Jesus used questions to provoke people to think. For example, in Matthew 16, when He asked His disciples, “Who do people say the Son of Man is?” (verse 13), this wasn’t a probing question. Jesus was just asking what the crowds thought. But then Jesus made it more personal by asking, “Who do you say I am?” (verse 15, emphasis added).
We can learn quite a bit from Jesus’ approach. Start general, then get more personal. In other words, don’t scare them away with the first question.
Think what this might look like with your kids: “Do you ever get irritated when you’re trying to hang out with your friends and they’re staring at their phones the whole time?” Pause to hear their answer. “Do you ever do that with your friends?”
Jesus used this kind of questioning to make a point. We can do the same.
LEAD THEM TO THE DECISION
Teachers use this method constantly. Asking students questions requires them to process the information they have just heard and use it to discover an answer.
My mother was an English professor at California State University in Sacramento, and she used this method on me growing up. I hated it! Whenever I had a question about the composition of a paper I was writing, she would never spell out an answer for me. I would ask, “What should I write in this paragraph?” She would always respond, “Well, what do you think you should put there?”
I’d always balk. “Come on, Mom! Just tell me the answer!”
Young people don’t always like it when we ask them to think. Sure, it’s nice that we aren’t telling them what to do. They enjoy being treated like an adult who can make decisions. But at times my kids probably would have just preferred I gave them an answer.
“Dad, can I watch the new Will Ferrell movie?”
“I don’t know. Would you let your kid watch it?”
Sigh!
They wouldn’t mind if I just said yes. But they don’t necessarily want every decision to become a huge discussion about the behaviors and attitudes young people glean from entertainment media.
You might be tempted to give in and answer for them. What good would that do them? (See what I did there? I asked you a question.)
It’s your job as a parent to make them think through decisions. Remember the old adage, “You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make them drink.” The same is true with today’s young people. It’s your job as a parent to lead them to the right decision. But they are the ones who need to learn to make said decision.
Sometimes the questions don’t have to turn into huge discussions. Do your best to just make your kids think.
“Dad, can I go to the drive-in this Friday?”
“I don’t know much about your plans. You tell me if you should go.”
This principle of teaching with questions doesn’t mean you let your kids make every choice. When my girls were in middle school, I used this same method, and then I still reserved the right to make the final decision (because they were still young). So if my daughter Ashley approached me and asked if she could download a certain song onto her playlist, I would start by asking, “What do you think of the song’s lyrics?” After discussing it, if she still wanted it, but I disagreed, I would tell her, “Sorry, Ashley. I just don’t think twelve-year-olds need to be listening to songs about midnight booty calls.” Interestingly enough, it rarely came to that with Ashley. Most of the time she was making good choices.
There’s one catch to using this method of leading our kids to decisions: we need to actually know where we’re leading them!
That means we need to know what values we stand for and what hills we die on. Sometimes we moms and dads need to talk and come to agreement about where we’ll lead our kids. If Mom lets little Christina watch anything she wants, and Dad doesn’t, Christina is never going to ask Dad (today’s kids are savvy like that). So do your best to talk about these bigger decisions and come to an agreement as parents. It’s okay to delay your kids and tell them honestly, “As you’re weighing whether downloading this app is a good decision, your father and I will look into it as well and see what’s best. Let’s talk tomorrow and see what all three of us think.”
Yes, this is much more difficult in split homes. When your kids are living in two homes with two different sets of values, often the rules will look different in each setting. In this situation, do your best to try to come to agreement between parents. But if the other parent wants to do things their own way, it might be a tough battle to fight. The best you can do is remember the influence you can have while bonding with your kids when you have them and providing realistic boundaries in your home. The biggest impact you’ll make in this situation is through your own attitudes and behaviors. If your kids see you living a life of love, grace, and purity, then it will be hard to argue with a life so well lived.
Know where you are leading your kids.
In my house, this process is much easier when my wife and I are spending time reading our Bibles together. The Bible is our source of wisdom, and when the two of us are reading it together and dialoguing about what we read, God’s teaching becomes cemented into our lives so we know what the truth looks like, especially in a world so full of cunning lies. (More on this in the next chapter.)
ON THE FLY
So what does teaching with questions look like day to day? How can we replace “You should” with “Should you?”
Let’s be real. These difficult parenting scenarios have a way of sneaking up on us when we’re unprepared. Our kids will run up to us while we’re in the middle of something important (almost strategically) and quickly ask, “Can I go to Michael’s house and watch the new TV show with Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson? It’s about football. Michael’s mom lets him watch it. Please!”
Now we have to make a decision on the fly. And it’s difficult to make wise decisions in five seconds or less. The Rock? He’s done kids’ movies. It’s probably clean, right?
Here are some thoughts to consider:
1. Remember to phrase your answer as a question. If you are pretty sure you need to tell your son no, don’t just say no; lead him to the no. So in this example, maybe say, “What do you think you should do?” If he replies, “I think I should watch it!” then try my next idea.
2. Offer to watch it together. Often our kids know a lot more about what they’re asking than they lead us to believe. That’s where the advice of the American Academy of Pediatrics to “co-view” comes in handy. Watch it with them. Or in this situation, instead of just saying no, ask them, “Should we watch it together as a family tonight and see what we all think?” If your kids still say yes, then consider the next idea.
3. Delay. If your kids are still young and you don’t have enough information…delay! Don’t be afraid to say, “I can’t make that decision right now because I don’t have enough information. The answer isn’t no; it’s not now. But I’m happy to look up the show or maybe even try the show with you later and see what you think.”
5. Remember incremental independence. If your kids are twelve, then they still need a lot of guidance, so don’t be afraid to veto their decision. But if they’re seventeen years old and in their senior year, after asking them what they think is best, release them to their decision. Let them fail if necessary. Then be there to lovingly pick them up. Maybe offer, “Well, as you know, you can make this decision on your own. So make the choice and let’s grab Starbucks tomorrow and you can tell me what you thought.” Make sure that Starbucks time isn’t filled with lectures or “I told you so.” Use questions to lead them to the truth.
Another helpful tool for thinking on the fly is a handful of versatile questions you can use and adapt in a variety of settings with your kids.
Here are some of my favorites:
• “Was he right?” I’ve used this question with my kids probably more than any other question. If my kids tell me about something questionable their friend did at school, or if they show me a music video on YouTube where a guy is hooking up with girls, instead of lecturing I just ask, “Was he right?”
• “How do you think he will feel about that decision next week/month/year?” This is a good question prompting young people to think beyond the temporary thrill of the moment and to consider long-term ramifications. Kind of like when Dr. Phil asks, “How’s that working out for you?”
• “How do you think he got to this point?” This gets your kids to ponder the choices someone made leading to the situation at hand.
• “Give me two or three alternate ways this situation could have been handled.” This question helps them think through options. Kids should understand they always have several choices how to respond, and each choice has consequences good or bad. That’s why you follow that question up with…
• “Knowing what you know now, which one would you have chosen? Which one would you as a parent choose?” This helps them consider positive alternatives.
• “What does the Bible say about this?” This question helps them go to the source of true wisdom.
• “Why do you think this is so?” If you ever see a truth manifested clearly through a story, simply ask this question so your kids can explain why. This is a great question when you see statistics showing consequences of behaviors.
You can use these types of questions over family dinner. You can use them when you’re watching the news or reading the paper. You can use them if you’re reading the Bible together as a family.
Try it next time you see an article like this one entitled “Sexual Media Exposure, Sexual Behavior, and Sexual Violence Victimization in Adolescence.” Here’s just a snippet of this scholarly study:
The relative odds of ever having sex were almost 4 times higher for youth who reported some of at least one media they consumed, and more than 5 times higher for youth who reported that many or almost all/all of at least one media they consumed depicted sexual situations, compared to youth who reported that almost none/none of the media they consumed depicted sexual situations.3
Rephrase it or explain it quickly if you must; then ask: “Why do you think this is so?”
Imagine the discussion this one question could incite. (And if you read more of the report, you’ll find it provides much more data provoking conversation.)
The key to this whole approach of teaching with questions is to limit lecturing while cultivating listening. Fight the temptation to sit them down and set them straight. Let questions guide them to the answer.
“Should you?”
This approach takes time and energy. That’s why most parents don’t do it. They either enforce a bunch of limitations with no conversations…or they let their kids do whatever they want. Either way is much easier than walking along the road with our kids and leading them toward the truth.
Let’s dive into the next chapter and talk a little more about that.
LIVING IT OUT THIS WEEK
QUESTIONS TO DISCUSS WITH YOUR SPOUSE AND/OR OTHER PARENTS
1. What is one thing in this chapter that stood out to you?
2. Which of the three types of parents—enablers, limiters, mentors—do you think you identified with the most?
3. How’s that working out for you?
4. How do questions help parents become “mentor parents” instead of limiters or enablers?
5. Why do you think Jesus used so many questions?
6. Can you think of an example of you using questions to lead any of your kids to a decision? How did it work?
7. Can you think of a time when you should have used this method but didn’t? How would you handle it if you had a do-over?
8. How would asking, “Should we watch it together?” help you in some of these “on the fly” situations?
9. Where can you see yourself using a versatile question like “Is he right?” or “Why do you think this is so?”
10. What is one thing you read in this chapter that you would like to implement this week? When will you try it?
