Chapter 8 of 16

Change 5: Segue

Change 5: Segue

CHANGE 5

SEGUE

When my kids were in middle school, I heard something repeatedly from my kids. “Dad, none of my friends’ parents are this strict.”

Name the topic:

Their phones: I had more rules.

Their music: I was more involved in what they listened to.

Their screen time: We monitored it much more than most of their friends’ parents.

And I don’t regret any of it.

Yes, I realize this book is about parenting practices I would do differently if I had a do-over. And truly, I would not change the guardrails I placed for my kids in middle school. I think my rules were on par.

The part I’d change is the segue.

No, I’m not talking about one of those cool little two-wheeled motor carts that mall cops ride. I’m talking about an actual segue—decreasing one thing while increasing another.

Remember at your high school junior prom when they faded out the song “Thriller” while fading in “Endless Love”? You could still hear Michael Jackson’s beat fading while Lionel Ritchie’s entrancing piano score began. DJs are the master of the segue, and a good DJ knows how to segue from one song to another seamlessly. Parents need to learn the same skill—gradually decreasing the boundaries they set for their kids while gradually increasing their freedom to make decisions.

I wish I would have implemented this strategy from the beginning.

Here’s what I mean.

When I first had kids, I didn’t really have a game plan. The ball was hiked and we just began running. I hadn’t thought through the amount of guidance my kids would need at different ages, and I had never really thought through the need for different degrees of help from Dad and Mom. I was just strict because I thought that would help my kids learn the difference between right and wrong. But soon they grew to the age where they needed to learn how to make moral decisions when Dad and Mom weren’t there.

How can our kids learn to make these decisions if Mom and Dad keep making decisions for them?

Or let me ask another question: When is the magic age?

We’ve all wondered how long to keep on the training wheels. When can my daughter spend the night at her friend’s house? When should I let my son have his first phone?

First consider the big picture. No one would argue with the fact that toddlers need a lot of guidance. If you take your kids camping and your two-year-old starts running toward the campfire, I don’t know many parents who would just sit there and say, “Let him learn his lesson the hard way!” Parents recognize toddlers require plenty of guidance!

On the opposite extreme, when our kids get to age eighteen, they can pack their bags, move out, and join the Marines. We don’t set their bedtime anymore. We don’t have control over what apps they download. At this point we don’t set the rules. A drill sergeant does.

Are all eighteen-year-olds ready to make decisions on their own? Sadly, no. But the reality is, when our kids are eighteen, they can legally move out, get their own place, and begin making all their own choices.

The point of debate is always the time in between age two and eighteen. Some parents stay strict until the day their kids leave (I gravitated this way with my oldest). Other parents don’t provide any guidance at all, even when their kids need it.

When do you plan to let your kids start learning to make their own decisions?

I had never thought this through with my oldest. When he was in middle school, I was very involved in all his decisions. Name it:

•  Junk food intake

•  Screen time

•  Chores

•  Homework

•  Bedtime

•  Curfew

Kids are still pretty immature in middle school and aren’t ready to make these decisions on their own. I didn’t leave it up to my twelve-year-old to decide if he wanted to eat Cocoa Puffs for breakfast every morning, watch HBO into the late hours, and go to bed at 2:00 a.m. Twelve-year-olds would probably make bad decisions in all three of those areas.

But then he turned thirteen…

and fourteen…

and fifteen…

Soon he turned sixteen, got his driver’s license and a job, and began looking at colleges. And I hadn’t backed off. I still monitored his homework, his screen time, his chores, his bedtime…

In less than two years he would be in a dorm making all these decisions completely on his own, and I still wasn’t giving him any practice making decisions.

I was shortsighted really. I had never asked myself, When do I plan to let him make some of these choices on his own?

Sure, he had a little more freedom than he did in junior high. We let him stay up later, and we let him have more screen time. Key words: we let him. We told him he was getting older and taking on more responsibility, but the truth is, we were still missing an important parenting principle: incremental independence.

We were the ones still making all of those decisions for him!

So as my daughters were entering adolescence, Lori and I made a drastic change in our parenting practices. In fact, I announced it to them when they were entering high school. I told them, “By the time you turn seventeen and a half, you won’t have any rules. Not one!”

Funny…they didn’t complain.

When they were thirteen years old, they had thought I was on the strict side. “Dad! Brianna’s mom lets us do that!”

So that’s when I told them, “For the next couple of years, you might think we’re strict. We might even appear more strict than some of your friends’ parents. But by the time you’re a senior in high school, your friends are going to think you have the coolest parents in the world…because you won’t have any rules.”

Some of my friends thought I was nuts. “Jonathan, that’s crazy! What if your daughter wants to stay out all night and party?”

Really? Should we wait until our kids are eighteen years old or out of the house to let them have their first try at making decisions for themselves?

Pause and think about that for a moment. If we’ve done our job as parents, teaching our kids strong values, helping them develop discernment, giving them more and more responsibility as they’ve gotten older, then our senior in high school will need very little guidance at this point anyway. Besides, our kids are legally free to do whatever they want at age eighteen, so we might as well set them up to win and let ’em have a trial run while we’re still there to pick ’em up when they fall.

This is what I called “the segue.” And I’m not alone.

Last year, in a North Point Web interview, Andy Stanley talked about the difficult task of raising middle school kids.

Stanley, the pastor of North Point Community Church in Atlanta, speaks to parents and leaders worldwide and has written some of the most insightful leadership books I’ve read in the last twenty years.

In this particular interview he was asked, “‘Begin with the end in mind.’ What do you mean by that?”

Stanley answered:

We heard something early on in our parenting that really was a defining moment. The general principle was, when it came to disciplining kids in general, you start super, super narrow and you over time give greater and greater freedom. So when we hit middle school…I sat down with our kids and said, “Let me tell you what our goal for you is. Our goal is that you will have no rules and no curfew.” And of course they [lit] up. “So our goal is to lighten up as soon as we can, because as soon as you’re showing responsibility, we’ll give you more responsibility and more freedom.”1

Consider what great news this is for our kids! Just when they’re beginning to wonder why they don’t have some of the same freedoms their friends presently have, Mom and Dad reveal a very promising future.

Sure, strict rules now isn’t the greatest news. But the hope of freedom!

Stanley says it so well. He told his kids:

“We don’t really want to parent you. What that means is, in the short term, you might have more rules and less freedom than some of your friends, but in the end you are going to have fewer rules and more freedom than some of your friends. We want you to have the same freedom you have your freshman year of college while you are at home with us.”

When I gave my girls this speech years prior (though probably not as eloquently as Andy Stanley), they had no objections.

It was surprising, honestly. I thought they were going to whine about how strict I was in the present. But they didn’t. They seemed to appreciate the fact that their mom and dad’s plan for the future was to give them freedom. They saw freedom as earned, not given.

REAL-WORLD RULES

Consider what this looks like in the real world.

First, remember what you’ve read so far in this book. This chapter has been focusing on boundaries. Even though I’m advising you to be strict with your kids when they’re young, this doesn’t negate a word I’ve said about the importance of bonding. So don’t make the mistake I confessed early in the book in “Change 1: Tip the Scales” when my focus on the perfect boundaries actually sabotaged my bonding! Boundaries are very important, but not at the expense of bonding. So keep searching for those venues of connection with your kids. Remember that values are often passed down during bonding time even more so than when you’re setting your kids’ curfew.

Finding the balance between boundaries and bonding requires us to pick our battles, as we learned in “Change 2: Let It Go.” It’s inevitable. Our kids will come home, skip their chores, and put their dirty feet up on the kitchen table while eating junk food and blasting loud music through their headphones. You’ll have to make on-the-spot decisions about which battles are worth fighting. When they’re young, be strict. When they’re older, remember real-world consequences speak louder.

These decisions are easier when you take the time to get to know your kid like we learned about in “Change 3: Notice.” You’ll make much wiser and more informed decisions when you invest the time to listen and silently observe.

Then—and only then—consider setting guidelines.

Imagine your eleven-year-old insists on getting her own smartphone. After all, “All my friends have one!” What’s the right decision?

The first thing you should do is research the answer. For many of us, that means going to Google and typing in, “What age should kids get smartphones?” Your inquiry could quite possibly bring you to one of our “Youth Culture Window” articles on our website, TheSource4Parents.com, like the recent article appropriately titled “‘Can I Have a Phone?’ Answering Every Kid’s Burning Question.”2 In that article you will read how most experts recommend kids do not begin using social media until age thirteen.3 Most social media platforms require kids to be thirteen to sign up because of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA), which prevents sites from collecting select information from kids under thirteen. Parents who allow their kids to sign up on these platforms before then are allowing them to lie about their age.

I think you’ll find a little research is quite helpful for making these decisions.

Once you decide what’s best, shrewdly communicate your decision to your child. Give them the big picture: “Our goal is for you to make all these decisions on your own by the time you get to your senior year of high school. So our job now is to teach you good discernment so you gain plenty of experience making good choices by the time you’re making these choices yourself.”

Then explain to them about COPPA and how kids under age thirteen aren’t supposed to be posting to Instagram or Snapchat. Let them know that they need to demonstrate maturity and trustworthiness so they can get their own phone at age thirteen and begin learning how to use some of these apps responsibly.

Once they get their own phone, segue from rigid rules to flexible freedom. The older they get, the more trust and responsibility they earn.

What might this look like?

Here’s just a sample. You may choose to be more rigid or flexible. The important element to observe is the incremental independence:

Music

•  When they are ten years old, they can only listen to music from the family playlists.

•  When they are thirteen, they can download their own playlists on their own device, but they ask permission before downloading any song.

•  When they are fifteen, they not only can have their own playlists but can download music without asking permission. But Mom and Dad have access to these playlists for accountability. No headphones.

•  When they are seventeen and a senior in high school, they can listen to whatever they want however they want. But communication is open with Mom and Dad.

TV/Movies

•  When they are ten years old, they can watch shows and movies with Mom and Dad or preapproved by Mom and Dad. Mostly G and PG material.

•  When they are thirteen, they can watch content a little more mature, but only with Mom and Dad.

•  When they are fifteen, they are trusted to start watching some mature content on their own (mature, not profane), but dialoguing with Mom and Dad about what they saw.

•  When they are seventeen and a senior in high school, they can choose what they want to watch. But communication is open with Mom and Dad.

Apps and Social Media

•  When they are ten years old, they can play with the family iPad, only accessing websites, games, and apps that Mom and Dad have okayed.

•  When they are thirteen, they can have their own device, but Mom and Dad use parental settings blocking out (most) inappropriate content, and Mom and Dad are the only ones with the password and the ability to download new apps.

•  When they are fifteen, they are trusted to start navigating some websites, social media, and apps on their own, but Mom and Dad still have the password and can monitor browsing history, etc. Settings are such that apps cannot be deleted—only Mom and Dad can delete (so they see what apps have been accessed).

•  When they are seventeen and a senior in high school, they can download and browse whatever they like. But communication is open with Mom and Dad.

I wish I would have implemented this kind of incremental independence from the beginning with all of my kids. Being strict made sense when they were young. But I kept making these kinds of decisions for my son Alec when he was sixteen and seventeen.

Think about this logic for a second…or lack thereof. What was my plan?

It’s the question I ask parents whenever they ask me, “At what age should I let my kid…”

I ask them, “When do you plan to hand them the reins for the first time—when they’re in a college dorm by themselves or when they’re still under your roof under the safety of your shadow?”

Let’s be real. Do you think our eighteen-year-olds are going to call us from their Marine barracks, their college dorm, or their own apartment and ask, “Dad, can I watch Game of Thrones?”

If we haven’t equipped them to make these decisions by then, we haven’t done our job.

WHAT IF THEY AREN’T READY?

Sometimes our seventeen- and eighteen-year-olds aren’t ready to be making decisions on their own. In fact, their little sister, who is only fifteen, is making far better choices.

It’s hard when our “legal adults” didn’t get the memo they are adults, so much so that it’s painfully obvious to everyone.

My wife, Lori, helped with the four- and five-year-old class at church recently and had a delightful conversation with a mature little five-year-old girl we’ll call Judith. She was extremely observant and verbal for her age. By the time Lori was done spending an hour with her, she knew almost everything about her family.

“We have someone living with us,” Judith offered.

“Oh really?” Lori asked. “Why is that?”

“Well, her parents kicked her out of her house,” Judith explained, “and now she doesn’t have anywhere to live. So she lives with us.”

“Well, how old is she?”

“She’s nineteen. She sleeps in my room in the top bunk. But she’s not a very good roommate.”

“Oh really?” Lori asked. “Why not?”

“She doesn’t go to bed when she’s supposed to. She just stares at her phone.”

“Well, sometimes grown-ups can decide for themselves what time to go to bed.”

“Oh,” Judith interrupted, “she’s not a grown-up.”

“Oh really?” my wife asked, trying not to giggle. “How old do you have to be to be a grown-up?”

Judith thought for a moment and then answered, “I don’t know. But she’s definitely not a grown-up.”

Sometimes our kids are eighteen going on thirteen. Especially boys. Research reveals the male brain often doesn’t finish developing until the midtwenties. Until then, there’s a lot of “do what feels good at the moment.” Blend that kind of cerebral activity with a world full of temporary distractions all screaming, “Do what feels good at the moment!” It can be a recipe for disaster.

The best you can do is consider the big picture. After age eighteen, our kids can move out completely on their own if they want. My son did. He didn’t like the rules, so he left to figure out life on his own.

In hindsight, I think I was too strict for too long. I never gave him enough of a chance to be a man. Yes, this is hard when a man is acting like a boy. But consider the alternative. Either you equip him to make decisions and release him to his consequences, or you try to hold on tight only to watch him slowly slip away.

Does this mean we need to let our kids violate “house rules”?

Please don’t misunderstand. “No rules” doesn’t mean your kids can deal drugs out of the house, come home drunk every Saturday morning, and have their significant other spend the night. It’s okay to have house rules—the same types of rules they’ll have in the military or on their college campus.

Just don’t let those rules turn into “I don’t like that song; turn it off!”

We can’t parent our kids forever. Take Andy Stanley’s advice: Begin with the end in mind.

When do you want your kids to be able to make decisions on their own?

What’s your game plan to equip them for this day?

DOES INCREMENTAL INDEPENDENCE WORK?

My girls are now away at college but come home and live with us for the summer. So I can truly look back in 20/20 and ask myself, Did this work?

Absolutely!

In fact, my only regret is that we weren’t proactive with incremental independence earlier. My youngest two are the only ones who really experienced it. And for them, the results were amazing!

When my daughters got to their senior year, we gave them the freedom to hang out with whoever they liked, stay out as long as they liked, do whatever they liked…(kind of sounds like a Miley Cyrus song).

Here are some of my observations looking back over the last few years:

•  During the early toddler years, my kids didn’t notice we were strict. They grew up learning, If Mom and Dad say it, they mean it!

•  As our kids grew older and began spending time with friends, they noticed some of our guardrails were stricter than those in other families…or in the families on the Disney Channel! This awareness caused a little pushback. “But Melanie’s mom doesn’t make her do that!” Or “Hannah Montana’s dad doesn’t make her do anything!” That’s when we let them in on our plan to give them more freedom as they earned it, eventually setting them free to make their own decisions by their senior year. This prospect excited them.

•  They began referring back to that conversation. “This is one of those areas where I believe I’ve been proving I make good choices.” We tried noticing this progress and rewarding good decision making with more freedom.

•  As our kids grew into their teens, we had to be proactive and literally force ourselves to “release the grip” and let them make decisions instead of Mom and Dad making all the decisions for them. “Dad, can I download Rihanna?” “No way!…I mean…let’s take a look at her lyrics and tell me your thoughts.”

•  By the time my daughters were sixteen and then seventeen, we began letting them make big decisions, like going to a dance or staying the night at a friend’s house. We’d tell each of them, “You make the decision; then let’s talk about it afterward and see how you think it turned out.”

•  By the time their senior year arrived, “no rules” really wasn’t such a big deal. Each of them had been making most of their own decisions by then anyway. In fact, both of them kept asking us permission to go places. I would always have to remind them, “You can do whatever you think is best. What do you think is best?”

•  Discussions with us were no longer about trying to convince us to give them permission—they already had that. Now conversations were about what they were learning from their decisions, good and bad.

Now, even though they’re both making decisions on their own, they talk with us frequently about their choices, asking advice. We always try to flavor this advice with, “Well, here are some things you could consider….” We provide them with good information so they can make an informed decision. Sometimes they even ask about our experience in the area, giving us opportunities to tell stories of our successes—and our failures.

YOU GOT THIS

Last Father’s Day my church showed a powerful video that featured different dads encouraging their kids through important moments in their lives. A dad held his toddler’s hands while she navigated her first steps, murmuring, “You got this.”

Another dad cheered as his young son went up to bat for the first time. “You got this!”

As another boy took the stage at his school, ready to give a speech, his dad gave him the thumbs-up from the front row, mouthing those familiar words: “You got this.”

A bride paused and took a deep breath as she got ready to the walk down the aisle on her wedding day. Her dad grabbed her hand and whispered, “You got this.”

And finally the video showed a nervous twentysomething girl sitting by herself in the foyer of a business office waiting for a job interview. Her name was called. She paused and looked at the empty chair next to her…where her dad would have been sitting. Then she stood up and whispered to herself, “I got this.”

Isn’t that exactly what every parent wants? Confident kids who feel loved, encouraged, and equipped to make it on their own?

Are you preparing them for that moment?

LIVING IT OUT THIS WEEK

QUESTIONS TO DISCUSS WITH YOUR SPOUSE AND/OR OTHER PARENTS

1.   What is one thing in this chapter that made you think?

2.   Why is it a good idea to have more rules when our kids are young?

3.   How do you know when to begin letting your kids have more freedom?

4.   What do you think Andy Stanley meant when he told his kids, “We want you to have the same freedom you have your freshman year of college while you are at home with us”?

5.   What might this segue look like in your home in regard to bedtime and curfew?

6.   What might this segue look like in your home with Netflix and YouTube?

7.   What might this segue look like in your home when it comes to apps and social media?

8.   What is one thing you read in this chapter that you would like to implement this week? When will you try it?

↑ Back to top

↑