Chapter 16 of 16

Being Smarter Than the Smartphone

Being Smarter Than the Smartphone

Being Smarter Than the Smartphone



“I can’t get my daughter to look up from her phone and actually talk with me.”

I hear this almost every weekend as I finish teaching one of my parent workshops. Moms and dads approach me and ask me how to connect with their tech-obsessed kids. Not so coincidentally, I’m experiencing the same struggle with my own kids. The smartphone is becoming a growing source of frustration, vying for everyone’s attention.

Two hours later, I’ll speak to a room full of teenagers. As I hang out with them afterward, inevitably I’ll hear, “My mom and dad don’t understand. All they do is nag me all the time. It’s not like I’m out dealing drugs or driving drunk!”

It’s interesting being in the unique position of hearing regularly from parents and from teens. Week after week, I hear the same thing. Parents regularly complain, “My kids spend too much time staring at their stupid phones!” And teenagers always protest, “My mom and dad won’t let up about my phone!”

So who is right?

Last month my youngest daughter asked me honestly, “Dad, you don’t think I spend too much time on my phone, do you?”

She had heard all the hype about “too much time on screens.” You probably have too:

•  Today’s thirteen- to eighteen-year-olds spend about nine hours (eight hours, fifty-six minutes) on entertainment media per day, excluding time spent at school or doing homework. Common Sense Media did the extensive research in 2015. When you add up the time today’s teens devote to TV, music, social media, video games, and all the personal time on their mobile devices, the numbers add up to more than a full-time job. And guess which device they’re clocking the most hours on?

•  Screens hinder sleep. In a recent study by the National Sleep Foundation, more than half of parents said their fifteen- to seventeen-year-olds routinely get only seven hours of sleep, or less, though the recommended amount for teens is eight and a half to ten hours. Why? Sixty-eight percent of these teens keep an electronic device on all night.

•  Screens can make your grades drop. A brand-new study by Michigan State University followed five hundred MSU students, monitoring their academic performance as professors competed with smartphones, laptops, and other devices to get participants to engage. “The more they relied upon their gadgets as a distraction—even if it was to undertake quasi-relevant activities such as reading the news—the further their grades fell,” the study states.

•  Screens are a new playground for bullying. Gossip has just been given a turbo boost. Roughly 43 percent of teens have been harassed online (with about 25 percent of them claiming to have suffered more than one instance of it). Girls are twice as likely to be victims of cyberbullying, compared to boys, and, sadly, they are twice as likely to commit it, as well. Not surprisingly, kids who’ve endured cyberbullying are much more likely to attempt suicide than those who haven’t. And parents are overwhelmingly unaware of the harassment their kids suffer. Studies have uncovered a rather large gap between kids’ experiences and parents’ perception. While at least one-third of students are frustrated by the reality of cyberbullying, a mere 7 percent of parents say they’re worried about it affecting their children.

•  Screens create a pressure to be liked in a world where many females already feel self-conscious about their looks. In fact, some researchers studying this struggle to keep up the perfect image online have observed low self-esteem, loneliness, and deep levels of unhappiness as a direct result of using the web. A growing number of teenagers use screens for sexting. Researchers from Drexel University recently surveyed college students, asking them if they had ever sent or received “sexually explicit text messages or images” when they were under age eighteen. Fifty-four percent said yes.

•  Screens provide so many distractions, experts now claim kids shouldn’t own them until they are thirteen years old.

So is this just a bunch of helicopter parents worrying too much, or are some of these legitimate concerns?

Let me come clean.

If I am being completely honest, I’d have to say that a smartphone can be a help or a hindrance. It just depends on who owns whom.

A phone can be a remarkably valuable tool. Let’s face it: all the people who wrote those articles mentioned above warning us about the dangers of the overuse of smartphones and social media own smartphones. I own a smartphone. I love it. (I just recently used it to find out the name of the song playing in a restaurant—thanks Shazam!)

So when does tech become a hindrance?

The answer is simple: tech is a great tool, but a lousy crutch. The moment we all become socially dependent on tech…Houston, we have a problem.

“Think about it,” I challenge teenagers at school assemblies, “how many times have you sat in a circle of your friends and none of them is talking because their heads are all down staring at their phones?”

Students always laugh and point to each other: “That’s so you!”

Smartphones can sometimes distract us from the person sitting right in front of us—often a person we care about far more than the endless stream of posts we’re scrolling through at the moment.

Don’t get me wrong: I believe smartphones can actually help people enhance their personal relationships. Think about how you use it. While eating your breakfast, you can see the new baby pic your best friend posted from a different state. You can text your kids from work to tell them what time you’re picking them up. You can call your spouse while driving home. Phones can actually help us connect.

But tech becomes scary when it’s our primary source of interpersonal communication. Reason being? Tech actually can hinder normal face-to-face communication.

I’ve been researching youth culture and technology for decades, and I’ve encountered countless studies about young people spending too much time with technology. I keep using the word technology simply because, if your kids are like mine, then they aren’t just staring at their phones, they are also clocking in hours looking at other screens. Even today’s video game systems offer interactive and chatting components. All over the country, teens and tweens are sitting in front of TV screens, wearing headsets, and talking with people they’ve never even met face-to-face as they explore a virtual world together. This may scare parents on many levels, but one by-product of all this screen communication is that the more time young people spend communicating via texting and IM, the less they recognize real-life face-to-face social cues.

For example, in 2014 UCLA did an eye-opening study in which they observed kids who were unplugged and mediafree for five days at an outdoor camp. By the end of the five days, these kids were better able to understand emotions and nonverbal cues than kids who were plugged into a normal media diet.

What does this mean? It simply suggests that real-life, face-to-face conversations are superior. Yes, even when we use “emojis”—part of the digital slang of the new millennium—digital communication isn’t as powerful as good ol’ fashioned face-to-face.

Similarly, researchers witnessed this reality clearly in a bonding experiment in which people engaged in conversation with friends four different ways: in person, and through video chat, audio chat, and instant messaging. As you can probably imagine, bonding was measured and differed “significantly across the conditions.” The greatest bonding occurred during the in-person interaction, followed by video chat, audio chat, and then IM, in that order. Good ol’ fashioned face-to-face communication always wins.

When today’s young people focus on digital connections as their primary social connections, the results are always negative. Research shows that many young people today base their own self-worth and value on online affirmation. The result is too much time trying to impress an online audience and a decline in intimate friendships. In other words, many young people today are substituting true friendships with online “friends.”

This even has ramifications in the dating world. A new study by researchers at Stanford and Michigan State found that couples who met online are less likely to stay together long term than those who meet off-line.

So how can parents help teenagers swing the pendulum back toward real-life, face-to-face connections?

Tech Enabled

We need to help teenagers move from being tech dependent to tech enabled. Phones are really convenient tools for helping us communicate with people outside the room, but they become a hindrance when they interfere with our connection with people inside the room.

In my “How to Be Smarter Than Your Smartphone” school assembly, after hashing through many of these realities with teens, I always challenge them:

If Mom or Dad accuses you of spending too much time with tech, don’t argue. Instead of getting defensive, just prove it with your actions. Slide your phone into your pocket, go hang out with your friends, and talk with them face-to-face. In fact, try this:

•  Log off social media for a day and just hang with your friends outside.

•  Go on a kayak ride with that girl/guy you talk with so well.

•  When you see that beautiful sunset, resist the temptation to snap a pic, find the perfect filter, caption it, and post it on Instagram. Instead, just enjoy the sunset! Maybe even look up and thank the Creator of that beautiful scene. Then pull out your phone and text your mom, telling her when you’ll be home.

Tool—yes!

Crutch—nope.

So I ask you, as a parent reading this book, which of these are you modeling?

Our kids will never learn how to be responsible with their phones if we ourselves are slaves to our own devices. It doesn’t matter how many lectures we give or how hard we try to teach what we know; we can only reproduce who we are.

I need to hear this just as much as anyone else. As a parent of three, I’ve failed at this countless times and am regularly learning hard lessons. (I should be brilliant by now, with all the mistakes I’ve made!) And that’s the key: learning from our mistakes, letting them make us better, and then adjusting our behaviors. I call this “adaptive parenting.”

As parents, we have the unique opportunity to demonstrate how to use technology responsibly and effectively. As imperfect humans with a phone in our pocket, we can model how to responsibly use our devices for entertainment, for knowledge, and as a tool for connection. More importantly, we can show them how easy it is to actually turn off the TV, set our phone or tablet aside as we enter the dining room, and enjoy a meal together uninterrupted. We can easily keep our phone in our pocket when we’re hanging out with friends. We can turn it off when we go away on a three-day camping trip—where we’re without a Wi-Fi signal—and actually survive!

This book is full of ideas that may help families look up from their devices and enjoy face-to-face relationships.

Before Diving into This Book

As you read through these fifty-two ideas, you’re going to start noticing some common denominators. In fact, some people may be tempted to discount some of them and say, “Eating a family dinner is pretty much the same thing as taking your daughter to coffee!” I’d be quick to reply, “Yes, and taking your kid hunting is really similar to going on a bike ride. They’re both outdoor activities that catalyze a climate of continuous conversations.” (Nice use of alliteration, huh?) But you’ll find these common denominators quite necessary—and extremely helpful—for two reasons:

1.   Each of these ideas presents unique characteristics and advice. In both the “Two-Player Mode” and the “Netflix-Binge Bonding” chapters, you’ll notice each setting involves parents actually using technology to connect with their kids. Similarly, you may notice several chapters helping you use questions to engage kids in conversation (“Fingertip Questions,” “The My Big Fat Greek Wedding Method,” et al.). Each of these chapters will provide new tools you can use for these specific situations. Besides…

2.   Your kids’ tastes are going to vary. One kid may really respond to late-night splurges but may never be interested in stopping for frozen yogurt on the way home from school. Another may be open to no tech at the table but would freak out at the mere suggestion of a media fast, especially regimented No-Tech Tuesdays. If your kids are like mine, they’ll be unique in taste and temperament. The more ideas you have in your arsenal, the better.

So enjoy these ideas, most of which I’ve drawn not only from years of research, but also from my years out on the front lines as an imperfect parent who wanted to connect with his kids. These are many ideas that worked for my wife and me. I hope some of them will be a help for you as well.

The Coviewing Connection

Way back in 2004, I read about a California mom who learned the hard way that she didn’t know as much about her kid as she thought she did.

Roberta “Bobbi” MacKinnon died from injuries after being flung from a playground merry-go-round propelled by a rope tied to the back of a vehicle. Bobbi and her friends had watched the MTV show Jackass and decided to try to copy their merry-go-round stunt. The result was fatal.

I read about the story in my local newspaper. Joan MacKinnon, Bobbi’s mother, said, “I had no idea that she watched the show. Maybe I would have made her stop and think that this is dangerous fun.”

I clearly remember my reaction reading Bobbi’s mother’s words that day. I swallowed hard and thought, That could be me! I don’t know every show my kids watch.

In the silence of the moment, I heard the TV on in the other room. I thought, Oh great! My kids are watching something right now, and I don’t even know what it is!

I popped up from my chair and ran into the other room. They were watching the cartoon SpongeBob SquarePants.

As I stood there in the doorway, I recalled a study I had just read in the journal Pediatrics, revealing the importance of parental guidelines with entertainment media. One of the techniques the authors suggested was “coviewing”—simply sitting down and watching entertainment media with your children so you can use it as an opportunity to talk about important family values.

So I sat down and watched SpongeBob with my kids (and found it quite hilarious…especially that Patrick!).

In a world where we are constantly at battle with kids and their screens, coviewing can be a really fun practice where you join them enjoying screen time. After all, we’re talking about a lot of screen time per day.

The screen today’s teenagers stare at more than any other is that small one they carry around with them in their pocket.

In fact, according to the Common Sense Media report I cited at the beginning of this book, teens spend two hours, forty-two minutes per day on their smartphones alone, then one hour, thirty-seven minutes on a computer, and another one hour, thirty-one minutes watching TV. That’s just the “average kid.” So your own kids may spend more or less time on these devices. And you can be sure that if your daughter doesn’t watch ninety-one minutes of TV per day, she has a friend at school who is more than making up for it in her home.

The point I’m making is this: use some of this screen time as a point of connection.

No, coviewing is not the most social activity you can do as a parent, but it accomplishes two tasks:

1.   It gives you a peek into their world of entertainment media. What shows do your kids watch? What online videos do they frequent? What is the content of all this entertainment? What lessons are they walking away with after watching it? Many parents have no idea what kind of entertainment their kids are consuming on their screens. Do you?

2.   It provides you with a springboard for conversations about what you just watched. When a major character makes a decision, simply ask your kids a question when the show is over. “Was he right?” Sometimes that simple three-word question can spark a debate between siblings where all you need to do is sit back and eat popcorn while they do all the talking. Other times it may necessitate asking more questions to provoke further discussion. Don’t feel the need to discuss everything you watch. This will quickly grow tiresome. But don’t hesitate to jump on occasional opportunities.

Coviewing opens up a host of possibilities for conversation.

No, I’m not endorsing watching just anything with your kids. If you begin watching something with your kids and it is completely against your family values, then it’s your job as a parent to say, “Sorry, kids, we aren’t going to watch this.” Or, better yet, ask them, “Kids, do you think we should watch this? Why not?”

Avoid overreaction. If you freak out every time you sit down to watch something with your kids, they’re going to hide from you and only watch TV at their friends’ houses. Make these coviewing connections a pleasant experience. Discover fun shows that you all enjoy watching together.

By the way, coviewing can be done on any size screen, not just on the fifty-five-incher in your living room (more on that later).

So look for those opportunities to simply enjoy some entertainment together. This practice can provide fun bonding times and sometimes a good springboard for conversation.

↑ Back to top

↑