Chapter 4 of 16

Change 1: Tip the Scales

Change 1: Tip the Scales

CHANGE 1

TIP THE SCALES

“My seventeen-year-old daughter won’t even talk with me.”

The middle-aged mom had wandered into my Get Your Teenager Talking workshop looking for answers. She dabbed at her eyes with a tissue, being careful not to smear her mascara. “I don’t know what to do.”

“Tell me about your conversations,” I asked.

After a little digging, I listened as she recalled her last few conversations with her daughter. I use the word conversation loosely. More like interrogation.

•  “Did you finish your homework?”

•  “Did you clean your bathroom?”

•  “What time did you get home last night?”

•  “Were you with that boy Chris? I knew I shouldn’t have let you hang out with that boy!”

As she unveiled what dialogue looked like in her home, the answer quickly became clear. Her daughter didn’t want to talk with her mom because in her mind, her mom was acting like a parole officer searching for malfeasance.

Think about it. Would you want to answer this mom’s questions? Probably not. You’d be scared your answers would get you in trouble.

That’s why most of the dialogue in this home would be more accurately described as monologue. Mom talked. Daughter didn’t.

As this woman shared her story, I immediately recognized her dilemma because I had made the same mistake with my oldest. My focus on boundaries had hindered bonding.

BONDING AND BOUNDARIES

At times these two important parenting practices seem almost at odds with each other.

•  Bonding is playing with your kid, going out for french fries, getting slaughtered by your son in the newest Madden game, laughing and talking together on a comfy couch in the corner of your daughter’s favorite coffeehouse.

•  Boundaries is when we tell our kids it’s time for bed, charge their phones on the kitchen counter while they’re asleep, or tell them, “No, sorry, you can’t stay out that late on Friday…especially with that boy Chris!”

Both are essential, and most parents tend to gravitate toward one or the other.

Ask yourself, Which do I lean toward? Which would my kids say I lean toward?

Now ask yourself another question: Which of these two parenting practices do I think most parents look back at later and wish they had done more?

Since you read the opening chapter to this book, you probably can guess the answer. In fact, the number one parenting practice moms and dads shared with me where they experienced the most regret was in the area of bonding.

“I wish I would have spent more time with my kids.”

It’s the number one area where parents wish they could have a do-over. They wish they had connected with their kids more and just “hung out.” In contrast, only a small handful of parents (less than 2 percent polled) said they wished they had applied more boundaries.

Let that sink in for a moment. Most parents enter into this parenting thing favoring either bonding or boundaries. Rarely is someone perfectly balanced. And after most parents finish raising their kids, the vast majority of them wish they would have tipped the scales toward bonding.

I know I wish I would have.

Don’t get me wrong. I’m not in any way trying to convince you to let your kids do whatever they want. Not even close. Reread what I’ve written in the previous pages if you must. Both bonding and boundaries are equally important. What I’m trying to communicate is simply this: Don’t skimp on bonding! Most parents look back and feel like they missed out on opportunities to bond and connect with their kids.

As I look back at how I parented my oldest, I definitely put too much weight on boundaries. When I walked into the room, I almost felt it my duty to be a drill sergeant, barking orders.

“Alec, shoes off the couch!”

“Put your glass on a coaster!”

Then I’d use the opportunity to question him, checking up on him.

“Did you finish your homework? Room clean? Trash taken out?”

As Alec grew into his teen years, I noticed something. When I’d walk in the room, he’d get nervous. He’d immediately start thinking, What am I doing wrong? I’m always doing something wrong.

Why did he think this?

Because that had become my job. To correct my kids.

My motives were pure. I wanted to teach my kids discipline and responsibility. Sadly, I believe my laser focus on boundaries hurt our relationship.

If our kids see us as drill sergeants, bonding will be hindered. Who wants to hang out with the parent who is making their life miserable?

Take this a step further. Who are they going to go to when they mess up or are facing a moral dilemma? Surely they won’t go to the person who seems ready to pounce on them every time they do wrong.

If I share with Dad, I know he’ll freak out!

If I ask Mom about this, she won’t help me—she’ll just bust me!

Here’s where the parenting strategy becomes a little counterintuitive. We think strict boundaries will help teach our kids values. But if we put too much weight on boundaries and neglect bonding, then our kids won’t feel safe to open up to us and we’ll miss key opportunities to walk through life with them and teach them discernment. In other words, when Mom or Dad doesn’t have a relationship with their kids, their kids tend to glean values and behaviors from other sources.

The parent who bonds with their kids has more opportunities to dialogue about real life. The closer the bond, the more they’ll absorb.

Bonding opens the doorway to applying boundaries.

So do parents still need to provide boundaries?

Absolutely. Just not like a tyrant. Parents don’t need to jump into inspection mode every time they see their kids.

So what does this actually look like day to day? How can we tip the scales toward bonding?

CONNECTION VENUES

The best way to tip the scales is by seeking out settings I like to call connection venues. This has become increasingly difficult in a world where people connect with screens more than they connect with human beings. And I’m not just talking about kids. The overwhelming majority of American moms and dads actually spend more time staring at a screen than talking with their spouse or kids. And now that most of us have access to mobile devices, our screen time is increasing, and good ol’-fashioned face-to-face time is decreasing.

What’s the result?

Sadly, it’s exactly what I shared at the beginning of this book. A huge number of parents are looking back in hindsight and wishing they had devoted more time to simply hanging out with their kids. “I would have worked less and played with them more!”

Have you ever spent time with someone lying on his or her deathbed? Those final moments often bring clarity to what we truly hold dear. Rarely do you see someone asking for their laptop so they can check their work e-mail. The typical request is to be surrounded by family and friends. Sometimes lifelong grudges are forgiven and forgotten in those final moments.

I’ve never heard someone say, “I wish I would have spent more time at the office!”

I’ve never heard someone say, “I wish I would have streamed more Netflix!”

People value connection with the people they care about. And we don’t need to wait until our deathbed to initiate this kind of connection. We should be searching for any opportunity to connect while our kids are still young and in the home.

Think about the last time you engaged in a meaningful conversation with your kids. Where were you? What initiated that conversation? Is that something you can duplicate and try again?

Note: I didn’t ask when you last “exchanged words with your kids.” I want you to think about the last time you sat down and truly talked, laughed together, or cried together. What was it about this venue that kindled that kind of conversation?

When I ask parents where this kind of meaningful dialogue occurs in their home, the setting I hear more than any other is the family dinner. In fact, in my survey of what parents would do over, I kept hearing moms and dads say, “More family dinners.”

The family dinner is one of those staple connection points for families. Most people use their hands to eat, so that typically means setting the phone or tablet aside…for a few minutes, at least.

Our family even declared family dinners tech free. We called it “No Tech at the Table.” Funny…more conversation happened at our family dinners than in almost any other setting. Think about that for a second. In this particular situation, our boundary of “No Tech at the Table” opened the doorway to bonding moments. As you can see, boundaries can help create an atmosphere where bonding takes place.

We need to be on the lookout for places where meaningful communication occurs in our homes and be proactive to seek out these venues.

Where are these connection venues in your home?

In a world so full of distractions, parents are beginning to take notice of these venues where their kids almost naturally open up. Another one of these settings is bedtime. An empty-nester parent shared with me:

I wish I had cherished bedtime more than I did. I used to pray with my kids and tuck them in when they were young, but the routine eventually faded. However, every once in a while when I’d take the time to tuck them in, it usually resulted in a pleasant conversation. Something about them being tucked neatly in their bedsheets. It’s like the sleepiness made them chattier than normal.

It’s interesting to observe which of these connection venues work with your own kids. Different young people will respond to different venues. I became so fascinated by these kinds of settings I wrote an entire book on the subject, 52 Ways to Connect with Your Smartphone Obsessed Kid, providing dozens of ideas for connecting with today’s kids who typically won’t pry their eyes from their mobile devices.

Ask yourself: Where do my kids tend to open up more and engage in meaningful conversation? How can I create more of these opportunities in our typical weekly schedule?

I’ll be honest with you. Bonding takes time. That’s why you shouldn’t overthink it. If you see an opportunity…

JUST SAY YES

Just say yes to any opportunity to bond, no matter how inconvenient. I call this the “yes factor.” I tried this with my younger two kids, and the results were revolutionary.

No joke—this morning, as I write this—my eighteen-year-old daughter, Ashley, came up to me and asked, “Dad, do you want to go on a bike ride?”

Allow me to put this into perspective. This is an eighteen-year-old asking her parent to do something together. This isn’t a four-year-old. When my kids were four, they asked me to do something with them every ten minutes.

“Daddy, will you play Barbies with me?”

“Daddy, will you watch Aladdin with me?”

“Daddy, will you play Velociraptor with me?”

When our kids become teenagers, everything changes. Many parents can count on one hand how many times their teen asked them to hang out in any given month…or year.

Ashley is pretty social, and we hang out quite a bit. So when she asked me to ride bikes this morning, I hesitated. Not because I didn’t want to ride bikes and not because I didn’t want to hang out with Ashley, but probably for the same reason many of you would have hesitated. My schedule is jam-packed right now! And when life’s to-do list is stacked to the ceiling, “hanging out” seems to get shoved to the back burner.

I easily thought of twenty plausible reasons why I should say no: I’ve been gone the last three weekends in a row speaking, I have two book deadlines in the next forty-five days, I have two articles due in the next four days, I’ve got a stack of administrative tasks in my inbox, and work aside, my backyard is a mess, I promised my wife I’d help her shop for a present for my other daughter, Alyssa, today…the list goes on. My guess is you have a list that rivals mine.

Every ounce of wisdom in my body was saying, “Jonathan, it’s completely reasonable for you to say no. She’ll understand.”

So I gave her my answer.

“Yes. I’d love to.”

So we ventured on a one-hour bike ride on a trail that parallels the American River not twelve minutes from my house. And it was one of the most rewarding times I’ve had with Ashley in months.

Maybe it’s because I actually listened to my own advice from my previous book about connecting with the smartphone generation. One of the ways to connect with today’s overconnected kids is seeking out settings where kids naturally break free from their devices to enjoy their immediate surroundings. Bike rides are a no-brainer. It’s hard to text while riding a bike.

That’s probably why Ashley and I literally talked for an hour without a single interruption (well…besides the squirrel I almost hit as it darted across the bike path). We talked about movies, music, college, friendships, conflict, and personality types. We even talked about parenting. It was probably one of the deeper talks we’ve had in a while.

All because I simply said yes.

I didn’t always say yes.

Sadly, this experience with Ashley only happened because I learned the hard way that saying no is a mistake. My parenting repertoire is filled with stories of feeling too busy, too overwhelmed, burning the candle at both ends; you probably know the feeling. It’s these times I answer with the most logical response when a person doesn’t have any time. Like the time my son Alec asked me if I wanted to play video games with him. I can remember the moment like it was yesterday.

He was in his late teens, working almost every day after school, and had an internship at church. It was an extremely busy time in his life. My schedule was very comparable. I worked full-time writing and speaking, was attending graduate school, volunteered at the church, was raising three kids—not a lot of free time.

Alec poked his head into my office one Friday and simply asked, “Dad, do you wanna play Xbox?”

I was finishing some last-minute prep for a parenting workshop I was teaching that weekend. The next morning I was going to leave the house at 3:30 a.m. on the first flight out. With time in airports, two planes, and a rental car, I’d travel over ten hours across the country (the problem with living in California and frequently speaking on the East Coast) then teach a two-hour workshop Saturday night, preach the morning services at a church Sunday morning, then teach a parenting workshop that afternoon. I had about seven items to finish on my to-do list, and playing video games just didn’t seem wise, if even possible.

I can’t remember my exact words, but they were something like, “Sorry, Alec, but I’ve got to finish my workshop helping other moms and dads be good parents.”

Yes, the word irony comes to mind.

He wasn’t brokenhearted. He was actually very kind about it. I can still see the expression on his face. “That’s okay, Dad. I understand. I know you’ll do a good job.”

Fast-forward two days later when in the middle of my parenting workshop I gave the parents a “self-quiz” that helped them look introspectively at how well they knew their kids. As they sat in their seats, pens and pencils busily scratching out answers, I read through the questions myself while standing onstage waiting. As a joke, I played the famous ’70s folk song “Cat’s in the Cradle,” in which a dad expresses his parenting regrets. I jested that they shouldn’t feel guilty if they did poorly on the quiz.

That’s when it happened.

I began reading my own quiz questions and my eyes rested on question number 13: “When is the last time you played with your kid?”

The lyrics to “Cat’s in the Cradle” resounded in my ears: a kid asking his dad to throw a ball and the dad saying, “Not today.”

I started full-on weeping.

I turned my back to the audience in hopes they wouldn’t notice. I had forty-five seconds to pull it together. But first things first. I whipped my phone out of my pocket and texted my son:

ALEC, I’M A TURD! YOU ASKED ME TO PLAY XBOX WITH YOU AND I LET MY WORK INTERFERE. I’LL TOTALLY PLAY XBOX WITH YOU WHEN I GET HOME TOMORROW! YOU GOT TIME?

Not ten seconds later I got a text back: SURE. WE’LL BLOW AWAY ZOMBIES!

The next day I got up bright and early and flew home (another ten-hour journey with a layover), and when my son walked in the door I was sitting on the couch with the controller in my hand. “You ready to show me how to play this thing?”

And we played for almost two hours until he finally had to go to work.

Let me be very clear. Say yes to any opportunity to connect with your teenager.

SINGLE-PARENT/SPLIT HOMES

I have countless friends who are either raising their kids by themselves or shipping kids back and forth to a different parent because of a divorce or separation. These friends always ask me, “Jonathan, how does this work in a split home?”

I have good news for these parents. Everything I say about bonding in this book is 100 percent applicable to kids in split homes. Bonding is potent. The connection between parent and child is powerful. And single parents will want to strive to make these connections just like any other parent. So the first four vital changes we walk through in this book apply to all parents regardless of their family’s makeup.

The difficult part for split homes is boundaries. One of the chief complaints I hear from moms or dads who have partial custody is that they are teaching one set of values, and then the other half of the week the kids are learning a completely different set of values. Boundaries in each home can differ drastically.

But here’s what I think you’ll find intriguing. Much of what I talk about in the final three chapters in this book has to do with “walking with” our kids on this journey and teaching them as we go. The boundaries are intrinsically linked with bonding. So even in those chapters parents raising their kids in split homes will find hope in the time they spend with their kids. Your bonding efforts will have more impact than you know.

In my two decades of youth ministry, I spent bonding time with a lot of young people, sometimes only an hour or two per kid per week. It was amazing to see what kind of impact God was able to make even in these short snippets of time. I’m not giving you an excuse to ignore your kids and only give them an hour or two. I say this simply to encourage you not to underestimate the impact of your time connecting with your kids.

So single moms or dads, divorced parents, grandparents…Leave It to Beaver families—it doesn’t matter. Make every effort to seek out these connection venues.

“I DON’T HAVE TIME”

I can hear it now. “But Jonathan, I can’t just drop everything! I work. I have a life.” Or the inevitable…“I don’t have time.”

The lawyer in me is coming out.

Exhibit A: Do you know how much time the average “adult” spends each day soaking in entertainment media and technology?

Add it up on your fingers really quick. Add up all your TV time, computer time, Facebook, smartphone, newspapers and magazines if you actually still read them….

A big part of my job is studying youth culture and technology. So I look at these reports all the time. And I’ve seen reports that would blow your mind. But let me just share with you a very conservative report when it comes to how many hours adults spend with entertainment media and technology. It’s the most recent report from Nielsen, and it reveals that the average adult devotes an average of nine hours and fifty-one minutes per day to entertainment media and technology.1

The biggest chunk of time is spent on TV. The average adult spends four hours and fifty-nine minutes daily watching TV, both live and DVR/time-shifted TV.

Now I know many of you might be saying, “I don’t watch five hours of TV per day!” Don’t worry; if you watch very little TV, then someone on your street, across town, or across the country is watching more than enough TV to make up for you. The average is four hours and fifty-nine minutes. The statistics are even more fascinating when you break them down by age, because teens (ages 12 to 17) average less than three hours a day of TV, while moms and dads (ages 35 to 49) average about four and a half. Then there’s Grandpa (age 65 and up)! He watches over seven hours a day! That’s a lot of NCIS!

My point? And I’ll speak directly, as a fellow parent who has struggled with this. Don’t tell me you don’t have time.

Some of us let our jobs get in the way. We work long hours, and when we’re home, we might be physically present, but we’re still technically at work on our phone and our laptop. I’ve heard parents share this struggle for years. “Gotta earn that extra paycheck to pay for football camp and gymnastics.”

Guess what your kids need more than football camp and gymnastics?

They need you!

Take it from this single mom I surveyed while researching this book:

I wish I could do over the amount of time I spent with my kids, especially as teens. As a single mom, I worked two jobs that kept me very busy during their teen years. One memory in particular was on a Sunday while I was working, my son went to our church and gave his life to Christ. He called me to tell me this, and that he had something else he needed to tell me when I got home. However, the moment passed, and he never discussed it until years later.

Consider this. I have never—and I mean ever—met an empty nester who told me, “I spent more than enough time with my kids!”

In fact, the typical 20/20 look-back is: “I wish I would have spent a little more time with Michael.” “I could have paid more attention to Taylor.”

Say yes to any opportunity to connect with your kid.

Does this mean we need to drop everything every time our toddler wants us to play Legos? No. If we said yes to toddlers every time, we’d never get anything done. But by the time your kids are tweens or teens, I’d go out on a limb and say if they want to hang out with you, “Say yes every time.” I could even say it another way: “Say yes a minimum of once a day to any opportunity to hang out with your kid.” The fact is, 99 percent of teenagers won’t ask to hang out more than once a week, much less once a day. So if they do, slide everything aside to make hangout time happen.

I probably didn’t realize this until my oldest was already out of the house and I was watching time slip away with my two high school daughters. It was then that I made a pledge to myself: “I don’t care how big the pile is on my desk—I’m saying yes to any opportunity to hang out.”

These opportunities came in bizarre forms. They weren’t always fun and they weren’t always things I wanted to do. Sometimes it was my daughter Alyssa coming in and sighing, “Dad, want to go to the DMV with me? I have to renew my license.”

“Woo-hoo! The DMV!” (Does the movie Zootopia come to mind?)

She wasn’t even that excited to hang out with me; she just didn’t want to go to the stinking DMV by herself.

I snagged the opportunity. In fact, I even asked, “Do you wanna grab a Jamba on the way home?” and extended our time together.

You have time. Make time. Even if it turns out to be a drag.

That’s the thing about quality time. It takes quantity time. We can’t choose quality-time moments. They just happen. It takes painfully boring DMV trips, family dinners that sometimes seem like a waste of time and effort, drives to school together, time spent tucking our kid into bed every night—it takes connecting time and time again to achieve those quality-time moments.

If your kids are going through adolescence, then these moments of connection are even more vital. Not just because our interactions with them are fewer and farther between, but because research actually reveals that quantity time pays off with adolescents more than with any other age.

I’m referring to a fascinating new study out of the Journal of Marriage and Family that argues mere quantity time is not enough. Yes, you read that correctly. It doesn’t pay off just to clock in hours hanging out with our kids. Don’t be confused. Hear me out.

This study compared the time parents spent with kids of different ages and revealed a surprising difference between young kids and adolescents. The amount of time parents spend with their kids between the ages of three and eleven has virtually no correlation to how children turn out. What’s more, the study found “one key instance when parent time can be particularly harmful to children. That’s when parents, mothers in particular, are stressed, sleep-deprived, guilty and anxious.”2

Hold the phone! Does this mean we shouldn’t “hang” with our kids?

Keep reading.

Notice this finding related to kids between ages three and eleven. If we keep reading the report, the authors note one key instance when quantity time does matter.

Adolescence.

And I quote:

The more time a teen spends engaged with their mother, the fewer instances of delinquent behavior. And the more time teens spend with both their parents together in family time, such as during meals, the less likely they are to abuse drugs and alcohol and engage in other risky or illegal behavior. They also achieve higher math scores.3

This new report isn’t alone in these findings. Columbia University has been noting the link between “quantity time” and raising healthy teens for years in its Family Dinners reports.4 These discoveries are particularly intriguing considering this is the time when many stay-at-home moms feel unneeded and consider jumping back into the workforce.

So what can we take away from this new report? After all, it seems to contradict conventional wisdom that the more time moms and dads spend with young kids, the better.

I think this report brings to light several realities I’ve witnessed firsthand:

1.  Mere proximity doesn’t produce quality time. If we bring our kids to the grocery store with us, ignoring them the entire time, talking on our phones, occasionally barking at them, “Put that down!”…we aren’t clocking healthy bonding time. Bonding necessitates dialogue. So if you’re going to drag your kids on errands with you, make it fun. Interact with them. Ask them their favorite meal and have them help you shop for it. Do more listening than talking. Make them feel noticed and heard. (We’ll explore how to do all this later in the book.)

2.  Adolescents have different needs than younger kids. Just when our teens—and even tweens—begin pushing us away, they need us the most. No, that doesn’t mean we need to smother them or put them on a leash. It simply means parents need to be especially proactive about looking for opportunities to bond with their teens. Healthy parenting requires healthy investments of both bonding and boundaries. Are you investing in both? Which bank is getting more deposits this month?

3.  Don’t use quality time as an excuse to avoid quantity time. If your kids are like mine, you’ll experience just one or two quality-time moments for every dozen times you hang out with your kids. Quality time usually necessitates quantity time. Parents need to clock quantity hours having fun with their kids, talking, laughing…listening! You never know when quality-time moments will materialize.

Spending time with our kids creates an interesting dynamic. On one hand, we really need to be proactive about doing it, because our tendency as humans is to get caught up in our own world. On the other hand, spending time with our kids should never be just a check mark in a box. I clocked in three hours today. In fact, our time investment should be without expectation of what that time will look like, not just seeking the “quality” but really showing our kids that they are worthy of our time. Period.

What can you do this week to truly connect with your child?

THE BOUNDARY FAST

Some of you might be reading this chapter and thinking, I’m that guy he described at the beginning of the chapter. I’m the drill sergeant. My dialogue with my kids typically involves checking up on them or disciplining them.

What can we do to tip the scales if the scales are already tilted completely the opposite way?

All parents need to be proactive about practicing bonding. But if your scales are already weighted completely toward boundaries, you’re going to need to work extra hard to reverse this trend. You may even need to go on a boundary fast. This means walking in a room and completely stifling the urge to ask your kids if they’ve finished their homework and chores…and just playing with them instead. Try it.

Again, I’m not saying that boundaries aren’t good. I’m talking to the person who is so focused on boundaries, they rarely bond with their kids. If that’s you, then try going twenty-four hours without giving any instruction to your kids at all. If the damage is really bad, you may need to go an entire week. For that week, don’t allow yourself to discipline, correct, or advise in any way. Instead, look for opportunities to bond.

Maybe you aren’t a tyrant and you don’t need a boundary fast. Maybe you are just like the majority of parents who feel like bonding is important, and you want to make sure you maximize these opportunities while you can. So look for these moments. Seek out settings where connection happens. Say yes to every opportunity to connect; and if your kids never ask you to connect, that’s all the more reason to be seeking out communication settings. Take the initiative. Give your children a taste of your full attention.

What are some of the ways we can tip the scales toward bonding?

LIVING IT OUT THIS WEEK

QUESTIONS TO DISCUSS WITH YOUR SPOUSE AND/OR OTHER PARENTS

1.   When parents look back in hindsight, why do you think far more of them regret missing opportunities to bond rather than placing too few boundaries?

2.   Bonding or boundaries: Which way is your scale tipped? What does that look like in your home?

3.   Which way would your kids say your scale is tipped? Why?

4.   What are some connection venues that have worked with your kids?

5.   What is it about those settings that seems to kindle conversation? Can you duplicate those factors in other settings? How?

6.   What are some specific connection venues you think might be worth trying with your kids?

7.   Do you think a boundary fast might be an experiment worth trying in your home? What do you think will happen?

8.   What is one thing you read in this chapter that you would like to implement this week? When will you try it?

↑ Back to top

↑