4. Will You Accept Me?
4
Will You Accept Me?
I stumbled upon a welcome mat with the words, “All are welcome here.” The notion behind these words is that anyone standing at the threshold will find acceptance in this home. I wondered why this statement needed to be on a welcome mat. Isn’t the very essence of a welcome mat to welcome everyone into the place where it sits on the threshold?
This saying is an affirmation of a cultural value, one that has been instilled in Gen Z: acceptance. More specifically, it is acceptance of those who may have not been welcome in many places, who have been shut out or excluded. To say “all are welcome here” is a way to spit in the face of the patterns of societal and systemic rejection.
A WALK WITH GEN Z
Acceptance is a core generational value. Gen Z sees themselves as more open and accepting than previous generations. Pause and ask a Gen Zer what makes their generation different than previous ones. When I ask this question, the first response is often, “We are more open-minded and accepting.” If it’s not the first response, it’s in the top three, revealing how important acceptance is to Gen Z.
In a study around stigma, Gen Z was more accepting than previous generations of people who identify as LGBTQ+, those living with a substance disorder, and those with nonnormative sexual histories. Gen Z is more open and accepting of different people and different practices than previous generations. For example, Barna found Gen Z considers not recycling as morally worse than viewing pornography.
Acceptance is a pathway to secure relationships. Maybe we all have asked the same question to others in our lives: Will you accept me? This could be personal or professional, in tryouts for a sport, applying for school or a job, or in moments where we have made a mistake and hurt someone else. In the throes of adolescence, while we are figuring out who we are and where we belong, we have probably asked this question countless times. To feel accepted is a good thing. For others to feel accepted by us is a good thing. But what if acceptance looks different to different generations? What if our efforts to express acceptance only unknowingly perpetuate rejection?
I recently witnessed this dynamic between a Gen X supervisor and Gen Z employee. The supervisor thought acceptance was extended by listening to the ideas of the Gen Z employee. The Gen Z employee felt rejected because the Gen X supervisor did not communicate any intention to look into or execute any of the ideas, but simply told the Gen Zer to pick one and follow through with it. The Gen Zer felt punished for sharing ideas, and the Gen Xer thought encouragement through freedom had been extended. For the Gen Zer, acceptance meant the Gen Xer would like an idea so much, the supervisor would join in executing that idea. Weeks went by and frustration only built as the Gen Zer felt rejected and abandoned by the Gen X supervisor, and the Gen X supervisor felt the Gen Zer was not following through. Acceptance did not mean the same thing for both parties, and that miscommunication leaked into relational conflict.
Parlez-vous Gen Z? Do you ever feel like Gen Z is speaking a foreign language? Do you ever feel like you are talking with a Gen Zer, but the communication is jumbled, frustrating, or just plain confusing for both parties? Bruh, I hope you’re vibing with the bars I’m spitting, no cap. Some think Gen Z is extra, full of sus randoms who need to touch grass, but they are fire. We are the ones who need a vibe check FR to get why the Christian faith gives Gen Z the ick. This slang is probably already being replaced. But the barrier we may feel isn’t really about slang, but about more complex and nuanced use of language.
Language gets us in trouble when we think we are saying one thing, but unknowingly saying something else. We may be using the same words as our audience, thinking we are speaking in the same terms, and we still aren’t. Acceptance is one of those words that has different meanings to different cultures, generations, or even different individuals.
Gen Z and acceptance. From my experience, Gen Z values few things more than acceptance. Acceptance is tied to the other Gen Z questions discussed here around enoughness, safety, truth, trust, and the importance of valuing all people. Acceptance is a paramount value, core to human relationships, which means a misunderstanding of what it means to be accepted can unintentionally cause a rift.
This is where we begin to see the breakdown of communication when it comes to how we talk about God’s acceptance of us. Gen Z understands acceptance through a specific cultural lens. However they experience the church discussing or displaying acceptance is not currently meeting Gen Z where they are. Gen Z concludes that the Christian faith is exclusive and full of rejection, and that either God is the source of this, and thus is a bad God, or that God is accepting, and thus the Christian faith is a bad faith.
We have to be careful in promising acceptance in the spaces we design and lead. If we say, “You will be accepted here,” but we are not working within the definition of acceptance of our Gen Z audience, we can quickly and unknowingly break that promise. Then we will have proved ourselves to be hypocrites and untrustworthy. Can you see what is at stake here? If we do not lean in and understand the lens of our Gen Z audience, we can unintentionally fortify an obstacle between them and following Christ.
We are left wondering, What does acceptance mean to Gen Z? The value or idea of tolerance has become wrapped up into acceptance in recent history. While technically, acceptance and tolerance have different meanings, these terms are often used interchangeably. The Cambridge dictionary uses the word accept in its definition of tolerance: “willingness to accept behavior and beliefs that are different from your own, although you might not agree with or approve of them.” It is this last part of the definition that has been dropped in cultural use of the word tolerance. If forced to use the Cambridge definition, Gen Z will likely choose acceptance and reject tolerance.
Gen Z views themselves as more accepting of others than previous generations, especially of those who have been traditionally marginalized or rejected. Gen Z’s cultural context is full of opportunities to unknowingly or accidentally offend or reject others. They worry about unintentionally breaking their value of acceptance: If I accidentally reject someone, I don’t belong in the community of acceptance, and if I don’t belong in the community, I’ll be alone.
Let’s look at some ways acceptance is understood by Gen Z. They may not be totally foreign to our older generations, but let’s pay attention to the subtle nuances of the meaning of acceptance from a Gen Z lens.
Acceptance is belonging. Acceptance is not merely being tolerated, but welcomed. It is finding a place where people are excited to see you, embrace you, and miss you when you are absent. It is feeling like you are a part of something bigger than yourself. Part of the adventure of adolescence is not only identity formation (who I am), but also figuring out friendships (where I belong). This is the search for community. For many Gen Zers, belonging means feeling like they can relax and be their “authentic self.” They do not need to change how they speak or interact, hide parts of their personalities, or be a different version of who they are. (This dynamic is often referred to as code-switching.) Acceptance means being fully seen and fully known, and then fully welcomed and embraced.
To be accepted is to be recognized, to have one’s unique identity acknowledged in a positive way. To be accepted is to belong, and to belong is to be accepted. I get to recognize and acknowledge what makes my Gen Z friends special. I’m smiling right now just thinking about it! I bet many of us recognize admirable, beautiful, incredible qualities unique to each of our Gen Z friends. Tell them right now—and make it specific to who they are! Recognition is seeing, and seeing is creating belonging, and belonging is acceptance.
It is painful for me to hear from a young person, “I don’t belong here,” especially if I contributed to the negative experience of disconnection or rejection. They do not see themselves as a part of the community. This contributes to loneliness as Gen Z processes: If I am not accepted, I do not belong. If I do not belong, I do not have community. If I do not have community, I am alone.
Belonging and acceptance are intertwined with each other but are interpreted by the individual. I can do my best to extend acceptance and belonging, but ultimately the accomplishment of that goal is in the eye of the beholder.
Acceptance is agreement. In Gen Z’s lifetime, acceptance has been wrapped up with having the same opinions, beliefs, viewpoints, and principles. Disagreement can lead to feelings of not feeling seen or not being heard as expressions of not feeling accepted. Gen Z’s cultural context dictates that if you do not agree with what I am saying or doing, then you do not accept me. This makes disagreement risky. It places landmines throughout both casual and close relationships. What if I say something my friend disagrees with? What if I say something my classmates disagree with? What if I don’t agree with my friend? If acceptance is a core generational value, and acceptance is being in agreement with those around us, it makes Gen Z relationships vulnerable in conflict. It also limits social circles to either those who agree with each other or those who hide what they really think or feel, for risk of losing friendships.
I feel the risk of disagreeing with my Gen Z friends because of the convictions of my faith. I risk them rejecting me or feeling like I am rejecting them, all without a follow-up conversation or a relationship. They may feel rejected because they disagree with me. What if I instruct a Gen Zer not to cuss at a gathering? Will they feel rejected and never come back? The statement of compromise, “Let’s agree to disagree,” may still be used, but the underlying weight of it now says, “Clearly you don’t understand or accept me, and I reject your ideas, so let’s stop talking.” It is the end of a relationship, not a truce to an impassable clash of ideas.
If we pause and take a step back, we notice Gen Z has come of age during a time when we haven’t done disagreement paired with acceptance very well, especially in the public realm. We are being pushed to take sides, form tribes, and create an “us versus them” dynamic in political, theological, and social realms. In the media, we generally do not see examples of opposing views together in friendship. We don’t see a heated debate followed by a meal shared together. We don’t see arguments followed by expressions of mutual respect. How can we fault Gen Z for not understanding something that they have not seen modeled for them?
Acceptance means not asking you to change. Sometimes we can extend the question of acceptance by adding four words at the end: Will you accept me for who I am? This is a loaded and heavy question, and it races around all the time. In some cases, it is a statement more than a question: You will accept me for who I am.
It is the last part that is the kicker: for who I am. Why do the last four words add weight to the question? They can imply that my personality, my character, my appearance, my ethics, or anything about me is fixed, unmovable, and unchangeable. This is who I am, rather than, This is who I am in this part of my journey of growth.
Discussions around sexuality generally include an expectation of not being asked to change. The term sexual identity binds sexuality to core identity: “This is who I am.” According to Dr. Carl Trueman, inner spaces define identity, and if the inner space is primarily sexual, then limits on sex are viewed as limits on who we are. Denying that core identity or asking for it to change (or be hidden as a form of change) breaks with Gen Z’s value of acceptance. It is understood as a violation of identity, and that is unacceptable to Gen Z. Accepting the gender fluidity and sexual identity landscape was not a shift Gen Z had to make; it always was.
Gen Z has internalized they are “never to be affected by any outside force that tries to shift my identity,” especially if it doesn’t feel like who I am. “I’m just a sarcastic person. This is how I am. It’s how I show love, so you just have to deal with it.” These words, stated in a matter-of-fact tone, were shared by an upperclassman as she faced our small-group Bible study. This young woman’s statement did not create a place of acceptance but demanded permission to be mean without apology. Acceptance “for who I am” has created a system where I should never be asked to change, adjust, or be different. Acceptance means you have to deal with me the way I am. As you can imagine, this also becomes a barrier to deep friendships and relationships.
Somehow asking anyone to adjust, grow, change, or develop became an opposing force to acceptance. Now a generation has grown up seeing any request to adjust, grow, change, or develop as a point of rejection. It is as if they are saying, “You want me to be different than who I am, so you don’t accept me for who I am.” The words make sense, kind of, but it is incomplete logic. I accept you for who you are, and I support you in your journey to become who you are meant to be. That means growth and change. It does not mean I reject you; it does not mean I don’t accept you. We are all on a lifelong journey of growth and change. To remain exactly the same our whole lives, even Gen Z would argue, is a problem.
I am a competitive, passionate, and argumentative person. Working in acutely intense environments in my twenties and into my thirties, such as running a program at summer camp or a fundraising event, I had been known to make coworkers cry with my gruff interactions, barking instructions, and arguing over the best way to do something. These characteristics were more pronounced in my youth. My hope is now, over time, growing in the Holy Spirit and fruits of the Spirit, growing in my own maturity, and submitting in discipleship, that these characteristics are less pronounced and less explosive, or at least more wisely stewarded.
I wanted to change, to take on patience, compassion, and humility. I yield to others more often, desire cooperation over competition, and take time to submit my passions to the Lord. Yes, on my worst days or when I am tired or hungry (or hangry), or when I am pushed to the edge, I am competitive and argumentative, fueled with unhinged passion, and I become like a firehose with my own agenda. But this is not who I am, it’s not who I want to be, and honestly, it happens less often than before. I do not stand up and say, “This is who I am so you better deal with it, or else you are rejecting me.” Growing and developing means changing. Acceptance can celebrate that growth and change.
Those who have been my friends all this time do not accept me more or less now than they did before. They did not ask me to stay stagnant. They accepted me in friendship, and also accepted, and even celebrated, as I have grown into a different person.
Gen Z and authenticity without a compass. Generation Z values authenticity, which is meant to go hand-in-hand with acceptance: Accept me for who I am, my authentic self. Because of this, it is important to understand what authenticity means to the next generation. To be authentic is to live life without hiding any parts of your personality or character. You are consistent in who you are. Authenticity is being the same person in all settings, public and private. In some ways, the way Gen Z uses the word authentic is similar to the way many older generations use the word integrity.
One unhealthy expression of authenticity is using it as an excuse to lack self-control. It is allowing emotions or circumstances to control our actions and interactions, rather than allowing them to exist, but also practicing self-control. This goes back to the young woman earlier who did not want to change her sarcastic interactions because “this is how I am.”
Here is the rub. What if I am authentic, and you do not accept me? Do I become inauthentic to be accepted or do I remain authentic and risk rejection? Anyone who has lived through adolescence has experienced this inner tug-of-war. For today’s young people, authenticity and acceptance are top generational values, but they are feeling tension when they have conflict with each other. Without a compass (like the Bible) to point in the right direction, or an anchor to their value system, Gen Z has been left with conflicting values, and no guide in how to order them. How are they supposed to figure out what to do? I can imagine the anxiety of not knowing what to do in those moments when core values are in direct opposition to each other. It would be easy to slide into a lonely place, afraid of rejection or unwilling to be honest and genuine.
Christians are exclusive. Gen Z wants to be authentic, and in their authenticity, be agreed with and not asked to change. I think you can begin to see where some of the disconnect with the church exists. This is where it gets complicated. If churches and ministries are sharing about a God who accepts all who come to him, and Gen Z is seeing a God who rejects and excludes, where is the disconnect? There is a breakdown in how these values are expressed and a disconnect in what acceptance means. The idea that God (and thus, the Christian faith) is exclusive and rejects people breaks a paramount value of this generational culture.
As previously discussed, we understand Gen Z has observed the Christian faith as exclusive, oppressive, and harmful through media and social media. This has no semblance of acceptance. We are not beginning a faith conversation with Gen Z from a neutral place; we, the church, have already been known to break their value of acceptance, and they aren’t wrong, especially with their lens of what acceptance means. (Remember, we begin working within the lens of our Gen Z audience, not assuming they are working within ours.) This is not limited to how they feel about a building or an institution, but it extends to how they feel about followers of Christ like you and me. When I acknowledge I am a Christian, a Follower of Jesus, a believer, or any other descriptor, the Gen Zer before me often defaults to categorizing me as exclusive.
How does this impact evangelism and discipleship?
THE SHORT ANSWER: WILL YOU ACCEPT ME?
We are going to reword this question for our conversation around evangelism and discipleship: Does God accept me? God accepts all who believe in and receive Jesus, making them his own children (John 1:12). We can approach God, on his throne of grace, with confidence (Hebrews 4:16), because we are confident he will accept us and provide mercy and grace to us as his disciples. Anyone who believes in Jesus and confesses he is Lord of their lives will be accepted by God (Romans 10:9-11). God accepts those who want to offer their lives to him. We do not need to code-switch or hide parts of ourselves from God. He fully sees us. He fully knows us. He fully loves us. And that means when we ask him to take our lives, to be our hope and saving grace, he fully accepts us.
As we talk about God’s acceptance with our Gen Z audience, we have to work with their generational ideas around acceptance: Does God agree with me? and Will God ask me to change? While acceptance may mean one thing to Gen Z, it is different in God’s economy, and that must be explained. Jesus does not condemn the woman caught in adultery, and he also asks her to leave her life of sin (John 8:9-11). I would argue in their entire interaction we see God the Son accept her and then ask her to change. The demoniac is outcast by his people, living in a cemetery, and Jesus comes toward him and changes him (Mark 5:3-15). I would argue again that Jesus accepted this man and then changed him. Jesus invites himself to the home of Zacchaeus, and he changes his heart (Luke 19:5-8). Again, God the Son accepts Zaccheaus, and he changes him. Change is part of the promise: anyone in Christ becomes a new creation, “the old has gone, the new has come!” (2 Corinthians 5:17). The changes mentioned here in Scripture are instantaneous changes, but there is also slower, long-term change. People like Moses and Peter changed slowly over time.
God both accepts us for who we are today and changes us at the same time. Does God accept me more now, a disciple of thirty years, than he did thirty years ago? No! We do not understand the fullness of God’s acceptance in each moment of our lives, because it does not fit our picture of acceptance. It is beyond our comprehension.
But once we understand what it means to be accepted, and we understand our identity in Christ, as not only accepted in forgiveness, but made children of God, we become a good neighbor to others. As disciples, we become the hands and feet of that acceptance by God to give others a taste of God’s love. As disciples of Christ, we each become a good Neighbor.
HI NEIGHBOR!
The disciple who is a Neighbor understands interconnectedness with the community and with all those who bear the image of God. The disciple who is a Neighbor understands the responsibility that comes with being a part of a community. Part of that responsibility is extending acceptance and creating belonging. A Neighbor is a neighbor not just to those who live close by, or those they like, or those who share the same faith. The outcast, downcast, marginalized, and rejected are also seen as neighbors by the Neighbor. God models acceptance to us, and we are to follow his example as we take on the feature of Neighbor as disciples of Christ. Being a Neighbor taps into Gen Z’s generational values, giving them a place to express their value of acceptance in a way that glorifies God. We get to affirm the Gen Z value of acceptance and celebrate this value the Lord has built into a generation. And we get to offer a new way to understand and express that acceptance through being a disciple who is a Neighbor to others.
A disciple is to be a Neighbor to all people, even people they see as enemies: “You have heard that it was said, ‘Love your neighbor and hate your enemy.’ But I tell you, love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you” (Matthew 5:43-44). Accepting our neighbors does not mean we have to agree with them. It means seeing them through the eyes of the Lord. Accepting others is seeing them as created in God’s image, as ones God desires to redeem and restore, as ones with purpose. Many times, it is setting aside what I think is comfortable to help my Neighbor feel belonging.
Being a Neighbor is loving others, which is a form of acceptance. Love facilitates and cultivates belonging. Love is more powerful than acceptance. It makes a way for acceptance. Love does not require agreement, and love can make us want to change for the better. Jesus instructs us to love our neighbors in the same way we love ourselves (Matthew 5:43-44; 19:19; 22:39; Mark 12:31, 33; Luke 10:27).
JESUS AS NEIGHBOR
I looked up the word acceptance in the concordance in the back of my Bible. It did not offer anything related to God accepting me. I put myself in the shoes of a Gen Zer searching for answers (though they may search TikTok before cracking the concordance), and realized how much we can help Gen Z by showing them God’s acceptance in the Bible. We can point out where we see what it means to be a Neighbor.
The good Samaritan (Luke 10:25-37). Jesus is asked, “Who is my neighbor?” by an expert in the law (Luke 10:29). Jesus’ story demonstrates that being a Neighbor is active. The robbed and beaten man was the neighbor of all the men in the story, but it was the Samaritan who acted as Neighbor, while a priest and Levite pass by. A Samaritan! The priest and Levite would have known the law well, been committed to a righteous way of living, and devoted to the Lord. Yet, it was the Samaritan, the despised and lower class, religiously impure, and an ethnic outsider, who Jesus uses to illustrate how to be a Neighbor.
We don’t know the exact reasons the priest and Levite passed by and did not help. Maybe the priest and Levite were afraid for their own safety, or perhaps they presumed the man dead and did not want to risk becoming “unclean” by touching a dead body (see Numbers 19:11). Both are self-protective modes: I don’t want to get robbed too, and I don’t want to become “unclean.” The latter could even be motivated by reverence for God’s Law. This is a good place to pause and ask, “Have you seen places where this happens today? Do you have examples of when people have put what they think is following God’s Law in front of being a Neighbor?” It’s a spicy question, an uncomfortable one, but asking it gives space and permission for our Gen Z friends to ask even more questions.
Jesus has a pattern of correcting the religious teachers and experts in the law, trying to focus them on the heart of the law: “Love the Lord your God” and “Love your neighbor as yourself” (Luke 10:26-27). The heart of the law should have motivated the priest and the Levite to help the robbed and beaten man, or at least check and see if he was alive. Jesus tells us not to let the letter of the law get in the way of living out the heart of the law. Who is my neighbor? According to this passage, it is those who need mercy (Luke 10:37).
Rich, young ruler (Mark 10:17-27). A man runs up to Jesus and asks what he must do to have eternal life, as if this rich, young man is asking God, “What must I do for you to accept me?” Jesus goes on to list the commandments, something the rich, young man agrees with, and claims to have followed since he was young. This young man is concerned with the letter of the law but not the heart of it. I also think he is not being truthful. Okay, I think he is flat-out lying about his religiously obedient life. It is an impossible feat to do what the rich, young man is claiming to have done.
In the next verse, Jesus reflects God’s acceptance and acts as a Neighbor. Jesus looks at the inauthentic and insecure man and loves him (Mark 10:21). Jesus loves him, just as he is, standing before God the Son. Jesus loves him, not for the things the rich, young man has done or hasn’t done, but just because he’s God. As we sit with this passage next to our Gen Z friends, pause here. Let’s invite them to wonder what it would be like for them if they realized how much God loves them. What would be different? Stop and set a timer for simply two minutes. For those two minutes, let’s sit next to our Gen Z friends, and silently focus on letting ourselves be loved. Maybe we can work our way to five minutes, or even ten, if we do this more often. This is the kind of love we get to share with our neighbors. What prevents us from experiencing God’s love?
Jesus then asks this man to change: to sell everything, give it to the poor, and come follow him. This does not mean Jesus would love him more if the young man did these things. Jesus is pointing the young man back to the heart of the law: to love God and love your neighbors. Jesus asks the young man to change, to let go of what prevents him from experiencing the fullness of his love as a new creation in Christ. Jesus does not reject the young man, but in the end of this story, it seems the young man rejects Jesus.
Because Jesus is God, he fully sees and knows this rich, young man. He would have known his life up to this point, and the choice he was going to make. In the midst of that, Jesus loved him. That love is the kind of love that should be shown by a disciple who is a Neighbor. It is seeing someone in the midst of their story and struggle and showing them love. That love shows that, if you come to Christ, he will accept you.
A TALK WITH GEN Z
Being a Neighbor reminds a lonely generation they are a part of a community. Within that community of beloved ones of Christ, they now can extend the acceptance of that community to others! They can share the good news for all people who believe. Gen Z will be able to see those who have been overlooked but desperately need the gospel.
I am so grateful for Generation Z and their eyes and hearts for others. Their value of acceptance is a gift to this world and a gift to the church. Gen Z pushes our older generations to wrestle with the letter of the law and the heart of the law. In discipleship, we get to work together to figure out how to be a Neighbor, each generation helping another. We can thank them for their partnership in this.
Part of this is learning how to separate acceptance and agreement. This takes time and proximity, and even verbalization. Our Gen Z friends need to hear us say, “I may not agree with that person’s view or choice, but I welcome and accept them as my neighbor,” and then witness how we continue to love. Model it and allow our younger generation to see what it looks like. This is not being inauthentic, pretending to accept someone when I don’t agree and want them to change. It is authentically showing love and acceptance through the Lord. Gen Z will learn from us how to extend acceptance to our neighbors as Jesus did. He accepted people as they were when they came to him, and he also changed them.
This may be a new place for our Gen Zers to step into. It is asking them to redefine the parameters of what acceptance means, reforming or breaking with how their generational culture has defined acceptance. This requires patience and courage, and partnership with a mentor, who can walk alongside and process this with a younger person, through all the different opportunities to be a Neighbor.
Gen Z’s value of acceptance in the hands of the Lord will change our communities and our world. As Gen Z disciples of Christ understand what it means to be Neighbor, they can create the belonging and sense of community many are looking for. If we are willing to be uncomfortable and stretched—both as older generations allow Gen Z to live into their value of acceptance, and as Gen Z is willing to let acceptance be redefined through God’s ways by being discipled by older generations—our communities will be formed into something new and life-changing.
Key Ideas
Ask Gen Z: What does it look like to be accepted? Where have you seen people put God’s law in front of being a Neighbor? What would it be like if you realized how much God loved you? What prevents you from experiencing that?
Gen Z Asks: Will you accept me? (Will God accept me?)
Answer: God accepts all who want to follow him. He fully sees you, and knows you, and welcomes you. God both fully accepts you today when you go to him, and he also makes you into something new.
Result: As we are fully accepted into God’s family, each of us learns to become a Neighbor to others: to reflect God’s acceptance to others. We learn to love our neighbors as we love ourselves. This is community-changing and community-forming loving acceptance.
