Chapter 3 of 17

Introduction: What’s Going On with Gen Z and the Church?

Introduction: What’s Going On with Gen Z and the Church?

INTRODUCTION

What’s Going On with

Gen Z and the Church?

Have I become irrelevant?

There has probably been a moment in the last few years when we looked at the ministry we were doing and asked: Am I effective anymore? For me, that moment arrived when Generation Z (Gen Z) entered the doors of the building. There was a shift I couldn’t put my finger on, but I knew something had changed. I saw panic attacks at events, students with too much anxiety to go to school, girls who would only meet with me one-on-one and not in groups, open hostility to faith unlike what I had seen before, and more. I hadn’t changed what I was doing, but I was experiencing a very different outcome. I had been leading youth ministry for twenty years, but was suddenly feeling lost, like I had no idea what I was doing. Why is what has worked for so long no longer working? My first inclination was to think there was something wrong with me; I was the problem. I had gotten too old for this, and I wasn’t effective in ministry anymore. Have I become irrelevant?

After a little digging, I realized there had been a generational shift, and Gen Z had arrived so quickly, we didn’t realize they were here until the oldest members of the generation were graduating from high school. Gen Z wasn’t the problem though. The problem was a disconnect between me, the way I had always done things, and this new generation. I did not know or understand Gen Z.

I realized I was out of touch, and I had better figure out who they are, what they are looking for, and what they are asking, in order to better share the gospel with them and help them grow in their faith, or risk becoming increasingly ineffective and irrelevant. So I began to listen, study, and read. I spent days, weeks, months, and now years seeking to understand the next generation. This book is an extension of my doctoral thesis. I became committed to knowing Gen Z, both in study and relationship, so I could better share the gospel and disciple this generation.

GEN Z FLIGHT

There has been a lot of buzz around younger generations leaving the church, and a lot of speculation about why. Gen Z is more likely than previous generations to be raised by parents who have no religious affiliation (those who would check the box atheist, agnostic, or none). Even those Gen Zers who were practicing Christians when they were younger are leaving churches. As Gen Z ages into their twenties, a significant portion turn away from Christianity or Christian communities like churches. A 2023 survey by Springtide Research Center found four-in-ten Gen Zers (aged 13–25) never attend religious services. The Survey Center on American Life also found Gen Z is leaving their faith at younger ages than previous generations, with 48 percent of those leaving doing so between ages 13 and 17, and 26 percent of those leaving doing so between ages 18 and 29.

Looking at surveys regarding Gen Z and the Christian faith, it’s hard to decipher what version of Christian faith they are leaving. According to the Jesus Survey, most Gen Z Christians agree Jesus, Mohammed, Buddha, and other belief systems or religions all have equal value and standing when it comes to the afterlife. This survey was conducted in 2012, just as Gen Z were becoming teenagers, and exhibits the influences on Gen Z as they grew up. These are Christians—those who have professed faith in Jesus Christ—who also believe all roads lead to heaven. This does not translate into religious practice for Gen Z, such as attending church services or reading the Bible. As of 2023, 68 percent of Gen Z agree there are many religions they agree with.

According to sources such as the American Bible Society and others, Gen Z is also not familiar with the Bible or the stories of the Bible, or how to read or understand the Bible. I recently sat with a college student who was brought up in a Christian family, was active in her faith, and had attended church her whole life. I was referring to the stories of Joseph and Moses as she was wrestling with having a multiethnic background, and thus shared a multicultural experience with these Old Testament heroes. She was unfamiliar with these stories, and I had to do an overview summary to get her caught up. The felt-board Bible stories from my childhood Sunday school classes were unfamiliar to my Gen Z friend. I’ve also sat with a recent high school graduate who in the midst of our conversation said, “But Jesus sinned too, right?” These are not outlier kinds of conversations. They are the conversations with a generation, even the Christians in that generation, who do not know what is in the Bible. With the absence of knowledge, Gen Z is making guesses, and it ripples out into not knowing what to believe about the Bible.

There are concerns and questions around Gen Z and the future of Christianity. What if Gen Z isn’t just leaving, but they weren’t here to begin with? In 2023, 31 percent of Gen Zers said they had never participated in a religious or spiritual community. Many such as Pew Research note it’s not just Gen Z’s interest or belief in Christianity that has decreased, but belief in all religions. Overall, Gen Z is not engaging with faith. As Gen Z is moving from middle schools and high schools to college campuses and careers, the impact on churches and ministries is more widely felt. Seeing the decline of engagement by the next generation, many churches and ministries are looking for answers to questions like:

  • Why is Gen Z leaving the Christian faith?

  • How do we reach Gen Z with the gospel?

  • What does discipling Gen Z look like?

  • What is going on with Gen Z and the church?

  • These are good and important questions to ask. A positive dynamic that has come with the arrival of Gen Z is that churches and ministries have done some self-examination to figure out where the disconnect is.

    A Barna Group study highlighted one such disconnect between Gen Z and older Christian adults: the faith and gospel prioritized by churches are not the same faith and gospel prioritized by Gen Z. This isn’t to say that there is more than one faith and one gospel, but in the full breadth and depth of the Christian faith and gospel, both parties are focused on different aspects. According to Church Doesn’t End with Z, Gen Z does not see a connection between the gospel they are hearing at church and their everyday lives; the gospel seems irrelevant. Churches are not addressing the questions around faith and meaning that matter to the next generation. What is being communicated to Gen Z is “that God is not concerned about the world they inhabit—and presumably that God is not concerned about them.”

    GENERATIONAL DISCONNECT

    About twelve years ago, I took a course with David Livermore, author of Cultural Intelligence, and an example he used stuck with me. He asked the class this question: “Why did the prodigal son go hungry?” (see Luke 15:11-20). I was quick to answer, “Because he squandered all of his money.” But the story points to three big reasons why the prodigal son was hungry: (1) there was a famine, (2) no one would give him anything to eat, and (3) he spent all his money. Livermore pointed out that depending on our cultural context, we all may answer that question differently.

    For the sake of this example, let’s say older Christian adults cite the reason for the prodigal son’s situation is (3) he spent all his money, but Gen Zers agree that (2) no one would give him anything to eat. Gen Z is focused on community and charity, while older Christians are focused on personal stewardship and responsibility. They are looking at the same passage, but not having the same conversation. They are prioritizing and focusing on different things, both valuable parts of the passage. This is what is meant by Gen Z and the older generations of Christians (who are leading our churches and ministries) not prioritizing the same faith or same gospel. As a result, the church and Gen Z aren’t having the same conversation and are missing each other. No one is at any fault, but we need to learn how to get back into the same conversation.

    Gen Z has the perception that the church is not open to, or is even hostile to, doubts and skepticism. The evangelism and discipleship that many of us practice do not fully address Gen Z’s life experiences, and many Gen Zers feel they cannot talk about it. For Gen Z, this translates to a lack of belonging in the Christian faith. They think, If you want to belong, accept everything that is taught and don’t ask questions or have doubts. By asking our Gen Zers a question that opens the door to their questions, we can demonstrate that there is room for them and all of their questions, doubts, and skepticism in conversation with Jesus.

    Studies from both faith-based and non-faith-based research reveal that Gen Z views Christians and followers of the Christian faith as ignorant, uninformed, hypocritical, irrelevant, and judgmental. This doesn’t leave me with a warm and fuzzy feeling inside. It makes me pause to see the lens a generation is looking through as they look at me. This could be a result of churches and ministries continuing the same messages and methods without considering who their audience is (and this is exactly what I was doing). What has worked for previous generations is not working for this one.

    It is time for many of us to admit that we don’t know or understand Gen Z. The good news is that we want to understand! We want to because we deeply care about and believe in Gen Z.

    Hold on a second. Pause and consider this question before continuing: Do I care about and believe in Gen Z? Is it possible that we want to care about and believe in Gen Z, but don’t currently? Is it that we tolerate Gen Z, but since they aren’t going away, we might as well figure out how to coexist with them? A friend once told me the most important part of finding directions on a map isn’t necessarily knowing where you are going, but knowing where you are now. Being honest, maybe uncomfortably honest, about where we are as we embark on this journey together is crucial to the process.

    Right now, the church is answering questions Gen Z is not asking while ignoring the ones they do ask. This furthers a disconnection between the Christian faith and the realities of everyday life for Gen Z. When many young Gen Zers were asked how much God is relevant to them, they answered, “Not much at all.” When we ignore the questions Gen Z is asking, Gen Z doesn’t have an opportunity to see how the Bible is relevant to the longings of their hearts and souls. This means the conversation around faith and the gospel does not intersect the worldview or experience of Gen Z in a meaningful way, even though it could! After all, the gospel is good news for everyone, everywhere, throughout time.

    The way the gospel is presented has been contextualized for the audience from the beginning. The work of contextualization is the work of the church to bring the gospel to all people. Contextualization is the intentional work of cultural translation to help the audience understand the gospel in their own language, in a way that is relevant to their experience. It’s the gospel presented through the lens of the audience, not the speaker. Practicing cultural exegesis is strategic for evangelism for Gen Z. We must do the work of contextualizing the gospel for Gen Z and contextualize what it means to be a disciple of Christ. This is not as difficult as it sounds. It has been modeled to us by God in his Word.

    Though God exists outside of a specific cultural context, God interacts with us within our cultural context. This is seen throughout the Bible, as God interacts with people within their time, place, family, cultural belief system, and worldview. He acted and spoke in ways that were significant to the audience, using illustrations and metaphors that had specific meaning to those people at that time in that place. He went as far as to enter into the world as a human child.

    We cannot be removed from our human and cultural context to enter a divine level to understand God, so God meets us where we are. In that, something amazing happens. God may start with where we are at, but he pulls us closer to him. He accepts us as we are, and at the same time, while God is accepting us, he changes us to be more like him.

    CONNECTING WITH GEN Z

    Gen Z has its own generational context and culture, which includes the questions this generation is asking based on its members’ worldview and values. If churches and ministries understand these questions, the context around these questions, as well as how Christianity reflects the values and questions of Gen Z, a more relevant and applicable faith journey can be presented to Gen Z. They can then understand that Jesus cares about, understands, and engages with their hearts and their real lives in a meaningful and real way.

    In this book, we are going to identify questions Gen Z is asking based on their values, experiences, and worldview. The goal is to equip older generations of Christians to provide relevant and meaningful answers to Gen Z’s questions with the gospel and discipleship. Let’s connect the dots between real life, along with its real questions and doubts, with the Christian faith. We will discuss how to open our Bibles side by side with our Gen Z friends to unpack the Word together in evangelism and discipleship. Why not invite a Gen Zer in your life to read this along with you? Don’t take my words for it, take theirs! Circle and underline passages and ideas, point to them and ask, “What do you think?”

    If you are a member of Gen Z, this is a time to reflect on your own values, experiences, and worldview, in conjunction with your larger generational context. Examine how the Christian faith provides answers to the questions your generation asks, but also engages Gen Z values and experiences through life as a disciple of Christ. Take the opportunity to invite an older adult Christian to read and discuss alongside you. I hope it opens the door to further conversation, and ultimately you feel seen, known, and valued.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑