35. Five Songs That Make You Think
Jonathan Writes …
CHAPTER 35
Five Songs That Make You Think
A few months ago, Common Sense Media surveyed eight- to eighteen-year-olds and asked them what activity they enjoyed most with their screens.1 You might be surprised at the results.
Even though social media, gaming, and watching videos on YouTube were high on their lists … listening to music ranked highest among teenagers, even more so among girls.
And now that our music collection is conveniently accessible in our back pocket, we are listening to more and more of it each year. Think about it. It’s almost always within reach. I know every time I get into the car with a bunch of teenagers, one of the first things they ask is “Can I plug in?” Next thing we know we’re listening to one of their playlists through the car speakers.
And playlists are fun.
One of the things I loved the most about driving my car in high school (actually, it was my parents’ car and I got to drive it every once in a while) was that I had control of the radio!
Back then cars only had radios and tape decks (this was before iPhones, iPods, even before CDs … yes, I’m that old). So I always brought a few tapes with me in the car so I could listen to the music I wanted to hear.
I remember one particular album from a Christian musician I had heard in concert. His name was Steve Taylor and his music was very innovative for the time. One of his songs was titled “Drive, He Said,” and it was the story of a man driving a car who picked up a hitchhiker. But it didn’t turn out to be just any hitchhiker; it was someone creepy who knew every little detail about this man. As the song played out, you realized this hitchhiker might not have been a man at all, but an evil entity.
Here’s the thing: Every time I played this song, my friends would always stop talking and listen. Then they would ask questions.
“Wait, did he just say he owned the man?”
“Did he just pick up the devil?”
Finally, we’d be asking each other, “What would you do if the devil was trying to get you to sell your soul?”
That song always had a way of grabbing us and catalyzing conversation.
And that’s just it. Sometimes music proves to be much more than just background noise. Music can resonate with us. Music evokes emotion. Music can even connect you to others.
Music is powerful.
Yeah, I know. Sometimes we listen to songs just to relax or escape. I’m with you. That’s a fun aspect of music. Most of the time when my friends and I listened to music, we just turned it up and zoned out. But sometimes music does much more… .
Do you ever craft a playlist that sets a certain mood?
I’ve got a playlist titled “Vegetate.”
I’ve got another one titled “Angst.”
I titled one “Lori” because it makes me think of my wife.
I’ve got one titled “Riding in the car with Thom” because it’s all the music my brother used to play in the car when we were kids. I played it for him this Christmas, and immediately we began reflecting on times when we were driving together, places we went.
Music can trigger nostalgia.
Does music ever stir your emotions?
Here are five random songs that always make me pause and think. Who knows—they might even provoke fascinating face-to-face conversations.
“EVERYTHING I WANTED” BY BILLIE EILISH
In 2019 Billie Eilish released a compelling song titled “Everything I Wanted,” and her fans loved it!
Eilish’s unique image and sound drew quick attention—she isn’t your typical pop star. But her music is what really captured the world’s focus. She swept the Grammys in early 2020 like no one her age has ever accomplished.
Even if you don’t necessarily enjoy Billie Eilish’s music, you’ll probably admit the lyrics to this song are intriguing. “Everything I Wanted” is based on one of her real-life dreams, one that impacted her so deeply she and her brother Finneas wrote a song about it. The song tells the story of how she dreamed she committed suicide and no one cared or even noticed. But then the song takes an intriguing turn. She wakes up and realizes there is someone who actually cares for her (in real life, this was her brother).
This caring person says, “As long as I’m here, no one can hurt you,” and goes on to say, “If I could change the way you see yourself,” encouraging her to see all the good in herself that he sees.
This song seems to resonate with people for several reasons: First, a lot of people wonder if there are others who truly care for them. Second, most of us would love someone to be there for us and say, “As long as I’m here, no one can hurt you,” not to mention seeing the good in us, noticing our potential, and liking us for who we are.
Aren’t those things that you long for too?
ASK YOURSELF OR A FRIEND
1. Have you ever felt unnoticed and unloved? When?
2. Do you have someone in your life who cares for you and wouldn’t let anyone hurt you?
3. Who sees the good in you, notices your potential, and likes you for who you are?
4. How does God feel about you? (Reread the passage Alyssa shared in chapter 8, “Liar, Liar,” from Psalm 139.)
“EVEN IF” BY MERCYME
MercyMe is a Christian band whose songs have been inspiring people for literally two decades ever since the release of their very first crossover single, “I Can Only Imagine” (and if you haven’t seen the powerful movie by the same title, I encourage you to check it out).
“Even If” is one of my favorite songs from the band, an honest conversation with God during a tough time, a time when they admit, “A little faith is all I have right now.”
The power of the song is in the background story, an inspiring moment from the book of Daniel, chapter 3, when three young boys, Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego, are about to be burned alive in a fiery furnace by the evil king Nebuchadnezzar, who wanted them to worship his false gods. When the king threatened to throw them in the fire, they replied:
“O Nebuchadnezzar, we do not need to defend ourselves before you. If we are thrown into the blazing furnace, the God whom we serve is able to save us. He will rescue us from your power, Your Majesty. But even if he doesn’t, we want to make it clear to you, Your Majesty, that we will never serve your gods or worship the gold statue you have set up.” (Daniel 3:16–18 NLT, emphasis mine)
In this song, Bart Millard, the lead singer, confesses some modern-day struggles where he is weak, but then he declares that he knows God is able to save him—but even if He doesn’t, he still hopes in God alone.
ASK YOURSELF OR A FRIEND
1. When is a time you’ve felt, “A little faith is all I have right now”?
2. What is MercyMe saying when they sing, “Even if You don’t” save me from these tough times right now, “my hope is You alone”?
3. Name a time when it is difficult to be faithful to God during tough circumstances.
4. Why do you think MercyMe finishes the song by singing, “It is well with my soul, it is well with my soul, it is well, it is well with my soul”? (Google the story behind the old hymn “It Is Well with My Soul.”)
“GOD ONLY KNOWS” BY FOR KING & COUNTRY
“God Only Knows” is not only a powerful song but also a powerful music video, and in a world where most of us have access to screens, I’m going to suggest you quickly search for the music video and watch it.
Many of us will identify with the words of the song, including phrases like “nobody sees you,” and with living a life where we feel like no one understands what it’s like to be us.
The music video follows a girl who wakes up obviously feeling alone and carrying the weight of something. She gets up regardless, puts on her makeup, and even practices a quick fake smile, one we see her use throughout the day.
Who can relate?
Here’s where the message of the chorus is clear: God alone knows everything you’ve been through; He knows what other people say behind your back; and He alone knows that it’s tearing you apart on the inside.
Eventually the girl in the video has had enough and she escapes her friends and finds her way onto the edge of a bridge to take her own life. That’s where the video takes a turn. I won’t spoil it for you; you’ll have to watch it yourself. It’s powerful.
The chorus of the song shares the idea that there is a unique and special kind of love that only comes from God. It’s followed by the idea of a new beginning … a brand-new start …
And the video reveals what that might look like. A restart.
ASK YOURSELF OR A FRIEND
1. Have you ever felt like no one knows what you’re going through?
2. Have you ever considered that there are others who are thinking, No one knows what I’m going through?
3. How did the friend in the video reach out to her friend?
4. How can we reach out to someone who is hurting?
5. What do you hear God saying to you through this song?
“YELLOW” BY COLDPLAY
Have you ever put on sunglasses with a yellow tint?
Have you ever put on sunglasses with a gray tint?
It’s amazing to see how a simple tint completely changes how you see the world. A yellow tint makes everything look bright, sunny, and cheery … and gray does exactly the opposite. Completely dreary.
Coldplay’s breakthrough hit, “Yellow,” starts with the simple claim, “Look at the stars, look how they shine for you, and everything you do …”
I always liked the song, but I think it really connected with me when my daughter Ashley heard me listening to it and said, “I love that song!”
“Why?” I asked her.
“It just makes me feel loved!” she said.
Stars, shining for you … and they were all yellow.
Makes me feel loved.
ASK YOURSELF OR A FRIEND
1. What do you think of when you look up at the stars and just stare at them for a while?
2. Why do you think Jonathan’s daughter Ashley said the song made her feel loved?
3. What makes you feel loved?
4. Read Psalm 8:3–4. What do you think David was feeling when he looked at the night sky?
5. How much does God truly love you? (See Romans 5:8.)
“EVERYTHING GLORIOUS” BY DAVID CROWDER BAND
This song is a simple prayer, a true praise song that helps us realize our value.
The message is simple: “Hey, God, if everything You make is glorious, and You made me … I guess I’m glorious!”
ASK YOURSELF OR A FRIEND
1. Sunsets, waterfalls, horses running through a meadow, the ocean crashing on the sand … What is something in God’s creation that you think is truly glorious?
2. How can a relationship with Jesus make the day and night “brighter”?
3. How can you reflect God’s glory in your life today?
REALIZATION #35: Sometimes the music we carry with us on our devices evokes emotion or provokes us to think.
FINAL THOUGHTS
It’s funny if you think of it, but today many people judge someone’s value based on a few numbers.
How many followers do you have?
How many “friends” do you have?
How many likes did you receive on that post?
The math is simple: A lot of likes means you are valuable. Not many likes … well … A lot of followers means you have influence. Not many followers … well …
One of the elements I like about the songs in this chapter is the conversations they each provoke about “value.” In a world where most of us struggle with feelings of insecurity, God reveals a totally different perspective on value.
“I wouldn’t let anyone hurt you.”
“I’m here for you during tough times.”
“I know what you’re going through and I love you.”
“I value you more than all the stars in the heavens.”
“I made you glorious!”
