Chapter 18 of 45

15. Talk, Text, Facetime, Call

15. Talk, Text, Facetime, Call

Jonathan Writes …

CHAPTER 15

Talk, Text, FaceTime, Call

Do you ever wonder how emojis came to be?

Because people were tired of their texts being misinterpreted.

It’s true. Emojis are just a feeble attempt to provide facial expression so texting is a little more understandable.

Think about it. You text your friend a question:

Do you want to come over and hang out?

Three little dots emerge.

You wait.

Eventually, one word appears.

Sure.

Most of us can’t help but wonder. What does she mean by this one-word reply? The possibilities abound. She could mean …

A. For sure! Woo-hoo! There’s nothing I’d rather do! That sounds awesome!

B. Sure. Hanging with a friend sounds okay.

C. Sure, and I really do want to, but I’m extremely busy right now and have no time to type out a long reply!

D. Sure, I guess. I mean, I have nothing else to do, so I’ll settle for hanging out with you. Sigh.

Which of these did she mean? (Please be choice A.)

We don’t have a clue because we can’t hear her voice or see her face. How are we supposed to know what “sure” really means?

Funny, sometimes people will jump to conclusions and get all upset over what a text “could have meant” when really it didn’t mean that at all.

Did she mean choice D? Rude! That’s so typical of her. I don’t know why I even asked her.

Then you receive a text.

Sorry for my short response. I was at the hospital visiting my grandma. She just had surgery, but she’s okay now. I’m really looking forward to hanging with you tonight!

Gulp!

This typical miscommunication in digital messages existed long before texting. Email and every kind of instant messaging suffered the same shortcomings. Why?

We can’t see what are called “nonverbal cues.” And nonverbal cues are exactly what the words imply, little cues or hints as to what the person is saying through nonverbal channels like facial expression, volume, and tone of voice.

Think of the last time you were severely upset and someone asked you, “Hey, how are you doing?”

You might yell sarcastically, “Oh, I’m just great!”

The words of your reply don’t match your nonverbal cues, but anyone within fifty feet of you knows loud and clear that you meant, “I’m doing anything but great! Leave me alone!” But that’s not what you said verbally. It was your tone, volume, and other nonverbal cues that made it clear.

My friend Karla received a text from her grandma when a close family member had died. Grandma typed some sympathetic words, then ended with LOL! Karla wondered when Grandma had turned into such an evil ice queen, laughing at Karla’s misery. Turns out, Grandma thought LOL meant “lots of love.”

That’s the problem with texting. Soooo prone to misinterpretation.

Don’t get me wrong. I love texting. Texting has its place. If you want to ask someone, “What pages do we have to read in our science book tonight?” then texting is very helpful. Or “What time should I pick you up?” Great method of communication.

But let’s say you text your friend, Hey, how are you feeling? Let’s be honest. You have no idea what they mean when they text you back, Fine.

In fact, a bunch of researchers tested communication effectiveness a few years ago in a clever bonding experiment where they tested pairs of close friends for “emotional connectedness” as they engaged in four different types of conversations:1

1.   In person

2.   Video chat

3.   Phone call

4.   Text messaging/instant message

The results were fascinating.

The researchers measured the bonding in each situation through the level of understanding the friends reached and the level of emotional connectedness they experienced. Interestingly enough, the participants felt connected in all the communication situations, but the measured bonding differed “significantly” for each one.

Guess which communication method made participants feel “most connected.”

The “in person” method won by a landslide.

Why? Because when people were face-to-face, they could not only hear what the other person was saying but also see their gestures and facial expressions, and sometimes even reach out and touch the other person—giving a hug, for example. In-person communication was by far the most rewarding to participants.

Video chat was second best, because facial expressions could still be seen. Nonverbal cues are a huge part of communication, but a video chat still isn’t as good as being face-to-face. Most of us experienced this when we were forced to stay home during the COVID-19 lockdowns. Even though we could FaceTime our friends, it still wasn’t as rewarding as truly connecting with them in person.

Phone was third in the experiment. People didn’t feel very connected just talking on the phone. But tone and volume were still perceivable. Participants could pick up sarcasm and voice inflection.

Texting or instant messaging was dead last, simply because it was prone to the most misinterpretation. All caps, exclamation points, and emojis try to fill in the gaps, but it just isn’t the same as verbal, nonverbal, and face-to-face communication.

Does this mean you shouldn’t text?

Not at all.

But you might think twice about engaging in important conversations via text or instant message.

How many times have we said it in this book?

Face-to-face is better!

REALIZATION #15: Texting is prone to misinterpretation.

1.   If you had a choice to be face-to-face with a friend or texting them, which would you choose?

2.   Why do you think some people feel more comfortable communicating through screens?

3.   Can you think of a time when you misunderstood someone’s text or they misunderstood yours? What happened?

4.   When is texting the most convenient?

5.   When is a time you think face-to-face is better?

FINAL THOUGHTS

I think I’ll text Alyssa to test this theory of texting.

There it is again! What does she mean?

A.   Shut up, as in, that is so cool! You’re so lucky!

B.   Shut up! I don’t want to hear it. I still have to write a chapter today. I hope you fall and break your leg.

I should have just called her and left a voice message!

↑ Back to top

↑