3. God’s Favor Lost
3
God’s Favor Lost
Every year around Christmas, local news stations report on a phenomenon that breaks out spontaneously at various drive-thru restaurants around the nation. Called a Line of Sharing or a Line of Caring or sometimes a Pay It Forward Line, it goes like this: one festive and generous soul making their way through the drive-thru not only pays for their own triple-grande, double-pump, sugar-free, low-foam, no-whip, skinny vanilla mocha with a splash of coconut (or whatever) but also pays the bill for the person in the car behind them. When that blessed but unsuspecting soul arrives at the window, they’re informed of the good news: the bill is paid, the latte is free, and there’s nothing more to be done. That person, overcome with gratitude, then pays the favor forward to the person behind them by paying for their order, and the cycle repeats itself again and again until some ungrateful cad simply grins, says, “Cool!” and drives away.
I got stuck in a Pay It Forward Line a few years ago at my local Starbucks. I say “stuck” because for all the generosity and Christmas cheer and fa-la-la-la that’s supposed to be involved, I look back on the experience with a certain amount of bitterness. It all started just like such things are supposed to. When I ordered my drink at the drive-thru, I was unaware that I’d already been swept up into a chain of joy and happiness, so it was a genuine surprise when I arrived at the window and the barista told me the person in front of me had paid for my coffee. I have to say, this brought me more happiness than a free cup of coffee really should. My heart swelled with gratitude, and I said, “Wow, that’s awesome! You know what? Let me pay for the car behind me, and tell them I said Merry Christmas too!”
“Great!” the barista said. “Will do! Their bill is $27.92.”
I honestly didn’t know joy and happiness could drain so quickly. I considered a few strategies for a moment. Maybe I could pay for just one drink or put a down payment on the bill; maybe I could just laugh and drive away. But finally, through some combination of guilt, evangelistic necessity now that I’d brought Christmas into it, and a spirit of generosity genuinely reasserting itself, I paid the $27.92. I hope the guy in the car behind me enjoyed his drinks. I also hope he remembers my generosity as vividly as I obviously still do.
However you look at it, and whether you’ve been blessed or burned by them, Pay It Forward Lines are another example of unearned favor. After all, the person behind you hasn’t done anything to earn your generosity. You aren’t in their debt; they haven’t performed some service for you; you don’t owe them anything. On the other hand, they also haven’t done anything to lose your favor. They haven’t been rude to you; they haven’t cut you off in traffic; there’s no bad blood between you at all. They haven’t earned your kindness, but neither have they forfeited it. You pay the bill as an act of pure, from neutral, unearned favor.
But let’s flip the script just a little bit. What if you knew the person in the car behind you was your very worst enemy, someone who for years had unfairly and maliciously wronged you at every opportunity? Would you pay it forward to that person? Or to make it perhaps even a little sharper, would you start a Pay It Forward Line for that person? Whether you would or wouldn’t isn’t really the important thing now. The important thing is to see this: it’s one thing to do something kind for someone as an act of unearned favor, when they haven’t done anything either to deserve or to lose that favor. But it’s an entirely different thing altogether to do something kind for someone who has set themselves against you in every way, who has in fact forfeited every right to your kindness and generosity. If we’re honest, we’d probably admit that it would take something more than a little Christmas cheer to show that person kindness. It would take what we might call gracious favor.
Gracious Favor
Grace is an awe-inspiring word. In the Bible, it has a wide range of meaning, including mercy, compassion, pardon, and favor. It’s not the kind of word that’s used for unearned favor, though. Rather, it’s the kind of word that has to sweep something else away to make room for itself—condemnation swept away by mercy, guilt swept away by compassion, sin swept away by salvation. And it turns out that this is the kind of favor we need from God—not merely unearned favor but gracious favor, favor that looks on us with pleasure and compassion and kindness and goodness not because of what we’ve done, or even for no particular reason, but in spite of what we’ve done.
If you’re going to understand the value and preciousness of God’s favor, you have to understand this first and above all: you do not deserve it. In fact, you deserve the opposite of it. You deserve to be condemned, to die, and to spend eternity under God’s wrath, and no amount of being kind to other people or thinking positively or praying more fervently or going to church or making pilgrimages will ever be enough to change that verdict. It’s as Paul said in Romans, “All have sinned . . . and the wages of sin is death” (3:23; 6:23).
I think the main reason so many Christians take the favor of God so lightly is because we think it’s still available to us if we try hard enough. In other words, we fail to see just how completely and catastrophically we have forfeited it. You see, if your understanding of sin is that it’s just a mistake or a misfire or even the violation of a duly enacted but not terribly important divine law, you’ll never understand why it is so astonishing that God shows his favor to any of us at all. After all, even a child knows that it’s good to be nice to people who aren’t nice to you, so why should we be surprised when God does that for us? In fact, why shouldn’t we expect God to do that? Well, here’s why: it’s because sin is not just a mistake or a misfire or a heavenly misdemeanor. It is rebellion and insurrection against the throne and crown and authority of God.
Sin Is Not a Mistake; It’s Rebellion
You probably remember the story of Adam and Eve from the book of Genesis. Having completed the creation of the world in five days, God finally created human beings on the sixth day. The story contains an interesting little phrase, though, that is packed with meaning. It says that he created Adam and Eve “in the image of God” (see Gen. 1:26). Have you ever thought about what that phrase means? Many things could be said about both what it means and what it says about us as human beings. For example, perhaps it points to our ability to reason, or to create, or to relate to one another. All those things may be part of it. Whatever else it might mean, though, the phrase also points to a particular role Adam and Eve were supposed to play in the world—a job God was giving them to perform.
The idea and function of an “image” was well known to the first people who read the book of Genesis. Often when ancient kings would invade and conquer new territory, they would instruct their servants to identify the tallest, most visible mountain in the land and put on top of it a statue—or “image”—of themselves. Sometimes images like this were made of stone or wood, but sometimes they were made of more precious materials. You might remember from the Bible that Nebuchadnezzar of Babylon had his ninety-foot-tall image forged out of gold. Whatever the building material, the purpose of the image was unmistakable: it communicated to everyone in the land, to everyone who saw it on top of the mountain, that this land is ruled by this king.
Once you understand that, you can start to see a bit more clearly what God was doing when he created Adam and Eve in his image. He wanted them to perform a certain function. Even as they exercised dominion over the fish and the birds and the animals, even as they worked to subdue the earth under their feet, they were also to act as reflections—that is, images—of God’s own rule over the world. In other words, their main job was to communicate to the universe by their very lives that this cosmos is ruled by God. Not coincidentally, that’s also why God put the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil in the center of the garden. As much as we might be tempted to think so, that tree wasn’t just a nasty test to see what Adam and Eve would do with it. Much less was it a cruel temptation with which God was trying to lead them to sin. No, the tree had a definite purpose, beautiful in its own way. It was a reminder to Adam and Eve that the authority God had given them in the world was not ultimate, and it was not unbounded. It was derived and limited. There was an authority in heaven that was even higher than their own.
In the first days after creation, everything worked perfectly. The world and everything in it were beautiful—ordered and exquisite and wonderful, just as God intended. The waves crashed, the winds sang, and the trees swayed. Fish frolicked, birds soared, and animals roamed the earth. Creation rejoiced and worshiped. And like a skilled conductor leading an orchestra in a symphony, King Adam and Queen Eve led all of it in praise and worship to the High King, God the Creator, and enjoyed his unbroken pleasure and favor. No wonder God looked at all he had made and saw that it was very good.
And then it all came crashing down. One day Satan came to Adam and Eve, promising them that if they would just eat the fruit from the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil, life would get better for them. They could rise above their station. They could be “like God.” Satan’s strategy was ambitious. He wasn’t just trying to get Adam and Eve to make a little mistake or to break a little divine regulation. Nor was he merely causing them to fail a nasty test God had set up for them. He was asking them to throw off the limits God had placed on their own authority, to declare independence from his rule.
He was asking them to join his rebellion against the High King.
And when they did, when they reached out their hands, ate the fruit, and set themselves in insurrection against God, they forfeited everything. Their relationship with him was severed, his pleasure turned to anger, and his favor and friendship turned to righteous wrath. He turned his face away from them.
Sin Is More Than a “Miss”
Sometimes our Sunday school definitions of biblical words can wind up confusing more than they clarify. Sadly, sin is one of those words. You may have heard someone explain that the Greek and Hebrew words behind our English word sin come originally from the realm of archery, and they mean “to miss” or “to make an error.” The idea is that an archer, though trying very hard to hit the center of a target, misses the bull’s-eye, sending their arrow flying out into the field beyond. No doubt that’s a striking image, but it can be massively confusing if we apply it to the Bible’s concept of sin. That’s because our sin against God is not at all what that image of the disappointed archer would imply. Just like Adam and Eve, we are not in fact trying to hit the target God has set for us and just missing it by an inch. In fact, the truth is that in the deepest corners of our souls, we’ve decided not to aim at God’s target at all but rather at his heart! We want him dead, gone, and out of our lives. We want his crown and his throne for ourselves so that we may rule and live as we please.
That ugly picture is the essence of sin. It’s not a mistake, not a little white violation, not a miss or a shortcoming or a mere imperfection but a revolution against God and his authority over us. That’s true of every sin, no matter how personal or small we may think it is. When we sin in anger, we are declaring that if only we could wear the crown, we’d make things work out better than God did. When we sin in pride, we are declaring that we ourselves are more worthy of honor and even worship than God is. When we chase after satisfaction and meaning and fulfillment in the things of this world, we declare that God and his beauty are not enough for us. When our hearts are filled with greed or lust or envy, we are declaring that we are discontent with the good gifts God the King has given us and that we want more, more, more! In all these things, we’re doing far more than merely making a mistake. We’re putting our finger in God’s face—whether we intend to or not—and saying, “You are not worthy of my worship. You are not worthy to have authority over me, and I declare my independence from you!”
If that’s true, then so is this: it is profoundly right and good for God to stand against us in our rebellion. After all, he is the Judge of all the earth, and as Psalm 97:2 says, “Righteousness and justice are the foundation of his throne.” If he doesn’t do what is right and just, in other words, the very foundation of his throne crumbles. And what is right and just when it comes to us and our sin?
To stand against us.
To pour out holy wrath against us.
To destroy us.
That’s why we can’t simply rest on a vague hope that God will understand we all make mistakes, or that he’ll agree to overlook this or that shortcoming, or that he’ll at least be reasonable enough to see we’re not as bad as we could be. After all, a rebel is a rebel, and no king worth his salt extends his favor to those who have declared a revolution against him. God’s withholding of his favor—his turning away from us in wrath—is wholly deserved and completely right and just.
But I’ll Do Better!
Of course, this is the point at which we all start trying to fix the problem as quickly as possible. And without fail, the first reaction of the human heart to the realization that we are cut off from God’s favor by sin is, “Okay, I’ll do better! This time I’ll change, and I’ll obey God’s law, and I’ll earn his favor.” I’ll be honest; that’s the first place my heart goes when I’m convicted of sin. Maybe yours goes there too—to a superhero-like determination to buckle down and just do better. But, of course, that’s never going to work. In fact, the whole idea of working harder to obey God’s law and win his favor is a lie that will cause us to wind up in nothing but despair.
Why despair? Because neither you nor I nor anyone else on the planet is capable—not even remotely so—of winning for ourselves the applause of heaven and the favor of God. Even on our best day, when we’re killing it, we’re not even close to winning that prize. Think about it with me for a moment. For one thing, we actually tend to get excited when we manage to obey one or two of God’s commands, or meet one or two of his standards consistently. But what God demands if we’re actually going to win his favor and earn his pleasure is comprehensive obedience. In other words, obedience in every detail. It’s not enough to obey just some of his commands or even most of them. Even if we were to succeed in that, justice and righteousness would always be there demanding, “Nope, 99 percent isn’t good enough. You broke that commandment, and that’s enough to ruin you.”
To make matters worse, winning God’s favor would require not just comprehensive obedience to God’s law and standards but unbroken obedience. So even if we could pull it together and obey everything from this moment for the rest of our lives, justice would still be there saying, “No, ten years ago, you disobeyed; you sinned. And so you lose.” See, it’s not enough to do good—or even to be perfect—from here on out. The sins we’ve already committed are still outstanding; they would still demand the loss of God’s favor and the pouring out of his wrath even if we never committed any other wrong. Winning God’s favor requires unbroken obedience, and the sad truth is we’ve already blown it.
Even worse, obedience to God isn’t simply a matter of doing, saying, or even thinking all the right things all the time. It’s a matter of doing all those things from the heart, with the right motives and for the right reasons. “Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength,” Jesus said (Mark 12:30). That doesn’t mean obeying with just some of your heart for some of the time. It means doing all the right things, with all your heart, all the time. Do you see how hopeless it is to decide you’re going to buck up and win God’s favor? Even if you could scrub your actions and your words and your thoughts completely clean from any disobedience to God, still justice would look into your heart and say, “No, that’s still not good enough. Your motives are impure.”
All this is what God’s law demands of us if we’re going to win his favor for ourselves. It’s exactly what Paul meant in the passage we read earlier from Romans 2, when he said that God will give glory, honor, peace, and eternal life to “everyone who does good” (v. 10). Paul didn’t mean that we need to be relatively good or mostly good or that we need to do a few good deeds. Even less did he mean that glory, honor, and peace will be ours if we just think more positively, or expect God to do great things, or keep the pipes of divine favor clear in our lives, or maintain an attitude of gratitude. No, he meant that if we’re going to take a deep breath and try to win the favor of God, the standard we have to meet is to be good and to do good to the same degree that God himself is good. “Be perfect,” Jesus said, “as your heavenly Father is perfect” (Matt. 5:48). Anything short of that, and we “fall short of the glory of God” (Rom. 3:23).
This Is Not a Game
I hope you can see why this is all so important to any discussion about God’s favor. For one thing, we simply must stop thinking of the favor of God as a kind of carnival game that will net us some nice prizes if we figure out the trick to playing it well, or as a power-up status—like running over a mushroom in Mario Kart—that brings wealth and respect into our lives until we unfortunately lose it and drop back into the “normal mode” of life. It’s not a game in which God is waiting to see if we’ll be prayerful or faithful or generous or kind enough, and then he’ll reward us by pouring out his favor on us in the form of a bunch of nice things and happenings. No, the favor of God is the most glorious and greatly-to-be-desired reality in the universe. In fact, it is not a thing at all. It is a relationship. It is God’s taking pleasure in us, God’s finding delight in us, and smiling on us, and turning his face toward us in love and acceptance. It is, most beautifully and staggeringly, for God the Almighty to say, “You are my friend.” To speak or think of God’s favor as anything less than that doesn’t even begin to do justice to the glories of enjoying the favor of God.
And yet if we’re going to understand even the basics of what the Bible says about the favor of God, we have to recognize that most of the books and sermons and YouTube videos out there about God’s favor are simply wrong: getting the favor of God is not simple. It has nothing to do with our attitude of gratitude, nor with the pipes of grace being clogged up in our lives, nor with how fervently and sincerely we expect God to do good things for us today. God is not sitting in heaven longing to pour out riches in our lives if only we’ll untie his hands by asking or believing or praying or whatever. He’s not eagerly waiting on us to throw out our old wineskins and show him new ones so he can fill them up with the fine wine of favor. On the contrary, if there’s anything the Bible makes clear to us about God’s favor and its blessings, it is that they are completely and utterly and hopelessly out of our reach. We have forfeited them. We have rejected them. And we can neither do enough good nor erase enough bad to win them again.
As stunning as that truth is, once you grasp it fully, it has profound ramifications for how you think about yourself and your relationship with God. Most importantly, it’s just deeply humbling. If you think of God’s favor as something you can win by doing one thing or another, you will inevitably approach him with a sense of flippancy. Neither his holiness nor your sin will carry for you the proper weight. Your relationship with God will remain mostly a game that you can either win or lose. But when you start to realize that sin has irreparably broken your relationship with him—that you’ve forfeited his favor and deserve nothing but the death of a rebel—then you’ll begin to approach him with the humility and solemnity he deserves. And that will change everything. Your prayers will be different as you stop demanding and expecting things from God and start humbly requesting them from the God of the universe. Your attitude toward other people will be different as you remember what you yourself deserve for your own faults and sin. Even your ability to weather the difficulties of life will increase, because you won’t be hamstrung and frustrated by some hidden expectation that you somehow deserve better. The fact is you don’t. And I don’t. We are rebels against the Most High God, and we deserve to die. Let that reality sink in. Let that truth have its full effect in your heart, and you’ll find it resets how you think about and approach every aspect of your life.
No One Is Righteous; No One
Do you remember that passage from Romans 2, the one in which Paul says you actually can win the favor of God if you just “do good”? We’ve already talked about what he means there—comprehensive, unbroken, all-the-way-from-the-heart good. But just a few verses later, Paul reveals how many people he expects to meet that standard and win God’s favor. Look at what he says:
None is righteous, no, not one; no one understands; no one seeks for God. All have turned aside; together they have become worthless; no one does good, not even one. (Rom. 3:10–12)
So here’s the point so far: God’s favor is not a game, and it is not some special gold-plated status that brings good things into our lives. It is the very friendship of God, and by our sin and rebellion against him—our repeated attempts to take the crown from him and rule ourselves—we have forfeited that favor. What’s more, there’s no way we’re able to earn it back, and God cannot and will not simply suspend justice and grant us his favor anyway. No, his standard must be met. His law must be obeyed. Justice and righteousness must be honored and satisfied. His favor must be earned and won. But how? If we can’t do these things ourselves, then how on earth will they ever happen?
Here’s the answer: God’s favor must be earned and won . . . for us. By someone else.
