2. God’s Favor—Is It Earned or Unearned?
2
God’s Favor—Is It Earned or Unearned?
Years ago, one of my best friends and I took a vacation to Spain. It was just a few months before I was going to be married, so this was what my friend insisted on calling (to my wife’s continuing disgust) my “last hurrah.” We did a ton of planning and settled pretty quickly on the general approach of the trip. We were going to rent a car and strike out on an epic ten-day road trip through sunny Spain. Beyond that, however, we didn’t really know what we were going to do. In fact, right up to the moment we boarded the plane, we weren’t sure if we were going to go east, which would have taken us to the beaches and party towns of Spain, or west to the mountains and ultimately through Portugal. In the end, about halfway through the flight, we decided to go west. Mountains, hiking, and history it was!
There are so many things I remember fondly about that trip. We explored cathedrals and nunneries, stayed a night in the famous Alhambra, watched swords being made in Toledo, hiked the Picos de Europa, and ate like kings. But I think the most memorable part of the trip was our stay right in the shadow of the Cathedral of Santiago de Compostela in northwestern Spain. The city of Santiago is stunningly beautiful, with ancient architecture surrounding quaint streets and the sounds and smells of the sea drifting through the air. And right at the very center of the city, overlooking a massive stone courtyard, is the cathedral itself. I’ll never forget what it looked like the night we arrived—seagulls careening around its spires and the sun setting behind it in a brilliant sea-refracted crimson. I think I have never seen anything quite like it.
My friend and I wandered around the courtyard for a time, reading the tourist signs and brushing past the hushed crowds. Eventually, we walked up the front steps of the cathedral, and I saw something there that continues to this day to break my heart. There on the top step of the cathedral, carved through the centuries, were two deep knee prints worn into the stone from thousands and perhaps even millions of people bowing to kiss the feet of a statue of St. James as they arrived.
These days many people put their knees in those stone indentations mostly as a tourist experience, kneeling down and turning back with a goofy smile and jazz hands so someone can snap a picture. But historically speaking, the Cathedral of Santiago isn’t a tourist stop at all. For well over a thousand years, it has been the terminus of a pilgrimage route called the Way of St. James. Millions of people have traveled that road through the centuries, sometimes for hundreds of miles and at great expense. For those people, the act of putting their knees in those granite indentations isn’t an opportunity for a good photo op. It’s a heartfelt, sometimes anguished cry for God to look down from heaven, recognize their great act of penance, and show them his favor.
Of course, that’s not unique to Santiago de Compostela. That’s how most of the world believes God’s favor is to be had—by winning it, by earning it. From the woman in New York desperately trying to have an attitude of gratitude so God’s favor will keep flowing into her life, to the man in Mecca marching around the great black Kaaba because this is what Allah requires of him, to the “good Christian” in Dallas going to church on Sunday in an effort to “balance out” what went wrong on Saturday—the human heart simply seems bent toward the belief that if God is going to show us favor, we’re going to have to pay our dues one way or another.
Earned Favor
Why is that? Why do we so naturally gravitate toward the desire to pay our way through, to earn whatever it is that we have? I think it must have at least something to do with the fact that we simply like the feeling of accomplishment, of being able to take credit—one way or another—for what we have. That includes, of course, the favor of God. In a funny way, those knee prints on the step of the Cathedral of Santiago are monuments to human accomplishment as much as they are symbols of humility. After all, those pilgrims made it. Over hundreds of miles, through rain and danger and difficulty, they did it. They won. They accomplished. They beat the Way of St. James. And maybe now God will take notice.
Does that sound familiar to you? It probably does; the desire for credit is a pretty universal phenomenon, I think. Maybe for you it doesn’t have anything to do with stone knee prints, but we all have our trophies, don’t we? It might be a job or a house, a car or a degree, or maybe even a literal trophy or plaque hanging on the wall that recognizes something extraordinary we’ve done. And that’s the thing: one of the main reasons we cherish such things and even display them is so that other people will think well of us, so that they’ll be pleased with us, so that they’ll favor us. In fact, for most of us, the best and most desirable kind of favor we can imagine is a favor we have earned—a favor people give us because we well and truly deserve it.
Oh sure, we like it when good things come our way that we didn’t strictly earn. It’s exciting when we open up the mail to find that unexpected “correction” from the insurance company. It’s fun to be the twelfth caller to the radio station and win tickets to a concert. But for most of us, when it comes to the main structure of our lives, we’d prefer not to live on the basis of other people’s charity, much less their pity. We don’t want people to show us favor and friendship because they have to or because they somehow think it’s right to do so. We want them to favor us because there’s something in us worth favoring.
Our desire to earn people’s favor is, to a large degree, a natural and even a good impulse. So it’s important to me as a father to teach my kids that they shouldn’t live their lives looking for a free lunch. Instead, they should develop a good work ethic and earn both a living and a good standing with other people. In my own life, I want to do a good job at what I do so that people will see benefit in being a part of the church I pastor. In many ways, this desire to earn favor from others is a good and necessary part of being a well-rounded and productive person.
But there’s another question: Does it work the same way with God? Is our relationship with him somehow based on earning his blessings? On the one hand, most evangelicals react immediately against that idea. “Of course not,” they reply. “Salvation is by grace, not works.” And, of course, that’s exactly right. But on the other hand, another part of us always seems to want to assert that even if salvation is by grace not works, God’s favor and blessings are something we can earn for ourselves. And that’s when it starts. If we’ll just treat people a certain way, we tell ourselves, or fill our minds with positive thoughts, or give money to this or that ministry, then God will respond and pour out his favor on us. If we’ll just believe a little harder, pray a little more fervently, read the Bible a little more often, then God’s pleasure will rain down like manna from heaven. It all sounds so simple, doesn’t it? And so satisfying at the same time. After all, everyone loves a good business transaction: I give God this, and he gives me that. Tit for tat, as they say.
Now why is that? Why do we seem so convinced by—and even attracted to—the idea that God’s favor has to be earned? I think there are probably many reasons. For one thing, many of us are quite convinced that, at least on our best days, we really can pull it off. We really can give God a reason to be pleased with us. We can win his favor. Have you ever felt like that? When things are going well, life is clicking, your mind is positive and full of gratitude, you did your quiet time, and you didn’t yell at the kids and even managed to turn that one situation into a deep conversation about their hearts—then, yeah, you’re feeling pretty good about yourself. And somehow we imagine God must be up in heaven giving us an approving nod and a slow clap from the throne. That’s one reason we’re so content trying to earn God’s favor: it’s because we think we can.
Beyond that, we also like the personal sense of accomplishment that winning God’s favor brings. We like admiring our trophies, our knee prints in the stone. When we get right down to it, we are all such self-sufficient people, aren’t we? And if we’re honest, when it comes to the most important things in life, we usually don’t like being given anything we didn’t earn for ourselves. It rubs us the wrong way, steps on our pride, and elbows our self-sufficiency. Think about it: What if someone put their finger in your chest and told you that everything you have and everything you are were simply given to you, that you didn’t deserve or earn or work for any of it, that it was all just charity? If you’re anything like me, you’d be incensed. You’d spit and sputter and insist, “That’s wrong! What I have I worked for.” That’s another reason the idea of earned favor is so compelling: we like to accomplish things; we like to win.
Another reason we want so desperately for God’s favor to be earnable is because, frankly, we like to be applauded by others when we accomplish something. We don’t want to keep our trophies in a closet. We want people to see them and celebrate them. So if it turns out that God’s favor can be earned—if it can be paid for by a moral life or a pilgrimage or a way of thinking or a generous donation—then there’s the possibility of applause for us in the end. And we like that very, very much.
Now at this point, you might very well be expecting me to make a decisive turn against the idea of earned favor, to say something like, “But that’s not at all what the Bible says about our relationship with God!” But I can’t do that. Why not? Because it turns out that this impulse we all have to try to earn God’s favor, to win his pleasure, is . . . exactly . . . right.
That might be surprising, but it’s true. In fact, the Bible couldn’t be clearer that God’s favor not only can be earned but actually must be earned. There’s no other way to get it. Look carefully with me at this passage from Romans 2:
[God] will render to each one according to his works: to those who by patience in well-doing seek for glory and honor and immortality, he will give eternal life; but for those who are self-seeking and do not obey the truth, but obey unrighteousness, there will be wrath and fury. There will be tribulation and distress for every human being who does evil, the Jew first and also the Greek, but glory and honor and peace for everyone who does good. (vv. 6–10)
Do you see what that’s saying? Perhaps more clearly than anywhere else in the Bible, these New Testament verses are telling us the terms of our relationship with God. And they’re stark. If you want eternal life, then persist in doing good; seek glory, honor, and immortality all the days of your life. If you want glory, honor, and peace from God, then do good—always and forever. That’s it; that’s the deal. But if you fail, if you are self-seeking, disobedient, and unrighteous, what you “win” is not eternal life but wrath and indignation.
It’s a pretty simple system, isn’t it? Do this and live; do that and die. If you want God’s pleasure, win it. If you want his favor, earn it. It’s not like this idea shows up in only one or two places in the Bible either (though that would be enough). It’s everywhere, and it forms the fundamental basis of God’s dealings with all of us as human beings. So in Psalm 62:12, David says, “You will render to a man according to his work.” Proverbs 24:12 asks, “Will he not repay man according to his work?” In Jeremiah 17:10, God says, “I the Lord search the heart and test the mind, to give every man according to his ways, according to the fruit of his deeds.” When God gave Adam and Eve their first instructions in the Garden of Eden, this was the deal: do these things and you will live, but if you violate this command, you will die. The New Testament says the same thing: “We must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, so that each one may receive what is due for what he has done in the body, whether good or evil” (2 Cor. 5:10).
Don’t let your mind race over this too quickly. It’s all too easy to use our presuppositions as snow skis—a way to slide right over a truth that doesn’t quite fit with the way we’ve always thought about it. What we’ve been talking about is one of those truths: God’s favor is nothing less than his pleasure, his acceptance, his welcome. It is salvation. And it must be earned.
I’m not kidding. I’m not pulling your leg. And neither was the apostle Paul when he wrote Romans 2. He also wasn’t kidding when he said a chapter later that one day each of us will stand before the judgment bar of God, that every mouth will be stopped, and that “the whole world will be held accountable to God” (Rom. 3:19). That’s a terrifying image, and Paul meant it to be so. What exactly will it be like to stand before God, the One who sees our hearts and minds, who knows us perfectly and intimately? What will it look like when his eyes—which the prophet Habakkuk says are too pure even to look on evil—flash down at us and see our sin? What will it feel like for our mouths to be stopped, that is, for us to realize we have no excuse?
Unearned Favor
Of course, this is where most of us are counting on the situation to change dramatically. It’s where you might even be expecting me to say something like, “But then what will it feel like to see God’s face soften into love and kindness and for him to say, ‘And yet my favor is given to you as a gift’?” It’s even tempting to counter everything I’ve been saying by insisting that, actually, what the Bible teaches isn’t earned favor at all but rather unearned favor. Maybe you’ve even heard a definition like that for the word grace—that it means “getting something we don’t deserve” or “unmerited favor.” I appreciate what definitions like that are trying to say; I really do. But I’m also afraid that, taken too far (which, let’s be honest, is exactly where we tend to take most things), definitions like that actually wind up making God’s grace and favor less glorious, less amazing, and therefore less valuable. They leave us thinking it’s really no big deal at all for God to favor us and welcome us into his presence and that the blessings of eternity are so much candy to be handed out for free at the door of heaven. And that leads us to value them less.
Why? Because saying that grace is simply “getting something we don’t deserve” or that it’s “unmerited favor” isn’t ultimately saying very much. It’s like picking up the restaurant check for a perfect stranger. No, they don’t exactly deserve that favor; they haven’t merited it. But they haven’t done anything not to deserve it either. You might say they’re, well, neutral. Like Mephibosheth.
There’s a wonderful story in 2 Samuel 9 about how David showed this kind of unearned favor to a man named Mephibosheth. Once he had secured the throne and deposed Saul, David called one of his advisers and asked if there was anyone from Saul’s family to whom he could show kindness. “Yes,” the adviser said, “there’s a relative of Saul named Mephibosheth who is crippled in the feet.” He couldn’t walk, which meant he couldn’t work either. David’s actions toward Mephibosheth were a model of unearned favor. He sent servants to Mephibosheth’s home, brought him back to the palace, and gave him lands and servants and a standing invitation to eat at the king’s table. Mephibosheth hadn’t done anything at all to merit or win or earn that royal favor; David just gave it to him.
But here’s the thing: Mephibosheth also hadn’t done anything to lose David’s favor. He hadn’t fought in any wars against David; he hadn’t made a claim to David’s throne; he hadn’t committed sabotage or espionage or treason in any way. He was a blank slate in David’s eyes, neither meriting his favor nor deserving his wrath. And David was kind to him. That’s unearned favor.
If only we were in that same position in our relationship with God. If only we were at “neutral,” having done nothing either to win or to lose God’s favor and pleasure. If only Christianity really was about God giving us unearned favor. But it’s not. Because we are not at neutral. No, our status is actually much, much worse than that.
We have forfeited God’s favor entirely.
