Chapter 17 of 57

14. A New Perspective of Back Talk

14. A New Perspective of Back Talk

14

A New Perspective of Back Talk

In a world where young people find it increasingly difficult to communicate face-to-face, today’s parents need to help their kids learn to articulate their thoughts and feelings as often as possible—even when it takes the form of back talking.

Yes, you read that correctly.

Don’t get hung up on the word back talking. Call it “respectfully speaking their mind,” if you will. Perhaps it may sound like this in your home:

“I thought I told you to clean your room.”

“You did tell me that, and here’s why I didn’t.…”

How many of you would be taking off your belt to teach this kid a thing or two?

At first glance, this kind of talk from your kids may seem disrespectful, or as some of us call it, “back talk.” But what if I told you that allowing this kind of talk can not only open doors for healthy conversations, but it can help your kids learn to say no to drugs or alcohol.

Don’t worry, I’m not advocating letting kids disrespect their parents. I’m advocating allowing kids to respectfully speak their minds. Not “type” their minds, but actually say what they are thinking through face-to-face communication.

Kids who can calmly and confidently disagree with their parents are actually 40 percent more likely to say no to drugs or alcohol than kids who didn’t argue.

Sound crazy?

The University of Virginia conducted the study and published the findings in the journal Child Development. Dr. Joseph P. Allen studied 157 thirteen-year-olds, videotaping them describing their biggest disagreements with their parents. Some parents just laughed and rolled their eyes when they watched these videos. But the parents who wanted to talk with their kids about what they heard were the ones Allen described as “on the right track.” The parents who allowed their kids to dialogue with them gave their kids practice handling disagreements.

Allen interviewed the teens again at ages fifteen and sixteen. “The teens who learned to be calm and confident and persuasive with their parents acted the same way when they were with their peers,” he says. They were able to confidently disagree, saying no when offered alcohol or drugs. In fact, they were 40 percent more likely to say no than kids who didn’t argue with their parents.

One of the biggest complaints I hear from teenagers is that their parents don’t listen. Do you listen? Would your kids say you listen?

How can we expect our kids to put down their phones or tablet and engage in dialogue if we can’t even provide a venue for said dialogue?

Consider the example of the parent telling her kid to clean his room. Is there a chance we may not know the entire situation?

Maybe we should listen to the rest of the story:

“I thought I told you to clean your room.”

“You did tell me that, and here’s why I was delayed. You also told me to feed the dog and finish studying for my SAT test. Molly looked hungry, so I fed her first. Then I went straight to studying because I figured that was the most important. When I finish studying in about fifteen minutes, I’ll get straight to cleaning my room. Is that okay?”

Gulp.

But let’s be realistic. This probably doesn’t happen too often. Some of us may experience much more flawed logic from our kids like this:

“I thought I told you to clean your room.”

“You did tell me that, and here’s why I didn’t. I got a phone call from Taylor, and he really needed to talk. So I talked with him, and he wanted me to check out this comment that Chelsea posted about him. While I was checking that, I noticed that Jake posted lies about Katy, and so…”

Does this sound more like your kid?

This is the type of situation in which parents can rise up and respond back to their kids in a manner that corrects gently while still keeping the doors open for future discussion and avoiding angry outbursts.

Besides, when we give our kids the gift of letting them be heard, we can do one better than just getting them to clean their room. We can teach them to articulate themselves and stand up for what they believe.

Parents need to provide an atmosphere where our kids can freely express their thoughts and feelings. After all, that study revealed that “effective arguing acted as something of an inoculation against negative peer pressure.”

That probably makes a lot of us think twice about simply responding, “Just shut up and clean your room!”

Questions to ponder:

•  Name a recent time something like the above scenario took place in your house.

•  What is your typical response in situations like that?

•  How can you respond better next time?

•  Do you believe allowing kids to speak their minds hinders teaching respect and obedience? How can you balance this?

↑ Back to top

↑