9. Addressing the Elephant…er…the Smartphone in the Room
9
Addressing the Elephant…er…the Smartphone in the Room
This book is packed with ideas for connection and fun conversation with your kids. But what happens when parents feel the need to address the elephant in the room—the kid who won’t look up from his/her smartphone?
I’ve seen polarized responses to this question. On one extreme, we have the parent who is constantly “up in the kid’s business.” This parent has downloaded every piece of software in existence to track her or his kids, monitor their every thumbstroke, and quiz them the second they walk in the door.
“Who is this Chris you were texting at 1:37 this afternoon?” comes the accusatory question when the teen walks in the door.
Sadly, kids of a parent like this one often count the days until they turn eighteen and escape the prison camp.
On the other extreme, we have the parent who just hands the kid a smartphone and delivers the only instructions the kid will ever receive: “Don’t break it.”
These kids never learn anything about media discernment and responsibility. They learn by trial and error, often paying a high price for some of those errors.
Don’t feel the need to float toward either extreme. It’s okay to provide helpful boundaries and to incrementally lessen those guardrails on your kids’ road to independence. In other words, you might start strict, with lots of guidance, but as your kids grow and mature, you can slowly provide them the freedom to make some of these decisions on their own while still under your shadow.
Exactly how strict or lenient should parents be? That’s the one question that still draws debate from experts. But when the smoke clears from this debate, every—and I truly mean every—expert agrees on one common denominator: frequent conversations.
So what does this look like?
Take what you’ve learned so far in this book (notice, affirm, ask questions…shut up) and engage your kids in dialogue about their phones. If you notice their phone distracting them from people in the room, address it creatively. Don’t confront them. Just bring up the issue and ask for their opinion. Share an article, like the many I mentioned in the introduction of this book, and ask them questions.
Consider the 2014 UCLA study I noted at the beginning of this book, observing kids who were unplugged and media-free for five days at an outdoor camp. Ask your kids, “Why were these kids better able to understand emotions and nonverbal cues after five days than kids who were plugged into a normal media diet?”
It’s always shrewd to ask questions about other kids first, instead of directing questions right at your own kids. In other words, don’t ask your kids, “Have you noticed that the smartphone is numbing your brain and turning you into an imbecile?” Instead, start with general questions, and then slowly segue toward questions about their world.
Here’s a sample of what this discussion may look like with a progression of questions. Read a summary paragraph from an article or study, and then follow up with some simple questions, like this:
Take a peek at this bonding experiment where people engaged in conversation with friends four different ways: in person, video chat, audio chat, and instant messaging. Researchers watched people communicate all these different ways and then measured the outcome. The results differed “significantly across the conditions.”
1. Can you guess which communication method helped people bond the most?
2. The greatest bonding occurred during the in-person interaction, followed by video chat, audio chat, and then IM, in that order. Why do you think this was the case?
3. Why is communication more effective when people can see facial expressions?
4. Do you ever notice a group of young people hanging out together, and all of them have their heads down looking at their phone? Why is this?
5. Why do you think people sometimes ignore the people in the room?
6. How can people better maximize face-to-face communication?
7. What might this look like in your world?
(Notice that I didn’t really ask a pointed question until the last query.)
Note: These questions are just a rough outline of what you could ask. You probably shouldn’t ask them all, and you most definitely don’t want to sound like a scientist, or worse, an interrogator when you ask them. So make the questions flow naturally, keeping the conversation simple and age appropriate.
Don’t be afraid to use teaching moments. Keep your eyes open for articles and studies and ask your kids their opinion. Share the AAP report from the “Family Docking Station” chapter, in which doctors recommended no phones in kids’ bedrooms. Ask your kids, “Why do you think doctors recommend this?” Make it a dialogue, not a monologue. Do far more listening than lecturing.
Subscribe to free articles like those I provide on TheSource4Parents.com. I link more studies on that web page than you could ever discuss. Then apply some of the fingertip questions I presented in chapter 3.
When the overuse of (dare I say “addiction to”) technology becomes a problem in your home (and it probably will), don’t be afraid to address it in this kind of calm, calculated, and creative manner.
Questions to ponder:
• What unhealthy use of technology may need to be addressed at your house?
• How can you address it?
• What are some articles or studies you may be able to reference?
• What are some questions you can ask to help your kids open up about this issue?
