4: Money, Money, Money
4
Money, Money, Money
A wise man should have money in his head, but not in his heart.
Jonathan Swift
I once read about a man who phoned a church and asked if he could speak with the “Head Hog at the Trough.”
The secretary said, “Who?”
“I want to speak to the Head Hog at the Trough!”
“Sir,” she replied, “if you mean our pastor, you will have to refer to him with more respect.”
“Oh, I see,” the man said. “Well, all I wanted to do was talk to him about this ten thousand dollars I want to give to the church.”
“Hold on,” the secretary said. “I think the Big Pig just walked in the door!”
There’s an old line that asks, “How much ministry can you do for a dollar?” Answer: one dollar’s worth. Churches are totally dependent upon the generous contributions of those who follow Christ. This shouldn’t be a problem, as the Bible clearly teaches Christ-followers to be generous and to start their generosity with a tithe of all that they earn to the local church of which they are a part.
But it doesn’t always turn out that way. And even if it did, you would still have to work with money.
Pastors find that they have to develop budgets, lead capital campaigns for expansion, institute long-range financial planning, navigate salaries and benefits . . .
And you thought all you had to do was preach.
Making things worse is that one of the most gaping holes in almost everyone’s seminary education has to do with money. It just doesn’t quite fit the curriculum of church history, theology, biblical studies, and homiletics. A theology of stewardship? Maybe. Spreadsheets? Not likely.
But a financial education is one every church leader needs, and needs from day one. So here are five foundational money lessons I’ve gathered over the years.
Teach on It
First, you must, must, must teach on money. Most people think that one of the cardinal rules in church life is to be sure to not talk about money. The conventional wisdom is that it turns people off, and you want to turn people on. That’s a dangerous half-truth, and it has killed church after church that desperately needed someone to stand up and talk about money.
Here’s the truth about people and money. People are incredibly interested in issues related to their personal finances. That’s why they subscribe to magazines about it, go to seminars on it, buy books about it, visit websites devoted to it, and log on to their financial accounts daily. They want to know how to manage their finances in a way that serves them and, as they grow in their spiritual lives, honors God. In fact, many of them are in deep financial trouble and would count financial life change among their deepest of felt needs.
The reason people hate it when the church talks about money is because of the way the church has talked about money. We have had a one-word vocabulary: give. We’ve had one way of talking about that word: guilt. We’ve had one concern when we turn on the guilt for the ask: self-serving institutional needs. So the problem isn’t money; it’s just how we’ve been dealing with it.
When someone attends and is instantly pressured to give, put on a guilt trip if they don’t, bombarded with great big red “giving” thermometers on the wall related to the latest capital campaign, and told they can look forward to the annual ten-week series “Tithe or Burn,” it turns them off.
This is one of the reasons why so many contemporary churches have started to tell guests not to feel obligated to participate in the offering. They say, “Let this service be our gift to you. We are much more interested in you than what’s in your wallet.” The negative ethos was so strong it needed to be defused.
So how do you bring it up? First, help them to see that giving is a matter of the heart. Show that it’s more about them than it is about the church and its needs. They need to give to honor and worship God. We must convey the deeply biblical idea that where your treasure is, there your heart is also. That’s probably the most important move you can make and your most important money message. It’s the heart of discipling someone in regard to stewardship.
Second, make the teaching comprehensive. This means that your teaching about money isn’t simply about tithing but is also about savings, debt, retirement, wise choices, materialism, greed, and envy. Help people with their finances by showing them how real and relevant the Bible is to the day-in, day-out issues they face with their money. Most of them are so strapped and so leveraged that they can’t even see daylight. The Bible is rich in financial guidance and counsel and insight—share it with them, help them apply it to their lives, and let them see how God can impact their financial world when they place it under his leadership.
Finally, when you talk specifically about giving, make sure that you teach them how much it matters—to them and to others. It is a very dynamic act. For example, let them see how giving will make an enormous impact on their personal lives. The Bible teaches some clear things about God’s blessing on their lives if they are generous and tithe, and giving will also provide adrenaline to the growth of their hearts for the things of God. Don’t let the excesses of the “health and wealth” gospel keep you from teaching the real, true blessings that can come.
They should also be taught how much giving matters to the kingdom. Electricity bills don’t get people too excited, but if that’s all people see in terms of their giving and the church, they haven’t been taught well. They need to be told what that electricity bill does. They’re not really giving to the electricity bill; they’re giving to the comprehensive needs of the revolution that God is leading, and through their gift, they’re playing a part in that revolution. What I’m really talking about is vision casting, which is simply helping people get excited about what’s going on so they want to be a part of supporting it.
The first large sum of money I ever had to raise was for the eighty acres of land on which our church now sits. When we raised the money for our land, one of the things I said loud and clear—and I meant it—was that I couldn’t care less about the land itself. I had no need for a big campus, or big buildings, or anything like that.
I told people that when I thought about the land, I thought about the lives that would be changed, the marriages that would be saved, the children who would be taught about Jesus.
I meant it.
Encourage First Steps
A second lesson that is absolutely essential is to be sure to encourage first steps that people take toward financial faith and obedience. Whenever a person makes that first, small step toward God’s leadership over their money, they should get a round of applause. Just like a toddler who takes his first step, when someone gives for the first time, they should get praised!
For example, send a special thank-you note to tell them how much their gift matters. And then, because their step is so important for their life and you’re so encouraged by what they’ve done, send them a free set of recordings of a sermon series on overall financial management that you may have given in the past or a book that celebrates the life of the giver.
Now, that sounds like a lot to do for a first-time donor, but making that first gift is a big step for folks, and they need to be encouraged and thanked. What you are trying to do is take that small flicker that prompted them to give and fan it into a flame of stewardship. By the time you add up the cost of the paper, postage, CDs, and time it takes to send them, many times it’s more than their gift. But it’s an investment in them, and one that is worth it—not just in terms of the support it will bring to the church and its ministries but in terms of the growth of their spiritual life.
Related to this is how you teach about moving toward the biblical tithe. I believe in helping people start where they are and then move toward a full tithe. As mentioned, many people come to Christ with their financial lives in a wreck. Giving 2 or 3 percent would be nothing less than sacrificial. Helping them be responsible to their creditors (which is also biblical) as well as generous is often a process. So we help people get out of debt and build toward a tithe.
I’ll never forget a thirtysomething man who stopped me after a service to say, “I’m there!” I didn’t know what he was talking about at first until he added, “I’m finally at a tithe!” It had taken him over two years, but he had reached the point of being debt-free and generously giving.
Integrity
A third lesson, one that is absolutely essential for any church, is to handle money with integrity. There can’t be even a hint of anything that might be out of sorts.
So first, if you haven’t already, get a bookkeeper, fast. Let him or her handle the money, not you.
Second, move toward a congregationally approved operating budget as quickly as possible. If that’s not your church polity, then get whatever governing authority you have to approve it. Somebody needs to be looking at your budget besides you and giving it a thumbs-up.
Third, get someone else to set your salary, even if you’re a church planter. When Meck started, I pulled aside a group of men to set my starting salary and benefits so that even from day one I could say that I had nothing to do with what I made. Now my salary is set by trustees, members who are set aside and voted on by the church for that task.
A fourth way to build integrity (and this is the one that I think might matter the most) is to have an annual audit of your books from an outside accounting agency. Then let people know about that audit and make the results available to anyone interested. We have done that from day one, and it has bred confidence and a profound sense of integrity. The church at large has an awful reputation when it comes to money, and this allows you to be proactive in combating that image.
Be Positive
The fourth money lesson is to be positive when you talk about money and the needs you face. Nobody wants to give to a losing cause, so when you talk about money, talk about it in positive tones. People give to make a difference. They give because they’re excited about what’s going to happen with their gift. Doom and gloom doesn’t motivate.
Let’s say you’re going to invest in a basketball team. Do you want to invest in one that is going downhill or one that is looking to make the playoffs this year? You want to invest in a winner, right? It’s no different with a church. Don’t lie, by any means, but do try to be positive.
I went to a church once where the pastor got up and said, “Folks, we’ve got a problem. Money, that’s our problem. Money.”
He was just warming up. “See these lights?” he asked as he gazed up at the ceiling. “Well, you won’t be seeing them much longer, because we won’t have the money to pay our light bill. Feel that air conditioning? Feels nice, doesn’t it? Well, you won’t be feeling that for much longer.”
I kid you not. On and on this guy went, going through just about every aspect of the church’s existence on life support. By the time he got finished, I didn’t want to give. I wanted to pull the plug and put the church out of its misery.
The cup can be presented as half full or half empty, and people want to give to one that is half full.
Capital Campaigns Are Capital
Finally, you must resign yourself to the fact that you will have to lead your church through multiple capital campaigns throughout your ministry. It’s the only way to buy land, build buildings, tackle huge kingdom endeavors, and make progress with the vision. Translation: it’s how you turn vision into action. Without capital campaigns, you are consigned to incremental advancement—just running the ball up the middle, over and over, for a yard or two. With them, you can throw the ball down the field for massive yardage and run up the score.
We’ve used capital campaigns to buy an eighty-acre campus, build buildings to worship, serve children and youth, and disciple adults. We’ve been able to purchase land and build a house in the Philippines so that sex-trafficked children can be rescued from brothels. None of that could have been done through our general operating budget. We needed to challenge people to give above and beyond. In the Bible, this is called giving an offering. An offering was anything you gave above and beyond your tithe. A tithe was, in truth, considered to be the bare minimum anyone would even dream of returning to God, because that’s what he had specifically asked for. So periodically, out of gratitude and commitment to God, people would give an offering above and beyond their 10 percent.
I used to dread the idea of a capital campaign. Now I relish giving people the privilege of making such a difference and seeing the kingdom ball advance so dramatically down the field.
Just call me the Big Pig.
