A Proposed Solution
INTRODUCTION
In the first manual of pastoral practice ever written, the apostle Paul defined the church as “the pillar and support of the truth” (1 Tim. 3:15). For many of today’s churchgoers, a pillar and support of truth is not necessarily what they seek when they look for a church. The first concern may be the warmth of the welcome, the style of a church’s music, or the number of weekly activities from which to choose. Faithfulness to biblical doctrine is becoming increasingly rare as the first thing people seek in a church.
The supreme test of a church, however, at least from the perspective of the New Testament writers, is this: Is the church the pillar and support of the truth? Is it thoroughly acquainted with the truth of the gospel as given in the Scriptures? Does it exalt God’s Word, giving it the place of preeminence in all its worship and in all its activities? Does it defend the truth at whatever cost, proclaiming it without compromise in a world of confusion and falsehood? Does it call its people to know God’s Word for the purpose of faithfully living by God’s Word?
THE CHURCH’S TASK
In each generation, the church’s most critical task is to uphold and proclaim the truth as it was delivered to her by her Lord. One important aspect of this task is the diligent preparation of the church’s children to continue to be the support and pillar of the truth in the generation to come. God calls the church of each generation to “contend earnestly for the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints” (Jude 3). When our children replace us as contenders for the faith, will they have a clear grasp of the faith they must defend? When they replace us as supporters of the truth, will they know the truth well enough to articulate it clearly and to recognize counterfeits?
Wise and godly men of another day understood the need for standards of truth and Christian doctrine. They saw the value such standards would have in presenting the fundamental teachings of Scripture in a concise and systematic manner and in providing a grid through which to sift all teaching and all ideas. With great care and much prayer, they worked together to formulate creeds and confessions to define the basic doctrines of the Christian faith. Aware of the importance of passing these doctrines on to their children, they also prepared catechisms for the instruction of the young.
A catechism is simply an instructional guide. It is a handbook of questions and answers designed to teach principles of religion. To “catechize” children is to teach them to memorize the answers found in a catechism, so that when the catechism questions are asked, the children can reply with the correct responses. Because a good catechism is at the same time concise and thorough, when children have learned it well, their understanding of the basic doctrines of the Christian faith can be tested and found to be complete. One excellent catechism is the Westminster Shorter Catechism. In concise fashion, it gives children key biblical teachings about God, Scripture, the Lord Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit, salvation, the sacraments, the Ten Commandments, and the Lord’s Prayer.
Once, catechisms were used routinely. Church and family worked together to provide the most effective teaching possible for children growing up in Christian circles. Parents would work with their children at home, requiring them to memorize the answers to the catechism (and memorizing the answers themselves, as well). Families would discuss together the meaning of the questions and answers. Pastors would preach on topics addressed in the catechism and would systematically visit each church family, asking the questions to see how well family members had learned the answers.
Puritan Pastor Richard Baxter made it his practice to visit each of the eight hundred families in his church in a year, centering his visits on the instruction given in the Westminster Shorter Catechism. Besides examining children and adults to see how well they knew the catechism, he would ask additional questions to see if the answers had been understood. He would then go on to encourage all the members of the family to live in the light of the truth of each memorized answer. Baxter claimed to have more outward signs of success in demolishing the kingdom of darkness among his church members through this practice than through all his public preaching to them.
Unfortunately, the practice of catechizing children has fallen out of favor, both in families and in churches. One reason for this is a fascination with new educational techniques that stress experience, student participation, and choice. Rote memorization has fallen out of favor. Yet, the things I remember best from my childhood are the things I memorized. The “ABC” song we all sing when we have items to alphabetize, the multiplication tables, common nursery rhymes, even lines from Shakespeare that I memorized just because they were beautiful, long before I understood what they meant—all these are indelibly fixed in my memory. I can call them up any time I need them, confident that they will be there to serve me.
It is said that if we require our children to memorize by rote, they will only memorize meaningless sounds and words without understanding them. Certainly we do a disservice to our children if we insist that they memorize words they do not understand, while we fail to take the time to discuss, teach, and explain the meanings to them. The solution, however, is not to discard memorization as a teaching method, but to faithfully supply meaning by discussing and explaining.
THE CHURCH’S FAILURE
There is, however, another, graver reason catechisms have fallen out of favor. It is that doctrinal instruction in general, for anyone and especially for children, has become unpopular. In an attempt to attract nonbelievers, the church has occupied herself with providing the things the world finds attractive. In doing so, she has lost sight of her true purpose of being the pillar and support of the truth.
From the pulpit, comfort, inspiration, and “spirituality” are acceptable; doctrine is not. In a misguided attempt to maintain unity at any cost, doctrinal teaching is shunned because “doctrine divides.” Churchgoers criticize sermons stressing doctrine as not being practical enough, without understanding that a truly changed life flows from a truly changed mind. Eager to meet people’s demands, more and more churches offer warm, inspiring messages that never clearly define the gospel at all. In a growing number of worship services and church programs, entertainment is replacing the substantive teaching of Christian doctrine.
Nowhere are these things more apparent than in the children’s and youth departments of the average American church. In my decade of service as Director of Children’s Ministries for a local church, I sampled many curriculums and received numerous advertisements for others. Commonly, the colorful, glossy promotional materials promised “better games, new crafts, fun experiences your children will really enjoy.” Certainly, there is nothing wrong with “games, crafts, and fun experiences” for children. Those of us who love children want them to enjoy learning. However, when page after page of promotional material describes the fun, while the curriculum’s content is only hinted at in an obscure corner of a brochure, priorities are clearly misplaced.
Advertisers appeal to what research tells them people want. What are the church’s priorities for its children? The advertising for children’s curriculum makes the answer all too clear. That the children are entertained and that they have fun—these are the primary goals to which everything else seems to be subservient.
Even where teaching the Bible to children is a priority, teaching Bible doctrine seldom is. Children hear the same Bible stories repeatedly, almost always as moral lessons on how to behave. Typical Sunday school lessons reduce Bible stories to moral tales much like Aesop’s fables. The focus is on the human being in the story, who becomes its main character. So the teacher comes to the end and concludes, “And you must be like David and God will bless you,” or “You must not act as Ahab did or you will find trouble.”
When Bible stories are used in this way, God sits on the periphery of the narrative, like the genie in a fairy tale, blessing human actors for good behavior or cursing them for failures. Children seldom learn to see that God Himself is the main character of every Bible story. They do not learn to ask about each account they read, “What does this story tell me about God?” They never learn to read all the biblical narratives in the light of God’s overall purpose to redeem a people for Himself. All they learn is: Be good and God blesses; be bad, and He does not. Not only is this a faulty representation of the gospel, it is not the gospel at all! What a tragedy!
God in His grace and condescension loaded Scripture with stories, concrete illustrations of abstract truth. But we must use the Bible stories as God intended them to be used. He gave them to us for the same reason He gave us all of Scripture—that we might know what He, the only true God, is like, and that we might understand the salvation He has provided for His people through His Son. Bible stories illustrate Bible doctrines. We who work with children should be grateful for that and should use the Bible narratives to help our children understand the doctrines of our faith. We waste Bible stories when we only use them to moralize or to equip our children to win Bible trivia contests.
Is the church equipping its children to be the support and pillar of the truth in the next generation? Several years ago, I heard a radio broadcast featuring on-the-spot interviews with Christian authors and publishers at a large Christian convention. Interviewers repeatedly asked attendees two key questions: “What is justification?” and “What is the gospel?” Most of those interviewed proved deplorably incapable of giving a lucid, biblical response to these questions. Yet Christianity is the gospel. The central issue of our faith is that of sinners being justified before a holy God. These things are essential to an understanding of the Christian faith.
If those being interviewed had been taught the Westminster Shorter Catechism, they would have had this response ready: “Justification is the act of God’s free grace by which He pardons all our sins and declares us righteous in His sight. He does so only because He counts the righteousness of Christ as ours. Justification is received by faith alone.” How simple and yet how thorough! Is there any reason people must wait until they go to Bible college or seminary to learn such a simple definition, one so basic to our faith?
Today, we are often content with “God” words and with warm feelings about Him. In a society rife with faulty ideas of God, we fail to give a definition to the word when we use it. Eager to include and to think the best of everyone, we rejoice when we hear those “God” words, assuming the person using them is one of us. When we combine this failure to discriminate with our natural sympathies toward children, we are even quicker to assume children are Christians when, in reality, they have no idea at all what it is to be one.
One summer, at a Christian camp for children from troubled homes, a counselor reported to me a conversation she had with a ten-year-old camper. “I asked him if he had ever asked Jesus into his heart and he said he did that when he was six,” she said. She went on to tell me that they were thumbing through his new Bible together when he saw a picture of the three crosses on Calvary. “What is that story about?” the boy asked, curiously. The result of the discussion with the child was comfort for the counselor, who was convinced that the boy was “saved” because of whatever he had done when he was six. Evidently, however, it never occurred to her that whatever “decision” children may have made, if they have absolutely no knowledge of the crucifixion of Christ, it is not safe to assume they are believers.
A PROPOSED SOLUTION
Those of us who care about passing on the baton of historic Christian truth must awaken to the importance of faithfully imparting its doctrines to our children. We cannot depend on haphazard, hit-or-miss Bible stories and memory verses, hoping that somehow our children will distill from them Christianity’s important teachings. Rather, we must provide careful, systematic instruction in doctrine. Children need a grid through which to sift all that they see and hear. We must provide this for our children while they are still young. Doctrine cannot wait until children are teens, because adolescents are making major life decisions. The theological framework on which to base those decisions, the biblical worldview, must already be in place.
The purpose of this book is to provide a tool for Christian parents and churches who take seriously this task of imparting doctrinal instruction to their children. Questions and answers come from The Westminster Shorter Catechism in Modern English, but the older version of the catechism may be used if preferred. Each question and answer of the catechism has six days’ worth of devotional readings for families to share together. The readings are simply written, with elementary and junior-high children in mind. They are brief, out of consideration for children’s short attention spans and for the busy schedules of contemporary families.
Each reading gives biblical support and simple explanations for the catechism answers. Every day for a week, the same question should be asked and the answer recited several times, followed by the reading provided. By the end of the week, the answer will be memorized. Prizes of some kind can be decided upon in advance, to be awarded after a certain number of questions and answers have been successfully learned. If one answer is memorized weekly, the entire catechism will be finished in two years. Because it contains such a wealth of information and because we remember best what we review repeatedly, I recommend taking children through the entire catechism more than once.
The apostle Paul called Timothy his “true child in the faith.” He instructed Timothy thoroughly and faithfully, then set him loose to carry on the ministry Paul himself had begun. This is what we as parents must do for our children. It is what we, the church, must do for the church that follows us, the church of the next generation. We must fulfill our responsibility now, so that we will be able to say with assurance, as Paul said to Timothy, “Retain the standard of sound words which you have heard from me, in the faith and love which are in Christ Jesus. Guard, through the Holy Spirit who dwells in us, the treasure which has been entrusted to you” (2 Tim. 1:13–14).
J. I. Packer, A Quest for Godliness: The Puritan Vision of the Christian Life (Wheaton, Ill.: Crossway, 1990), 45.
