Chapter XXI. The Modern Church
Chapter XXI. The Modern Church
Part One. The Puritan Movement. The Wesleyan Revival. The Rationalistic Movement. The Anglo-Catholic Movement
In our study of the modern period, the last two centuries and a half-century, our attention will be directed mainly to the churches which arose out of the Reformation. The Roman Catholic Church has pursued its own way, entirely apart from the Protestant world; and is outside our horizon. Our aim will be to sketch very briefly certain important movements which, since the Reformation, have influenced the lands mainly Protestant, as England, North Germany, and America.
Soon after the Reformation three distinct parties appeared in the English Church; the Romanizing element, seeking friendliness and reunion with Rome; the Anglican, satisfied with the moderate reforms accomplished under King Henry VIII and Queen Elizabeth; and the radical Protestant party, aiming for a church similar to those established in Geneva and in Scotland. This latter party became known about 1654 as “the Puritans,” and so strongly opposed the Anglican system under Queen Elizabeth, that many of its leaders were driven into exile. The Puritans also had their division into two elements, those favoring the Presbyterian form, and the more radical element seeking the independence of each local society, known as “Independents” or “Congregationalists.” As yet, however, all these parties remained as members of the English Church.
In the strife between Charles I and the Parliament, the Puritans were strong champions of popular rights. At first the Presbyterian wing became dominant, and under the order of Parliament, an assembly of Puritan ministers held at Westminster, in 1643, prepared the Westminster Confession of Faith, and the two catechisms, long regarded as the Presbyterian and Congregational standards. During Oliver Cromwell’s rule (1653-1658) the Independent or Congregational element triumphed. With Charles II (1659-1685) the Anglicans again assumed power, and the Puritans were persecuted as Non-conformists. After the Revolution of 1688, they were recognized as Dissenters from the Church of England, and obtained rights as separate organizations, entirely outside the Establishment. Out of the Puritan movement arose three churches, the Presbyterian, the Congregational, and the Baptist.
In the first half of the eighteenth century, the churches in England, both Established and Dissenting, sank into a state of decline, with formal services, cold, intellectual belief, and a lack of moral power over the population. From this condition England was awakened by a group of earnest preachers led by the brothers John and Charles Wesley and George Whitefield. Of these, White-field was the greater pulpit orator, stirring the hearts of untold thousands both in England and America; Charles Wesley was the sacred poet, whose hymns have enriched every collection since his day; but John Wesley was the unquestioned leader and statesman of the movement. At the age of thirty-five, an Anglican clergyman, John Wesley found the reality of a spiritual religion among the Moravians, a body of Dissenters from the Lutheran Church. In 1739 he began preaching “the witness of the Spirit” as a personal consciousness, and formed societies of those who accepted his teachings. At first these societies were conducted by class-leaders, but later Wesley called forth a body of lay-preachers, who carried his doctrines and their experience to every part of Great Britain, and to the American colonies. His followers were early nicknamed “Methodists,” and Wesley accepted the name. In England they became known as “Wesleyan Methodists,” and before his death numbered many thousands.
Although for many years violently opposed in the Church of England, and shut out of its pulpits, Wesley always declared himself its loyal member, regarding his society not as a separate denomination but an organization within the English Church. Nevertheless, after the American Revolution in 1784, he organized the Methodists in the United States, numbering at that time 14,000, into a separate church according to the Episcopal plan, and gave them “superintendents,” a title which he preferred to “bishop;” but in America, the name “bishop” was soon preferred and became general.
The Wesleyan movement awakened the Christian life among Churchmen and Dissenters to new power. It also led to the formation of Methodist churches under varied forms of organization in many lands. On the American continent, at the opening of the twentieth century, the enrolled membership of Methodists was more than six millions. No single leader in Christian history has obtained so large a personal following as John Wesley.
The Reformation established the right of private judgment regarding religion and the Bible, independent of priestly or churchly authority. An inevitable result came to pass, that while some leaders of thought accepted the old views of the Bible as a supernatural book, others began to regard reason as the supreme authority, and to demand a rational and not a supernatural interpretation of Scripture. Those scholars who followed reason as against the supernatural, were termed “rationalists.” The germs of rationalism existed in England and in Germany from the beginning of the eighteenth century, but its activity as a distinct movement in the church began with Johann Sender (born 1725, died 1791), who claimed that nothing received from tradition was to be accepted without proof, that the Bible was to be judged by the same criticism as that applied to other ancient writings, that all accounts of miracles were to be discredited, and that Jesus was only a man and not a divine Being.
The rationalistic spirit grew until nearly all the universities of Germany were controlled by it; and it reached its culmination in the publication of Friedrich Strauss’ “Life of Jesus,” in 1835, undertaking to show that the gospel accounts were “myths” or legends. This work was translated by George Eliot (Marian Evans) in 1846, and obtained a wide circulation in England and America. The three leaders who in the nineteenth century turned the current of thought from rationalistic to orthodox channels were Schliermacher (1768-1834), who has been rightly called “the greatest divine of the nineteenth century,” Neander (1789-1850), and The-luck (1790-1877). Rationalistic scholarship awakened a new spirit of investigation, called forth many strong theologians and Bible interpreters in defense of the truth, and thereby caused the contents of the Bible and the doctrines of Christianity to be widely studied and more intelligently understood. For example, the life of Christ had never been written in a scholarly way until the publication of Strauss’ book in 1835; now the intelligent, thoughtful works on the subject may be counted by the thousand. Rationalism, which threatened the overthrow of Christianity, in its effect has developed its strength.
When the nineteenth century was ending the first third of its years, a spirit was awakened in the Church of England, which aroused strong controversy, and in its varied aspects received different names. From its aim, it was called “the Anglo-Catholic movement;” from the university in which it arose it was named “the Oxford movement;” from its promotion through the publication of ninety numbered tracts by different writers setting forth its views it received the name “Tractarian,” and from one of its leading exponents it was frequently spoken of, especially by those who opposed it as “Puseyite” or “Puseyism.”
It was an effort to restore the Church of England from Protestantism back to the doctrines and practices of the earlier centuries when the Christian Church was one, and needed no reformation. The leaders in the movement dated its inception from the publication, in 1827, of “The Christian Year,” by John Keble, a series of poems which awakened a new interest in the church. The formal beginning, however, was a sermon preached by Keble in July, 1833, in St. Mary’s, Oxford, on “National Apostacy.” Soon afterward a series of remarkable “Tracts for the Times” began to appear, on the polity, doctrines, and worship of the English Church, and continued from 1833 to 1841. While Keble inspired the movement, and was in thorough sympathy with it, its leader was John Henry Newman, who wrote many of the Tracts for the Times, and whose sermons from the pulpit of St. Mary’s were the popular presentation of the cause. Another of its advocates was the able, scholarly, and deeply religious Canon Edward B. Pusey. Thousands of clergymen and prominent laymen in the Church of England gave their active support to the movement. Great controversies arose; the leaders were denounced as Romanists in spirit and purpose, but the general effect was to strengthen the power and uplift the standards of the church. As the spirit of the movement was to discredit the Reformation and encourage Anglo-Catholicism, it had an inevitable tendency toward Rome; and in 1845, its great leader, Newman, followed the logic of his convictions into the Roman Catholic Church. His secession, with that of others, was a shock, but did not stop the Anglo-Catholic current.
The results of the Oxford movement have been, an increase of the churchly spirit, a higher dignity of the service, a more loyal fidelity in the ministry, and a stronger authority of the church. On the other hand, its tendency has been to separate the Anglican Church, and in America the Protestant Episcopal Church, from the Protestant communions.
