Chapter 14 of 15

Knowing Good

Knowing Good

No, no, no. He sees her to the bottom and still offers. “He saw everything I’ve ever done.” He said, “I don’t care about your sexual history.” Do you know why Jesus can do that? He can offer us the water of life free, even though we don’t deserve it, because on the cross he said, “I thirst.” When he was up on the cross, one of the things he cried out was, “I thirst.”

Was he just physically thirsty? Probably not. He was being separated from God. His soul was shriveling up. He was experiencing what we deserve to experience because we don’t live the life we should. Jesus Christ went onto the cross and took our sins and took the punishment we deserve so that when we believe in him, God can accept us and give us the water of life freely. That’s grace, and that changes your identity.

What do I mean by that? Some social therapists actually say that everybody has their identity based on difference. That is, “I feel good about myself because I’m not like them.” You know the old prayer that Jewish men prayed centuries ago? You get up in the morning and say, “O Lord, I thank you that you didn’t make me a slave, a Gentile, or a woman.” “I have self-esteem because I’m not a woman, I’m not a slave, and I’m not a Gentile.” What is that? That’s pretty obvious. That is an identity based on difference. In other words, “I’m better than you.”

Honestly, even though it’s not usually that overt, when people say, “I have traditional values” and somebody else over there says, “Well, I am a progressive, open-minded person” and somebody else says, “Well, I am a religious, moral person” and somebody else says, “Well, I’m a free thinker,” you can just tell the background is, “I’m not like them.”

If you belong to any other religion but Christianity, or if you actually think you’re a Christian and pretty much don’t understand the gospel, which is true of many, many people, you believe that you have a relationship with God because you’re a good person, because you’ve tried hard, because you’re moral. Therefore, when you meet somebody who doesn’t believe in God, you can assume you’re better than they are, and then your motivation for sharing your faith publicly is one of pride and arrogance, and you just like telling people they’re wrong.

But what if your salvation was not achieved but received? What if it comes in unmerited? What if your self-esteem is based on a gift? What if your salvation comes not because you’re better but because you have admitted that you’re not better than anybody else and that you need grace salvation and you know you’re loved despite your bad record? That creates a new kind of identity, so that when you talk to someone, if you know you’re saved by grace, not because you’re better, not because you’re wiser …

If you talk to somebody who doesn’t believe, doesn’t have salvation, you would never assume you’re necessarily better than they are, because you’re not saved because you’re better. They might be better. They probably are better. They’re probably wiser in some way or more self-controlled in some way, maybe a better husband, a better wife, a better father, a better mother than you. Why not? Because you’re not saved by being a good father, a good mother, a wise person.

No, no, no. All of the superiority is gone. You have a different kind of identity, and because you have a different kind of identity, because you’ve seen that Jesus has died on the cross for you, because you see that because he said, “I thirst,” you can get the water of life freely, you become part of the solution. You become someone who can talk about your faith out of love but without the haughtiness, without the self-righteousness.

Look at this. He was able to say to her, “I don’t care about your sexual history. I don’t care if you are a hit man for the mob. I can offer you this water of life because I said ‘I thirst.’ ” She goes back to her friends and says, “He saw me at my worst and loved me. I’ve never met a man like this. Come see this man. He saw me to the bottom but loved me to the skies.” You know, she was a great witness, and she didn’t know much about Christianity, really. You and I know a lot more. What is our excuse? Let’s pray.

Father, thank you so much for eternal life. It comes to us through the thirst, the cosmic thirst, the death of Jesus Christ. We do want to be part of the solution. We live in a pluralistic society. We desperately need people who know how to share who they are but in such a way that it’s disarming, respectful, loving, and brave. We pray, Father, that you would make us those kinds of people. Thank you for giving this to us through the grace of Jesus Christ who came not to be served but to serve and to give his life a ransom for many. In his name we pray, amen.

The Sickness unto Death

A Public Faith—October 6, 2013

Ecclesiastes 2:9–26

9 I became greater by far than anyone in Jerusalem before me. In all this my wisdom stayed with me.

10 I denied myself nothing my eyes desired;

I refused my heart no pleasure.

My heart took delight in all my labor,

and this was the reward for all my toil.

11 Yet when I surveyed all that my hands had done

and what I had toiled to achieve,

everything was meaningless, a chasing after the wind;

nothing was gained under the sun.

12 Then I turned my thoughts to consider wisdom,

and also madness and folly.

What more can the king’s successor do

than what has already been done?

13 I saw that wisdom is better than folly,

just as light is better than darkness.

14 The wise have eyes in their heads,

while the fool walks in the darkness;

but I came to realize

that the same fate overtakes them both.

15 Then I said to myself,

“The fate of the fool will overtake me also.

What then do I gain by being wise?”

I said to myself,

“This too is meaningless.”

16 For the wise, like the fool, will not be long remembered;

the days have already come when both have been forgotten.

Like the fool, the wise too must die!

17 So I hated life, because the work that is done under the sun was grievous to me. All of it is meaningless, a chasing after the wind. 18 I hated all the things I had toiled for under the sun, because I must leave them to the one who comes after me. 19 And who knows whether that person will be wise or foolish? Yet they will have control over all the fruit of my toil into which I have poured my effort and skill under the sun. This too is meaningless.

20 So my heart began to despair over all my toilsome labor under the sun. 21 For a person may labor with wisdom, knowledge and skill, and then they must leave all they own to another who has not toiled for it. This too is meaningless and a great misfortune. 22 What do people get for all the toil and anxious striving with which they labor under the sun? 23 All their days their work is grief and pain; even at night their minds do not rest. This too is meaningless.

24 A person can do nothing better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in their own toil. This too, I see, is from the hand of God, 25 for without him, who can eat or find enjoyment? 26 To the person who pleases him, God gives wisdom, knowledge and happiness, but to the sinner he gives the task of gathering and storing up wealth to hand it over to the one who pleases God. This too is meaningless, a chasing after the wind.

The Word of the Lord. Thanks be to God.

Did you know that Herman Melville in Moby Dick (chapter 96) said that Ecclesiastes is the truest book in the world? You knew that, of course, and you knew what chapter, right? Actually, Ecclesiastes, which you just heard read, at least it’s one of the most confusing books of the world (certainly the first time through) because it depicts a very, very, very disillusioned man.

In fact, the very beginning of Ecclesiastes in the very first verses, this is what the author says: “Meaningless! Meaningless! Utterly meaningless! Everything is meaningless.” Then of course, those wonderfully inspiring words there in verse 17 that we read: “So I hated life, because the work that is done under the sun was grievous to me. All of it is meaningless …” The reason it’s confusing is you’re looking at this, and you’re saying, “Is the Bible really saying all human life is pointless?”

To understand what’s going on here, you need to keep two things in mind. In verse 1 of chapter 1 in the very beginning of the book of Ecclesiastes, the author is called the qoheleth. It’s a Hebrew word that’s actually pretty hard to translate, but many people would say it means the professor. Those of you who have been in good graduate seminars know a professor at a graduate seminar doesn’t preach and doesn’t even lecture usually but goads you with questions, tries to get you to think it out for yourself.

The other thing that’s important to recognize is this little term. In fact, you can see it in the very beginning of the reading here. It says, “I became greater by far than anyone in Jerusalem before me. In all this my wisdom stayed with me.” Over and over again, the author says, “So I lived for pleasure, but my wisdom stayed with me. Then I achieved more things in Jerusalem than anyone before me. In all this, my wisdom stayed with me,” which sounds a little strange, but it’s actually an aside. Here’s what he is doing.

It’s an ancient way of saying this is a thought experiment. I am imagining I’m in this situation. You know, if I ask you to do a thought experiment, I’m usually saying, “Imagine this. Imagine this. This is the condition. Now put yourself in this situation. What would you think?” That’s what he is doing.

Every so often he says, “My wisdom stayed with me,” which is a way of saying, “Now look. I’m looking at this, and I’m trying to figure out what it teaches us.” It’s a little bit like an actor who comes up on stage and begins to act a role and then every so often, comes over on the side and speaks to the audience and says, “Now here’s what we can learn about this and here’s what we can learn about this.”

Actually, that’s the secret to understanding the book of Ecclesiastes. It’s a set of thought experiments in which the professor is saying, “So let’s imagine living like this, and let’s imagine living like this.” What do we see? What does that mean? Does that work? “All the time my wisdom stays with me” is his way of saying, “Well, yeah. I mean, obviously I’m doing this as a thought experiment. I’m still myself. I started to live for this, but I was looking at myself.” Got it?

Therefore, if you want to understand what Ecclesiastes is after, we need to look at these thought experiments. Let me show you a long thought experiment and the main lesson. Then in here (the passage we’ve read), there’s a short thought experiment and an arrow. Okay? There’s a major thought experiment with a lesson and there’s a small thought experiment at the very end and then an arrow or a pointer. Are you with me? Let’s go.

1. The major thought experiment

First of all, the main one. The big one. The big thought experiment is how to look at life under the sun. Do you see? Thirty times in the book of Ecclesiastes it uses the phrase “under the sun.” You’ll notice what he says is not that life is meaningless. He says life is meaningless under the sun. It says in verse 11, “… everything was meaningless … nothing was gained under the sun.” You see this. That’s verse 11. That’s also verses 17, 20, and 22. It actually happens 30 times in the book.

Now what does that mean? Commentators and scholars will say when he says, “I looked at life under the sun,” what he meant is, “I considered life here on earth without regard to eternity or God. Let’s make believe for a moment that this life is all there is.” That’s what he is doing. Now this is what’s called a secular mindset, and you have to be careful here. To be a secular person doesn’t mean to be an atheist. Certainly the author of Ecclesiastes here wouldn’t have known any atheists. They didn’t exist back then.

Even today even though we live in basically a secular culture, there’s not a very large percentage of people who are actually atheists. Charles Taylor (a Canadian philosopher who wrote a big book recently that everyone thinks is so important on secularism, on a secular age) says to be secular is not that you don’t believe in God or an afterlife. It’s to say but nobody can know if there’s a God. Nobody can know if there’s an afterlife. Therefore, this world …

By the way, the word secular comes from the Latin word saeculum, which means the present. Basically what a secular mindset is is it says, “Well, there may be a God, maybe not. There may be an afterlife, maybe not. All we can know is this world and this life, time and space.” Therefore, a secular person says, “Well, there may be a God or not, but we have to find our comfort here. We have to find our happiness here. We have to find our meaning right here in this life. This is life under the sun.”

Basically, this major thought experiment, which is a big part of what the book of Ecclesiastes is about, is essentially saying this. The author is saying, “Okay, deal. I am going to look at life as if this life is all we can know, and then I’m going to base my life only on things that can be had here and now. Then I’m going to ask on its own terms is such a life meaningful. On its own terms, is it satisfying?”

That’s what he does. He does this experiment looking at life under the sun in three ways. What does it mean to live as if this life is all there is? Well, one way to do it is what we can call here the pleasure project. In verses 1–11 (it comes down to 1 to 11), he imagines he is living with all the sensual pleasure you want. Sensual pleasure. By that, I mean the pleasure of the senses. In verses 1–11 (even though they’re not printed here) in chapter 2, he talks about he has a harem. There’s sex. He has food. He has houses. He has servants.

He has every sensual pleasure, every pleasure of the senses. He summarizes it in verse 10 here at the top where he says, “I denied myself nothing my eyes desired; I refused my heart no pleasure.” He lived for pleasure. Okay? What happened? He tells you. Verse 11: “Yet when I surveyed all … everything was meaningless, a chasing after the wind; nothing was gained under the sun.”

By the way, that phrase “chasing after the wind” is so perfect to talk about what it means to live a life of pleasure. When you live for pleasure, it’s like chasing after the wind. How so? Well, the wind is something you can feel, can’t you? Certainly you can feel the wind, but try to grab it. Try to actually get ahead of it or try to get ahold of it. You can’t! Pleasure is like that, actually. All pleasure is like that. When you live for pleasure, you find that, yes, it feels good, and yet it fades even as you’re grasping hold of it.

I think I’ll actually read you this. Years ago, there was a woman who lived in New York, and she wrote for the Village Voice. Her name was Cynthia Heimel. Later she moved out to LA, and she wrote not for the Village Voice but for Playboy. She is a very acerbic writer. She wrote a column in the Village Voice in 1989, the year I moved here. In it, she talked about … Again, she was very acerbic, but she was right on.

She had known at that point a number of people who had been working as bouncers in nightclubs and hatcheck girls and things like that and had become famous. She actually named two or three people she knew who had become big movie stars. She named them. She knew her (that big movie star) when she worked behind the cosmetic counter at Macy’s. She knew him (another big movie star) when he worked at a movie theater just punching tickets and things like that. Now they were famous.

Here’s what she said. She either still knew them, or she knew people who knew them. In every case, they were unhappier than they had been before they were successful. They were angrier. They were more anxious. Actually, kind of cynically she wrote this. This is from the clipping.

She says, “… that giant thing they were striving for, that fame thing that was going to make everything okay, that was going to make their lives bearable, that was going to provide them with personal fulfillment and … happiness, had happened. […] They were still them. The disillusionment turned them howling and insufferable.”

That’s exactly the same thing the qoheleth is saying. He says, “You know, when you live for pleasure, it just doesn’t work. It just simply doesn’t. It’s like a chasing after the wind.” On its own terms, living for pleasure isn’t pleasurable, and everybody who lives for it says so. Okay, what else could you do in order to live as if this world is all there is?

The other thing you can do is live for … See, he turns (notice), and he says in verse 12, “Then I turned my thoughts to consider wisdom …” He turns away from the pleasure and he tries wisdom. “Then I turned my thoughts to consider wisdom, and also madness and folly. What more can the king’s successor do than what has already been done? I saw that wisdom is better than folly, just as light is better than darkness. The wise have eyes in their heads, while the fool walks in the darkness.”

Now what is he talking about? What does he mean to live for wisdom? Well, probably since it’s part of this thought experiment of life under the sun, by wisdom here he is really thinking of philosophy. By definition ever since the Greeks, in a sense, invented philosophy, philosophy is trying to use human reason to figure out the meaning of life and how you should live without recourse to religion.

Not that there aren’t religious philosophers, but by and large, the whole idea of philosophy is you use reason, and with reason, you are seeking the meaning of life and how human beings should live without recourse to religion and God and things like that. The Greeks, of course, were the first and maybe the best.

They had all sorts of ways of trying to figure out the meaning of life and what was behind the universe and what were the moral absolutes behind the universe so that if we conformed to them, then we would be living along the grain of the universe, and we would be living full lives and wise lives.

The philosopher’s whole job was to say, “What is the right way to live, and what is the wise way to live? What is a way of living that fits in with the reality of things and the grain of things?” He said he got into that. He started to live for learning and scholarship and wisdom, but look. What happened? Oh, this is amazing, I think. This is one of the great things about this book. This is verse 14. He says, “… but I came to realize that the same fate overtakes them both.” Who? The wise and the fool.

You know the person who is working like crazy to be wise, the philosopher who is trying to think it out, “What is the meaning of life? How should people live? What is right and wrong? What is the meaning of justice? How do we define justice?” You’re thinking and thinking and thinking and thinking and trying to make this world a better place.

What does it say? “Then I said to myself, ‘The fate of the fool will overtake me also. What then do I gain by being wise?’ I said to myself, ‘This too is meaningless.’ For the wise, like the fool, will … both have been forgotten. Like the fool, the wise too must die!” Now this is extremely interesting. In the history of philosophy actually, if you get down to Jean-Paul Sartre and Kierkegaard and Albert Camus and people like that, this is really what they said.

That is, if this life is all there is and when you die you rot and when the sun goes out the whole civilization dies and there’s no one even around to remember anything you’ve ever done, do you know what that means? That means it doesn’t matter how you live. It doesn’t matter whether you’re a nice person or a nasty person. It doesn’t matter whether you’re a philanthropist or a serial killer. The product is the same. Think about this.

What if human civilization lasted a million years (I don’t think it will) or two million years or a billion years? Okay. Nevertheless, in comparison to the oceans of dead time that happened before the universe kind of came together and the earth came together and life began to grow up on the planet and the oceans of dead time after the sun burns out and all civilization goes away, even if human civilization lasted a billion years, in comparison to the oceans of dead time before and afterwards, that’s just like a flick. That’s just like a second. It’s just like a blip.

Everything that’s ever been done, nobody will be around to remember it. Everybody will be forgotten. What that means is nothing you do matters. Nothing you do makes any difference. Nothing you do has any significance final at all. You say, “Well, but it does, because it makes the world a better place.” For how long? See, if this life is all there is, everything you do is insignificant. All philosophy is insignificant. There’s no difference between living a wise or a good life or a foolish or a bad life.

That’s not all. Finally he thinks, “Okay, what about work?” The qoheleth says, “Well, what if I was living for achievement? What if I was living for not pleasure and not wisdom and brilliance and insight but achievement, just hard work?” Well, of course the same thing happens. You can see it in verse 17.

“So I hated life, because the work that is done under the sun …” If this life is all there is … “… the work that is done under the sun was grievous to me. All of it is meaningless, a chasing after the wind.” Why? Well, he gives two reasons, and they’re something. He says, first of all, “I hated all the things I had toiled for under the sun, because I must leave them to the one who comes after me. And who knows whether that person will be wise or foolish?”

By the way, I want you to take that seriously. In fact, let me push you on this. He is absolutely right. This is an absolute fact. There’s no doubt about this. All the people who worked very hard to establish Harvard, Yale, and Princeton and who gave their money to establish Harvard, Yale, and Princeton 200 years ago and back further, you know that if they were suddenly brought back to life and saw what was taught at Harvard, Yale, and Princeton today, they would be absolutely appalled. Right? They’d be totally appalled. They’d say, “I want my money back!”

Everybody says, “Yes, of course, but you see, they were back then. We’re enlightened now. Of course we couldn’t teach what they taught. We’re enlightened now.” But you realize, don’t you, that 100 years from now, your great-grandchildren (if you have great-grandchildren) are going to think you’re just as unenlightened, just as stupid.

The beliefs you have right now that you think are so progressive and so right on and they’re so different than those poor, benighted, unenlightened people from a hundred years ago, you know, people are going to look at you that way in a hundred years. Everything you do, even if you do anything worth keeping and anything that’s lasting, will be used by people who you consider fools.

Therefore, nothing you do will accomplish anything. You’re not going to accomplish anything at all. It’s meaningless if this life is all there is. Here’s what you get for it. Verse 23. “All their days their work is grief and pain; even at night their minds do not rest.” You spend all of your life anxious, all of your life restless, all of your life working like crazy. In the end, it goes nowhere. That’s the end of the thought experiment.

2. The lesson

What is the lesson? Well, the lesson is actually clear. The way to get an understanding of Ecclesiastes is to look at the repetition, the repetitious, the repeated phrases. The phrase “under the sun” is a key to the first thought experiment, and the phrase “Meaningless, meaningless. This is meaningless. That’s meaningless” is the lesson.

It’s saying that if this life is all we can know and if you base your meaning in life on just things that are here, you have no meaning, no lasting meaning, and no sustainably enduring satisfying life. Now you know the new atheists, people who in the last few years have been writing very aggressive atheist books, say that’s wrong. They don’t like what I just said.

See, here I’m saying and what the qoheleth (the professor) is saying is if there is no life beyond the sun, if this world is all we have and we only have to live for what’s here, well, there is no meaning in life. There’s no solid meaning in life. Of course they say, “That’s not true!” Stephen J. Gould, who has passed away, used to teach at NYU and at Harvard. One time he was asked, “Why are we here? What’s our purpose?” He said we’re here because one group of fish had a peculiar fin anatomy that could transform into legs for terrestrial creatures.

Then he said, “We may yearn for a ‘higher’ answer—but none exists.” In other words, we’re here by accident. Nobody put us here. He says, “This explanation, though superficially troubling, if not terrifying, is ultimately liberating …” Why? Because we can’t get meaning in life by looking at nature. We must construct these answers for ourselves.

Richard Dawkins said the same thing. He says, “The truly adult view … is that our life is as meaningful … and as wonderful as we choose to make it.” Here’s what they mean. They said, yes, of course, you can’t … When Stephen J. Gould said you can’t read meaning out of the facts of nature, what he means is you can’t say, “Why were we put here? What is our purpose? What is our meaning? Why were we put here? We weren’t put here. We just came. We’re here by accident. When we die, darkness.”

They say, “But you can decide what you want your meaning in life to be. You can decide, ‘I’m going to live to deal with hunger in Africa.’ You can decide, ‘I’m going to live for this cause,’ or, ‘I’m going to live to be a good artist.’ You decide what you want to live for, and you can have a perfectly meaningful life. You decide what you want to live for.” That doesn’t work.

Not only has the qoheleth, the professor, shown how that doesn’t work … That only works if you don’t think, but it doesn’t work even if you don’t think. Viktor Frankl is the Jewish psychologist who was put into the death camps during World War II, but he survived. He came out, and he wrote a lot of books. Much of what he says I’ve always found fascinating and applicable to a variety of things, but I’ll tell you what I think they are now. Let me apply it to this.

Frankl noted that in the death camp, some prisoners lost everything. Some prisoners became bad. They started to steal from other prisoners. They started to collaborate with the enemy. Other prisoners just became like zombies. They just became lost, and some of them literally curled up and died. In other words, they lost themselves.

There were other prisoners who stayed strong, stayed courageous, stayed brave, stayed caring for people. Here’s the question. Why? Why was it that some people went into the death camps and basically just went away? I mean, they lost themselves. Other people remained themselves. What was the difference? Here’s what Frankl said. It depended on what they made their meaning in life.

If you make your meaning in life something the death camp can take away, then you have no self left. What sort of things can a death camp take away? Anything under the sun. If you live for family, you may think you’re pretty noble. “Oh, I live for my family.” The death camp takes it away. It’s gone. They may be dead. You don’t know where they are. They’re taken away from you. Maybe they’re all dead. So what?

What if you live for some political cause? What if you live for status? What if you live for career? What if you live for making money? What if you live for sex and romance? Whatever you live for, the death camp takes it away from you if it’s something here, something under the sun, some thing. Got it? You don’t have a self left. The only people who stayed strong, stayed themselves, were people who lived for something the death camps couldn’t take away, something that wasn’t under the sun, something like God, something like faith. See?

Therefore, here’s the lesson. You actually can’t create meaning for yourself. You have to discover meaning in something, some reality higher than yourself. Let me say that again. You actually can’t do what Dawkins says you can. You can’t create meaning for yourself. You have to discover meaning by discovering some reality more important than you.

See, if you say, “Well, I decide I’m going to have meaning in life by living for that. No, I think I’ll do that. No, I think I’ll do that,” you don’t really have any higher thing that gives you meaning. You’re just living for yourself. You’re just serving yourself. You’re doing that because it makes you feel good about yourself. You’re doing that because it’s satisfying. You’re just living for yourself. You don’t really have meaning.

There’s nothing that is higher than you. There’s no higher meaning. You don’t have a meaning that will last. Not just death camps, but all sorts of things can take it away from you. You know that. You won’t have a self left. If you live for God, if you live for him, if you base your meaning on something beyond the sun, above the sun, nothing can take that away. You understand.

Therefore, see, Sartre was right, not Dawkins. The existentialists were right when they said this. If your origin is meaningless, if you’re here by accident and your destiny is meaningless, you’re going to nothing … See, Dawkins says, “Okay, we’re here by accident. Nobody put us here. When we die, we rot. Meanwhile, we can have a meaningful life. You can decide what to live for.”

Sartre basically said, “If your origin is meaningless and your destiny is meaningless, have the guts to admit your life is meaningless. Everything in the middle is meaningless.” See, Soren Kierkegaard wrote a book in 1849. It’s a little book called The Sickness Unto Death. Do you know what it is? It’s the spiritual nausea of trying to build your meaning in life on things here and always of being afraid, always being restless, always afraid.

You know, it’s like a chasing after the wind. You never can quite do it. You’re always anxious. You never can seem to quite grab it. It’s a spiritual nausea, a sense of meaninglessness, a sense of futility underneath everything. I think that’s probably where Sartre got his idea for his great work Nausea. If your origin is meaningless and your destiny is meaningless, have the guts to admit your life is meaningless.

3. The small thought experiment

Now that’s the big experiment, and that’s the lesson. What’s the small experiment? There’s a little thought experiment, which fortunately for you if you’re looking at your clock, is not going to take as long to get through as the first one, the main experiment. It’s only here in verses 24–26. See, if you’re reading the book of Ecclesiastes, the word God is nowhere to be seen except just one little place in the beginning of chapter 1.

All through chapters 1 and 2, the word God isn’t here. Why? Because it’s a thought experiment. We’re looking at life under the sun. Suddenly in verses 24–26, God comes up. In fact, all the way to chapter 3, the word God is used 10 times. He says, “A person can do nothing better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in their own toil. This too, I see, is from the hand of God, for without him, who can eat or find enjoyment? To the person who pleases him, God gives wisdom, knowledge and happiness …”

Now suddenly everything is changed. God is back in the picture. We have a new thought experiment. Now let’s look at life with God in the center. Suddenly all the things that before were chasing after the wind where it never was quite in our grasp, were always sort of burdens or emptiness, suddenly these things are gifts.

See, if you look in verse 24, work now is a gift. “… satisfaction in their own toil.” God’s hand gives us satisfaction in our work. That’s verse 24. God gives us pleasure in even our daily food (verse 25). You don’t need harems and feasts. If God is in the picture, even your daily food is a gift. You can get satisfaction in your toil. It says, “To the person who pleases him, God gives wisdom …”

All the things that before were burdens (wisdom, work, pleasure) are now gifts. Why? You say, “Well, I guess it’s just saying you have to base your life on God.” Yes, but how? What, if you make it your meaning in life, will change things such that now the things that were burdens suddenly become gifts? What will give you meaning in life that will last, that will give you solid satisfaction and a solid identity? What is it?

It’s not just obeying God. It’s pleasing him. Twice it says, “To the person who pleases [God] …” I want you to think about that for a second. What does it mean to live for somebody’s pleasure? See, there are many people who say, “Oh, I have lived for God.” When I say, “What do you mean?”

“Well, I went to church, and I obeyed the Ten Commandments. I read my Bible every day. I’m not doing that anymore. I’m not religious anymore.”

“Why not?”

“Well, I prayed, and God never gave me anything I asked for. I tried very hard. I lived a good life, and yet he wasn’t coming forth. I didn’t have good health. I didn’t get into the school I wanted to get into. This and that bad happened.”

Do you know what? It’s possible to obey God not for God’s sake but for your sake. You’re praying. You think you’re very religious, but you’re obeying God to get the things here in this world under the sun. They’re the real reason you’re living. Then you have a meaning in life that is actually just as unstable. You have an identity that’s just as unstable as the so-called secular person.

You may think of yourself very religious, but if you’re living for God you think in order to get things, to get blessings, to get health, to get success, you’re just as unstable as everybody else is. You’ll have that spiritual nausea too. Well, then what should you be? You should be someone who serves God, yes, and obeys God, yes, just to give him pleasure.

Let me tell you what real love is. It’s not just emotional. It’s not just saying, “I want a relationship with you because I desire you. I’m attracted to you, and being with you makes me happy.” That’s part of it, but that’s certainly not the heart of it. Also, love is not mainly volitional. It’s not just, “Well, I have to do my duty, and I have to serve you.” Let me tell you what real love is.

You know you love somebody when you put your happiness into their happiness so that your greatest happiness is just to see them happy. You’ve inserted your happiness in their happiness so that you don’t make them happy to feel good about yourself, and you don’t just seek them just because it makes you … You put your happiness into their happiness so when they’re happy, you’re happy. Their joy is your joy. Their delight is your delight. There is nothing beyond it. Then you know you love somebody. Then you know you love somebody!

The only way to get a meaningful life is not just to obey God in some dutiful way, in which case you’re still essentially building your life on things here that death camps can take away from you (and a lot of other things can too). You need to obey God because you just want to delight him, because you adore him that much, because you love him that much. You say, “Well, how does that happen?”

4. The arrow

This little thought experiment kind of ends, but there’s a pointer in it to something else. Do you know what the pointer is? Commentators point out that God in these three verses is constantly giving gifts. God gives the gift of satisfaction. God gives the gift of finding enjoyment. God gives the gift of wisdom and knowledge.

Then guess what? He gives one more gift. Do you see what it is? He gives the sinner the gift of “… gathering and storing up wealth to hand it over to the one who pleases God. This too is meaningless, a chasing after the wind.” The last thing he gives, the last gift he gives, is he gives people the gift of futility and meaninglessness.

You say, “How in the world is that a gift? Isn’t that a punishment? Isn’t that a curse?” It depends on what you do with it. In Romans 8:20 it says God subjected this world to futility, meaninglessness, in hope.

See, right now if God is giving you an enhanced feeling of meaninglessness and futility in life (this is New York, so I bet you that’s true for quite a number of you), it could be a gift if you let it drive you to where you should go. It could be a gift if it points you, if it gets you, somewhere. You say, “Well, where? What?” Here’s what you should be looking at.

When Jesus Christ died on the cross, he cried out, “My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?” Do you know what he was experiencing when he said that? He was experiencing life without God. He was praying to God, and God wasn’t there. He looked to the heavens, and the heavens were brass. He was stuck here. He was experiencing life without God. He was stuck under the sun.

He was experiencing spiritual nausea, profound nausea, spiritual futility, meaninglessness because God wasn’t there for him. Why was he doing that? He was getting what we deserved. We’ve tried to get away from God, and we deserve life without God and the nausea and the meaninglessness. Jesus Christ came, went to the cross to take the punishment we deserve so God can forgive us. He can love us, and we can connect to him.

Jesus Christ got life without God on the cross so we can have life with God. I’ll put it this way. On the cross, Jesus was putting himself in our lives. He was inserting himself. He was putting himself in our misery. He was putting himself in our mortality. He was going to the depths for us. That’s love!

He couldn’t be happy unless we were happy, so he put himself in our misery. When you see him doing that, that will get you to want to just delight in him. When you see him sacrificing for you, when you see him putting his love into you, his happiness into your happiness, that makes you want to put your happiness into his. It makes you delight in him. That is what you need. You can’t just say, “Well, I need to delight in God. I need to be a God-pleaser. I need to be someone who loves God and obeys God just in order to please him.”

You have to see him do this to attract you so that his pleasure is your pleasure, that there’s nothing that delights you more than to delight the one who did this for you. Then if you can do that, to the degree you can do that, you’ll have a meaning in life that is bomb proof, that is deathcamp proof. Everything in life will become a gift. Wow! That’s quite a lesson, professor. Let us pray.

Our Father, we thank you for helping us to see that Jesus Christ took the meaninglessness of our lives. He took life without God so we could have life with you. When we see him doing that, that makes us want to please him. Now, Lord, as we partake of the Lord’s Supper, as we see, in a sense, you pouring yourself out for us, O Lord Jesus Christ, move us so we can delight in you more deeply and have the life of meaning that sees everything as a gift. We thank you for this. We pray you’d apply it to our hearts by the Holy Spirit. In Jesus’ name we pray, amen.

Facing Doubt

A Public Faith—October 13, 2013

Psalm 73:1–3, 12–26

1 Surely God is good to Israel,

to those who are pure in heart.

2 But as for me, my feet had almost slipped;

I had nearly lost my foothold.

3 For I envied the arrogant

when I saw the prosperity of the wicked.

12 This is what the wicked are like—

always free of care, they go on amassing wealth.

13 Surely in vain I have kept my heart pure

and have washed my hands in innocence.

14 All day long I have been afflicted,

and every morning brings new punishments.

15 If I had spoken out like that,

I would have betrayed your children.

16 When I tried to understand all this,

it troubled me deeply

17 till I entered the sanctuary of God;

then I understood their final destiny.

18 Surely you place them on slippery ground;

you cast them down to ruin.

19 How suddenly are they destroyed,

completely swept away by terrors!

20 They are like a dream when one awakes;

when you arise, Lord,

you will despise them as fantasies.

21 When my heart was grieved

and my spirit embittered,

22 I was senseless and ignorant;

I was a brute beast before you.

23 Yet I am always with you;

you hold me by my right hand.

24 You guide me with your counsel,

and afterward you will take me into glory.

25 Whom have I in heaven but you?

And earth has nothing I desire besides you.

26 My flesh and my heart may fail,

but God is the strength of my heart

and my portion forever.

This is God’s Word

We’re in a series called A Public Faith: Sharing the Hope That’s Within. We live in a Western society that does not encourage people to be public about their faith, their religious beliefs. We’re told basically it’s a private thing; we shouldn’t be talking about them. It’s ironic, because our culture actually encourages us to be absolutely open and public about everything else, including sexuality, because it’s who we are.

There’s nothing more fundamental to who you are than your religious beliefs, than your deepest faith beliefs. Therefore, the challenge before us as a society is … how can we be honest about who we are, which means how can we be public about our faith beliefs, and yet do so in such a way that is respectful and supports the peace? We all have to learn that, and one of the things we’re doing in this series is talking about that.

Now if we’re going to become a mature society in which we’re able to talk about faith, we also have to be able to know how to talk about doubt. We don’t get much help here from either religious people or secular people. Religious people tend to see doubt as a very bad thing, a terrible thing, and around many religious people, it doesn’t feel safe to express doubts.

On the other hand, many secular people, certainly in a place like New York City, believe that perennial doubt, constant doubt, deep skepticism, is the only sophisticated and intellectually mature position. The Bible, however, doesn’t look at doubt anywhere nearly as positively or as negatively as that. The Bible doesn’t see it as positively as secular people do or as negatively as religious people do. Actually, doubt is not so simplistic. It’s not all good. It’s not all bad.

Only when you begin to see it in a nuanced way can doubt actually be something through which we make progress. Now in order to understand what the Bible says about doubt, we’re going to look at this very famous psalm, this very famous passage. We’ve read the beginning and the end of it. Just for economy’s sake, we left out a certain part of the middle, which I’ll refer to. It’s very rich, and it’s the case study of one man’s (his name was Asaph, the psalmist) experience of doubt and how he moved through that doubt to actually a higher level of faith.

Even though his circumstances may not exactly be the same as yours, nevertheless, the basic principles of what the Bible says about doubt … I actually think what the Bible says about doubt is almost unique. I don’t know of anywhere else to look in which doubt is not so good and not so bad but this nuanced, multidimensional thing. There’s no better place to find that biblical view than here. So let’s look at doubt in this passage under three headings: What is it? What causes it? What transforms it?

1. What is it?

The metaphor for doubt that’s used is in verse 2: “But as for me, my feet had almost slipped; I had nearly lost my foothold.” That’s a great image. When you’re losing your foothold, for a moment you’ve lost your balance, and when you’ve lost your balance, you’re experiencing a kind of vertigo, a kind of disorientation, a certain dizziness.

One of the Greek words in the New Testament for doubt is dipsychos, which means two psyches, which basically means spiritual double vision. If you have double vision, it means your eye is not giving your brain sufficient information to know where to put your foot. When you’re not quite sure where to put the foot, there’s an uncertainty. That’s what doubt is. Spiritually, it’s this uncertainty. You lose the certainty you might have had before. That’s doubt.

Now what do we learn right off the bat about doubt from the very introduction here in the beginning? First of all, we learn anybody can have doubts. Even though we don’t know much about Asaph, the author of the psalm, we don’t know much about who this guy is, still, he was an author of the Scripture.

That’s a rather high level of spiritual attainment, don’t you think? Here’s somebody who wrote Scripture, divinely inspired. Yet here is a man who, in spite of his level of spiritual attainment, was filled with doubts. He said, “I almost lost my foothold,” which means, “I almost lost my ‘faith-hold.’ ” So anybody can have doubts.

The other thing we learn almost immediately, just by the quick read-through, is that doubt can be a positive thing. Here you have doubts that, by the end of the psalm, will have led to a higher level of faith and some of the most famous affirmations. “My flesh and my heart may fail, but God is the strength of my heart and my portion forever.” In other words, there has been progress here.

The idea of doubt and questioning leading to progress shouldn’t be all that strange. Francis Bacon, who was one of the first modern scientists a couple hundred years ago, has a place where he basically says (he’s kind of overstating it a bit, but he’s right), “If you begin with certainties, you will end in doubts; if you begin with doubts, you end in certainty.”

What he’s really saying is as a scientist, if you look at what right now is accepted by people … If you don’t question that, if you just accept everything that is told you, you’ll never grow. You’ll never grow to new realms of understanding if you just accept things. No, no. The scientific method is based on doubt. Ask questions. Be skeptical. Don’t accept things. What he’s saying is if you start with certainties, you actually will find you don’t learn as much, and if you start with doubts you learn more.

That’s obviously in any area of inquiry, but spiritually it is true too. The most famous place in the Bible that talks about doubt is doubting Thomas. Thomas was one of the twelve disciples. After the death of Jesus Christ, there was a meeting of the disciples, and the resurrected Jesus appears and shows that he is alive. The problem is Thomas missed the meeting.

I remember some years ago I heard a preacher say in Isaiah 6, Isaiah went up to the temple and saw the Lord high and lifted up. His train filled the temple, and there were angels saying, “Holy, holy, holy,” and Isaiah fell on the ground as dead. I remember the preacher said, “Of course. He went to church, and the last person he expected to actually see there was God.” In the same way, Thomas is a warning to you: never miss church. You never know. Jesus might show up and you missed him. I admit it doesn’t usually happen, but sometimes it does.

Thomas hears that Jesus has been risen from the dead, and all of the disciples said, “We saw hm.” Thomas says, “I will not believe unless he appears to me and I not only see him, but I see the nail prints still in his hands and I can put my fingers in the nail prints.” What does Jesus do? Jesus appears to Thomas and remarkably does not say, “Thomas, why did you question me?” No. The first thing he says is, “Okay, you wanted to see my hands? You wanted the nail prints? Here they are. Put your fingers in.”

Of course, Thomas responds with the great confession and affirmation, which in a way is the climax of the book of John. He says, “My Lord and my God.” There is no place in the book of John where anybody looks right at Jesus Christ and says, “You’re God.” In other words, this expression of doubt brings Jesus into Thomas’ life and leads Thomas to a higher affirmation of faith than he would have had if he hadn’t asked the question, if he hadn’t doubted.

See, on the one hand, Jesus doesn’t say, “How dare you question me?” He gives Thomas what he asked for. On the other hand, he ends by saying, “So Thomas, stop doubting, and start believing.” This is where the Bible shows us an attitude toward doubt that neither religious people nor secular people have. It’s not nearly as bad as religious people say it is, and it’s not nearly as good as secular people say.

He says, “Look, don’t acquiesce in your doubt. Let the doubt drive you to something else.” At the same time, Jesus doesn’t squelch the doubts at all. So there’s some important understanding about doubt and the vertigo and disequilibrium it brings, but also the positive it can be.

2. What causes this man’s doubt?

There are two things he points out. First of all, he says, “I saw something.” Secondly, he says, “I experienced something.” What did he see? Verses 1–3 put it in a nutshell: “God is good to those who are pure in heart.” That’s the traditional, biblical doctrine of God. God is a good God and he cares for the pure in heart.

That doesn’t mean sinless; it means people who are committed to God. So he starts off with good theology: “God is a good God and he cares for the pure in heart.” But down in verse 3, it says, “I saw the prosperity of the wicked.” Then verses 4–11, which we didn’t read for the sake of economy, say things like this. He’s looking at the wicked. What does he mean by that? He says:

“They have no struggles; their bodies are healthy and strong. They are free from common human burdens; they are not plagued by human ills.… they clothe themselves with violence. […] with arrogance they threaten oppression. […] They say, ‘How would God know? Does the Most High know anything?’ ”

What Asaph, the psalmist, is saying is in this universe, in this world, supposedly under a good God, people who promote themselves, people who manipulate others, people who exploit others, are having a great life. By the way, this didn’t just happen then. The fact is this world is such that proud, self-promoting, ruthless, manipulative, egocentric, exploitative behavior can make you a lot of money, can make you pretty successful, can help you up the power ladder.

What he’s seeing isn’t anything we haven’t seen forever. He’s bothered by it. He says, “Why would a supposedly good God who’s in charge of this world allow that kind of injustice, allow the powerful to oppress the poor and the marginalized?” So that’s the first thing. But it’s not just an intellectual problem. It’s not just he sees something; he experiences something firsthand.

In verses 13–14, he says, “Surely in vain I have kept my heart pure and have washed my hands in innocence. All day long I have been afflicted, and every morning brings new punishments.” Tell me if this doesn’t sound familiar. Basically, he’s saying, “Look, I tried to be pure. My understanding was that God cares for the pure in heart, so I’ve tried to keep my heart pure. I have washed my hands in innocence. But it seems to be in vain, because all day long I’m afflicted and every morning brings new punishments.”

We don’t know what they were, but the point was his life was so filled with bad things that almost every day he felt like he woke up and learned something new was wrong. Finally, he says in verse 16, “When I tried to understand all this, it troubled me deeply …” In other words, he’s not just having an intellectual problem; he’s having a personal experience, and that personal experience means things he believed with his mind are now not very real to his heart, like the love and goodness of God.

Now here’s what we learn. Let’s pull out of this, because you might say, “Well, that’s not my problem exactly.” Okay, be careful. Don’t get lost in the weeds here. We step outside of it a little bit and go a little bit higher up, and here’s what we see. Doubts come from a combination of reason and rationality and personal experience.

Let me put it like this: all of our doubts, as well as all of our faith beliefs, are always the product not just of thinking and reasoning, but a combination of thinking and reasoning and logic and intellectual thought, as well as social and personal experience. How so? Well, let’s talk about this. What do I mean by that?

First of all, social and personal experience. Social experience. There’s a whole field of sociology called the sociology of knowledge. The sociology of knowledge essentially says that we think we’re arriving at our beliefs by thinking and working these things out, but, to a great degree, we find most plausible the beliefs of people we want to like us.

Can I say that again? I’m boiling down an entire course in sociology of knowledge, which some of you paid thousands of dollars for. If you had only been here first, you would have been able to save that and said, “Oh, I got that.” Here it is: you tend to find most plausible the beliefs of people you want to like you.

We have certain circles we want to be part of. We have certain social situations we want to be included in. We have people we identify with. “These are our people. These are the kinds of people I want to be identified with.” For some strange reason, those people’s beliefs just seem more plausible to us than other people’s. Why? Because we are not just brains in vats. We are social creatures. We’re not just rational creatures.

Therefore, who we hang out with and what they say has an enormous impact on what seems credible and plausible to us. So your social experience has a lot to do with not only forming your beliefs, but also forming your doubts. But there’s also the personal experience. Our beliefs are not simply a product of reasoning; they’re also the product of personal experience.

You may read a book or you may get a class in which people are saying, “The founding documents of the American republic are absolutely right. All people are created equal. The races are created equal. Individuals are created equal. Everybody has equal dignity.” But what if you meet two or three members of a particular race or nationality, and you’ve never met anybody else from that race or nationality, and those are nasty people to you?

They’re nasty to you. They’re cold to you. They’re cruel to you. They’re the only three people you’ve ever met. I want you to know that no matter what the book says, you’re going to have a visceral negative personal feeling that there’s something wrong with those people. In other words, your racial attitudes and your beliefs, to a great degree, are determined by the personal experience.

That’s unavoidable, because we’re not just rational creatures. We’re not just robots. We’re not just computers. We’re social beings, personal beings, as well as rational beings. Therefore, your beliefs as well as your doubts come from a combination of thinking and experiencing, which means if you’re in doubt, if you’re doubting things you used to be certain of, it’s because a combination of reason and personal experiences has now made those beliefs unreal to your heart.

“Now what does that matter?” you say. Here’s why it matters a lot. On the one hand, I want you to avoid falling into one of two opposite mistakes. The one mistake is to think if you have fallen into doubt about Christianity, it’s strictly an intellectual thing. It’s not very flattering to admit the degree to which we are socially shaped, the degree to which our experiences shape us.

Let’s just say you were raised in a church, raised in a Christian belief, and then you go off to some really great, elite academic institution, and everybody around you, all of your friends, all of the people you want to be included with, all of your professors, are all laughing at traditional religious belief.

Then you pick up a book and read Sigmund Freud, The Future of an Illusion, and say, “Oh, that convinced me Christianity isn’t true.” Come on. It’s not just that. You know that. It doesn’t work just that way. Nobody works that way. You were set up by your social environment to find what Sigmund Freud said to be pretty plausible. I’m not saying he didn’t have good arguments. I’m just trying to say recognize the fact that your doubts are not simply intellectual. They’re also personal.

On the other hand, do not think you can’t reason and you can’t think. Don’t fall into the other extreme, which is to say, “Well, all of our beliefs are just the product of our culture. You’re from Madagascar. You’re from Canada. You’re from here. You’re from there. You’re this race. Of course you’re going to believe that, because all of our beliefs are socially constructed, and that’s just the way it is.”

Peter Berger, who was a pioneer in sociology of knowledge, wrote a little book some years ago called A Rumor of Angels. In that book he has a great, great little chapter called “Relativizing the Relativizers.” In it he says something like, “In my field, which has empirically proven that people are very, very shaped in their beliefs by their culture and by their social location, it’s sometimes common to have people say all belief is socially constructed and therefore, you can’t trust it.

Everybody is just the product of their culture. Everybody is just the product of their social setting, so you can’t trust their beliefs. All beliefs are socially constructed.” He says the only problem with that statement is that statement is a belief. If all beliefs are socially constructed and can’t be trusted, then that belief is the product of your social situation and it can’t be true, and if it can’t be true, then all belief isn’t socially constructed. Relativism always eats itself.

So what are we left with? He says we’re fine. We should have chastened, humbled views of ourselves. We should realize to a great degree we’re not objective. To a great degree we don’t like to think outside the box of our social setting, and yet we have to. Peter Berger says in the end you have all of these competing truth claims. We can’t say we’re just socially constructed, and therefore, we can’t weigh our beliefs, because that belief would be socially constructed, and therefore, in the end, we still have to say which of these beliefs is true. We still have to think.

Don’t just say, “Well, I’m just prejudiced.” Why? “Well, the three people I met from that race were all mean and cruel to me.” Think. Do you think that maybe in your race there might be three cruel people? Don’t you think it’s possible that maybe somebody could run into three cruel people from your race and think all of you are that way? Think! So on the one hand, your doubts are not just from thinking, but on the other hand, you still have to think if you’re going to process the doubts.

3. What transforms doubt?

All right, so how does he process the doubts? How does the doubting become something he doesn’t get stuck in but essentially uses to move himself up to a whole new levels? Three things (this shouldn’t completely surprise you since we just talked about it): experience, thinking, and an enlarged view of God.

First of all, experience. This is going to be kind of counterintuitive. Where does the turn happen? In verses 1–16, he’s oppressed. “I tried to understand all this, and it troubled me deeply.” Then in verse 17, he says, “Until …” There’s the turn. Things started to turn around right there. What happens? What’s the first thing he does? “… till I entered the sanctuary of God; then I understood their final destiny.”

Don’t make this mistake. Don’t think he was walking along the road and saw one of these big beautiful cathedrals, which we have in New York. You notice the door is open and it looks beautiful in there, so you go on in. It’s a beautiful sanctuary, and you sit down and just sort of think. That’s not what he’s talking about. Do you know why? Because the only sanctuary would have been the temple, and what happens in the temple is worship.

He went to a worship service. He heard the Word of God sung. He heard the Word of God preached. He heard people singing. He was surrounded by believers. You say, “Well, that’s a strange thing to do.” No, that’s not a strange thing. Here’s why: it’s fair. If you acknowledge (and I don’t know how you fail to do this) that your doubts did not come strictly through thinking, then you’re not going to get through your doubts strictly through thinking.

If your doubts came, to some degree, because you were in social and personal locations where God seemed less real, then it’s only fair to level the playing field and go to some place where God seems more real. Go to a place where people believe in him. Go to a place where people are talking about him. Go to a place where there’s art. Go to a place where there’s teaching. In other words, at the very least, pray.

You say, “My goodness, I don’t understand that. If you have doubts about God, how can you pray to him?” I don’t know. I’ve had a lot of people who had doubts about me, and they came and talked to me about it, and it helped the relationship. I’d rather you not sit around and think about, “What do I think Tim is like? Maybe he’s like this. Maybe he’s like that.” Well, come ask me. Let’s talk about this thing.

In the same way, if you drifted away from belief through a combination of thinking and experience, why shouldn’t you come back to belief or through belief through a combination of not just thinking but also experience? He didn’t just go off and think; he went into the sanctuary. So that’s the first thing. He was willing to put himself in an experiential location where God seemed real to him. It cleared his mind. He says, “… till I entered the sanctuary of God; then I understood their final destiny.”

The second thing is he does do some thinking. He does some profound thinking here. There’s more in here than I’ve ever thought about. Every time I preach this I keep thinking, “Maybe I’ll go a little longer and give you a few more.” No, I can’t really, but I still want to show you two things he does, two profound ways he thinks through this.

First, he is willing to admit his bad motives. Notice in the very beginning he talks about how he sees all this injustice. “Why are the powerful oppressing the marginalized?” Notice what he says. Even in the beginning he’s willing to be this honest. He says, “But as for me, my feet had almost slipped; I had nearly lost my foothold. For I envied the arrogant …”

Isn’t that interesting? This is not just an intellectual problem. “I was resentful because I’d like to have that kind of power. I’d like to have that kind of wealth.” He’s very, very involved emotionally in this. That’s why he says, “Wait a minute. I kept my heart pure. I’ve washed my hands in innocence. I deserve what they have.”

Again, he’s not simply having an intellectual issue. It’s not completely objective. His motives are involved. Or put it like this: until you admit that you find it hard to believe “X” is true partly because you don’t want “X” to be true, you’re never really going to come to grips with the pros and cons of the belief. You’re never really going to be intellectually honest.

Thomas Nagel, who’s a professor of philosophy, a very prominent philosopher at NYU … I have the greatest respect for the man for a lot of reasons. Some years ago, he wrote a book called The Last Word. Though he’s a convinced atheist and argues very eloquently for it, nevertheless, in this book he writes:

“[I want to talk about] the fear of religion itself. I speak from experience, being strongly subject to this fear myself: I want atheism to be true … It isn’t just that I don’t believe in God and, naturally, hope that I’m right in my belief. It’s that I hope there is no God! I don’t want there to be a God; I don’t want the universe to be like that.” Then he adds in a little footnote, “I am curious, however, whether there is anyone who is genuinely indifferent as to whether there is a God …”

This is what I mean by saying it’s such intellectual honesty. He talks to atheists who say, “The only reason I’m an atheist is I looked at all the evidence very objectively and decided the evidence was there was no God.” He says, “Listen, nobody is objective about this. Sure, you can say, ‘Well, Christians are people who want to believe in an afterlife. They want to believe if they believe in God they’re going to live forever with their loved ones.’ ”

But here he’s saying, “But atheists know if there is a God, they can’t live the way they want to live.” He says, “I don’t want the universe to be like that. I don’t want to have that limitation on my freedom.” Therefore, he says, “Nobody is objective. You have a lot of reasons for not wanting God to exist, and you may have some reasons for wanting him to exist. Admit it.” That intellectual honesty is crucial. Admit your motives. Admit you’re not really that objective. It doesn’t mean you might not still come down where you were, but you should recognize that.

Here’s the second thing: he comes to recognize the deep faith that is hidden in all doubt. Deep faith is embedded and hiding itself in all doubt. I think this is the most profound thing he sees. It’s not that easy to see right off the bat until you put the stuff together. Notice how he says, “… till I entered the sanctuary of God; then I understood their final destiny.”

Here’s the money quote. Here’s the main thing he saw: “Surely you place them on slippery ground …” Now remember the metaphor here. This is a metaphor: your foot sliding, your foot slipping. He has already used it. What is it a metaphor for? Where your foot is is where you have your faith. It’s the thing you have your faith in. Therefore, when your foot slips, it means you’re having trouble keeping your faith.

Now he turns around and says, “Now wait a minute. Their foot is somewhere too. They have faith in something, and where their faith is is even more precarious than where my faith is.” What does that mean? Remember, I’ve already read this to you once. In verse 11, when describing these oppressive people, he says, “They say, ‘How would God know? Does the Most High know anything?’ ”

See, these people who are living very selfishly, who are being cruel and exploiting people, are doing it on the basis of a view of God. They say, “How can God know? Does the Most High have knowledge?” What that means is they’re assuming there either is no God or there’s a God who isn’t going to judge them. In other words, they’re assuming either God is not there or God does not care. Either there’s no God or he’s some kind of pantheistic, force-field kind of God who isn’t going to judge them for how they live.

They are living, then, on the basis of a view of God they can’t prove. If you are assuming in the way in which you live a view of God you can’t prove, what is that? That’s faith. You cannot prove God, maybe, but you can’t prove there is no God. You can’t prove there isn’t a God who’s going to judge you. Therefore, when you live as if that God is not there, that is an act of faith. You are betting your eternal destiny that either God is not there or he’s not a God who cares. Blaise Pascal talks about that in his famous “Pascal’s wager.”

If you’ve ever heard about Pascal’s wager or heard it presented, you probably have heard it presented in the worst possible light. I’ve never heard it presented in a way that’s as powerful as it really is if you read it and think about it. Here’s what Pascal was trying to say: “Sure, if you believe in God it’s a step of faith, but if you don’t believe in God or live as if God is not there, that is also a step of faith. That’s a huge step of faith. You’re basing your life, no matter how you live, on a view of God you can’t prove; therefore, everybody is living by faith.”

Not only that, but why is he saying at the end, “Whom have I in heaven but you? And earth has nothing I desire besides you. My flesh and my heart may fail, but God is the strength of my heart and my portion forever.” Why is he saying that? A portion is your inheritance. A portion is your wealth, your security. For him to say, “God is my portion,” he’s comparing his portion to theirs.

See, if God is your portion, if God is the thing you’re living for, if God and his love is what you’re living for, nobody can take that away from you. If wealth is what you’re living for, if power is what you’re living for, like these people he was envying so much, that can be taken away in a second. They’re the ones who have put their faith in power, in money, in accomplishment, in acclaim, or whatever.

They’ve put their faith, their feet … They’ve rested their souls in something that can be taken away from them forever, just like that, quickly. Therefore, he’s saying, “Wait a minute, wait a minute. Here I’m getting filled with doubts, yet I realize the alternative …” Remember, he envies them, which means he actually was thinking about, “What would it be like to live like them?”

He suddenly realizes, “For me to live like them would mean I would have to put my faith in there not being a God, which I can’t prove, and I would have to rest my soul in these things that could be taken away forever. Wait a minute. They’re in a more slippery place than I am. Their faith is less well grounded, and they are living by faith.”

In the heart of his doubt, he was beginning to say, “Maybe I’ll live like these people instead of the way I’ve been living. But that would take faith. It would take an enormous amount of faith.” He says, “No, no, no. The faith I have is better.” Do you see what he’s doing? This is the reason Sheldon Vanauken in his book A Severe Mercy, when he’s talking about how he became a Christian …

First of all, he talks about the fact that he realized to become a Christian he had to believe in Jesus Christ. He didn’t like that, because he wanted to be certain, and he wasn’t getting … Here’s what he says: “[I saw] a gap between the probable and proved. How was I to cross it? If I were to stake my whole life on the risen Christ, I wanted proof. I wanted certainty. […] I wanted letters of fire across the sky.” He was shrinking back.

To paraphrase, he says, “But then I realized, O my God! There was a gap behind me. Yes, there would have to be a leap of faith to accepting Jesus Christ, because I couldn’t prove that Christ was God, but by God, I had no proof that he was not. This was not to be borne. I could not reject Jesus without great faith. Once I realized it would take faith for me to jump over the gap behind me, I flung myself over the gap in front of me toward Jesus.”

Now here’s the last thing, and this is extremely interesting and important. The man expands his view. He doesn’t just experience. He doesn’t just think. He expands his view of God. Thomas Kuhn wrote a book called The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, a very, very famous book. What he tried to say was that all of us have paradigms. We have ways of thinking about life, and we have doubts when the paradigm receives some data it can’t account for.

When it can’t account for it, then there’s a paradigm shift, which means you experience doubt, but then you expand the paradigm so it can explain the data you couldn’t understand. For example, have you ever seen this with little children? Generally, little teeny children, as they grow up, trust adults, because the only adults in their lives are their parents and maybe aunts and uncles and their babysitter and all that. They expect all adults to be self-controlled and do this and that.

At some point, the little child will see an adult doing something she never thought in a million years adults would do. Then Mommy has to sit down and say, “Now honey, you have to understand something. Your theory of life, your paradigm of human nature is small. You’re 4. You didn’t think adults could act like this, but honey, adults really can act like this.” What’s happening is she’s going through a paradigm shift. Her theory of life was too small to handle the reality.

I want you to consider that when doubts come into your life, it’s because your understanding of God was too small to handle it. The way to get through it is not just simply to go back to the way in which you believed before. You have to have a broader view of God, a bigger view of God, and that’s exactly what he does here.

Do you know where the heart of it is? It’s here in verses 21–23: “When my heart was grieved and my spirit embittered, I was senseless and ignorant; I was a brute beast before you. Yet I am always with you; you hold me by my right hand.” Look here. He has changed his view of God. When he talks about himself as a beast … “I was a brute beast.” Let me give you two little stories.

Elisabeth Elliot, missionary and writer, once told a true story about how she was visiting with some farmers, some shepherds, in the highlands of Northern Wales. She found out that once a year they have to take their sheep and dip them in a vat of insecticide. Otherwise, the insects would literally eat the sheep.

It’s very hard on the sheep because you have to grab the sheep by the feet up here and the hind legs and just immerse them so they’re submerged for something like 15 seconds. I want you to know that even though it’s exactly what the sheep need, none of them like it. I just want you to know that.

As Elisabeth Elliot looked at that and she was thinking about herself as a sheep and the Lord as her Shepherd, she says, “You know what? God does that to us a lot. He gives us what we really needed even though we may not know it for 10 years, 20 years, 30 years, 40 years, or maybe not until after death.”

What this man is suddenly realizing is, “Wait a minute. If I really believe in a God who created the world, of course he’s going to be able to let things happen that I can’t understand. How dare I think that somehow everything has to happen just the way I think?” Then he realizes, “I’m the sheep. I’m like the animal, and I’m not trusting my master.”

Another story is years ago I was at a picnic. There was a little kitten that had fallen into a very cold stream and certainly would have drowned. A boy went in and pulled the kitten out and rescued it, but as he was pulling the kitten out, the kitten of course was very scared and was biting and scratching the hand of his savior until it bled.

What this man is saying is, “My heart was grieved, my spirit embittered. I was senseless and ignorant. I was like a brute beast before you. Yet I am always with you, and you hold me by my right hand.” He’s getting a bigger view of God. He’s letting God be big enough to do things he can’t understand. He said, “My goodness, why wouldn’t I have a God who can do things I can’t understand?”

So his view of God is getting bigger and, at the same time, more tender. He says, “You’ve never given up on me. You’re always with me. You’re still holding me by my right hand. In spite of how stupid I’ve been, in spite of how I’ve bitten and scratched you, you have continued to love me and be faithful to me.” His view of God has gotten bigger and more tender, and as a result, he can handle the life he sees around him.

Here’s what I want to ask you, though: How did that happen? How can he be sure that in spite of the fact he has been beastly to God, in spite of the fact he has been doing all this and has been questioning him and treating God like this, God is still with him? How can he be sure God has forgiven him? How can he be sure God has never let him go? I don’t think he can be sure except that he’s inspired by the Holy Spirit to write a part of the Bible. It’s divine revelation. He just knows it.

But how can you and I know it? Why wouldn’t God when we act like this …? And we do act like this. Why wouldn’t God just say, “Hey, natural consequences; just go your way”? How do we know God has not let us go and won’t let us go? I’ll tell you how. We don’t have direct divine revelation, but we have the New Testament, and here’s what we see. When Jesus Christ was on the cross, he cried out, “My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?”

Do you know what he was saying? What he was saying was, “Father, I can’t feel your hand.” See, all of Jesus’ life, he was utterly different than the rest of us. He was never beastly toward his Father. He was always faithful to his Father. He never questioned his Father. He always loved his Father. He was the one person who deserved to have God hold him by the hand, but at the end of his life, God let him go. He says so. “My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?”

Why? Because on the cross, Jesus Christ was getting what you and I deserve. He was losing the Father’s hand so you and I can know if we believe in Jesus and are accepted by God because of what Jesus has done, he will never let us go. He will never forsake us. In other words, we have a bigger view of God even than this man did. He had no idea God would be so great as to come to earth and become a human being and go to the cross and do this for us.

We have a bigger view of God and a more loving view of God than he ever had. Therefore, how much more should we be able to inhabit a large view of God that handles life? How much more than he should we be able to say what he says at the end? “Whom have I in heaven but you? And earth has nothing I desire besides you. My flesh and my heart may fail, but God is the strength of my heart and my portion forever.” Let’s pray.

Our Father, we pray that you’d make us great through our doubts. We pray that you would move us to new levels through our doubts, but we pray you would help us to know what to do with our doubts. We have gotten some pretty good instruction from this passage of Scripture. But most of all, O Lord, help us to see that in light of the cross, we can trust that you do not give up on us, that you do not let go of us, even when we’re pretty bitter, even when we’re crying out, even when we’re yelling, even when we’re filled with doubts.

We thank you that we’re saved by grace, not through our good works, not through the level of our certainty. We thank you that we’re saved by grace through Jesus. We pray that you would help us to grow in grace because of what he did. Make all this true and realized in our lives. We pray this in Jesus’ name, amen.

Knowing God

A Public Faith—October 20, 2013

Romans 1:16–21

16 For I am not ashamed of the gospel, because it is the power of God that brings salvation to everyone who believes: first to the Jew, then to the Gentile. 17 For in the gospel the righteousness of God is revealed—a righteousness that is by faith from first to last, just as it is written: “The righteous will live by faith.”

18 The wrath of God is being revealed from heaven against all the godlessness and wickedness of people, who suppress the truth by their wickedness, 19 since what may be known about God is plain to them, because God has made it plain to them.

20 For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that people are without excuse. 21 For although they knew God, they neither glorified him as God nor gave thanks to him, but their thinking became futile and their foolish hearts were darkened.

This is the Word of the Lord

We are again in the fourth week of a series we’re doing called A Public Faith: Sharing the Hope That’s Within. Each week in the small groups we’re talking about what we are talking about here on Sunday morning. We don’t live in a society that encourages people to be public about their religious faith and their religious beliefs, which is really ironic because we are encouraged in our society to be public about everything else. We have to tell people who we are.

Think about it. There’s nothing more fundamental to your identity and who you are than your religious beliefs. Therefore, if we’re going to have a truly open and pluralistic society, we all have to learn how to be public about who we are, about our deepest faith beliefs, and yet to do so in a way that’s respectful to others and promotes peace. That’s what we’re exploring in these morning messages and in the small groups each week.

This week we want to talk about how you talk about God and about God’s existence. You’re not going to be able to talk publically about faith if you can’t talk about God and his existence. How do you go about that without getting into a shouting match that goes like, “God does exist.” “No, God doesn’t exist”? That’s the Internet right there (and sometimes actually out on the street).

I think one of the ways to make people more reflective is to not ask the question, “Does God exist?” but “How do you know whether God exists? How do you know God?” or “If you say you can’t know whether there’s a God or not, how do you know that?” As soon as you start to ask the question, “How do you know whether there’s a God?” or “How do you know you can know whether there’s a God?” it slows things down and makes people reflect a little bit more.

There is no better, more ingenious, and brilliant answer to that question, “How can you know whether there’s a God or not?” than Romans 1, and this particular part of Romans 1, written by Saint Paul. I don’t think there is any more brilliant and ingenious answer to the question, “How can we know whether there’s a God or not?” than here, because Paul actually gives you four answers, pretty much all at once.

We’re going to look at them all just in these few verses. Here’s what he says. We can know God, we do know God, we don’t know God, and we can truly know God, all at once, by the way. He says it all right here. Let’s take a look.

1. We can know God

As I said, he does say here you can know there’s a God. For example, the famous verses 19 and 20 (they’re all famous) say, “… what may be known about God is plain.… For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made …”

What’s he saying here? He says, “… from what has been made …” That’s nature, the created world. There are plain clues to God’s existence. He’s actually saying it’s possible to infer God’s existence from what you see in nature. The reason I used the word clues is many people have, sometimes people have, I think, misnamed these clues as proofs.

Some people say by looking at nature and looking at the world you can prove there’s a God. If you go online, if you go to any philosophical textbook, they’ll give you those proofs, the proofs that come from looking at nature and the created order. They have these great big long names. If you know how to say them, then you feel so much better about yourself. It really helps your self-esteem.

There’s the cosmological argument. There’s the teleological argument. Paul doesn’t use the term proof here, and I think we’re reading too much in. A proof is something no rational person can deny. No rational person can find any reasons not to believe it. I don’t think Paul is saying that. I think he’s actually saying if our cognitive faculties, if our hearts and minds, were in better condition, we would acknowledge those clues more readily, but they’re there.

What are they? He doesn’t tell you much. He just says there are clues to God’s reality, his divine nature, and his power. I’ll just go into the two for a minute just to show you how it works. They’re not proofs, but they’re clues. The cosmological argument works like, “How could something come from nothing?” That’s it.

For example, do you know the Big Bang Theory? The universe started with a bang. How could nothing have exploded? Nothing can’t explode, so how could the explosion come from nothing? Somebody says, “Well, it wasn’t that it was nothing. There was something.” Okay, but where did that something come from?

If you keep asking that question, “Where did that something come from?” if you go all the way back to say, “Well, there was something that had no cause. It didn’t come from nothing. It was always there,” since we know nothing in this world like that … Everything we know has a beginning.

Everything we know is an effect with a cause. As soon as you start talking about an uncaused cause, as soon as you start talking about something that was always there, you’re talking about something supernatural, something we don’t know here in nature, something beyond nature, something divine.

That’s how the cosmological argument goes. It says, “How could all this come from nothing? If it didn’t come from nothing, then what brought it about?” The teleological argument is actually kind of fun too. They’re not enough to make people believe in God. They haven’t, but the clues are there.

The teleological argument comes from the word telos, which means design. It talks about the fact that the world is so perfectly designed, how could it have come about by accident? The physicists will tell you this, and I have to look at my notes just to say it right. The fundamental regularities and constants of physics, things like speed of light, gravitational constant, strength of weak and strong nuclear forces, all of these things have to be perfectly calibrated.

It’s almost like there are a hundred dials, and every single dial has to be exactly at the right spot. Not a single one can be off a hair. They all have to be so perfectly calibrated in such a way for matter to coalesce. Unless all those things were exactly the way they are, we wouldn’t have matter.

We wouldn’t have a world. We wouldn’t have human life. What many people have said is so many things had to happen exactly the way they are for there to even be human life, even to be life, even to be matter … that couldn’t have happened by accident, so God did it. That’s the teleological argument.

People like Richard Dawkins or Stephen Hawking who are atheists spent a lot of time refuting that argument. Do you know what that means? It means it must have force or they wouldn’t spend the time. Do you know what they all say? Do you know what Dawkins says? Do you know what Stephen Hawking says?

What they say is at the Big Bang there could’ve been an infinite number of possible universes formed, and we just happened to be in the universe where matter coalesces, where all the various fundamental regularities and constants of physics are exactly the way they ought to be for life to happen. So there we are. There are zillions and zillions of those universes, and we just happen to be in the one where it happens.

Of course, the philosophers have a lot of fun with that. Let me just give you one. John Leslie is a philosopher who tells you this story. He says imagine there’s a man about to be executed. The sergeant gets 50 crack marksmen with their rifles and lines them up six feet from the prisoner. “Ready. Aim. Fire,” and they all miss. The sergeant says, “What happened?” Every single man, says, “Gosh, sarge. I just had a twitch. My nose … Something in my eye … I’m sorry,” all 50 at once.

The sarge says, “It can’t all be 50 at once.” Then one guy who took a philosophy course says, “But sergeant, at the Big Bang, there could’ve been zillions of possible universes formed, and we just happened to be in the universe where all 50 crack marksmen happened to have a twitch in their noses at the very same moment.”

First of all, if the sergeant also took a philosophy course, he would have to say, “You’re right. I can’t prove this was a conspiracy, because we just happened to maybe be in the one universe. I can’t prove it, but I know it was a conspiracy. In a million years it wouldn’t be reasonable to assume we just happened to be in the one universe where all that can happen. I want you to assume it’s a conspiracy, that somebody did it, that it was contrived, that there was some personal design involved.”

He wouldn’t assume the one in a zillion chance happened. He would assume it was a personal design. For you to say there’s a one in a zillion chance maybe there is no God, does that make sense to base your entire life on that? These are the cosmological and teleological arguments, and these are basically forms of the kinds of clues people have seen over the years.

Paul says they’re there. There really are clues, but Paul says something a lot more radical than that. He doesn’t just say it’s possible to know God by looking at nature. He actually goes way beyond that and says every human being actually does know God. Do you see where he says that?

2. We do know God

He says God is mad, and why is he mad? “The wrath of God is being revealed from heaven against all the godlessness and wickedness of people …” This is everybody, humanity. “… who suppress the truth …” What truth? “… what may be known about God …”

Down in verse 21, he says, “For although they knew God, they neither glorified him as God …” What he is saying is all people are suppressing the truth about God’s existence. You can’t suppress something unless you have it. What he’s saying is at some very deep level every human being knows God is there.

This, by the way, is a very offensive statement to people. In fact, just in the New York Times yesterday there was a letter to the editor. The letter to the editor had to do with some op-ed piece I happened to miss. Some op-ed person had said this term in one of the op-ed pieces earlier this week, that there are no atheists in foxholes. You’ve heard that. When the shooting begins, even the atheists show they actually believe in God.

One atheist wrote in, and he was very offended. This is what he said. This is fair. He says, “The implication—that atheists are all really theists at heart, our convictions casually and shallowly held and easily abandoned in the face of adversity—is simply untrue.” He’s an atheist. He says, “To say I’m really a theist at heart and my atheism, my beliefs, convictions, are casually and shallowly held and easily abandoned, it just isn’t true.”

Paul is not saying anything like that. Here’s what Paul is saying. Yes, Paul is saying at some level everybody knows there’s a God, but as we’re going to see in a minute, he’s also saying at a profound level we all believe in God and yet we don’t believe in God. What’s interesting is the translators can never get this right because it’s a very awkward construction.

When Paul says, “… what may be known about God is plain to them.… For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood …” the verbs there are present passive participles in Greek. This is what the commentators say. What it means is the reality of God bears down on us constantly.

That is, there is part of our heart that doesn’t believe God is there, and yet there’s another part of our heart that’s sensitive to his reality and that reality bears down on us. What Paul is describing is a deeply conflicted dialogue between the part of our hearts that denies the existence of God and the part of our hearts that’s sensitive to his reality. There is nothing casual or shallow about that, and yet Paul is saying at some level in some part of our heart we know God is there.

You say, “What’s the evidence for that?” We’re not talking here that you can look at the arguments for God and infer his existence. We’re saying, Paul is saying, all people already know about his existence. At some level they know he’s there. What’s the evidence for that? After many, many years of finding it interesting to read the biographies of atheists who have become Christians, I see what Paul is talking about.

There are a whole slew of prominent British intellectuals who were atheists and who became Christians. Some of them are more famous than others, like T.S. Eliot, W.H. Auden, C.S. Lewis. Some are a little less famous, like C.E.M. Joad and A.N. Wilson, people like that. They all have a lot of initials there.

A lot of these were British intellectuals, brilliant men, and they were biographers and literary critics and thinkers and poets. Even though they had rejected Christianity growing up and they became part of the intellectual elites, all of whom laughed at religion and Christianity, they shocked their contemporaries and their peers by embracing Christianity in one form or another.

When I look at them and I study them, I see very seldom, if ever, do they look at the evidence like the cosmological argument and the teleological argument and they come to conclude, “I guess there’s a God.” Rather, when they talk about how they found faith, they come to see they believed God all along. They were living as if there was a God. They weren’t admitting they were living as if there was a God, and they finally admitted he has to be there. It’s very interesting.

Let me just give you two. One is not as well known as the other. A.N. Wilson is more recent. Kathy and I know A.N. Wilson because he really turned on Christianity, and he wrote a terrible biography of C.S. Lewis, basically attacking him for his beliefs. He wrote biographies of Jesus, of Paul. He was very skeptical of Christianity, rejected it. He’s a very brilliant man, but on Easter 2009, he put an article in the paper and said, “I have embraced Christianity.” It just shocked everybody.

He gave an Easter testimony. In it this is what he said. He said most public voices … He’s talking about in Britain. “… they have all but accepted that only stupid people actually believe in Christianity.… As a matter of fact, I am sure the opposite is the case and that materialist atheism is not merely an arid creed, but totally irrational. Materialist atheism says we are just a collection of chemicals. It has no answer whatsoever to the question of how we should be capable of love or heroism or poetry if we are simply animated pieces of meat.”

He goes on and tries to say people who believe there is no God and we are just, what he called us, bags of chemicals and animated pieces of meat that have evolved, then we say we need to be noble and we need to believe in justice and we need to love each other … He says there’s no basis for that. You say, “Where does that come from?” Let me give you a second case study, because it’s a little clearer and more fascinating.

W.H. Auden, a poet, was considered one of the most brilliant writers of the twentieth century. What’s interesting to me is his conversion happened right here in the Upper East Side years ago. He was British, but he moved. He was living in America during World War II, and he had embraced atheism just like everybody in his intellectual class.

It started, evidently, when he was a … You know just the northern part of the Upper East Side, sort of the northeastern part of the Upper East Side, Yorkville, was back in World War II and in the 30s and 40s a very, very German place. A lot of German people lived here. In fact, when we got here to start the church, there were still a lot of German-speaking churches and restaurants and places like that still in the late-80s up in the Upper East Side that have largely vanished.

During the 40s, W.H. Auden was working on his German actually, and there were a number of German cinemas, places that showed German films. He went into a film house somewhere in the late-30s and saw a film that obviously had been influenced by Nazism. He saw German-American people, at least Germans living in America, yelling slurs at the screen against the Jews who appeared in the story.

It shook him. He came back to Christianity, shocked everybody, and eventually this is what he wrote. Let me set this up for you because it’s very important. Auden thought all educated, enlightened people would believe in freedom, reason, democracy, and human dignity, basically believed all educated people, all cultured people, all reasonable people, who believed in the importance of human reason and who are cultured, would believe in the values of freedom, reason, democracy, and human dignity.

What happened was Germany had embraced Nazism, and Germany was second to none as a sophisticated, educated society. There was tremendous science, tremendous music, tremendous art, scholarship, and yet they had embraced the idea that loving your neighbor and justice and human rights was a fiction. It created a crisis for Auden, and here’s what he wrote.

“If I am convinced that the highly educated Nazis are wrong, and that we highly educated English are right, what is it that validates our values and invalidates theirs? The English intellectuals who now cry to Heaven against the evil incarnated in Hitler have no Heaven to cry to. The whole trend of liberal thought has been to undermine faith in the absolute. It has tried to make reason the judge. […] Either we serve the Unconditional, or some Hitlerian monster will supply an iron convention based on reason to do evil by.”

Here’s what he means. He believed in human rights, liberty, and freedom. Why should you believe in human rights and freedom? He says let’s use your reason, and let’s look at nature, what you see when you look at nature. Reason looks at nature. It’s science, empirical. What do you see? You see the strong eating the weak. That’s nature. That’s how you got here, the strong eating the weak.

Now on what basis do you see a strong country eating a weak country or a strong race eating a weaker race, destroying, oppressing? On what basis do you say that’s wrong? Just using your reason, not morality, not heaven, not moral absolute, just your reason, how do you decide human freedom and dignity and human rights and justice for all …? Why believe that when that’s not how nature works? He says Hitler was using reason, and reason is, “We’re products of evolution.”

Here’s basically what he says. Oh, listen carefully, everybody. Of course, without God you can have moral feelings. Sure. You can feel it’s wrong to oppress people. You can feel human rights are right, but without God there can be no moral obligation. That is, you have no right to say your moral feelings should determine their behavior.

You have moral feelings. You’re English. They have moral feelings. They’re Nazis, and they’re Germans. How dare you say your moral feelings are right and theirs are wrong when there’s no standard? Therefore, here’s what he decided. If you believe human rights and justice are not imaginary values but are real, and if there is no God they would be imaginary, but they’re not imaginary, therefore, there must be a God.

Without God there can be moral feelings, but there can’t be moral obligation. You can’t say, “You are obliged to follow my moral feelings, but if you believe …” Genocide is wrong. Oppression is wrong. Human rights are right. They’re not just my feelings. They’re right. There must be a God. Auden realized he was believing in God all along; he just wasn’t being honest with himself. We know there’s a God deep down. We suppress it, but that’s the third point.

3. We don’t know God

The other thing that is so brilliant about Paul’s analysis is the human condition. We can know God and we do know there is a God and yet we don’t know there is a God. The very moment he says we do know God, he also says we suppress it. We repress it. We don’t know it, yet we do know it, and yet we don’t know it. Both are fundamentally the same. They’re equally strong.

What kind of stuff do we modern people know we tend to suppress or repress? Why do you suppress something? Why do you repress something? If it’s traumatic. Sometimes memories can be traumatic. One of my favorite Agatha Christie novels is Sleeping Murder, and it’s about a young woman who buys a house, and in the house she starts to have flashbacks of a murder she saw. It turns out as a little girl she was in the house, and she had repressed the memories of a murder, and that’s how the murder works.

The fact is psychologists will tell you there’s really probably not that many truly repressed memories that are traumatic. There’s a lot of fiction about it, and there are a lot of people who talk about it in the media, but the reality is it’s probably not true that some memories are so traumatic we simply repress them. It’s pretty rare.

I’ll tell you what you do repress. If you’re really angry, you can repress that. “No, I’m not that angry.” If you’re really feeling guilty about something you’ve done, you can repress that. “No, I don’t really feel guilty.” Anything about your heart that doesn’t fit in with your identity, your way that you’d like to think about who you are …

You have a chosen identity. “I like to think of myself as this or this or this.” When data comes in, things you’ve done or feelings you have that doesn’t fit that data, you screen it out. You suppress it. You repress it. Paul says that’s exactly what we’re doing with God. Why? Because the knowledge of God is incredibly traumatic.

How so? It tells you right here in verse 21, a key verse. “For although they knew God, they didn’t glorify God.” What does glorify mean? They didn’t treat God as big and as glorious as he truly is, as multi-dimensional and as great, as magnificent as he is. Why? Because they didn’t want to thank him.

You might say, “What? That’s the big sin? That’s the whole problem, we don’t want to thank God?” Yeah. By the way, even at the legal level, there’s this thing called plagiarism. What’s plagiarism? Refusing to thank somebody for the intellectual property you’re ripping off, refusing to thank somebody, saying, “And I want to acknowledge I got all these ideas from …”

We don’t say that. Why? Because then we are showing our dependence and showing our obligation and showing we may actually not have complete control over what we’re saying. If there’s a God, then we are utterly dependent on him, and we are totally obliged to him. If there’s a God who made us and keeps us alive every second, then that’s traumatic because it means we need to thank him for everything, which means there’s not a single spot in your life you don’t owe him allegiance, and we hate that.

Our image of who we are is we can call the shots. We are our own masters. We decide what is right or wrong. Especially our Western culture tells us that. Along comes the God of the Bible in particular, and there is no god that’s more traumatic than the God of the Bible. Why? What if you say, “Well, I believe in a god of love, just a god that’s a spirit of love everywhere,” that does not get …

First of all, you don’t have to thank that person, do you? That’s not a person. You are still in control. You can still live with the illusion you’re in charge of your life. There are other kinds of gods. “I just believe god is the force of life and everything.” There are all sorts of ways of believing in God that aren’t traumatic and we embrace, but the God of the Bible …

I’ll put it like this. Imagine you had this really great scam going. There was a neighborhood in New York City you go to and you dress up as a police officer. You impersonate a police officer. The waters part when you go there, and people give you free sandwiches. They say, “Top of the morning to you, officer.” Everything goes really nicely.

While you’re impersonating the police officer, you’ll probably be a little nervous. You’ll be a little afraid maybe you’ll say something that might make somebody say, “What? Why would a police officer say this?” You’re a little nervous. Of course, because you’re impersonating an officer. What if, in the distance coming walking toward you, you see a real police officer? You’re not just nervous now. You’re scared. Why? Because there’s not just a chance the real police officer is going to expose you as an impersonator; it will happen.

Therefore, all human beings according to Paul want to call the shots. We want to be our own bosses. We want to be in control of our lives. We want to take credit. That’s cosmic plagiarism. We want to take credit for who we are and what we’ve done. We want to pat ourselves on the back in all those ways.

What are we doing? We’re impersonating a god. We’re impersonating a creator. We’re self-made people, and we’re worshiping our creator. When somebody comes along and says, “I believe in a god who kind of made the world and now he’s off in the … He’s remote,” or somebody says, “I believe in a god who is nature. I believe this. I believe that,” there are a whole lot of gods that actually don’t threaten you.

When you get to the biblical God who creates you and sustains you, who is a glorious God, and to whom you owe everything, that is a God who is going to freak you out. You’re going to melt down. That’s like when you’re impersonating a police officer and you see a real police officer coming.

You’re impersonating a god, and when you see the real God coming, the biblical God coming, you go nuts. Paul says that’s the reason why, even though we know there’s God and we actually in some ways live as if there is a God, if we were honest with ourselves, we can’t not know there is a God. His reality presses on us all the time.

At the same time we desperately do not want to believe in God. This says everybody in this room, including the guy behind the microphone right now, suppresses the truth to some degree. None of us can bear the full reality of who God is. It’s too threatening. It’s too traumatic. We all try to whittle God down somehow, flatten him, but the biblical God is very traumatic. Though we can know God and we do know God, we don’t know God. What do we do about it? What can we do about it?

4. We can truly know God

There actually are clues here as to what we can do about it and how we can truly know the God who’s really there, how we can heal ourselves of our fears so we can know him truly. What is that? Let me put it like this. This in some ways gets into the rest of the book of Romans, and we’re not looking at the whole book of Romans.

Let’s go back to verses 19 and 20 for a minute. He says if you look at nature, if you look at creation, if you look at the things that have been made, what can you learn about God? He’s invisible. He’s eternal. He’s powerful. He’s divine. What’s missing from the list? Is there anything there that says you can’t know about God just by looking at nature, just by using your reason, just by using all your rational powers, by trying to be objective?

No matter how hard you try looking at the things that are made, there’s one thing you’re not going to know anything about. What is it? It doesn’t say anything about his love or his grace. By the way, that’s true. Let’s look at nature, class. Let’s look at it geologically. Oh, look at the volcanoes. Look at the earthquakes. Do you just look at that and just say, “I just see God is a God of love”? No. Let’s look at nature meteorologically. Hurricanes. Tsunamis. Do you just look at nature and say, “I just know God is a God of love”?

Let’s look at it astronomically. We’re in a galaxy. Our galaxy is just zillions and zillions of miles wide. There are a hundred billion galaxies we even know of, and we only probably know of a tiny amount of how many there really are. You look at that, and the idea there’s a God who made all that, do you just look at that and say, “Oh, I just really want to know a God like that?” No, you’re scared to death. “If there is a God that made all that, what am I?”

Let’s look at it biologically. Annie Dillard wrote a great book, Pilgrim at Tinker Creek, and went out to live in the mountains of Virginia years ago. She won a Pulitzer Prize for the book, and she said, “I wanted to observe nature.” So at the creek she watched nature. She thought it would make her close to nature, and she saw how violent nature was. She saw a giant water bug sting and paralyze a frog and then put its thing down into its brain and suck its brains out till it just sort of collapsed like a piece of clothing with nobody in it. She said, “Ah, nature.”

Do you look at nature, red in tooth and claw, and say, “I just know God is a God of love”? No. You will not find God is a God of love. In fact, this is a little more controversial. I’m going to take 20 seconds on it. I promise I can back it up, but I’ll just tell you. Do you look at other religions and say, “Well, other religions all say God is a God of love”? No. You go to Buddhism. They talk about being compassionate if you’re a Buddhist.

Of course, but it’s because this world is unreal, and you shouldn’t grab ahold of anything. The idea is God is an impersonal All-Soul, and we’re going to become impersonal all-souls. No. They don’t believe God is a God of love. In fact, if you talk to Islam, “Do you believe your god is a god of love?” they’ll talk about being merciful, but I know with many, many Muslims I’ve talked to, “Is God a God of love?” they’d say, “No, we wouldn’t say that.”

Where do you get this idea that God is a God of love? It’s so pervasive in the world. I’ll tell you where you get the idea. It comes from the Bible. That’s the only source in human thought. If you really don’t just pull what you want out of the Bible and really find the biblical God, here’s what you see. In verse 18 is a wrathful God, a God who gets incredibly angry at sin. A little later on in Romans 6, it’ll say, “For the wages of sin is death …” Wrath demands death because we disobey him.

Then yet look at verses 16 and 17. “For I am not ashamed of the gospel, because it is the power of God that brings salvation to everyone who believes: first to the Jew [the good person], then to the Gentile [the pagan person].” It doesn’t matter. “For in the gospel the righteousness of God is revealed …” It’s a righteousness that is not earned, not something you develop, but is given as a gift. It’s by faith from first to last, and you will live by it.

Here is the point. When you give yourself to someone in love, when you get into a love relationship and you give yourself to someone in love, do you lose control? Yeah, you lose control. You can’t just live any way you want. When you get into a love relationship, you lose control, and it’s great. Why? Because the other person loses control too. If it’s a true love relationship, you don’t exploit each other.

If you just simply look up at the sky and say, “I want to believe in a god of love,” that just flattens God. Do you know what? You are afraid of losing control. You and I are afraid of losing control. If we just say, “I just believe in a god of love who doesn’t judge anybody and accepts anybody the way they are,” that’s a flat god that won’t threaten you, that won’t show up the fact that you’re impersonating.

The biblical God, the God of the gospel is an angry God because he’s angry at sin, and yet Jesus Christ, Son of God, comes into this world and goes to the cross and loses total control. Everyone has his way with him. He’s beaten. He’s speared. He’s nailed. He loses complete control. Why? He takes what we deserve. He takes that wrath. He takes that death.

In other words, the Son of God, God incarnate, loves us so much he was willing to lose control so he could take our punishment so he could then give us and love us. Now what is that? That’s a love that does not exploit. You can give yourself to this God because he went to the cross for you. No other religion has anything like that. No other philosophy has anything like that. Now finally I have a God I can give myself to.

The gospel is the gospel of a loving God and a holy God, a God who is so holy he has to punish sin and a God who is so loving he would take the punishment himself. There you have now a glorious God. You have a multi-dimensional God, a complex God, a real, personal God, someone I can know and also a God I can give myself to and not be afraid. The fear that keeps me from really knowing God is healed by the gospel. It’s unique.

My favorite part, in fact the only part in that novel, The Life of Pi, that I like, is this one spot. I have to read it to you. It’s just too great. Every couple of years I have to get it out and read it to you. It’s the place where the boy is exploring all the different religions and he’s leaning toward Hinduism, but then he talks to a Catholic priest. The priest starts to tell him about Jesus and his death on the cross. The boy freaks out, and this is what he says.

“That a god should put up with adversity, I could understand. The gods of Hinduism face their fair share of thieves, bullies, kidnappers and usurpers. What is the Ramayana but the account of one long, bad day for Rama? Adversity, yes. Reversals of fortune, yes. Treachery, yes. But humiliation? Death?

I couldn’t imagine Lord Krishna consenting to be stripped naked, whipped, mocked, dragged through the streets and, to top it off, crucified—and at the hands of mere humans, to boot. I’d never heard of a Hindu god dying. […] But divinity should not be blighted by death. It’s wrong. […] It was wrong of this Christ God to let His avatar die. That is tantamount to letting a part of Himself die.

For if the Son is to die, it cannot be fake. If God on the Cross is God shamming a human tragedy, it turns the Passion of Christ into the Farce of Christ. The death of the Son must be real. Father Martin assured me that it was. But once a dead God, always a dead God, even resurrected. The Son must have the taste of death forever in His mouth.

The Trinity must be tainted by it; there must be a certain stench at the right hand of God the Father. The horror must be real. Why would God wish that upon Himself? Why not leave death to the mortals? Why make dirty what is beautiful, spoil what is perfect? Love. That was Father Martin’s answer.” Let’s pray.

Our Father, we see the thing we’ll never ever learn by scanning the heavens and using our reason and our rational arguments is the sacrificial love of God in Jesus Christ. Lord, we’ll never know that except in the gospel, but that’s what we need to heal our hearts so the primordial and deep, innate knowledge we have of you is finally free to be released.

We’re afraid of you, Lord. We’re afraid of losing control. Your glorious reality is just too traumatic for us, but only in the gospel can we be healed, can we embrace you and finally be reunited with our Creator, with our Maker, with our Redeemer, with the One we were built to worship and love and know. Oh, Lord, teach us how to be public about our faith, those of us who understand the gospel and have experienced that healing.

Teach us to use the gospel in our hearts so we can constantly get a better and more glorious view of your reality, because even now so many of us are believers, and yet we still don’t completely grasp the greatness of who you are. We still sometimes distort that. Father, teach us how to be public with our faith so others can know the healing of the heart that comes through seeing the gospel of the love of your Son Jesus Christ. In his name we pray, amen.

Knowing Good

A Public Faith—October 27, 2013

Romans 2:12–29

12 All who sin apart from the law will also perish apart from the law, and all who sin under the law will be judged by the law. 13 For it is not those who hear the law who are righteous in God’s sight, but it is those who obey the law who will be declared righteous. 14 (Indeed, when Gentiles, who do not have the law, do by nature things required by the law, they are a law for themselves, even though they do not have the law.

15 They show that the requirements of the law are written on their hearts, their consciences also bearing witness, and their thoughts sometimes accusing them and at other times even defending them.) 16 This will take place on the day when God judges people’s secrets through Jesus Christ, as my gospel declares.

17 Now you, if you call yourself a Jew; if you rely on the law and boast in God; 18 if you know his will and approve of what is superior because you are instructed by the law; 19 if you are convinced that you are a guide for the blind, a light for those who are in the dark, 20 an instructor of the foolish, a teacher of little children, because you have in the law the embodiment of knowledge and truth—21 you, then, who teach others, do you not teach yourself? You who preach against stealing, do you steal?

22 You who say that people should not commit adultery, do you commit adultery? You who abhor idols, do you rob temples? 23 You who boast in the law, do you dishonor God by breaking the law? 24 As it is written: “God’s name is blasphemed among the Gentiles because of you.”

25 Circumcision has value if you observe the law, but if you break the law, you have become as though you had not been circumcised. 26 So then, if those who are not circumcised keep the law’s requirements, will they not be regarded as though they were circumcised? 27 The one who is not circumcised physically and yet obeys the law will condemn you who, even though you have the written code and circumcision, are a lawbreaker.

28 A person is not a Jew who is one only outwardly, nor is circumcision merely outward and physical. 29 No, a person is a Jew who is one inwardly; and circumcision is circumcision of the heart, by the Spirit, not by the written code. Such a person’s praise is not from other people, but from God.

This is the Word of the Lord

We’re in a series called Public Faith: Sharing the Hope That’s Within. It’s about the fact that all of us in a pluralistic society (an open pluralistic society, as we want to have in our country) need to find ways of sharing our deep faith beliefs with each other (being honest about who we are, in others words) but to do so in such a way that’s respectful and promotes peace.

The objection to what I just said goes like this. The objection says, “No, no, no, no, no. Look. Not all people have faith beliefs. Not all people are religious, and those of you who are religious should keep your beliefs private. Otherwise, we’re just going to fight. Not all of us are religious. Some of you do have religious beliefs. Fine, but keep them private. Otherwise, we’re just going to fight.”

That statement is both untrue and unfair. I think I can show you why just by asking you a question. Do you believe in human rights? Do you believe all people have human rights, all people have equal dignity, and no one should have their human rights violated and taken away from them? Do you believe that? If you live in New York or most places in Western society, you believe, “Yes, of course, I believe in human rights.”

Okay. How would you prove human rights exist scientifically? You can’t. No one has ever dissected a human right in a laboratory. There’s no way to prove such a thing. There is no empirical evidence for it, by the way (the idea that every human being has equal dignity). There’s no evidence scientifically that all human beings are equal. There’s almost nothing we’re equal in.

Also, Aristotle and a whole lot of people never believed everyone had equal human rights. In fact, probably half the human race today doesn’t believe everybody has equal human rights. So if you believe in human rights, do you realize what that is? It’s a belief. It’s a belief, and it’s essentially the same as a religious belief, even though you don’t call it a religious belief because it’s a belief about human nature and about what life is about.

It’s not something you can prove, and it’s not self-evident to everybody, so it’s a belief. You see how unfair it is to say, “Those of you who call your beliefs religious, you have to keep them private. Those of us who don’t, we can do anything we want with them.” That’s just completely unfair. Now we’re still back to where we said we were, which is a question … How do we avoid just not shouting at each other?

“This is the right standard for right and wrong!” “No! This is the standard for right and wrong!” We just yell at each other, but maybe one of the ways we can calm each other down and maybe make for a more civil conversation is ask this more fundamental question: Where do you get your moral convictions about what is right and wrong, like human rights? Where do you get your moral convictions? What do you base them on? How do you determine what is right and wrong?

The reason that’s a great question is it slows everybody down because actually we all have very strong moral convictions about what we think is right and wrong. But as soon as you say, “Well, why do you believe that? On what basis do you believe that? Where do you get that?” right away we’re not as quick to know what to say.

It makes us stop and think and talk and, therefore, we suddenly have a better conversation, a better public conversation. I would say there’s almost no place I know that has a more interesting and ingenious and creative answer to the question, “Where do you get your moral beliefs?” than Romans 2. Here is Saint Paul. This last part of Romans 2, is going to tell us three things.

The first paragraph is verses 12–16. There Paul is telling us no one can succeed in being a relativist. The second paragraph is verses 17–24. There Paul’s thesis is, “But on the other hand, no one really can succeed in being a moralist.” Then the last part of the passage is where Paul says, “Therefore, this is our only hope.” No one can succeed in being a relativist. No one can really succeed in being a moralist. Therefore, this is our only hope. Let’s look at these three things.

1. No one can succeed in being a relativist

Verse 12: “All who sin apart from the law will also perish apart from the law, and all who sin under the law will be judged by the law.” Who is he talking about? He is talking about the law. He means by “the law” the moral law of God that’s revealed in the Bible, in the Scriptures. Of course at the time, Paul was talking about the Old Testament but in the Scriptures.

He was saying some people have that. That is to say they believe it. They believe the moral law of God is revealed in the Bible, and they accept it, and they embrace it, and they take it. There are other people who don’t have it. That is, they either have never heard of it, they have never read the Bible, they didn’t even know about it, or they don’t accept it.

In that day, most of the people who believed the Bible was where the revealed moral law was were Jews, but not all. There were Gentiles who believed that too, but they were mainly Jews. What Paul was trying to say is some people accept the moral law of God as revealed in the Bible; some people do not. That’s the people who have the law and people who don’t. What does he say about them? He says three things, one of which is interesting, one of which is startling, and one of which is radical and controversial. It’s in verses 14 and 15.

“(Indeed, when Gentiles, who do not have the law, do by nature things required by the law, they are a law for themselves, even though they do not have the law. They show that the requirements of the law are written on their hearts, their consciences also bearing witness, and their thoughts sometimes accusing them and at other times even defending them.)”

Here’s what he is saying. Here’s the interesting thing. “All who sin apart from the law will also perish apart from the law, and all who sin under the law will be judged by the law. (… Gentiles, who do not have the law … [still show] … they are a law for themselves …)” The first thing he is saying which is interesting is that God the Judge will not judge you according to standards you don’t accept.

If you don’t accept the Bible as your moral standard, then you won’t be judged according to the Bible. You’ll be judged according to the moral standards you yourself have. Therefore, what he is saying is no one is going to be judged by any moral standards they don’t accept themselves and embrace during their lives. Interesting. I told you it was interesting, right? Okay.

Secondly, he says something else which is more startling. That is, even if you don’t have the Bible as your moral standard (you see he sneaks it in in the very beginning of verse 12), you’re still going to perish on judgment day. See? “All who sin apart from the law will still perish.” Why? Because in your heart, you still do know something about the moral law, and you’ll be judged according to that.

The illustration that helped me more than anything … When I was a young Christian, I read a book by Francis Schaeffer, who was talking about Romans 2. He used an illustration, which of course is a bit fanciful but basically gets the idea across. Some of you have heard me use it before because it’s so helpful to me.

He says when it says God is not going to judge you according to any standard other than your own that you already know, it’s a little bit like this. He says it’s like when you were born, God puts an invisible recorder around your neck. It’s not only invisible; of course, you can’t feel it or hear it either. All it does is record things you say to other people that they ought to do. All it does is pick up your own moral standards.

So anytime you say, “You ought to do this,” or, “You should do this,” it’s picking up your moral standards so on judgment day … You show up at judgment day, and you’re already upset because you didn’t know there was going to be one. There you are. You know, it’s a little fanciful. It still gets across the idea. This is how the illustration goes.

There you are. “My goodness. Judgment day!” God says, “Hey, hey, hey, hey, hey. Calm down. I’m a fair guy. I’m only going to judge you according to your own standards.” He takes the little recorder off your neck. You say, “I didn’t know that was there.” “No, it was invisible.” He puts it down, and he says, “I’m just going to judge you by your own standards, and you’re going to play it.”

See, what Paul is saying (and what you know in your own heart, I hope) is there is nobody on the face of the earth, there is no one in the history of the world, who will be able to stand, will be able to pass that standard on judgment day. Nobody! Just nobody has ever lived up to their own standards they have imposed on other people. No one!

The first thing is God is very fair. He is the judge of all the earth. That’s what Paul was saying. He is very fair. He won’t judge you according to a standard you don’t already have. But then secondly, on the other hand, no one is going to pass judgment day.

Then thirdly, he says something very radical and controversial when he says … Notice he doesn’t just say people without the law of God have their own moral standards. He says, “(Indeed, when Gentiles, who do not have the law, do by nature things required by the law …)” What’s the law? Well, it’s what’s in here. Notice it doesn’t say people who don’t believe in the Bible know in their hearts and in their consciences everything in the Bible. It doesn’t say that. That would be silly.

There are plenty of people out there who have never read the Bible or don’t know anything about the Bible. What it does say is deep in their hearts or deep in their consciences, there are some things in the moral law of God that all people know because they’ve all been created by God. At a deep level, deep level, deep level, everyone has some understanding of the moral law of God and that Divinity is behind it, and everyone is living as if that’s true.

Therefore, there’s a sense in which no one is really a relativist. That’s very, very controversial, but let me spend a moment trying to give you some of the evidence for this. One of the things I’ve always found fascinating is when I’ve studied over the years, especially the conversion accounts of very, very, very highly intellectual, intelligent, sophisticated academics or professors or thinkers who were skeptical or atheists or agnostics and were converted to Christianity … It’s very interesting.

When I study those kinds of people, very seldom do they come to faith in Christ by looking at the arguments for the existence of God or the evidence for the resurrection and they say, “Ah! I see the evidences that this is true.” They don’t look at it that way. Usually they come at it like this. Usually I have seen they realize their moral convictions, their moral intuitions they feel very strongly, actually assume the existence of God, and they just haven’t been honest about it.

They come to realize in their moral convictions and in their moral intuitions they actually have sensed God. They’ve intuited the existence of God. They haven’t wanted to admit it, and now they do. That’s how they become Christians. It’s amazing how often that happens. You say, “How does that work?”

Well, let me give you three examples, one of which is not a conversion. In fact, what I’m about to give you is a little summary of a philosophy book. Please be patient with it, because even if you find it a little tough to follow, it’s kind of fun. If you find it tough to follow, I’ll immediately illustrate it and help you get it down to earth.

Recently there has been a book written by a man who is not a convert who stays what he would call an atheist or an agnostic. Thomas Nagel, a professor of philosophy at NYU, has recently written a book that has created a firestorm because it’s brilliantly argued and yet at the same time … Let me just read you … The title is Mind and Cosmos, but the key is the subtitle. Okay? Are you ready for the subtitle? The subtitle is Why the Materialist Neo-Darwinian Conception of Nature is Almost Certainly False.

Let me give you the nub of it. He has one chapter in their called “Value.” Here’s what he basically says. By the way, he is not against evolution altogether, but what he is saying is evolutionary materialism is the idea that you are just a body. You’re just a body, and there’s nothing in you that isn’t there through natural selection. Everything that’s true about you is true because one of your ancestors had a trait that helped them survive. Because that trait helped them survive, they’ve passed that down to you.

You’re just a body, and everything in you is strictly the result of natural selection. It helped your ancestors survive. That’s evolutionary materialism. Now he says that means in that account of things, all your moral feelings are just that. They’re subjective feelings. For example, he says, in this view, why do we all think torture for fun is wrong? You know, there are a lot of arguments about torture, but here’s the point.

Don’t we all believe torture just for fun is wrong … really, really wrong? If you ever do find somebody (and there are people who we find) who doesn’t think torture for fun is wrong, we consider them very sick and twisted. We all believe torture for fun is wrong. Why do we believe that?

See, in the view of evolutionary naturalism, it’s a subjective belief, and you only believe it because some of our ancestors felt that way, and that feeling helped them survive. All the people who did enjoy torture for fun have not survived, probably because they tortured each other and killed each other. I’m not kidding. I mean, we don’t know why, but that’s the point. What was the mechanism?

The point is the reason we all believe torture for fun is wrong is all the people who did feel the torture for fun was okay died out. The reason you have the hair color you have is because of evolution. The reason you have the moral feeling that torture for fun is wrong is also because of evolution. Your hair color and that moral feeling come from the same place. They are in the same category.

They’re only subjective. All your moral feelings are subjectively moral. You feel those things are wrong subjectively because they helped your ancestors survive, not because they are actually, objectively, universally, and really wrong. They’re subjectively wrong because you feel it, not because they’re actually and objectively and universally and really wrong. They’re just subjective.

Now well what happens, though? Suppose it turns out there’s a tribe we’ve discovered in some remote part of the world that their evolution operated in a very different way. First of all, their hair is white from the minute they’re born. The pigment of their skin is half-red and half-yellow. Very different. They also find torture for fun great. They love it. It’s fun! Now they’re starting to move out into the world. How do you feel about them?

You say, “Well, okay. They can’t help their hair color and things like that, but that torture for fun is wrong.” Well, why is it wrong? You feel it’s wrong because of your evolution. They feel it’s okay because of their evolution. Why should their hair color and their practice of torture be any …? Why should you differentiate?

Here’s what Thomas Nagel says. Nobody believes torture for fun is only subjectively wrong. We believe it’s actually and objectively and universally and really wrong, whether they feel that way or not. If evolutionary materialism is true, then value realism (the idea that things are actually and really wrong) can’t be true. Since we know some things actually and really are wrong, evolutionary materialism can’t be true. Got that? See how easy that was?

You say, “That just seemed like a slight of hand.” Let me give you two personal examples. W.H. Auden (one of the great poets of history, considered one of the great writers of the twentieth century), like most British intellectuals of his time, abandoned any kind of religious faith, abandoned Christian faith. He was an atheist, or he was an agnostic and that sort of thing.

Then World War II happened. His understanding, his religion-less belief, was thrown into chaos, and he came out on the other side of World War II embracing Christianity, which shocked many, many of his peers. He explained it. Here’s how he explained it. Let me set it up this way. He had believed until World War II that basically all reasonable, enlightened, cultured people would believe in human rights. They’d believe in freedom. They’d believe in democracy. They’d believe in justice for everybody.

Suddenly, along comes Nazism, and it’s embraced by Germany. Germany is every bit as cultured and as sophisticated and educated a society as Britain. You know, it’s second to none (science and art and music and everything). Yet Germany embraced a philosophy that did not believe in human rights for all and did not believe in justice for all. This is what Auden said to try to explain what happened to him.

“If I am convinced that highly educated Nazis are wrong, and that we highly educated English are right, what is it that validates our values and invalidates theirs? The English intellectuals who now cry to heaven against the evil incarnated in Hitler have no heaven to cry to. The whole trend of liberal thought has been to undermine faith in the absolute. It has tried to make reason the judge.”

Here’s the problem. “Either we serve the Unconditional, or some Hitlerian monster will supply an iron convention to do evil by.” Here’s what is going on. Do you hear what he is saying? Auden is saying, “Let’s look at nature, okay? Let’s be scientists. Let’s look at nature. What do we see? The strong eating the weak. That’s how nature operates.” Oh, but then we turn around and say, “Well, we don’t want strong races to oppress weak races or strong nations to oppress weak nations.”

Why? If the operational principle of nature is the strong eating the weak, what in the world is wrong with strong nations oppressing and destroying weak nations? See, reason will find nothing wrong with injustice, with trampling on human rights. Therefore, here’s what he realized. It’s possible without God to account for moral feeling. Social construction or evolutionary biology, we can say, “You have your moral feelings.”

But it’s impossible without God to believe in moral obligation. Do you hear this? Moral feeling means I subjectively feel this way. Moral obligation is you have to do this whether you feel like it or not. Moral obligation. If there’s no God, there is no moral obligation. There are only moral feelings. Here’s what he said. “If there’s no God, then moral obligation is imaginary, and I know moral obligation is not imaginary. Therefore, there must be a God.”

He’d been living that way all along, but he hadn’t wanted to admit it. See? Romans 2. I’m going to give you one more example. Again, not a conversion story. Some years ago in the Chronicle of Higher Education, I read a very interesting article by a woman who was a cultural anthropologist at Northeastern University. She was a very respected academic, and she was studying certain African societies in which women were very oppressed.

There was polygamy. There was female genital mutilation, and there were these things that really bothered her very much. She was a cultural anthropologist, and she had bought into the idea that there is such a thing as moral feelings but not moral obligation. She was a skeptical, secular person. Her understanding was that if you have a moral feeling, it comes either because your culture has constructed that feeling in you or because of biology.

She began when she was there in Africa to sometimes push back against some of the people in authority in those societies about how they were treating women. Basically what the people in authority said was, “Don’t you lay your white Western individualistic human rights thing on us. How dare you think your culture’s values are right and ours are wrong? What’s right for us is right for us.”

It infuriated her because she realized she had absolutely no way to answer. No way to answer! See? She had no basis for what Thomas Nagel calls “value realism.” She had no basis for moral obligation. She could say, “I subjectively feel something is wrong, but I cannot say on any basis that something is actually, objectively, universally, or really wrong.”

Do you know how she ends the whole article? She basically says, “In the end, I unavoidably believe that equal rights for women is universally true even though I have no basis for it, so I’m going to work for equal rights for women anyway.” See, in other words, what she is doing is she is coming really close … really close … to admitting what Paul is saying, but she just won’t go all the way. She just won’t go there.

Here’s the question. If your premise that there is no God and, therefore, no moral obligation leads you to a conclusion you know isn’t true (which is, namely, there’s really nothing wrong with oppressing women in Africa), why not change your premise? Why not change your premise? So, you see, it’s impossible to really succeed in being a relativist. However, on the other hand, paragraph two. I’m giving you less time, because in some ways, we’ve covered this, and we will cover this.

2. No one can really succeed in being a moralist

The next paragraph is, “Now you, if you call yourself a Jew; if you rely on the law …” He turns to people who say, “Okay. I do believe the Bible. I absolutely believe the Bible, and I accept the Bible, and I’m living according to the Bible.” Now we can call those people moralists. They’re not relativists. They believe in morality, and they’re living on the basis of morality. They say, “I’m going to honor God, and I’m going to obey his law.”

Let’s not forget what Paul has already said. You have no more hope on judgment day than the relativist. You’re just more consistent. I’m not sure that’s going to be a great deal of consolation. Why is that true? Why is it also impossible to succeed in being a moralist? Well, the answer is down here in verses 21–23 basically.

“… you, then, who teach others, do you not teach yourself? You who preach against stealing, do you steal? You who say that people should not commit adultery, do you commit adultery? You who abhor idols, do you rob temples? You who boast in the law, do you dishonor God by breaking the law?”

If you look carefully, he is giving you two reasons why no moralist will stand on judgment day either. The relativists won’t. They’ll find out they didn’t live up to what they did know. But the moralists won’t either. Why not? First, hypocrisy. Second, idolatry. Hypocrisy we all kind of know about. The fact is there are very high standards in here, and nobody lives up to them.

Paul gives some obvious examples of hypocrisy. I mean, I don’t know of any Christian church anywhere where everybody believes, “Thou shalt not commit adultery” and there isn’t still adultery. Everybody says, “Thou shalt not steal,” or, “Thou shalt not bear false witness,” and yet there’s lying and there’s stealing and there’s embezzling.

On the one hand, he is saying, “First of all, there’s hypocrisy. The fact is none of us live up.” Then there’s idolatry. It kind of sneaks in there, and it’s actually a bit of a puzzle, except when you ask commentators what this means, they usually all say the same thing. He is talking to Jews now, remember? He starts in verse 17. “Now you, if you call yourself a Jew; if you rely on the law …” He says, “Do you not commit adultery?”

Then he says, “You who abhor idols, do you rob temples?” This has always been a puzzle because there seems to be no evidence that Jews robbed temples. You know, he is writing to Jews in Rome, right? Is he saying, “Well, you know, you Jews in Rome should stop at night going and robbing temples and getting the idols and bringing them home”? Jews didn’t do that. He is speaking metaphorically if he is obviously not speaking literally.

Metaphorically (as we often point out), the Bible says it’s one thing to say, “I believe in God, and I’m living for God,” when actually you’re living for money or you’re living for power or you’re living for status. At this point, I think what Paul is trying to show us is what I would call the terrible inwardness of the law. Terrible? Yes.

When Jesus, in the Sermon on the Mount, expounds the Law, he shows the terrible inwardness of it. You know how he says, “You have heard it said, ‘Thou shalt not kill,’ but I say you shouldn’t even resent your neighbor. You’ve heard it said, ‘Thou shalt not commit adultery.’ But I say don’t lust.”

See, what Jesus is showing is the Law, when it forbids a behavior, is also enjoining the opposite and calling for a spirit. For example, where does murder come from? Murder comes from resentment that’s nurtured and nurtured and fertilized and eventually becomes murder. Right? He says, “Then you ought to realize all of you have resentment. Most people don’t murder, but everybody resents.” What is that? It’s murder in seed form.

When the Bible says, “Thou shalt not kill,” it means you should love with your whole heart and not resent. When the Bible says, “Thou shalt not steal,” it means you should never envy and also be incredibly generous. When the Bible says, “Thou shalt not commit adultery,” it means you should be totally faithful and chaste. When Jesus is expounding the Sermon on the Mount, you realize, “Oh my word! Nobody lives up to this,” and yet we want other people to live up to this.

I’ve forgotten the name of the lady, but there was a woman who taught English at a public university somewhere. She was a believer, but it was a public university. She one time had her class read the Sermon on the Mount. Most of them hadn’t ever read it before. Some of them hadn’t heard of it. What was interesting … They wrote response papers, and most of them hated it … utterly hated it.

If I remember, the article went something like this. Most of them basically said, “I did not like the Sermon on the Mount. It made me feel very guilty.” You know why. One person said something like, “I did not like the Sermon on the Mount because nobody can live like this.” Here’s the hypocrisy. Would you like to live in a place where people serve your needs ahead of their own? Would you like to live in a place where people are absolutely honest and transparent and they never hide anything from you and they always keep their promises?

See, in other words, we want to live in a society of people who act the way the Sermon on the Mount dictates, but we don’t ourselves want to be held up to that standard because we feel, “Oh, that’s awful! I did not like the Sermon on the Mount. It made me feel very bad.” David Martyn Lloyd-Jones, in his sermons on the Sermon on the Mount, says anybody who has really read the Sermon on the Mount will not say, “How wonderful.” They’ll say, “God, save me from the Sermon on the Mount.”

Do you see the hypocrisy? We want people to act like this, but we don’t want to be held to it ourselves. That’s hypocrisy, and it will be condemned on the last day. It will be condemned on the last day! What’s our hope? Is there any hope? Oh my goodness! See, if there is no Divine Judge, if there really is no God, what hope is there for the world?

What hope is there that all the injustices and the terrible things that are happening will ever be put right? What hope is there for even us to have a basis for trying to put things right? If there is no Judge, if there is no Divine Judge, what hope is there for the world? If there is a Divine Judge, what hope is there for you and me? Hmm. We’re stuck.

3. Therefore, this is our only hope

Thank God for point three, because point three brings us to the very end. In the very end, there’s this very strange discussion about a strange thing for most of us today, which is circumcision. The heart of it is right here in verse 28. “A person is not a Jew who is one only outwardly, nor is circumcision merely outward and physical. No, a person is a Jew who is one inwardly; and circumcision is circumcision of the heart, by the Spirit …”

What he is saying is the only hope is a new heart. Circumcision of the heart means the new birth. It means a new heart, a new inward heart. Now how does that work? Why? What is he talking about? First of all, let’s talk about circumcision for a second. This whole section is about circumcision.

In the Old Testament, circumcision was the rite by which a family showed they were in a covenant relationship with God. It’s how the Israelites showed they were in a covenant relationship with God. It was the sign that they were in a relationship with God. They were obeying God, and they were following his law. When all the males of the particular family were circumcised, that said, “We are under the law of God, and we are obeying God, and we’re following God.”

But there’s a problem. What’s the problem? Well, the problem was verse 17. “Now you, if you call yourself a Jew; if you rely on the law and boast in God …” Then he goes on to talk about all the problems. Here’s the issue: law relying. See, there’s no problem with being law abiding. That’s good.

What’s law relying? It’s not the same as law abiding. Law relying makes you boast, “I have a relationship with God. Why? Because I’m a good person. I’m a decent person. I don’t do this bad thing and that bad thing. I do these things and these things, and I’m a good person.” See, law relying screws you up so much inwardly.

Do you know why? You’re always going back and forth between superiority and inferiority. See, on the one hand, deep inside we know, like those students who read the Sermon on the Mount, we’re not living up to it. We’re not living up to what should be done. We know we’re not what we should be.

When you’re law relying and when you’re saying, “I’m obeying God’s law, and I’m trying to be moral. Then I know God will bless me, and he will take me to heaven,” if you’re law relying like that, on the one hand, you’re always struggling with inferiority and guilt and shame, and you’re very sensitive to criticism, and you’re always feeling a little bit like a failure.

Or sometimes you’re feeling very superior because you’ve done this and you’ve done this. Then it makes you self-righteous and that makes you pharisaical. You’ve going back and forth between superiority, inferiority. There’s always this churn. It does not make you a nice person. There’s always this kind of inward churn and a lack of rest and a lack of peace and a back and forth.

See, you need something. You need something in there that you don’t have. What is the solution? The solution is a new heart! How do you get a new heart? Circumcision of heart. It can only happen, obviously, by not relying on the law. Well, what do you rely on? Here’s what you rely on. Why was circumcision used as a sign? Does anybody know? It was a symbol of the punishment or the curse of the covenant.

I don’t know if any of you remember there’s a place in Genesis where Abraham makes a covenant with God in Genesis 15. He cuts some animals in half, and he puts them on both sides. The reason why he did that was in ancient times, we know 2,000 years ago, one of the ways covenants were made between people was you cut an animal in half, and you walked between the pieces, and you took your vow.

You didn’t sign a document like we do now. You cut an animal in half and walked between the pieces. Why? Because you were saying, “If I don’t do everything I’m saying today, may I be cut into pieces.” You’re acting out the curse of the covenant. You’re acting out the punishment for disobedience and oath breaking. Circumcision was like that because circumcision is bloody, it’s icky, and it means being cut off.

What God was saying is, “If you take the law on and you say, ‘Yes, I’m going to come under the law, and I’m going to make this my guide,’ but you don’t follow the law, then the curse of the covenant is to be cut off from me.” Honestly, if you think, “Whoa! This is all kind of weird and kind of nasty,” listen. You do it yourself.

↑ Back to top

↑