Search this study guide
Scripture focus
Thou shalt guide me with thy counsel, and afterward receive me to glory.
Psalm 73:24 KJV
At a glance
Why do so many sincere Christians live anxious about missing God's will for their lives?
Not usually from doubting that God can guide, Packer observes, but from fearing their own capacity to misread him — an anxiety that clear thinking about how guidance actually works can largely resolve.
Summary of the chapter
Packer identifies guidance as a chronic source of Christian anxiety, but locates the real problem precisely: most believers do not doubt that God can guide them; they fear missing his guidance through their own carelessness or self-deception. Resolving this, he argues, starts with two settled truths — God does have a purpose for each life, and he is entirely capable of communicating it.
He then names a common error: expecting guidance to arrive mainly as inward promptings of the Spirit, detached from Scripture and reasoned judgment, especially over 'vocational' decisions where more than one lawful option exists. True guidance, he insists, engages the mind and Scripture together rather than bypassing them for a feeling. He lists six recurring pitfalls that derail sincere seekers of guidance: refusing to think, refusing to think ahead, refusing to take advice, refusing to suspect one's own motives, being swayed by someone else's charisma rather than their substance, and refusing to wait.
Packer closes by refusing easy formulas: following God's will faithfully does not guarantee an easy road, and hardship after a decision is not proof it was the wrong one. Even genuine mistakes in discerning guidance are not final, since God is able to work them back into his good purposes. The chapter's counsel is to seek guidance within confidence in God's goodness, not within anxious perfectionism.
Key points
- Anxiety about guidance usually reflects fear of one's own error, not doubt about God's ability to guide.
- Guidance rests on two truths: God has a purpose for each believer, and he is able to communicate it.
- A common mistake is expecting guidance mainly through inward feelings, detached from Scripture and reasoned thought.
- Six pitfalls commonly derail the search for guidance: refusing to think, to think ahead, to take advice, to suspect oneself, to weigh substance over charisma, and to wait.
- Hardship following a decision does not prove it was wrong, and even genuine mistakes can be woven by God into good purposes.
Related Scripture
- Psalm 32:8
- Proverbs 3:5-6
- James 1:5
- Romans 8:28
For reflection and discussion
- Which of Packer's six pitfalls — especially unwillingness to think, to take advice, or to wait — do you recognize most in yourself?
- How does engaging Scripture and reasoned thought, rather than feeling alone, change how you seek guidance?
- Where has fear of making the wrong choice, more than uncertainty about God, been the real source of your anxiety about guidance?
These notes are an original UECF.NET study companion and are not a reproduction of the book. Read the full chapter — chapter 20, “Thou Our Guide” — in Knowing God by J. I. Packer (InterVarsity Press / Hodder & Stoughton, 1973).