This Story Is True
How many different ways can we have our coffee made at Starbucks?
One hundred? Two hundred? Over five hundred?
Howard Schultz, who bought the fledgling coffee company in 1987 and turned it into one of the world’s most recognizable brands, once estimated in an interview that there are over seventy thousand ways we can order Starbucks coffee. When John Naisbitt first wrote his best-selling book Megatrends (1982), he said that one of the top ten trends of the modern world is a shift from no choice to multiple choice.
It is certainly true of spirituality.
When it comes to an authoritative spiritual text, there’s the Bible, the Bhagavad Gita, the Qur’an, and the Book of Mormon.
When it comes to religious leaders, you can select from the Pope, the Dalai Lama or your local imam.
When it comes to religious groups, you can link up with those in Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Judaism or Scientology.
But do you even have to choose?
Is There More Than One Way to God?
Today, increasing numbers of people believe that there are many roads that lead to God. The idea is that searching for God is like climbing a mountain. Since everyone knows that there is not just one way to climb a mountain—mountains are too big for that—there must be any number of paths that can be taken. Similarly, we tend to look at all of the ideas about God throughout the religions of the world as different ways to God. Thus, the names of God in all of the world’s religions identify the same God.
It reminds me of the poem “The Blind Men and the Elephant” written by John Godfrey Saxe, which he wrote from an ancient Indian parable. As the story is told, six blind men in search of truth come upon an elephant and try to determine what the elephant is like. The first one, without knowing it, touched the elephant’s side and instantly said, “Well, I know what an elephant is like—it’s like a wall!” The next blind man first touched the elephant’s long, ivory tusk, and said, “No it’s not—it’s like a spear!” The third blind man discovered the elephant’s trunk and said, “Elephants are surely like a snake.” The fourth stumbled on the elephant’s leg and declared, “An elephant is clearly like a tree.” The fifth found the elephant’s ear and said, “I think it’s like a fan.” The sixth blind man came upon the elephant’s tail, and said, “I don’t understand any of you—if an elephant isn’t like a rope, then I don’t know what it’s like!”
The intended moral of the story is simple: Each of the six men insisted that they knew what an elephant is like. Each was partly right, yet also entirely wrong, because each had only a part of the picture, not the whole.
This is how many think about spiritual things and even God. All of the different religions, worldviews and philosophies are like blind men attempting to feel reality and then drawing dogmatic conclusions that can’t possibly be right because they are trying to describe something beyond their limited senses. When people try to describe God, much less the way to God, they are like blind men trying to describe an elephant. For this reason, many believe we are free to choose from among the many philosophies and religions of the world.
When it comes to spiritual truth and knowing God, can we really know anything for sure? Or are we all just blind people groping in the dark? And if we are blind, then isn’t it fair to say that there really isn’t one way to God, but many? The question matters, because if there are many ways, we can relax. All roads lead to God. All spiritual paths are equally legitimate. It doesn’t really matter what we believe or who, what and how we worship. It doesn’t matter whether we accept the Bible or the Qur’an, Buddha or Jesus. All ideas about God throughout all the religions of the world are equally good.
Jesus spoke directly to such pluralism: “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14:6). Jesus did not say that he is a way or a truth, but the way, the truth and the life. This is an invitation, not just a declaration. We are invited to know God as Father through following Jesus and believing in him. This does not invalidate our spiritual experience but promises it can be so much more.
What About Being Tolerant?
You might be thinking, But isn’t believing that Jesus is the only way to God intolerant? Isn’t saying that there’s just one way or one truth dismissive of other perspectives?
Yes.
But isn’t that a bad thing?
No.
If we believe Jesus is who he says he is, then all we are doing is accepting the spiritual truth of his words. But let’s bracket that off for a minute and speak to tolerance itself as a philosophy. In our day we have made tolerance of all views the ultimate virtue. But we haven’t been careful with how we use this idea. In truth, tolerance can be good or bad.
Why? Because there are three kinds of tolerance.
The first is legal tolerance. If you are an American, this has to do with our basic first amendment rights to believe what we want to believe. There is nothing in what Jesus put forward that would war against such an idea. In fact, the Bible is a great advocate of legal tolerance. When God placed Daniel in a place of public influence in pagan Babylon, God did not tell Daniel to stop people from worshiping as they chose, even if that meant false gods and idols. The same is true for other politically placed and influential biblical characters, such as Joseph and Esther.
The second kind of tolerance is social tolerance. We should accept others as humans regardless of what they believe, interacting with them in love and exhibiting openness to them as persons. There is nothing in the Christian faith that stands against this kind of tolerance. If Jesus stood for anything, it was open, loving acceptance of others as the image bearers of God.
The third kind is intellectual tolerance, which is accepting every idea as being equally valid, good, right and true.
Does anyone really embrace that?
Imagine a woman approached us and said, “The best way to optimize your laptop’s performance is to remove your antivirus protection, open every e-mail attachment from people you do not know, and download free software from questionable websites.” We, of course, would be legally and relationally tolerant of her without buying into what she says about optimizing our computer’s performance. Not all points of view are equally valid. When we talk about the importance of tolerance, we mean legal tolerance or social tolerance—but not necessarily intellectual tolerance.
Let’s bring this back to spiritual things. When the apostle Peter stood in front of the religious leaders of his day and said regarding Jesus, “Salvation is found in no one else, for there is no other name given under heaven by which we must be saved” (Acts 4:12 TNIV), he wasn’t refusing anyone their right to believe differently or rejecting anyone socially or culturally. Instead, he was taking a clear, intellectual stand about his understanding of spiritual truth—which is something we all must do. There is little value in the wholesale embrace of intellectual tolerance.
What About the Good Things in Other Religions?
So what about the good and true in other religions? Well, it is good and true! Jesus did not teach that his followers will believe that every other world religion is completely wrong or that they have to deny the existence of some truth or goodness in other perspectives.
C. S. Lewis, in his book Mere Christianity, once wrote that “if you are a Christian you do not have to believe that all the other religions are simply wrong all through. . . . If you are a Christian, you are free to think that all these religions, even the queerest ones, contain at least some hint of the truth.” Lewis goes on to suggest we think of it in terms of arithmetic. There is only one right answer to 2 + 2—and that’s 4—but if someone answered 6, it would be a lot closer than answering 37. While there is only one right answer, some answers are closer to the truth than others, and it takes nothing away from the correct answer to acknowledge as much. If all truth is God’s truth, then it remains true wherever we find it.
As a Christian I can appreciate the truth in much of Buddhism. For example, the first two of the Four Noble Truths state that there is a lot of suffering in the world, and our desires are often at the root of the suffering. Buddhism also teaches many things that I appreciate and affirm as clearly moral: we shouldn’t take the life of another, we shouldn’t steal, we shouldn’t engage in immoral sexual behavior, and we should not lie.
But here’s where it starts to get a little messy. While many world religion courses show how much is held in common, the reality is that there are vast differences on the most foundational issues. So while there is some common ground between Buddhism and Christianity, there are also enormous tension points. The Dalai Lama has stated publicly that the central doctrines of Buddhism and Christianity are not compatible. He has been quite open to the fact that you cannot be a Buddhist Christian or a Christian Buddhist. (See, for example, the Dalai Lama’s book The Good Heart [Somerville, Mass.: Wisdom Publications, 1996], pp. 81-82.)
And he is right.
Christianity believes in a personal God; Buddhism does not even believe in a higher being (essentially, Buddhism is an atheistic religion). That is a divide that is simply insurmountable. These are not the two different ways up the same mountain; they are facing entirely different mountains. This is true when you compare Christianity to the other world religions as well: Christians believe there’s one God; Hindus believe there are millions. Christians embrace Jesus as God in human form; Muslims don’t even rank him as the chief prophet, much less the Savior of the world.
Whenever we have divisions of this nature, we have two options: we can say that somebody is right and everybody else is wrong, or we can say that everyone is wrong. But we can’t say that everybody believes the same thing. That would be intellectually dishonest. Unless God is a senile, confused, muddled, schizophrenic, unbalanced being who isn’t sure what he stands for, there is religious truth and religious falsehood. And the areas of disagreement are not trivial. They deal with the very nature of God, the identity of Jesus, and how a relationship with God is established.
What About the Really Good People?
Okay, let me add this up. There is just one way to God, and it’s through Jesus. And to believe such is not being socially or legally intolerant, just intellectually intolerant, which is a kind of intolerance we all believe in. And while there may be some truth and goodness in other religions, that doesn’t mean they are equally valid ways to God.
“So,” you might ask, “are you saying that all those people who aren’t Christians go to hell? Does someone really good and noble, like Gandhi, go to hell just because he didn’t acknowledge Jesus as the only way to God? Because if you are, you’ve lost me. I just can’t believe that’s right.”
Fair enough. In fact, let’s up the stakes, because this goes far beyond the Gandhis of the world. Recently a young woman who had been attending Mecklenburg Community Church for over a year as a spiritual seeker asked to speak with me about her journey. As we talked, she readily shared how far she had come—now believing in the Bible and even Jesus as God’s Son. Coming from a deeply Jewish heritage, this was no small pilgrimage. Then came her stumbling block: “I can’t believe my Jewish parents are in hell. I just can’t believe those two wonderful people are not with God in heaven.” I know of only one response to such heartfelt cries, and it is the most significant response.
We must trust in the character of God.
Much of the Christian’s relationship with God rests on our understanding of—and faith in—his character. If God is God, he is utterly, completely fair and just. He will do the right thing by every person. God will treat every person with complete and total love and justice. This applies to all persons—including those who have never heard the good news of Jesus, who were not able to comprehend that news or who seemed to reject that news. The character of God, as revealed throughout the Bible, demands that Christians be “optimistic agnostics” when it comes to the salvation of others. Yes, we are saved by Christ alone, but it is God who will make the perfect assessment of where someone stands in relation to Christ’s saving grace.
Yet in saying this, we must not lose sight of the reality of sin, our sin condition and our need for Christ’s saving grace. Perhaps no other reality is less understood in our modern world. We either project sin onto the world, removing it from within our own lives, or if we own it’s personal presence, we trivialize the degree of its darkness.
We need to examine this idea of people being good. The Bible teaches that no one is truly good, and even our most noble spirits would agree. During her life Mother Teresa always reminded people who told her how good she was that she was not good, that nobody was truly good, and that she—along with everyone else—was a sinner in need of forgiveness and reconciliation with a holy God.
No one is in less of a broken relationship with God and in less of the need of the way to God than anyone else. This is behind Jesus’ reply to the rich young man who asked what good thing he had to do to gain eternal life. “ ‘Why do you ask me about what is good?’ Jesus replied. ‘There is only One who is good’ ” (Matthew 19:17).
God made us to be in relationship with him. We chose to break that relationship through sin and rebellion. God offers us a chance to restore that relationship and repair the broken relationship. God wants to be with us. If we want to be with God, we can. The Bible teaches that it isn’t God’s desire that anyone should experience hell but that everyone would receive the gift of eternal life through Christ. If I don’t choose to return to God—never entering into that relationship—then my course for eternity is set as well. Whatever choice I make in this life, God will say at the end, “So be it.” I will receive that which I desired.
And make no mistake—we must come to God, and he has said we come through Jesus.
Think of it this way. If you were in a broken relationship with someone—let’s call him Mike—because of something you did, would it help your relationship with Mike if you spent your life trying to be in a good relationship with Bill? Of course not. Your problem is not with Bill. The only way to mend the relationship it is to deal with Mike and hope he is gracious enough to forgive you.
Because of sin, every human being is in a broken relationship with God. The only way to repair that relationship is to become reconciled with God, and he has said there is only one way for that to happen: to have our sins against him forgiven. And that forgiveness comes through what God did for us through Jesus on the cross. Jesus’ death on the cross is the payment for our sins. It is the only way to have our sins forgiven. And the choice is real, and truly ours to make.
So where is Gandhi?
Gandhi is where Gandhi chose to be.
The real question is where you choose to be.
There is a game show on TV called Let’s Make a Deal. You have probably seen it. At one point in the game the contestant has to pick one of three doors. When I used to watch, if the wrong one is picked, the contestant gets a dud—maybe a goat, a clunker car or a case of tomatoes. If the right door is picked, the contestant would get a room of electronic components, a convertible car and a trip to Europe.
Jesus wants you to pick the right door.
He said, “Enter through the narrow gate. For wide is the gate and broad is the road that leads to destruction, and many enter through it. But small is the gate and narrow the road that leads to life, and only a few find it” (Matthew 7:13-14).
We might want there to be more than one way. We might want all the ways to be fused into one. But that is not reality. The decision is a stark one: When it comes to God, we can believe the gate is broad and the road is wide, full of options and opinions, different takes and approaches. We might appreciate that this road is easy to travel, having multiple lanes to choose from and lots of room to maneuver.
And thus we pick a bad door.
Or we can realize the way is singular, a defined path that must be taken, with a clear entrance that cannot be confused with any other entrance; a road that has a singular direction, with clear boundaries.
And thus we pick the right door.
Making Your Choice
So what should we do? How do we come to God to repair the relationship through what Jesus did on the cross? First, we have to own up to the fact that we are in a broken relationship with God through the sin and rebellion in our life. There has to be honesty in coming to God. Which is why the Bible says, “If we claim we have no sin, we are only fooling ourselves and not living in the truth” (1 John 1:8 NLT).
The second step is to have that broken relationship break our heart. It’s coming to that point where the deepest part of us is sorry, is in grief, over the sin in our life. This is what repentance is all about.
The third step is to accept what Christ did for us on the cross, which was to step in and take our place and pay our debt through his shed blood. There is a way to God. It’s through Jesus; he’s the only way. Only his death dealt with our sin. And only his death can pay for it.
Which reveals how God feels for us. He loves us. He cares about us. He did everything he could to reach out to us.
You may not be able to imagine Jesus loving you, forgiving you, accepting you. All you have to do is reflect on what he did for you on the cross. The pain, the blood, the agony—and then remember—it was done for you! He did all of that so that you could be forgiven, so that you could come back. Don’t throw it back in his face by thinking you’re unworthy, unforgivable or unlovable. Or that somehow what he did wasn’t enough. Don’t let anything stand between you and the gift he gave—his very life—to you. Come to him and enjoy a relationship of love with him.
All it takes is praying one, simple, sincere prayer. But make no mistake, that only begins the adventure. It involves not only embracing Jesus as the only way but also as your only leader. It is a robust, muscular, demanding and serious prayer.
Then ask for forgiveness, ask for the relationship to be healed, ask for what Christ did on the cross to be applied to your life. And the Bible says that if you will, he will. The Bible says, “Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved” (Romans 10:13).
This is my challenge to you: Don’t kid yourself into thinking that it will all come out okay in the end, that there are lots of ways to God, so making a choice isn’t that big of a deal. It’s just not true. And your eternity rests on one thing: truth. And make no mistake—truth exists. God wants to be in relationship with you. The question is whether or not you want to be in a relationship with him.
This Story Is True
On the wall of my study is an enlarged photograph I took of Addison’s Walk, just behind Magdalen College, in Oxford, England. The path runs beside several streams of the River Cherwell, with an entrance just beside the “New Building” of Magdalen College. During a summer of study, I took evening walks there on a regular basis. It became very dear to me, and not just to me.
On Saturday, September 19, 1931, C. S. Lewis invited two friends to dine with him in his rooms at Magdalen, where he taught. One friend was Hugo Dyson, a lecturer in English literature at Reading University. The other name hardly needs introduction, for it was none other than the author of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings trilogy, J. R. R. Tolkien. On that fall evening, after they had dined, Lewis took his guests on a walk through the Magdalen grounds, ending with a stroll down Addison’s Walk. There, they began to discuss the idea of metaphor and myth.
Lewis had long appreciated myth. As a boy he had loved the great Norse stories of the dying god Balder, and as a man he grew to love and appreciate the power of myth throughout the history of language and literature. But he didn’t believe in them. Beautiful and moving though they might be, they were, he concluded, ultimately untrue. As he expressed to Tolkien, myths are “lies and therefore worthless, even though breathed through silver.”
“No,” said Tolkien. “They are not lies.”
Later, Lewis recalled that at the moment Tolkien uttered those words, “a rush of wind . . . came so suddenly on the still, warm evening and sent so many leaves pattering down that we thought it was raining. We held our breath.”
Tolkien’s point was that the great myths might just reflect a splintered fragment of the true light. Within the myth, there was a kernel of eternal truth. They talked on, and Lewis became convinced by the force of Tolkien’s argument. They returned to Lewis’s rooms on Staircase III of New Building. Once there, they turned their conversation to Christianity. Tolkien argued that the poet who invented the Christian story was none other than God himself, and the images God used were real men and women and actual history.
Lewis was floored.
“Do you mean,” he asked, “that the death and resurrection of Christ is the old ‘dying God’ story all over again?”
Yes, Tolkien answered, except that here is a real dying God, with a precise location in history and definite historical consequences. The old myth has become fact. Such joining of faith and intellect had never occurred to Lewis.
It was now 3 a.m., and Tolkien had to go home. Lewis and Dyson escorted him down the stairs. They crossed the quadrangle and let him out by the little postern gate on Magdalen Bridge. Lewis remembered that “Dyson and I found more to say to one another, strolling up and down the cloister of New Building, so that we did not get to bed till 4.”
Twelve days later Lewis wrote to his close boyhood friend Arthur Greeves: “I have just passed on from believing in God to definitely believing in Christ—in Christianity. I will try to explain this another time. My long night talk with Dyson and Tolkien had a good deal to do with it” (adapted from Humphrey Carpenter, The Inklings [New York: Ballantine, 1978], pp. 45-48).
The great call of the Christian faith is not to reject truth and beauty where it might be found, but to embrace the full truth and beauty revealed in Christ alone.
